Can't believe I had to find out about this place from a video about La Frieda steaks. I went to the store next day to get some lunch. There are street parkings available in front of the store. Inside the store, there's a beautiful small sitting area. There are few arcades available. The ordering station is far end of the store. I was so excited I ordered the cheesesteak, the sliders and mac & cheese bites. Gina was very friendly and helped me with deciding the order. Prices are good, 2 sliders for $13 and cheesesteak was $14. Took them about 10 minutes to prepare all the items. The sliders and cheesesteak were so good. The quality of La Frieda steak was so obvious. The yellow cheese, caramelized onion and buns, all of it complimented the patty. Loved the Mac & cheese bites as well. It was a unique item, haven't seen anywhere that I remember. They looked like nuggets with soft filling. I'll be back to try their burger and other sandwiches soon. read more

See all

Today I flipped a coin to see if I'd enjoy my favorite burger at Mel's Butcher Box or order it home. The coin tossed was to GO visit the restaurant Which was very nice, because today the town had a temperature of 23°C, delicious air, partly cloudy. I walked there. It helped me 'cause I did some exercise. It takes 23 minutes to go and 23 minutes get back home. Which is great, because that way I burn off all the calories from my burger . I ordered one Mel's Double burger and regular HOUSE fries with an ice-cold Coke. AMAZING FOOD!!! The place is always super clean. You can see people enjoy the place and customer service, just like I do. It's a place where I feel very comfortable, employees treat you warm and the food is so tasty. It continues to be my best burger option in the area. Excellent work to the entire team. My blessings again. Thank you so much. read more

See all

My husband wanted a really good cheesesteak and we've been having trouble finding one in the Bergen County area. He read about this place online so we decided to make the drive one Saturday to go try it out. We called it ahead of time and Mel answered the phone and was very friendly. It is very easy to find and we were able to get a parking spot right in front. I was surprised by the decor and how unique and cool it was when we walked inside. There is exposed brick and lots of Arcade style games. The place was empty when we arrived and our food was ready and Mel greeted us with a big smile. She mentioned how there is a karaoke night that she has often and that we should check it out. We ordered two sandwiches. One was the cheesesteak and one was the roasted pork. I preferred the roasted pork over the cheesesteak one. I thought the roasted pork was cooked perfectly and it had enough broccoli rob and cheese. It also had a great crisp on the outside, which I really liked. The cheesesteak the meat was really good and cooked very well, but there was some type of sauce on it that we did not care for that made it a little bit sweet. I don't know if it was worth the 30 minute drive to go there for the sandwiches, I'm happy we did go, but don't know if we'll do it again. read more

See all

If you're looking for the PERFECT place to host a private event--or just want the BEST burger, milkshake, and onion rings of your life--go to Mel's Butcher Block in Tenafly. Full stop. We recently celebrated my son's graduation here, and I can't say enough about how amazing the experience was. Mel and her sister, Gina, went above and beyond to make it unforgettable. We rented the entire place for a Friday night party with 20-25 food-loving guests, and every single one of them was raving and highly impressed - and these are foodies, (from - NYC, Brooklyn, the Bronx, Queens, Long Island, Greenwich, Philly, Chicago, Maine, Vermont, Miami, Guatemala, Romania, Israel and Egypt); all BLOWN AWAY. The food? Absolutely off the charts. - Perfectly cooked hamburgers, cheesesteaks, chicken sandwiches - Creamy, fresh Caesar salad and mac & cheese - To-die-for onion rings - Killer fries and even potato skins that were a surprise hit - And the star: a jaw-dropping Tomahawk steak with my son's name and "Class of 2025" etched into the bone--an unforgettable touch. - And the milkshakes, delicious, were next level Beyond the food, Mel is simply the best. She was responsive, creative, thoughtful, and a joy to work with. She helped plan the menu, presentation, and even set up music and decorations. She made my son feel like a star, and that meant the world to us. My nieces and nephews loved the vintage pinball machines, and the whole space had the perfect energy--cozy but vibrant. Gina was outstanding too - constantly making sure everyone felt welcome, well taken care of, and was having a great time. She brought such a warmth and energy, ensuring every guest loved the food and felt special. You can tell Mel loves what she does. She's passionate, professional, warm, and deeply committed to making people happy through incredible food and a great experience. This place is a gem--whether you're planning an event or just stopping in for lunch, Mel's Butcher Block is a 10/10. read more

