If you're looking for a delicious deli add McCalister's to your list. They offer a wide variety of soups, sandwiches, and spuds,with drinks and sweet treats also available. They have dine in or carry out. I went with the pick 2 option, which is perfect for indecisive people like me who can't quite choose what to order. It allows you to mix and match 1/2 portions of some of the original entrees. I chose a spud and salad combination. For the spud, I went with the Honey BBQ Pork Spud- a baked potato loaded with pulled pork,honey BBQ sauce,green onions, cheddar-jack cheese,and butter. To make it even better, I added diced tomatoes and grilled chicken. Everything was fresh, and the potato was mouthwatering. It looked so good I started eating and forgot to take a picture. For my second choice, I picked the Chef Salad, which came with mixed greens, black forest ham,roasted turkey, bacon,cheddar-jack cheese,diced tomatoes, cucumbers and croutons. I went with the buttermilk ranch for the dressing. Once again, the ingredients were fresh and the sald was delicious. The portions are sizeable, so depending on your hunger level, you may have leftovers. A great place to add to your lunch rotation. read more

McAlister's Deli - Chef Salad - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Great lunch. Fabulous tea. I have never had a bad meal. Service is fast. Try the desserts.

McAlister's has been a go to deli since 2009 for me, more specifically this location. Service was great, the parking lot is shared amongst several other businesses therefore cluttered, & the outdoor patio is CLEAN! I am giving this visit 4 because both mine & my daughter's sandwiches were cool and our soups were not hot. The choose 2 ( 1/2 sandwhich & cup of soup) is perfectly priced & a great amount of food. read more

McAlister's Deli - Choose 2 - BLT+A and Chicken Tortilla Soup - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

The food was good, and all family members found something they liked, from the kid's mac and cheese to soup and salad. Service was quick, but no curbside service anymore, must go in to pickup. When I have children, I'll have to stick to drive-thru somewhere else, but if on my own, I would still go here. read more

I had no idea that they renovated McAlisters. They now have a self-serve for drinks (except lemonade). I was able to secure my birthday treat. They no longer have oatmeal raisin cookies, but they do have lemon blueberry. I ordered a pick two with a veggie sandwich and veggie nachos. Of course, it was good. The lady taking my order was super helpful and patient. She even wished me a happy birthday. Plus, when they called my name when my order was ready. She said my name right. So, of course, I was happy. I didn't get to take any photos because I was starving. But make sure to check out the new renovations. read more

While in town I have stopped here 2 times in the first 24 hours so far and I'm sure I will be a few more times 4.5/5 star rating -1/2 star because staff is not the most friendly bunch but not bad either Out of all the McAlister's I have been to this one is by far the best when it comes to the food and average for the staff read more

Anderson, Indiana's food really sucked. I've been there twice since they opened up twice. Were there baked potatoes dry?The food on the baked potato was hard.The cheese was like rubber. My roast beef sandwich was burned. It was so hard and the burnt tasted so nasty. When you go to a place and spend this kind of money you expect good food.There's no excuse for this food to be burnt hard and looking like it's been sitting for days. read more

So the good and the bad of tonight's dinner. Lets start with the bad. When we got to the curb side carry out area I called and the phone rang at least 15 times before it disconnected me. The spinach on my club looked awful and past it's shelf life, so I removed it all. The amount of chips we got with the choose two was seriously a joke. It was less than half full small clamshell container with lots of broken chips. The good. I didn't have to cook. Once we got thru on the phone it took less than three min to get our food. My club was a King Club and did have a great amount of meat. The baked potato was great with a good amount of cheese and bacon. County potato soup was neither good nor bad just ok. For some reason the location on Meridian ,which is closer ,was already closed at 6pm tonight. read more

Take out only November 2021 because no staff available for inside dinning. So we ate outside. Excellent Sandwich and soups. All around very good. Would of like to eat inside but the food was excellent. read more

McAlister's Deli - Take out only. No staff for inside dinning. - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Can they cut back anymore, ordered the ultment nachos, pretty much h a plate of chips with very little toppings. Not a fan, too many other good.places.to eat. read more

