While I've never actually been to the store front, I do want to rave about their catering/delivery services! We frequently order from here for work events and they food is always on-time, set-up for us, and gets great reviews from the guests. The cookies and brownies especially are a favorite (and the vegetarian options too!). It is a little more pricey, but the sandwiches are a higher quality than the ones from Panera (or at least, that's our opinion). read more

I tagged along with a friend through the drive thru. I'd never been to a McAlister's before and also didn't know one had opened up in Speedway. The area has changed quite a bit! It appeared clean. There was no wait in the drive thru on a Saturday afternoon. The female staff member at the window was efficient and pleasant. It was pretty cool to find out McAlister's has a tea pass for around $10 with unlimited refills for the entire month. Nice if you're into iced tea. read more

I had a really nice experience at this location with my friends. I wasn't wanting an entire meal, so I opted for a kids meal. The kids meal was huge! It came with a loaded potato, a side, and a cookie! The service was so fast! My friend had gotten a tea, and the employee filled up her tea at the table- wonderful service! read more

McAlister's Deli - Kids potato - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Eaten here often as we live close. My favs: chicken salad, pecan berry salad, M'c's club, carrot cake, and tea... Oh and you can't forget the spud. Only a handful of restaurants still offer baked potatoes... Hubster goes for the grilled chicken options & others. We luv going to the other famous deli downtown whenever we get a chance, but it's more affordable here. read more

Tried the Sweet & Savory chicken sandwich with BBQ chips and loved it! The sweet tea was excellent, prices were reasonable, and the restaurant was clean, spacious, and not too crowded. Would definitely visit again. read more

McAlister's Deli - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

QUICKIE REVIEW Good sandwiches. FOOD This is what I tried: -grilled chicken club Went to an event that had box lunches from Mcalisters and tried one of their sandwiches. This thing hit perfectly and was still fresh. Bread was not soggy, and there was just the right balance of all the ingredients. PARKING NA SERVICE NA PRICE NA TIP/OTHER THOUGHTS Sandwich was so good that I wouldn't mind going there and trying out the restaurant or having them deliver for an event of my own. read more

McAlister's Deli - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

I love McAllister overall. They did not mk my order right on last visit and took a bit long to remake which was frustrating but I'd still go bk as long as this isn't the overall experience each time read more

The inside of this deli is gorgeous! Must have just been redone it is very modern and large inside. The bathrooms were also clean. The people working were kind and quick. I got a veggie spud and the potato was cooked to perfection. I was not a fan of the cheese sauce that came on top... it was a weird bit spicy??¿ read more

McAlister's Deli - Veggie Spud - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I placed an order and it was made wrong. I spoke to a manager about it was supposed to get replaced. So I reordered my food and explained my situation to the Male manager.Told him I thought I was left a VIP card. Manager went in the office and came out saying there wasn't one for me then explain that they get a lot of people trying to get free food at their location so he needed to check into it. I described the other manager to him and I said that I knew he was there that day so he wanted to go check one more time in the office to see if there was a VIP card. He already told me there wasn't one so I didn't understand why he was going back into the office by this point a lot of time has went by. He left again and never came back out. I had to go back to work because I only had a half an and I was gonna be lateso that day I got to work at 12 hour shift with nothing to eat all day. I literally would've paid for it if it was that big of a deal just so I could eat. When I was there, the young girl working told me he was the GM. read more

This was a take-out order. I ordered the Loaded Spud. IT WAS AWFUL! It simply didn't taste right. It tasted like it had been warmed in the microwave multiple times. I only ate about 1/3. The next day I was sick as a dog. Contacted the restaurant. The manager was so nonchalant about it. He offered me a free dessert which I did not go pick up. He attitude made the situation even worse. I will NEVER go to a McCallister's again. read more

We were able to grab something for a soccer game quickly and with confidence from the app. It was easy to use and then gave us the option for drive up, which we chose so as to head to the game. Everything was prepared with taste and flavor and we loved our sandwiches. Our cousin immediately ate his Mac n cheese and toastie so was energized for the big game! We would go back and love being able to have options for good for you salads, sandwiches and other things. Plus their tea is yummy! read more

