Definitely my go-to spot for greek food. The chicken was seasoned perfectly, the pita was fresh, the lemon orzo soup A+, the gyros and falafels were delicious! The portions were big and everyone had left overs. The reason im taking a star is due to the front girl. She seemed to be very flustered and was a little condescending and eye-rolley, the person in front of me needed the dressing on the side and it seemed to be a BIG deal. Still, highly recommended and i will be returning for more of their delicious food! read more

Ordered a chicken souvlaki sandwich which was mostly salad and had 4 chunks of meat in it. I was extremely disappointed in this sandwich, it wasn't anything special. The salad ontop had a oil and lemon dressing on it. My husband ordered the gyro platter. Again nothing special, very basic. This was the least greek, greek restaurant. We wont be ordering from here agin. read more

Best around. Always consistent with taste and quality. Extremely reasonably priced as well. Never disappointed!

Little on the pricy side for a gyro. No lettuce on Gyro. They dont "hook it up" either even though I repeat often. Meats Dry...and over all forgettable. Place is a take out joint with only a couple of seats to sit. I would take my business elsewhere considering there are a few other Greek joints close by. If im eating greek food I want some greasy hairy guy behind the counter with gold jewelry and speaks loud. Anyone feel the same way? Maybe a random animal pacing back and forth while I wait. read more

Have been going here for YEARS. Lately I'm not sure if they switched owners or what, but every dressing is watered down, the chicken isn't the same and they skimp out on toppings lately. Not sure what happened but so upsetting! read more

Great, quick, and accurate service. One of my favorite Greek take-out restaurants! Dining area is a bit small, but since I typically pick-up my order for home, it doesn't bother me at all. The food quality is excellent as well. read more

Decent Greek take out place. Service is a bit slow because it's often busy so it's best to order ahead. They have minimal space inside to eat if you want to stick around but come lunch and dinner time it gets packed inside. Gyros are pretty good but the lemon and lentil soups are a bit on the salty side. It's a good place to order take out if you're craving a gyro. read more

Mediterranean Express - Gyro - Greek Near Me - Bay Shore, New York

See all

Was in the mood for Greek food on the way home from out East, looked on Yelp and found this place. It's takeout with a few tables. We ordered gyro and chicken gyro platters and grabbed a table. First came Greek salads and Pita, both very good. Then came the gyros. Honestly some of the best we've had. If you are looking for an inexpensive takeout or quick bite, you can't go wrong here. read more

It is a small store front restaurant, but don't let that fool you. The food is delicious, and the staff is very friendly. The portions are generous. My husband and I shared the saganaki as an appetizer and ordered the chicken islander as the main course, both to share. We left full and brought home left- overs. The pita bread was definitely freshly made and outstanding. I'll be coming back. read more

Greek Carryout does not get much better than this. As a plant based eater, I love their falafel, hummus, and baba ghanouj options. I simply just ask for the salad without the feta and without the Tzatziki Sauce. Their tahini is delish. read more

Abandon all hope ye who enter here. "Falafel" that looks like chicken mcnuggets and clearly frozen. Topped with a salad that two people couldnt even finish and containing no feta. Good garlicky dressing though, so there's that. My son had a "gyro" sandwich which looked, smelled and tasted like reprocessed dog food. Again, good dressing though, and pita on both wasnt bad. People who rave about this dump have obviously never had greek food. read more

I love this place, I order almost weekly and its always fresh. My favorite dishes are the spinach melt, souvlaki sandwich, and the chicken greek salad. The food is consistently good, they usually do my order correctly. Only once did I ask to have the meat cut up and they wouldn't do it LOL, so I never asked them again. The ladies there can be quite stern. The customer service is definitely hit or miss. So being just a pick up and go place works for them. I would never sit there to eat not even pre covid. It's not welcoming, but then again with the high volume they sell at, I guess they figured they don't really need to be nice LOL If they were nice they would get 5 stars. Shout out to the cooks!! I know those guys work their butts off. read more

Authentic healthy Greek food! Everything is always so delicious and there's plenty to go around. We love this place!