I ordered 2 loaded spuds and they where horrible. First the potato was so dry and they hardly put any toppings on it total disappointment. The service was not so good either I ordered this online I live 5 mins away I go to the to go register and the lady was so rude rolled her eyes at me when i told her i was there to pick up my to go order. I use to love the atmosphere of this restaurant but this will be my last time going. I do not recommend going to this location. read more

I was pretty excited to see a McAlister's Deli since I ate out often at college back in TX. Ordered the gigantic sweet tea and had the roast beef cheddar. The protein was quite thin and I understand the inflation factor. Glad I got a soup too otherwise I'd be hungry after the sandwich. read more

my food was great I ordered table side and the young lady avi was supper polite bringing my drink she asked how my day was even though it wasn't great that made it better a guy axel delivered my food and he was awesome great customer service I will be back ordering from table side I love this play thanks selinsgrove team yall are the best read more

Service was really good. The manager and staff were very friendly and helpful. They really made an upbeat environment. The food was ok. The spud was dry. The toppings had an ok flavor. It definitely needed more broccoli and cheese sauce. I added grilled chicken and would definitely skip that next time. The chicken is thinly shaved rotisserie flavored. read more

Good food. Messed up my takeout. Best ice tea around. Very good salad but would have been better with the dressing they left out.

Should have took the warning when there were zero customers here on a Thursday night at 7pm. Food was horrible. They acted like we interrupted them going home early. Would not recommend this location. read more

Their online presence as well as their door says they're open until 9 o'clock yet they are closed at 8 o'clock. Pretty annoying when you drive all the way here to get food and you've checked online and you see the door says it as well and they don't even bother to change the door saying it's closed. Try to support a business and they act like this. ridiculous! And will advise others not to come either. read more

McAlister's Deli - Mcallisters lack of following their own hours of operation. - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I went into the East Washington location grilled chicken queso cheese. 5 to 6 people came in after me order their food waited and left. I say something to the cashier about my order. She's unsure of what's going on and the girl who's preparing the food just yells from the back it's not ready yet. Why not I've been here 30 minutes only to find out we're ready. Not even sure if they've even been started only to be told that I just have to wait..... trash service. read more

I visited today with about 18 other family members about 230 pm. Found the tables and the long booth at the back of the restaurant. I am going to assume the lady with the Blue polo shirt with glasses on is some sort of manager. She was helping us decide if we would be better suited out of the way of traffic on the other side or to just stay put. We decided to stay. This lady went out of her way to make sure we had everything, all the kids were happy, and talked to each of us. Such a wonderful experience we had. Glad we had this lady to interact with us today. read more

Food was awesome, service was the best, I had trouble with my card and Victoria helped me! Super nice lady. It was busy but not busy enough to help. Everyone was smiling, you don't find that normally. Loved everything about it read more

This is a continuation from my earlier post. Mccallister didn't refund me my money. Instead they used the Money that DoorDash sent them, that was supposed to be for my order. Bottomline, Mccallister didn't provide great customer service and refund my money back as agreed, instead DoorDash did. Senita L read more

Very dependable chain for a casual lunch. We stopped in this location while on the northwest side. Our order clerk at the counter was energetic, informative, patient and efficient. We selected two salads - the Savannah Chicken salad and the Grilled Chicken salad - and a side of Mac & cheese. Salads were well portioned and excellent. Mac & Cheese - Tami's 'crack' food - was creamy and flavorful. The food was brought to the table using the numbered order cards displayed on a stand. Roving staff checked on us 3-4 times and were very upbeat and friendly. read more

I usually am a fan of McAlister's however today I visited McAlister's off Michigan rd and it was not as good. I had the chose 2; avocado chicken salad which was good with the exception of brown on my avocados. I love my avocados pretty with no brown or black! Whatever dressing that is, it is really yummy! Then I also had the chicken Caesar wrap which for some reason was extremely salty‍ Then my daughter got her usual spicy southwest chicken grilled sandwich with chicken tortilla soup. The chicken tortilla soup was really salty‍ these are items we get on regular basis just at a different location. So not sure what's up with all the saltiness today. To drink I had the un sweet tea, my favorite! read more