Mel's Butcher Box - Burgers Near Me - Tenafly, New Jersey

See all

This was my first time trying Mel's Butcher box and I'll definitely be back! I ordered a bacon cheeseburger with a chocolate milkshake and a chocolate chip cookie. Everything was absolutely amazing! read more

Mel's Butcher Box - Bacon cheeseburger Chocolate shake - Burgers Near Me - Tenafly, New Jersey

The roast beef with melted mozzarella and gravy not rare as described bland dry taste. Tater tots and French fries overly salted

5 star! We loved the atmosphere and the food was beyond delicious! We had the sliders and sweet potato fries. Can't wait to go back and try more delicious food! The service was fast! read more

Mel's Butcher Box - Burgers Near Me - Tenafly, New Jersey

See all

My friend and I stumbled upon Mel's after our original lunch plans fell through. The service was quick and friendly. My friend ordered a cheesesteak and I got the Mel's Double with a side of mac & cheese bites. The food came out quickly and everything was very solid. My burger had a good amount of meat and it was seasoned well. The onions and sauce complimented it perfectly. The meat was juicy and it had the right amount of cheese on top. The bun wasn't my favorite but it was not bad at all. Overall a very, very solid burger. The mac and cheese bites were solid as well. Nothing mind-blowing but I definitely enjoyed. My friend was also pleased with his cheesesteak. The place is pricey but they serve quality food. I would definitely come back. read more

See all

A solid Pat LaFreida beef Burger. Cozy spot, and loved the two throw back videos games especially Burger Time. Fries ok, could do with more seasoning. Interested when we go back to try some of the other items but needed to go for the Classic so we had a baseline. Service was friendly and quick, but a bit overpriced for 2 Burgers, 2 Fries, 2 bottles of water for almost $50. read more

The burgers, the sandwiches, the chips fries, and milkshakes are all great love their place. But my favorites is definitely their giant chocolate chip cookies. read more

I will start with the Ambiance. This place is awesome inside!! Love the fun decor, colors, and extras! Decorated for Halloween love that! Seasonal decor is the best! Check out my pictures. Very clean too!!! You can tell the people running this place the pride in it. Love that! Service was really good and they are in a really nice location. The burger! I ordered a plain cheddar cheeseburger and the meat quality was so good! The burger was juicy and had a really good grill char taste! Love that they have different options for cheese and not just American cheese. Nice menu selection especially for sides. Not huge on fries so usually prefer tots which they had! They were really good especially the spicy mayo sauce. The burger also came with homemade chips that were thin and crispy. Pretty good and I am not a big chip fan. Oreo milkshake was decent and they give you the thick straws which is like because the cookies always get stuck in the thin straws so that's a plus in my book! I will definitely be back for more!! read more

See all

The burgers fries and onion rings are amazing. I had their food at a private party everything was fresh and amazing. Cant wait to go to their store and see what else is on the menu read more

Very good and I'd go 3 1/2 stars. Burger was delicious but my double burger bun cost Mel's a star compared to bun on my wife's single burger. Chips and fries were very good. We'll be back. read more

Holy crap is the food here amazing. Not only that, the staff are super friendly. This place wants you to truly enjoy their food, and they come through again and again. I bring all my friends here. read more

I just came across this fantastic spot just 3 minutes from my house. I couldn't believe I had not noticed this place before. My wife went out for a walk and noticed it so we went for an early dinner. The service was outstanding with the staff being friendly and welcoming. We sat in a nice looking booth decorated in really nice faux hide skins, and comfortable. The Cuban sandwich was truly delicious, using pork seasoned like my Puerto Rican grandmother made it. The sandwich was served with some home made chips and we ordered some sweet potato fries too, that were crispy and delicious. I had the pastrami sandwich which was served with some fantastic tasting slaw and mustard. It was so fresh and delicious I can't wait to go back to try some other items from the menu. This place uses Pat Lafreida meats which are the best cuts money can buy. They have a couple of pinball machines in the place and the design is quite unique which I like. The place is family friendly and is a true gem for some good food. A little expensive but you get what you pay for. I'm so glad they have opened a great place to eat near my house, since I was getting bored with my choices close to home. read more

See all

Best burgers in Bergen County! Mel and Gina run a fantastic business. I have lunch there a few times a month and every sandwich and burger are part of my rotation. Mel even goes as far as stocking amazing Pat LaFreida meats in her fridge and will often order me a brisket in a pinch. Shakes are worth the trip and the pretzel is insanely good. read more

