This is an old school ice-cream-only place in Mattituck - out on the North Fork of eastern Long Island. If you are in Riverhead or touring some of the vineyards on the North Fork, you should hit this place. We drove by on the way back from afternoon golf on a Friday. From the size of the crowd, I thought it was a Beatles Reunion Concert or something. The locals told us that it is REALLY GOOD, but evening waits can easily exceed an hour. Parking looked tough. We dropped by the next day around lunch time. No line, easy parking. The menu board has over 40 flavors, which include some intriguing ones such as honey cinnamon, honey lavender, blackberry ginger, avocado coconut. I did the cinnamon, the wife opted for the lavender. They were REALLY UNIQUE AND REALLY GOOD. My daughter has some food allergies, and we were impressed by the careful listing of potential allergens on the menu list. Next time I'm out on the east end of Long Island, I'll be going there again and getting some quarts to go. I just advise you to either go off-peak, or be prepared to hob-Nob with a lot of locals for a while in line. read more

Honestly will never stop raving about this place. I love how they have rotating flavors so it never gets boring. I come to Mattituck every summer so it's always a treat to come here for ice cream. My personal favorite flavors are Cookie Monster, Lots of Stuff, and Krispy Kreme. They even have pints to take home and treats for your pet! read more

every time I come to New York, I enjoy having ice cream one of my favorite spots I love the soft serve vanilla

I've been coming to Magic Fountain since I was a kid, and for good reason! They have delicious ice cream from a rotating menu of flavors that has so many interesting concoctions. On my most recent trip, they had Dubai Chocolate and Spicy Mango, both really fun and delicious in their own way. I ended up getting a scoop of the North Fork, and it was delicious. My friend got a vanilla milkshake and gave rave reviews as well. There's usually a line snaking out the door (the inside isn't very big), but they've got a good system for keeping things moving, so don't be dissuaded. If you're driving to/from the North Fork, make the drive even better with a stop here! read more

See all

This is one of the best homemade ice cream shops on the Island, yes it's on the East End in Mattituck but so definitely worth the trip. They have over 50 flavors and priced right for your enjoyment. Great store where you wait in line until they call you in, there are benches outside where you can sit and a lot of people start talking to one another... the power of ice cream, highly recommend and they make ice cream cakes as well. read more

See all

this guys have the best soft ice cream on Long Island. best brown bonnet too. nothing like it!

I really enjoyed my gluten free coffee ice cream. Yes - it is a bit touristy Yes - the prices are a bit high Yes - the line can get quite long But - everyone seems to be ok with that and just loves the ice cream - including me. I LOVED it. A pro-tip: order online and just pick it up at the window and skip the line. read more

Magic Fountain - Outside - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Mattituck, New York

See all

This place is THE BEST ice cream I have EVER had, and that's no understatement. This place has been part of the Mattituck community for many years and for good reason. They have well over 50 flavors, all which are homemade on site including weekly speciality flavors like cucumber, goat cheese or lavender. No matter that time you go, especially at night, this place always has a long line and is jammed pack. Despite the long line, the staff is unbelievably quick with getting orders out. They're also extremely friendly. It's a casual place to go after the beach, date night or if it's hot and you want a snack. This place needs to be on everyone's list. As a local, I come here once a week. I truly can't articulate how fantastic this place actually is. read more

Magic Fountain - Red velvet and rainbow cookie ice cream with gummy bears - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Mattituck, New York

See all

Visiting with friends and we checked hours on line to be sure they were open. Drove 30 min to get there in the evening. Guess what - closed on Tuesday and Wednesday. Wish that was clearly stated when we checked hours on line. To be fair my friends who live in the area had been there before and enjoyed it. read more

Lines weren't too bad but the later it is the longer it will be. Service was friendly and pretty fast once you get to the counter.

I love Magic Fountain!! I've been here several times but for whatever reason, I never reviewed. I love their creative flavors and creamy delicious ice cream. Their scoops are generous and everything is super fresh. Homemade and scrumptious. The service was great and the prices were reasonable for the amount of ice cream that you got. We just got back from Boston and had some proper homemade ice cream as well but it was so pricey. I think it was also in tony Cambridge and Magic Fountain is much more basic, but in the best possible way. I had the pralines and cream and rainbow cookie flavors. Both were excellent. The Pralines & Cream were a proper PNC but not too sweet. I loved the Rainbow Cookie which I've had elsewhere. The base had a nice almond flavor to it and I was surprised that it was pink. But pink is my favorite color so...bo complaints from me. The other rainbow cookie icecream I've had was a vanilla base with big chunks of rainbow cookie, which had the signature almond flavor. I liked both but I'd give the other place a slight edge because I prefer big chunks of anything in my ice cream. :-) I can't wait to go back to Magic Fountain again. Definitely one of my favorites on the Island. read more

Magic Fountain - Pralines & Cream/Rainbow Cookie - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Mattituck, New York

A small takeaway ice cream shop. When you see a line you know it must be good! For such a small place they had tons of flavors! I had soft serve and it was great! I highly recommend this place! read more

I've been to Magic Fountain a few times and enjoyed it each time. You place your order inside with friendly staff (you can try a flavor or two to be sure you like what you're ordering) and there's an extensive menu of flavors. The outside has a few benches and a cute mural and some vintage inspired signage in front. I can't wait to return this summer! read more

See all

This place is an absolute gem, next time I am in the area it's an absolute must! Great flavor selection and excellent quality.