See all

I really like this place! It's a good go to when you are looking for something to eat and you don't know what you want. It's also a great place for those picky eaters and if your bringing the kids along! They have a large dinging room with table and booth seating and a large patio with a shade cover. They have all the typical soups, sandwiches, and salads as well as nachos, and amazing spuds with great toppings. I have never had a problem with any special requests or additions. My favorite feature is you can pick two smaller portions of menu items if you can't just decide on one. They have AMAZING iced tea with free refills! Their quality is always consistent. Beware of the carrot cake! You get a piece large enough to share and it's super yummy! read more

McAlister's Deli - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

We ordered two pics. Club sandwich & maxi spud. Massive portions even though it was only a half order. Sandwich was delicious and filling. Potato was hot with a range of toppings. Service was courteous and fast. Will return. read more

I'm giving 5 stars to a 3 tier carrot cake! It's delicious!!! Totally recommend to anyone that wants real carrot cake. Oh, and 5 stars for the unsweetened iced tea too! read more

Back again for a business meeting and they screwed up again. Me and the 3 behind me didn't receive our orders. Everyone behind us in our group got their food and have since finished eating and here we are still waiting for our food. The food showed up on our receipt but apparently not on their end. The manager handled the situation a little better than she did last time. And brought the four of us cookies for our trouble. The food came out hot but me and one of the other gals they had our spuds mixed up. read more

Overpriced!! it feels like McAlister's is on its way out of business. None of the restaurants' Wi-Fi service works, but they still have routers active, so it highjacks your phone or computer but does not give you Internet access. you have to shut off Wi-Fi and go with cell connection. the food has gotten VERY expensive for what you get! the one I went to today was even "out of spuds". I thought that was supposed to be their signature item. I ordered a choose two with chicken dumpling soup and half a french dip sandwich. They charge an EXTRA $1.50 if the half sandwich is a French dip. So for $15.73 I got a pretty meager sandwich, a cup of soup and an iced tea. I think McAlister's just got itself removed from my lunch rotation. read more

Today my coworker and I stopped in for lunch. All the people were friendly and cheerful. The one who stood out, who I found out was a lead, was Lisa. Her concern for and care of all the guests was visible to all. Her dedication and passion as someone with a servant's spirit shines and brings a joy to all who come in. Thank you Lisa for such a wonderful experience. read more

Went to the Greenfield store tonight ordered a club and potato salad. I was going to stay and eat there but the big guy behind the big window has a raw mouth. I am not sticking around a family deli for that. read more

McAlister's Deli doesn't miss with this hearty meal at all! I was a starving Marvin and getting real mannish and thought I want something filling that isn't fast food but made timely. Plus I wanted to sit down and eat. That's kinda hard with the presence of Covid-19 rules and regulations. But I enjoyed this place with all the cleanliness and social distancing. Plenty of room to sit outside as well. Plus they give you the largest free water cup I have ever seen! Good stuff McAlisters read more

McAlister's Deli - The Biggest & Best Free Water Cup Ever! - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

I love eating at McAlister's either I'm eating there, or I'll order delivery using the Door Dash app. When, I do order from McAlister's I get the same thing which is Justaspud on that giant spud I get bacon, cheddar- jack, butter, and sour cream. That's so delicious, and very fulfilling too. For dessert I get either a sugar cookie, or chocolate chip cookie. read more