Mel's Butcher Box - Gina packing my NY steaks, burgers, and some tomahawks. - Burgers Near Me - Tenafly, New Jersey

So the gal taking the order was super friendly and helpful. The food was fantastic and way too much without an army to finish. Go hungry. Located in Teanfly downtown district this cute little shop is the perfect balance of trendy and traditional. The cheesesteak was amazing. The friend mozzarella and homemade vodka sauce what my favorite. They have happy house milkshake flavors from 3-6pm Chocolate, Vanilla and Strawberry. The only reason I did not give them 5 stars is because it was a bit pricey. But loved the experience. read more

See all

Yum! The food was really good. The place is very small so you need to get there early if you want to sit and eat there. I will go back to try other burgers. read more

Great atmosphere, friendly staff, and killer food. I've visited Mel's on three occasions and haven't been disappointed once. All their food is top notch using the best ingredients. Everything has tons of flavor which comes from the toppings and not just added salt like other places. Fries are killer so be sure to try them. Can't wait to go back read more

See all

Gf and I just tried this place after finding it on Yelp. They recommended the burger sliders and the cheesesteak. Both were amazing, juicy and exactly what we wanted from a burger and cheesesteak. They also served us crinkle cut fries which were crispy and delicious. The chips were homemade and crunchy. We'll be back! read more

We had a great lunch at Mel's today. We had a salad, burger, and awesome pretzel. The burger was cooked to perfection, juicy, on a great bun. Salad was well adorned, delicious, and plentiful. Took home leftover salad, it was so big. Pretzel was also great. We will definitely return. Yummy. read more

Excellent burgers. Not quite smash-style, but not a pub burger either - somewhere in the vicinity of, but a little thicker than, Five Guys or Shake Shack. Special attention should be paid to the buns, which appear to be homemade, and are buttery and toasted - they remind me (in the best way possible) of the burger buns at Fuddrucker's. Mel's offers minimal toppings, suggesting that diners taste the meat rather than what is often effectively a salad on top of their burger. I appreciate this in principle, but in practice I feel a slice of raw onion and some pickles helps make something as fatty as a burger more enjoyable as it helps avoid "richness fatigue". Nitpick aside, this is easily as it good as it gets for burgers in the vicinity. read more

While visiting my brothers new home we decided to grab lunch at this well regarded establishment and boy did I make a good choice! We ordered a good portion of the menu and not a single item disappointed. From the classic hot dog to the ribeye cheesesteak and everything in between was delicious. I'd certainly recommend this place for great eats in Tenafly read more

Yummy lunch! Amazing service and fun spot to have lunch. Have been here more than once and always delicious. read more

Mel's Butcher Box - Delish chicken sandie! - Burgers Near Me - Tenafly, New Jersey

See all

BAD BAD SERVICE!!!! The manager is rude to the people who visit the place. I don't recommend the place read more

Mel's Butcher Box - Area - Burgers Near Me - Tenafly, New Jersey

This place is sooo good! Everything is delicious. The burgers are really good quality and the hot dogs were the best I've had in a very long time. The staff is very nice and helpful and the ambience is laid back and kind of retro.Highly recommend. read more

Fantastic burgers, personal service, BYOB. Get the double cheeseburger with bacon, and bring your own beer

AMAZING . Mel's double burger might have been the most delicious burger I've ever had. The burger was prime beef but the bun and the sauce really put it in its own league. So perfect. Everything we ordered was great. From the mac & cheese balls to the milkshakes. Do yourself a favor and do not miss this experience. read more

OMG delicious eats at Mels ButcherBox with Pat Lafrieda meats! Frickin amazin and friendly service with a fun atmosphere. I'm picky about my cheesesteaks having spent 4 years in the vicinity of Pat's Cheesesteaks in Philly...but Mel's may have them beat. Brooklyn's Best Chicken Sandwich was perfect cooked...crispy on the outside and sooo tender on the inside. Even the hot dog my daughter got was delicious. Bravo Mel...so far sooo good! read more