The home made ice cream flavors change regularly, and they will surprise you with the creativity. The wait staff is welcoming. There is always a line, and it is worth the wait!!! read more

On the way home from picking up a Christmas Tree, we drove past Magic Fountain, a mom and pop ice cream shop out in Long Island. Ice Cream in the middle of winter? Why not? The inside looks similar to most other small ice cream shops. Unfortunately due to COVID, they do not give out samples. The kids each got a small cup, but I opted for the sampler, which is 12 small scoops served like mini cupcakes! The black cherry pistachio was my favorite...my least favorite was the purple one...not sure what flavor it's supposed to be, but it smelled and tasted like scented soap! Kids all liked the ice cream. Seems to be freshly made with a lot of different flavors. Too bad they are an hours drive from home... read more

See all

Arrived at 9pm and young girl said sorry can't let you in it's 9pm. I drove 45 minutes and they refused to serve me. While 10 people were inside of the store. She said let me speak to the owner. Comes back and said owner told me to turn you away. Never had magic fountain and never will attempt to again. Ridiculous Owner of store want to speak to me you can email me krgrestaurants@gmail.com. read more

Magic Fountain - Proof of time I'm writing this review. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Mattituck, New York

Local classic spot for homemade ice cream with a large selection. They get busy but keep things moving. Ice cream is good , not mind blowing. But definitely one of the best in the area. read more

We have been coming to Magic Fountain since we were children. It was Giada's first time and they made they made it a wonderful experience! read more

See all

This is a really cool old school ice cream joint that's been on the north fork forever. They always have new unique flavors like the honey lavender! I'm not a fan of lavender anything, but this is so good and reminds me of early fall! Their milkshakes are so good and if you come in the warmer months expect a line. It's part of the experience! This is one of the places we all look forward to visiting every time we are out on the north fork! read more

Magic Fountain - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Mattituck, New York

Stopped here after dinner on 4th of July for dessert. Their flavors are so amazing. We always love stopping here for a treat. Always a great idea to stop here. The line wasn't long either. read more

Best ice cream ever!!! This is a must-go place whenever I'm visiting. I've loved the mint chip since I was little but I definitely recommend the adventurous flavors as well! Great spot! read more

Best. Ice. Cream. Ever. Yes... I said that! The ice cream is so creamy and so flavorful. It's a tiny little ice cream shot with a whole lot of flavors. It is decently priced. read more

Magic Fountain - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Mattituck, New York

The service was excellent and the ice cream even better. The owner chatted with us and gave us all the tips on local attractions. Beautiful little town. Must visit. read more

Magic Fountain - Ice cream from heaven - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Mattituck, New York

See all

Really amazing ice cream. Last time, we got mint chip, cookie monster, and chocolate, all of which are among the best of that flavor I can remember having, but the cookie monster is especially great. The line can be insane here, but it's worth it, in my opinion. read more

Magic Fountain - Chocolate / Cookie Monster - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Mattituck, New York

Not a lot of room inside but there are some benches outside. They have great flavor options.

Still good, wildly creative homemade ice cream. Where can you find Fig & Honey, Rainbow cookie, Cucumber, Choc Rasberry Truffle ice cream. That's that week. Other weeks were all kinds of odd ice cream flavors to test how adventurous you really are for ice cream. They change them up and dare to try all kinds of things. Sometimes I get a taster of a few and stick to the basics. : ) read more

Magic Fountain - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Mattituck, New York

The lines long and totally worth it-- but moved fast! There are so many options of homemade ice cream flavors. I got the black raspberry and peach in a waffle cone. It was fresh, creamy and refreshing. Definetly worth another trip out there! read more

Magic Fountain - Waffle cone with peach and black raspberry Cup with cookie monster - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Mattituck, New York

See all

This place definitely lives up to the magic in the title of the business. I found myself randomly in Mattituck one day and overheard talk of Magic Fountain. I was skeptical about how good it could be because it felt like I was in the middle of nowhere but if you find yourself in the middle of nowhere too MAKE THE TRIP TO MAGIC FOUNTAIN. Their set up is a little weird where you wait outside until they call you in via their loudspeaker but it's actually kind of genius because it limits overcrowding inside. Once you're in, the staff is super friendly and willing to answer any questions and provide samples. On to the ice cream. We had a hard time choosing because there were so many flavors but I went with my old standby of butter pecan in a waffle cone. It was the creamiest ice cream I have ever had in my life. The texture was unlike anything I have had...velvety is the best way I can describe it and dare I say...magical. They have all sorts of ice cream novelties and I would have LOVED to take some home but I was concerned it would be soup. Probably the best ice cream I have had in my life, no joke. read more