McAlister's Deli - Justaspud with bacon, cheddar Jack, and sour cream on it. Yum - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Gather around friends...let me tell you how this location has ruined my McAlister's experience SEVERAL times... Now don't get me wrong - I absolutely LOVE this place. The best sandwiches, salads, soups, spuds ever. I seem to have the best luck at the Fishers locales - but I'll have to review them separately to give them 5 gleaming stars. Now back to my story..well, one evening I decided to stop in with my husband to grab something to go. It was not a busy time, not many people were there. We went to the counter and placed our order with the young lady at the register. If you're unfamiliar with McAlister's, they have an option where you can "choose a Pick 2" (soup/salad/sandwich) combo for somewhere between $6-$8 depending on your choices. I chose that option and my husband chose a spud, sandwich and we had two drinks. When the young lady cashed me out, the order was close to $40. I didn't really pay attention to the cost until my husband made me look and realize that was way too much for what we ordered. Not to mention that I never was given an itemized receipt, and when I asked for one it was like I asked for all the tea in China. When I went back and let the cashier know, she proceeded to re-enter my entire order one by one into the register to make sure it was correct...but it took her about 20 minutes for her to get it right. 20 minutes!!! I was literally standing there helping her add up the cost and continuously reminding her of what we ordered. It took her manager to come out and redo the order, refunding my debit card by at least $10 and straightening out the mess. I was literally not even hungry after going through that ordeal. Did I mention that the young lady said to me (after all of this is done), "I apologize for the mistake, I'm only 16". What???? I love McAlister's and still will frequent it but this location has frustrated me with that particular experience plus other instances of my orders being wrong and items missing. read more

I saw 2 toothpicks in the sandwich, one on each side. IDK if someone thought it was funny or what, but there was a hidden third toothpick inside one of the halves that I cracked my tooth on. Thanks. read more

I just have a suggestion; I walked in to have lunch and as I was ordering noticed that one preparer scratched her head. (Did she wag her hands) and the other food preparer in back was eating or grazing. Not sure if she washed her has or had a break time. I was put off by this unsanitary act. It hard enough having to adjusting to the fact that people are not wearing mask while preparing food etc. I guess in todays world businesses have to take whim ever will come to work and the consumer just has to deal with whatever we get as we support businesses. read more

I love these restaurants when I'm craving a fresh deli sandwich with nachos or a baked potato. The cheese spud is amazing and gooey! The ultimate anchors have all the best fresh toppings and amazing cheese and chili too. The best sandwiches I recommend: New fresh turkey on multigrain bread Turkey Cobb sandwich The Cuban sandwich And the Chicken salad sandwich!!!All great choices. The complimentary pickle bar with crackers is always nice while you wait too :) read more

I used to love avon in mcallister. Not so much anymore. They are overpriced, asking for tips, and food has gone down hill. Boycotted it for awhile but decided to give them another shot. Ordered ultimate nachos not only did the reduce the toppings but the nachos were so stall I couldn't eat them. Told counter girl nachos are stale. Her response sorry but that. Blacklisting. read more

At first, I didn't see what the big deal was, but I appreciate that you can customize just about anything on this menu, and I like that online ordering is simple, easy, plus you can calculate the exact amount of calories and macros of what you're eating, even if you sub something out or add extra of something else. Their broccoli cheese soup is delish and keto friendly. I usually get the grilled chicken salad when I forget my lunch. I work nearby. I haven't dined in, but when I do an online order, I pickup from the pickup station and it's always ready super fast. I appreciate them being here and staying here as many other places nearby have left because they couldn't survive the pandemic. I work at a nearby hotel so I'm sure a lot of our guests with kids dine here. read more

The worst service I've ever received. They overcharged but just told us they didn't know how it happened. Even the manager who refunded us did not apologize. Won't visit again read more

We visited the McAlisters on 86th street, across from Keystone at the Crossing. It was disappointing, to say the least. I ordered a veggie sandwich but was told they couldn't make it because they were "out of veggies." Okaaay. I ordered a grilled cheese instead, and stressed that I wanted just a grilled cheese because I'm a vegetarian. We waited approximately 15 minutes for our food and they brought me a ham and cheese. I said I'll just have a bowl of tomato bisque but was told they no longer it at that location. Sooo.... while my husband ate his French dip (he liked it) I had a pickle. (We stopped by Jimmy Johns on the way home so I could get a sandwich.). I had also ordered a slice of the advertised banana butterscotch pie but was told, you guessed it, they didn't have any. We won't be back. read more