I am consistently impressed with the service, cleanliness and food quality at this location. Not sure why star rating is as low as it is. I went with a friend last week and tried the Chicken N Dumplings for the first time. Very good! read more

McAlister's Deli - Pick 2 Southwest Salad and Chicken n Dumplings - Delis Near Me - West Lafayette, Indiana

Ordered the Savannah Salad online for pickup. Went inside to pick it up. Restroom was clean. Salad was ready to go.... and it was beautiful!! Thanks for the great service! read more

McAlister's Deli - Loaded Savannah Salad - Delis Near Me - West Lafayette, Indiana

When you walk in the door, you're greeted with people that are smiling and welcome you to the business. The waitresses are wonderful, and the food is outstanding. The soup was very good! read more

Delivery French Dip sandwich didn't come with au jus. I paid for delivery... so now I'm supposed to drive to the store to pick up sauce?

I ordered a soup + mac & cheese. The food itself is okay but it was pretty pricey and the portions were not that good.

This is a cute place for lunch. The food is good and the service is fast. Mac and cheese is bomb!!

Why have I never noticed the Memphian on the menu? What a sandwich! Piled high with turkey, ham and Angus beef, with melted cheese and brown mustard on a hoagie bun. I sunk my teeth into it and it was so amazing. The cheese had just the right amount of melt. The meats were warm and tender. The hoagie bun had just the right texture. I think there was tomato and lettuce on it but they were superfluous to the heavenly meat covered with melted cheese. At first I wasn't sure I could eat all of it but I couldn't stop and finished it off. This is now among my all time favorite sandwiches. Long live the Memphian! read more

I've eaten there for years. I've gone though getting a nice pile of free standing potato chips to a pathetic bag of Kettle chips. From a decent serving of potato salad on my plate to a premeasured little cup. They went from having a big jar of pickles to serve yourself to giving you a pickle spear if you asked. But now it's a little two bite pickle chip at best. Ridiculous. read more

McAlister's Deli - This is what they now are calling a pickle spear. Two bites and it's gone - Delis Near Me - West Lafayette, Indiana

I ordered extra chicken salad... paid and extra $1.35 I believe and this is what my sandwich looks like. This is the second time this has happened. Just sad. read more

McAlister's Deli - Delis Near Me - West Lafayette, Indiana

One of my favorite national chains finally getting another location in the area, the mobile app is smart and intuitive offering all the great ways to customize items especially triggering my fancy with able to load up sandwiches with spinach and peppers, the rewards program is wonderful, and this location boasts a fresh new building and friendly staff. I ordered takeout with the app getting the reuben and a Southwest sandwich both made perfectly and loaded up on moist and savory meats and veggies. Both were enjoyed by me and a few others within the hour for dinner, like seeing paper based take out boxes! Much better for the trees and water cycle - definitely an easy fast food option for West Lafayette knowing they can get properly cooked ingredients on a large menu. My mom loves the huge spuds! I'm stuck on the chili and broccoli sides especially as few places offer a healthy side menu. It's all good to go here and real fine to dine in. read more

See all

Went here for to-go at 6:00PM on a Wed. Place was dead. Ordered my food- while waiting could easily hear a loudmouthed employee (manager?) complaining about a large returned delivery order. Got my order- you guessed it -wrong food. Returned it to manager- (same one) and she had a very negative attitude asking me to repeat my order 4 times. Got the remake- no pickle. Don't go here if you actually expect to get the food you order read more

Every time we come here the service is terrible and so super slow. The workers are very unorganized and seems to need better management. The plate my food eventually came on was dirty and didn't have the usual paper on it that comes standard at McAlisters. Horrible experience every time we come here, so we just drive to the Lafayette location instead as they are so much better. read more

I love their savannah chopped salad and will order again but my order was completely wrong the last time I visited for carry out!

Soo.. I was hired at McAlisters in Plainfield in early March. WHERE AND WHO I LOVED WORKING WITH. but then I moved back to town and started at the West Side location which was built the same month I started in Plainfield. I came home & I was very open with my managers at both jobs, (McA & Yata) about my last year, my therapy, & my situations at the time. I tried to contact many people about the people in charge of this store because especially at the time and the regional manager Amber did nothing. Then her boss Tom came when he heard that one of the managers was talking about how she pictured all of us NAKED & how we all had SEX. (In better wording.) the stores attitude depended on the assistant manager most times. The text message screen shots tell them all. There was so much that happened including them selling expired meat. If you wanna work with children go to one of the elementary school cafeterias. They will know how to manage & lead people more and what's right instead of thinking they're your minions. At first it was all fun and games until it wasn't. -Cutting hours for going to higher ups -Refusing my day off for therapy due to a "black out" schedule that was never mentioned -management is petty and refuses to talk to you -after I didn't show the day I had therapy *refer to allison and Nicole's screenshots* -they will give you the silent treatment while at work -single you out -rules that apply to those they don't like -the GM screaming at the assistant manager calling her a bitch in front of a group of toddlers & their parents *refer to Malik's texts* -never sending my W2s -most of the other employees didn't speak up because of how they saw the management treating me when I was put as the face of texting upper management (which originally was never me but I never corrected them because I could take it) -Never even told me about my employment or my status. -My mom is the DON of Bright Star told her girls not to eat at the West Side location and a couple weeks later 2 of her girls did and they got sick from it. read more

See all

Excellent restaurant. Clean and friendly staff. Food is nice and very good portions served. read more

McAlister's Deli - Southwest Chicken & Avocado Salad - Delis Near Me - West Lafayette, Indiana

Even though there was a mishap with my order. The manager Neil and staff were more than willing to make it right. The food was delicious and after everything got resolved I couldn't be happier. Can't thank the manager and staff enough for their service, especially in today's times when the service industry act's like it is an inconvenience to give you what you have paid for. Thanks again for your professionalism, much appreciated! read more

Sunday, lunchtime: One person behind the register taking orders; line of customers all the way out the door.

Disgusting. When a customer orders a salad, their simple expectation is that the greens be GREEN and not BROWN intermixed with slimy signs of deterioration. First time at this location and very likely the last. read more

I patronize the West Lafayette McAllister Deli when I want a sandwich. The last three times I have ordered, the order was wrong. While waiting today for my takeout order, a sandwich and salad to go, I counted three orders that had to go back because the order was incorrectly filled-not including mine. This establishment has jacked prices, but the service is less than stellar. The cooking group can't read. The only reason for giving three stars is that the food is generally fresh. I recommend that if you order takeout, before you leave, check your food. It is better to find the problem before you leave than to deal with the problem at home. One more thing. I gave up telling them not to include plastic utinsels; but today they sent an unwrapped fork with my order. Who knows who has touched that fork. read more

I like the food a lot. But the service here is slow and almost every time my order is wrong -- they leave something out or give us the wrong food. Workers at the pickup window are not very friendly. Now we usually only go if we have a coupon or gift card and we don't expect to get what we ordered. read more

Slow!!! I placed an order a 5:20 to be picked up at 7:30. I arrived at 7:38 and my order was still being made!! I gave them a 2 hour heads up! I finally got my food at 7:50! The restaurant was dead....people who were walking in were leaving because the cashier told them the wait for food due to so many online orders. I would rather drive to the Lafayette location!! It's sad because WL needs a good deli type restaurant but this is definitely not it! I am done coming here! read more

service was awful. they all seemed annoyed and we sat at this place for 20 minutes before they came out and asked if anyone was missing anything. then when we told them that we were and they took their sweet time to get it out to us. read more