See all

We ordered the butcher box sampler online for $46 because we thought it was a really good deal. Unfortunately, we did not receive the onion rings or house fries as mentioned online. We called the restaurant and the person who answered stated that the sampler does not come with onion rings or fries. He said he would let his boss know about the error online. BUT if I would have just ordered the steak sandwich, chicken sandwich, and sliders separately, the total would have been $39. I am not sure if the restaurant is trying to deceive their customers or maybe the person on the phone was uninformed. Either way, this left a bad taste in my mouth which sucks because the sandwiches were actually delicious. read more

Mel's Butcher Box - Online order - Burgers Near Me - Tenafly, New Jersey

Overpriced.. it shouldn't cost $18 for a double bacon cheeseburger with a small handful of potato chips. I also ordered their "$5 special milkshake" but asked for Oreos to be added to it. I was fine with an extra charge for the Oreos. I was given a plain vanilla shake and told that if I wanted to add the oreos I would have to be charged the regular $10 shake price and then have the Oreo topping price on top of that. What? So they have no way to add toppings to the special drink price for a fee? Terrible. I will not be returning. The woman working the counter was very nice though she was just doing her job. read more

Everyday other Thursday (on pay day) my co workers and I order lunch. I stumbled upon this place as I always pass it coming to work. For some reason I always thought it was a steak house lol. So when we were looking up food places to order from, this place came up and it ended up being a burger spot (and I am a hugeeeee burger girl). We decided to give it a shot, some of us got the Mel's double, the rest of us got the cheese steak. Needless to say, everyone rated this 10/10. Fries were soggy when it got to us but I'm sure if we had it in the restaurant it would've been so crispy and fresh. Burger was soooo good, nothing special nothing crazy just a good ass burger with perfect caramel iced onions and their secret sauce. I have to try the mozz sticks and cheese steaks next time! read more

Mel's Butcher Box - Mel's Double Burger - Burgers Near Me - Tenafly, New Jersey

See all

We ordered multiple burgers and sides from Mel's and the food is good. Sure it's expensive, but considering that Mel's takes advantage of the affluent town of Tenafly, perhaps it's not such a bad deal. The vibe and decor inside also provide a nice ambiance. However, the service was abysmal... they did not honor a coupon/flash deal as advertised, and they also inadvertently left out a side order which was paid for. Mistakes obviously happen, which is understandable, but the staff (i.e., the two main ladies) were extremely off-putting and rude in fixing the order. All-in-all, if you like decent expensive fast food, then this place is for you... but if you're a snowflake like me and prefer not to deal with a staff that won't treat you with the respect and patience that you deserve as a customer, then there are better (and less expensive) spots out there. read more

New Burger place in the area. It was pretty good. The fries were delicious. The burger was good which comes with chips, but it just needed some kind of sauce, like what's on Mel's double burger. The restaurant itself is cool and quaint. We definitely will try again, just to try the speciality burger. read more

Mel's Butcher Box - Vanilla and Oreo shake - Burgers Near Me - Tenafly, New Jersey

See all

Food was amazing. Some of the best staff we have had. Very personable. Shared and still too much! read more

Mel's Butcher Box - Burgers Near Me - Tenafly, New Jersey

Holy cow.... I don't know how I've never stopped by here before. The food here is AMAZINGGG! The first time I stopped by was literally yesterday, I ordered the steak frittes (SO GOOD), my boyfriend ordered the prime rib sandwich and we shared the giant moz sticks which were to die for... today I had to come back for more. I was in the mood for a burger and ordered the butcher box classic and fries... YUMMMMM! Not disappointed at all, the service here is really friendly as I walked in as they were closing, she took my order no problem! They have games and nice seating I would give the ambiance a solid 10. I advise everyone to eat here!!! read more

Mel's Butcher Box - BIG MOZZ, Steak Frittes, Pats Prime Rib Sandwich - Burgers Near Me - Tenafly, New Jersey

This was a hidden gem in Tenafly the burger was amazing the pretzel was amazing and the homemade chips were amazing. We couldn't finish everything because it's so many carbs but we needed to try everything read more

If you have been eating the average to good burgers for a while, take one bite of a burger at Mel's and your tastebuds will remember what a real burger tastes like! Perfection in quality Fat to beef ratio Taste Freshness Texture Preparation Not full of salt , just the taste good beef. read more

Amazing food and accommodating to allergies! Small cozy atmosphere. Highly recommend!

We stopped just as they were closing. They were so kind to unlock the door for us and make us food. Super friendly crew and the food was fresh. They are super dog friendly for those looking for pet friendly places. Glad we stopped by. read more