Magic fountain is a hike from me so it's really a "special occasion/I'm out East" kind of stop, but if I'm anywhere around the area you KNOW I'll be going. They make their ice creams themselves, have so many different options, are allergen friendly, and even have dairy free options! Can be a little bit pricy, but you're paying for quality. I wish it was closer (though my wallet is happy that it's a treat). read more

Magic Fountain - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Mattituck, New York

Magic Fountain is worth the trip! I live 20 miles away. Was in area to see a show. We had some time so we looked up ice cream and came to Magic Fountain. Amazing homemade ice cream! Don't let the long line scare you away because it moves. The fastest, friendliest ice cream scoopers you have ever encountered are here. Service with a smile! Well organized & efficient customer service in a place that has crowds all summer long I'm sure. They have classic ice cream flavors & unique choices too. I went with the rainbow cookie after sampling several and it was fantastic! My kids got different flavored shakes and they were the best shakes I've ever tasted! Loved it & cant wait to go back! read more

What a delicious ice cream spot! Definitely a go to on your home from the vineyards! (Especially if you need to sober up!) Everything is also homemade! There are so many different flavors it's hard to make a decision! I sampled rainbow cookie, a bunch of stuff, and cake mix. The rainbow cookie tasted exactly like a rainbow cookie! It was probably the best ice cream I've ever sampled. A bunch of stuff was vanilla ice cream with cookie dough, Twix, m&ms and I believe fudge. It was good, but a little too sweet for me. Cake mix was vanilla ice cream with rainbow sprinkles and something else...but I can't figure it out. (Lol!) I went with this one because it wasn't as sweet as the other two that I sampled. It was delicious. The girl behind the counter was super sweet and knowledgeable about the ice cream. She answered all the questions that I had. The servings are pretty generous. They said a small is one scoop. It was more of a scoop and a half, and it was just enough! A kiddie is half the size of the small. I wish this place was closer to my house! It's hard to find amazing homemade ice cream places nearby. I will absolutely be returning. read more

See all

Delicious soft serve swirl w sprinkles. Great after a hard day of picking pumpkins. Never here enough to try all the flavors! read more

Magic Fountain - Soft serve swirl w sprinkles! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Mattituck, New York

Years ago we meant to come here didn't. Then again we were out there for our babymoon meant to come here but didn't. Our son is 2 1/2 we were at Harbes and I was like we are getting ice cream finally from magic fountain! Deliciousness. I also loved I could jump online order then swing by and grab it as we headed home. Honestly it's the best thing ever I kept joking how I help make my hubs life easier lol. He was the one going on. Anyway next time we're out here we'll be back. If out here you should obviously come by. It's not on all the amazing ice cream places for no reason. read more

Amazing homemade ice cream. They have so many flavors. This place is a must try if you're in the area. read more

Magic Fountain - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Mattituck, New York

Just stopped by Magic Fountain to grab a cool treat on a hot day... and thrilled we did! Three delicious ice creams later, and we are very impressed. The chocolate raspberry truffle was one of the best ice creams i've ever had, and the same could be said for the chocolate peanut butter chunk. If you love rainbow cookies, you have to get the rainbow cookie ice cream! I bet you'll be back for more! You can order from a window outside the building, or they'll call you inside the building to order. The large array of flavors are listed on a sign outside, in addition to the many toppings. The establishment as a whole is clean, the workers wear masks, and you enter one door and exit the other. Lovely experience and I highly recommend stopping by! read more

Magic Fountain - chocolate raspberry truffle - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Mattituck, New York

A staple on the North Fork. If you're in this area, you HAVE TO stop here. So many cool flavors. This desi girl at heart loved the roohafza, kulfi, and most desi flavors they always seem to have around. I love the inclusiveness. Means a lot to people who look like me on that part of the island. The ice cream is done right. They do not skimp on the mixing, and every flavor I've tried is delicious. It's a MUST VISIT IMO. It's the one cheat I allow myself, and It's totally worth it. Always the highlight of our trip read more

Been coming here since I was a little girl. This place has the best ice cream and they are so so kind in there!! Please come try this ice cream place! Its a local owned place and it shows! Its so yummy! read more

Some of the best ice cream around! Lots of flavors (some unusual but hey it's fun to be adventurous). Worth the wait or order ahead on app and pick up at the window to beat the long lines during the summer. read more

Classic East End Ice Cream place that isn't to be missed. Came here after the wineries. Place had a line out the door but it was well worth it. I got a scoop of the Cookie Monster Ice Cream and a scoop of the Chocolate peanut butter fudge. Both so good and of course had to be topped with some Rainbow sprinkles. So so good! read more

Magic Fountain - Cookie Monster and Chocolate Peanut Butter Fudge. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Mattituck, New York