Not sure I'll be visiting this location anytime soon. Well to start they didn't give us any pickles with our sandwich which is OK but they will be asked it's almost 10 minutes for them to come back. Then we asked for one to go container when they brought it to the table the inside was wet. I took it back to the counter. I swapped it out and they gave me another one that was also wet. Very confused. Also when I pickles finally came to the table, the plate that they were on was covered in some type of gravy I said it wasn't clean. I hope that this was just the one day that they were off their game because I feel like I should've went somewhere else to get lunch that day. read more

McAlister's Deli - Dirty, dirty plate - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

This location is huge! In addition to 2 dining rooms and a patio, they also have 2 glasses in rooms you can reserve by contacting the manager. I went inside to order right at 10:30 when they opened in a Thursday. I was the only customer but they still greeted me right away and I got my order quick. Looked like they also had a drive-thru so you have multiple options for ordering. They also had a cute IndyCar display right outside the front door since this location is near the Speedway. Very cute! read more

McAlister's Deli - Chicken Salad Sandwich - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

First, I want to say I have the best bestie ! She took me on an outing today that landed us at McAlister's Deli ! Neither of us had ever been, so it was a new experience for us both ! We both got the pick 2 deal. I got a cup of chili and half of a horseradish, roast beef, and cheddar sandwich ! I also got a sweet peach tea to top it off. This was the perrrrfect meal ! The chili was absolutely spot on. Not a very spicy chili, but definitely full of flavor. And that sandwich ! I think I'm going to be dreaming about it for awhile. The sauce is what brought it together. The ordering process was super simple, kind of a fast food set up. And they bring the food to your table, which is a plus. I'd say it's a little on the pricey side for the amount you're getting. But the food is definitely worth it ! read more

McAlister's Deli - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I really wanna like this place but I just can't. First off.. Waiting a line and hearing an employee drop the N word ..(I am a person of color btw)..unprofessional. Secondly,the gentleman who took my order just could not get it right. Even after I told him exactly... He added oil and vinegar to something that made no sense. Thirdly, I ask for a sandwich And told the gentleman when I ordered. I wanted everything except for bread, condiments and all. The first time they gave me the sandwich as listed with the bread.. Then I had to wait another ten minutes just to get them to fix it and had To go back and ask for the rest of it. This took way too long for me to get my food. Especially when they weren't busy enough for that to even be a issue. And I'm disappointed that all these things occurred. read more

I didn't feel like cooking anything! I wanted quick but delicious food. So i decided to order me some food ol' McAlister's. I did the mobile order and it was such a breeze!! I was a bit sad because i didn't see the chocolate chip cookies on the desserts part. Those cookies are my fav! Big and soft. Yum!!! ignore me. I'm greedy But my order was ready and waiting on me. It was close to closing so.. no one was really in there. The restaurant was nice and clean and the staff was friendly. Thank you guys i would recommend this location!! read more

See all

I ran over here to grab something to eat while my dog was at the emergency vet. I forget what restaurant was here before but this is very nicely decorated. The girl taking my order was not listening to me at all. I specifically asked for the pick 2 either the club no cheese. She then asked what side. Uhhh you don't get a side. She says oh you wanted the pick 2. My food is done. My iced tea is no where around. I realize I wasn't charged for it. I offer to pay but the person just apologized and gave it to me. Chalk it up to they were focusing on closing. Overall the food was good. The salad was a great size for a half. read more

See all

Today I stopped to get lunch at this location. The service was fast and the food was tasty. However, the great personality and helpfulness of a staff member made this experience. After going to get my pick up order (after I ate my meal inside), I thanked Phyllis for the great experience and her help, assuming she was the manger. Phyllis was fantastic! She told me that she was a new employee and actually not the manager. This wonderful woman has a leadership demeanor and customer service excellence that the company should celebrate. We will definitely return and hope to see Phyllis next time. read more

Have come here many times. Not expecting perfection, just a decent sandwich and salad. I understand where I'm going so I don't believe I'm getting filet Migon or anything. But today, the sandwich look like it had been wrapped by a toddler and tasted "off." My daughter and I got the same thing and agreed it wasn't right. Then we shared a salad, but could only do a few bites because the sandwich was not sitting well on our stomachs. They forgot her side and no pickles. The place was empty when we walked in. For the cost, I need to at least not feel sick when I'm done and get all the food I paid for. read more

friendly staff. Please was clean. Got my food fast . Love the tv room........ Restrooms clean..

always a good meal every time i order from them. particularly like the broccoli cheese soup and potato salad.