I have ordered from here many times over the years...I have always thought the food was satisfying for having a local Greek place to fulfill my gyro crave when I can't make it to a top choice place of mine, but the terrible customer service I received the other night will make it so I NEVER return. They close at 9pm. Around 8:30 I'm driving home from work (I am local and in the area mind you...) and call in a gyro to pick up. I ALWAYS order a gyro with the gyro meat sliced on the thicker side...any place I've ever ordered from, including here it has never been a problem. So, as I am placing my order the woman taking it keeps saying "WHAT!", "I DON'T UNDERSTAND WHAT YOU WANT!"...so I repeat...slowly...with an explanation..."I'd like a gyro with the meat sliced on the thicker side please...the gyro meat. Please slice it thicker." She proceeds to tell me they don't do that. I'm sorry, what??? You're slicing the meat off the spit so you can slice it as thick as you'd like...I asked her what she meant...she can't have the kitchen slice it thicker? No. I get annoyed and say forget it...but I REALLY was craving a gyro. So I call back and ask to order a gyro to go. No thick sliced meat...nothing. 2 mins passed since our last conversation, so now it's about 8:37pm. I'm on the way...she says about 10-15mins. At 8:50pm she is calling me (I'm up the street just about to be there) saying where am I...they're closed and they're waiting on me and I need to hurry up!!! First of all you CLOSE AT 9PM!!! SECONDLY, YOU SAID 10-15MINS!!! THIRDLY, YOU DO NOT CALL A CUSTOMER DEMANDING THEY HURRY UP BECAUSE YOU'RE WAITING!!! You're here for your customers and because of your customers....so, I told her she was absolutely ridiculous for calling me and being flat out rude...I told her to keep her gyro and just go home...now, I am in the service industry, and I completely understand how if it's a slow day you just want to go home, or if you've been busy all day and you're tired and want to leave...I GET IT! But, in this industry you have to suck it up and deal because good customer service is what keeps your customers happy and returning...you can bet after this I will not be... read more

Very good food! Everything we've tried on the menu we have liked. Call your order in ahead of picking it up b/c ordering onsite takes much longer. read more

I called in an order at 9:15... the website hours for Saturday was until 9:30. They refused my order... But I still love their food ... next time read more

Med express has great Greek salAds. Really love the chicken here whether it's in your salad or if you get say a slouvaki sandwich. They have a lemon chicken soup which is perfect on a chilly day! read more

Delicious Greek food! Awesome value, very consistent, and reasonably priced. If you love Greek food, you've got to go check them out

Too much white pepper in the spanakopita. It grabs you in the back of the throat. Not the first time the food eas spicey. The chicken Diana was also spicey. Sorry, never had anything cooked spicey when i was in Greece. It must be the kitchen staff taking liberties eithout the owner's knowledge. read more

The food is always delicious. Love the Gyro and Chicken Diana. Grilled chicken Greek Salas's are delicious as well. Tip ask for dressing on the side as sometimes salads swim in it. read more

This place is really great when I'm craving Greek food, but don't feel like making the drive out to my favorite spot in Commack. The food is always fresh and delicious. It's reasonably priced as well. Try the chicken islander, it's amazing! read more

Passed this place for years and only recently decided to go in and try it... since then I've been back nearly half a dozen times. The food is always fresh, hot and extremely scrumptious! I normally get the chicken souvlaki without the vinaigrette (which is amazing btw!) because I prefer to drench it in their yummy yogurt sauce. I could honestly guzzle that stuff by the gallon! It isn't runny and isn't too thick, it's just right...goldilocks style!!! :-) The other gem here is their greek salad! The feta isn't overpowering, but also isn't bland or tasteless like it tends to be at many places when it isn't overly strong. The dressing is the same way. The perfect compliment to the fresh ingredients they use and not overdone. My girlfriend got a gyro platter last time and the lamb was fresh and crisped on one side just the way we both like it! Yes, I ate almost all of her platter because I'm a glutton. But she still loves me anyway. The rice that came with it was seasoned tastily and very moist. The portions are generous for the price as well. Staff is extremely friendly and courteous as well. I had to take a phone call one day while waiting for my order and instead of letting my food languish on the counter, the young woman behind the counter kindly brought it outside to me when it was ready, which I appreciated greatly. There are a few tables inside as well if you're looking to stay, which I recommend because the food comes out of the kitchen piping hot! I'm so hungry just thinking about this place after writing this review that I'm headed there right now to stuff my face lol. Do yourself a favor and check it out if you're in the area and have a hankering for some Greek food. It's well worth it! read more

USED to LOVE this place and been going here for at least 10 years and a few times a week, but they must of changed owners and chefs because it has not been the same for at least 6 months. If you knew their food you know it's not the same! So sad. Their dressing and yogurt sauce not the same, the Greek salad completely different now its just generic tossed salad with a couple little blocks of feta. If you ever had it before you would know the difference just looking at it. The chicken used to be so good. Now I don't even know why they bother. Their spinach melt now has disgusting oregano sprinkled on top which is such a strong taste that messing the entire thing up and the frozen watered spinach now in it equally gross! It used to be the same like 3 to 5 different girls/woman who worked there (possible related) and now just young girls so I KNOW it's new owners but they keep denying it. I will be looking for a new Greek place as this food is so not worth the money anymore. So disappointing! Definitely find a different Greek place to eat!!!!! read more

Excellent food, never disappointed! Big fan of Greek food and this little piece of heaven is perfect!

