Wife and I stopped by today after reading all the reviews. I had the banana split in a big waffle…read morecone. It had bananas and fresh juicy cherries in it. Wife had the Car 54 which was coffee ice cream with cut up chocolate donuts. Donuts and coffee, for the car 54 cop theme, get it? Very friendly employees and absolutely delicious ice cream. My wife can sometimes have stomach issues after ice cream but at this place she felt fine. Maybe it's better quality or something. Definitely worth a stop by if you are in the area like at lavender by the bay

Outstanding service, flavor selection, and delicious ice cream. I ordered the pistachio cherry and…read moredad got cherry vanilla.

Been here a few times, and enjoyed it each time!…read more Went last night with my parents and fiancé. We each got something different, and all was enjoyed. There was something for everyone and when we thought we made our decision, we saw something else that interested us. I had a delicious oatmeal raisin cookie. I was only able to eat half, and I'm looking forward to having the second half later. My fiancé had the Tiramisu, my stepdad had cookies and cream cupcake and my mom had a cookie/tart. Service was very friendly! We sat inside. There are a few tables available. Yum!

Loved it -- lemon burst cake was moist and even better tasting than it looked. That's saying…read moresomething! My husband got a delicious ice cream cone. Great vibes and I loved seeing the people come in and out. Amazing service with samples!

The Treatery in Jamesport is a must stop while on the North Fork. The cookies are out of this…read moreworld. My fave is the chocolate covered oatmeal raisin. A customer sitting next to me had their GRILLED CHEESE it looked so delicious. They greet you with a smile. They maybe a small store, but they pack a big punch for flavor. Ciao for Now.

Words can not describe the flavors coming out of this quaint bakery. If you are passing through…read moreJamesport or staying here, you must stop In and try something scrumptious. People are so nice.

OMG the peach and strawberry cream pies are incredible and completely worth the price! my family…read morewas so excited to enjoy them, I'm honestly not sure how they werent devoured in the car. staff was friendly and made recommendations - wish we lived closer to go back and get more pie!

Briermere has been one of my favorite pie spots for years, and I finally got to try the famous…read morePeach Cream Pie after always missing it. Wow...the hype is real! Now it's a tie between the Peach Cream and Raspberry Cream pies. (The peach is only available in the summer, so don't miss it.) The apple cider is still the best. If you haven't been here yet, what are you waiting for? A North Fork trip isn't complete without Briermere!

The real thing, icing covered brownies tasting like old world heart and soul in every bite, flavor…read morepopping on all cylinders making your eyes water, wow, Highly, highly recommend!! Mike Guerra

Such a cute place. So happy to have found it. Hot coffee and some delish cakes and donuts too…read more Staff were so sweet. So peaceful to sit outside and enjoy the grounds there. We will definitely be back.

Amazing!! Such cozy vibes and the treats are always baked with love & SOOO YUMMY…read more I would definitely recommend going here! One of me and my boyfriends new favorite places hehe

I visited the truck at Ace Hardware after following them on Instagram for a while…read more I ordered the cookies and cream cupcake, peanut butter and jelly cupcake, tiramisu cup, s'mores cookie and chocolate chip cookie Doug cookie. You need to order the chocolate chip cookie, it is unreal!! The tiramisu was my second favorite, so delicious. Make sure to check their Instagram to see their menu and schedule. I highly recommend their baked goods.

The worst customer service! Rude and obnoxious. I will never go back. I pre ordered 1 dozen…read morepastries to be picked up at 9am on a Sunday. When I arrived there was a long line, I wasn't sure how pickups were handled so I walked in to ask. The owners wife screamed at me to get out and go to the back of the line. I walked out and went elsewhere. An hour later I get a phone call from the bakery asking if I was going to pick up my order. I informed her that I was there but after being treated so poorly I left. I was a customer for yrs. Never again. I didn't want to give them 1 star but had no choice.

Best cookies ! It's a winner. small lots huge taste. Everything they have is outstanding…read more Cookies danish bread cakes. Once we give Kriegs as a gift and now those people became huge Kriegs fans

You just cannot beat this place…read more A true donut staple on Long Island. The restaurant is extremely inviting outside and the donut flavors are super fun. I stick with the plain old chocolate, but it never disappoints!

Delicious doughnuts and very friendly service. I loved my Fruity Pebbles doughnut. One of the best…read moreones I've ever had. Yum! I'll be back.

What an unforgettable experience!! From the moment we walked in until we left (we chatted with the…read morestaff until we kicked ourselves out), everything was amazing! The food, atmosphere, and service were top notch! From choosing what hats to wear (full wall of hats to choose from) to having to decide which sandwiches to eat, we left very full and very happy. I would highly recommend going here for a lovely tea party. Just remember, you need a reservation!

The charm of the place was nice. Very whimsical and felt like you were in Alice in wonderland…read moreitself. Went for Mother's Day and we had to get the high tower which was good, I think it was priced high for what it was. Shrimp sandwich was my favorite. Why I'm not rating it higher: I made the reservation 2 weeks before Mother's Day, the only thing available was a 10:45am so I took it. They called me two days before to confirm and said they had a 1:30 available, I started asking questions about the food more being suited toward lunch or breakfast, a bit snippy they put me on hold, I txt my wife quick and she said take the 1:30, the woman gets back on the phone and says sorry someone on the other line just took the 1:30... I said.... What! I was offered it and didn't give you an answer yet. She didn't care and was very dismissive. Won't be returning,

I would give this 3.5 stars if I could, because I love the charm of this place and do think there's…read morea lot they get right here. This place has been here for so many decades, it almost feels like stepping back in time with the big wooden booths and pastry counter. It's giving old school diner. When you walk in you'll notice the bakery portion of the store to your right, where you can order any freshly baked breads, pastries, cookies and the like. Straight back is where you go to place food and coffee orders. You place your order on a kiosk. Options include a variety of egg dishes, omelets and frittatas, as well as waffles, pancakes and avocado toast. There's a full coffee bar as well with iced coffees, lattes and other espresso drinks to choose from. We went with a bunch of iced coffees, a "build your own" omelet, breakfast burrito and mushroom omelet. Despite the crazy line here on a Saturday afternoon our food came out very quickly. Coffees took another 20 minutes or so until we were able to ask someone about it (we felt bad, they were so busy), and they handed them over to us. The food here was good and fresh, but also very no frills and portions are small. The prices here are so high though that when we were walking by Donahue's on our way out we realized we could've had a fancy brunch there for just about the same price as we paid for a few small dishes.

Tables were dirty (as others have mentioned).... Food was okay but very expensive. It's nice they…read morehave that back lot for parking. Pastries were very good.