Small place but super nice people. I usually order the falafel greek salad with the dressing on the side it comes with a pita bread and tahini sauce. I've also had the falafel platter and it's soo good. On days I feel wild I get baklava, last time I had the chocolate baklava. Omg! read more

I've tried a bunch of different things on this restaurant's menu, and here are the dishes that I can wholeheartedly recommend: 1. The Gyro Sandwich (much better than any other in a 20 mile radius). 2. The Hummus (better than most, anywhere). 3. The Greek Salad. read more

Love this place!!! Food cook fresh to order. So order if you are impatient, but always worthwhile.

Heard friends raving so I checked it out. Sorta run down looking place with faded art on the wall. I got a gyro that came out with decent authentic gyro meat (compared to the fake gyro meat at a diner) but that was the highlight! No lettuce, yogurt sauce was ok and three randomly chopped pieces of tomato. Considering they have a very small menu, I would expect the gyro to be amazing and it wasn't. Took a while as well and I was the only one there. Update the inside, print nice menus and ask more questions when people are ordering so they know their options. read more

Truly love this place! Have been eating their food since they used to have the old restaurant Aegean east, it was delicious and the food here at this spot is equally amazing. Have known the owners forever and they are so awesome, friendly, and great cooks ! Elaina makes the most amazing split pea, potato dill, Yankee bean, and avgolemono ! Try them all (all soups aren't listed above those are just some of my personal favorites) I usually call before to see what soups they have so I can plan what else to order along with it.. Also, the spanikopita here... To die for... Creamy deliciousness spinach mixture stuffed in phyllo dough flaking everywhere omg. I'm marrying a Greek and he's been around the real deal Greek food his whole life, he loves the food here. I highly recommend ! Strictly take out unless you are dining with 1 or 2 people.. They have 4 tables inside with 3 seats at each table and a waiting bench... Reasonable prices as well.. read more

See all

Love this little Greek spot. Great Greek salads. Add the chicken, it's awesome. I think the best part of their salads is their dressing. More garlicky than most, but so so good. Their gyro is also very delicious as is their baklava! Very friendly inside as well. Typically a take out place however there's a table or two in there should you decide to sit. Quick service. Definitely recommended. read more

Excellent Greek food - we always order and pickup the food. Gyro Salad is my go to and my family like the Gyro Platter & a Chicken platter...always good! They have been around for years and consistent...recommend read more

Absolutely love having a neighborhood Greek joint as good as this one. The gyro is fantastic, the chicken shish kabab is delicious. If you like mushrooms, the chicken islander is a must. read more

Everything is homemade and fresh! Im got a falafel sandwich aka gyro and it was amazing. It had fresh ingredients. I got it to go because I work at a local hospital near by but when opening the foil I was greeted with an amazing "salad" on top and was pleased with the dressing . This was filling and delicious! I highly recommend this to anyone interested in greek food or even quick delicious food. It was around 7.35 but it was a high quality meal. read more

Food is decent, but have definitely had better. Their meat portions are small for the price and their dressing is nothing special.

Salads are always fresh and proteins always good! I have been going to them for abt 10yrs and when I get on a kick I'm on a kick, ordering like 3x/week for a month, lol and that number dbls when I'm pregnant, had 3 children in the past 10yrs, so do that math. They have made 2 minor errors and fixed them above and beyond the error. Customer service is always good and that counts for a lot. I'm writing a review today because frankly it's about time, but truly I went in today and ordered 2 salads and had some stooopid (lol) requests, basically this and that on the side, but keep this on the other salad and xtra of this because I want this held. They made my salads just as requested (eating some now). This is why I keep going. I have always gotten into a squabble or two, three.... with places I frequent for food (it's bound to happen), and I usually return after a cooling period (maybe a yr, depends on how good the food is). This is one of the places that I have been frequenting the longest and never a squabble, not even a squibble (I have never been slightly upset with them). read more

My family orders takeout from here about twice a month and it's consistently good. Platters are nice portions and I've never had an issue with freshness. read more

Love the food here but it's a little pricy. What annoys me about this place is their food takes forever to cook and their customer service sucks. I would go there a lot more often if it weren't for the latter two. read more

Mediterranean express has decent gryo 's love their sauce the place is clean and staff is friendly . The Slovakia is very good the gryo meat was a tad bit dry , however they put way too much onions in there gryo. I would good back and order again however on a Friday night i suggest ordering early it gets busy . read more

Prices have adjusted for inflation, but the food is still great take-out. Instant gratification, and the baba is still the tits. Love that little kick of spice at the end of the bite. Service is great -- fast, friendly, and cheery. Place is clean, and even with the increase, item rates are still better than fair. The two thumbs on this gal still point up! read more

I prefer the Athena in Amityville. Small but a real restuarant. Salads always great and owner usually on premises to ensure consistency. Love all dishes. Chicken pandora although seems an odd combo is so great married together. The lamb shanks are incredible. My tip is: Dine in on a week night as weekends are crazy w/long take-out. OR order take-out on earlier side during week and set your table for a special home dinner! read more