Stopped in for lunch with a few friends. Haven't been to a McAlister in a while and this one has not been open that long. It's clean and bright inside and was not too busy when we arrived. I ordered the veggie sandwich with chips and my friends got the chicken salad croissant with broccoli cheddar soup. Our food was good and the service great. We did sir and chat after we fi ished our meal. They didn't mind and didn't asknus to leave which was nice. Woukd visit again though they are limited on vegetarian options. You just have to customize your meal to meet your needs. read more

I am an avid fan of McAlister's and have previously rated this location high, but I'm highly displeased with the service I received tonight. This location forgot the Mac and Cheese for a kids meal AND gave us bbq sauce instead of the fat-free peach dressing we ordered with our Savannah Chopped Salads . Highly irritated and disappointed. If 0 stars was an option, that's the rating I would give it. read more

McAlister's Deli - Savannah Chopped Salad with BBQ sauce - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Great deli food. the service is excellent. May have to wait a bit to order during lunch rush.

First off I just asked my best bestie and we decided to go to mcallisters to grab some grub. The food was alright but really this review is about my best friend. Isnt he cute??? read more

McAlister's Deli - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

We like to order from McCalisters... we like their food... and they deliver in our area for lunch -- BUT THEY SCREW UP THE DELIVERY ORDER EVERY TIME. There is really nothing worse than an office full of people... making an order spending more than $100 -- $20 or more of which is their "convenience fee, delivery fee" and then the tip -- and someone doesn't get their food... and the rest of the people eat in front of the others. McCalister's never makes it right by delivering the correct items... they say oh you can bring your receipt in and get your food... or get a credit for another time etc.... All not convenient at all... no refund of the "convenience delivery fees" --- and then there is the one person going hungry or thirsty because they don't want to really eat half of someone else's lunch. You would think for a $100 lunch for 4 or 5 people... it's not filet mignon... they would try to get it right once. Again today... forgot someone's drink and side. Sure wish we had more options in this area... we would definitely kick this location to the curb! read more

We love McAlister's because of their healthy options and we came across this location that's newly built and very clean. They are friendly and quick, too! I like to get the McAlisters club wrap, no mayo though because like I mentioned above we appreciate the healthy options they have and I always get the side of fruit or steamed broccoli. Both are good but the fruit is a slight up charge. My husband loves the sweet chipotle chicken sandwich and he also gets fruit or broccoli. We have tried the Mac and cheese and it's okay but not great. I am Mac and Cheese's biggest fan so I am pretty picky about it. read more

Brand new in Speedway. Everyone received a free meal today. It is bright and cheery and the food is fresh and fantastic. All the staff are friendly and excited. Their official grand opening is Monday October 28th. A great addition to Speedway. read more

McAlister's Deli - Delis Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Awesome dining experience. The service was exceptional, even as the store was crazy busy at the time. The food was above and beyond expectation. Every team member we had an encounter with was friendly and very accommodating. Very clean environment and the food was awesome and came out exactly as ordered. Will definitely suggest this speed9way store to friends and family. Thank you for a great experience!! read more

This is a brand new McAlister and it proved to be awesome. 1st off I ordered online and they order was complete correct. They confirmed the ordered once i arrived and gave my name then she showed me the order promptly got my teas I ordered with extra ice. I Stated i needed the order by 6:15pm online and it was ready!! I hope they continue the prompt efficient customer service at this speedway location! read more

Ordered to go (postmates) last saturday and it was bit a good experience. It was a club sandwich but it was just mostly vegetables. The packaging was not good as well it was so wet when delivered. The mac and cheese did not have taste. It was unfortunate. read more

I love McAlisters so when my husband told me they were opening in Speddway, I couldn't have been more excited! I order using the app all the time and just pull up to the drive thru to which my food is always ready and hot! Keep it up!! read more

Our group of 6 in for lunch today. About an hour ago. All had a variety of everything and was real good. My rueben was for sure. All said their soups were excellent. read more

McAlister's is great! The food is tasty and the service is always dependable, professional and friendly. The menu always has a good variety to choose from for everyone in the family and I love their tea and salads! The app and the website are both easy to manage and order from. During these busy times I need a restaurant that can do all that and deliver and they even do that! read more

Worst McAlisters in the Indianapolis area nobody is working literally nobody-- first trip 20 min on food i was informed-- 2nd trip pickup through app still waited 30 min --- 3rd trip was told 40 min on food ... why stay open even??? read more

Good food Good portions but a little over priced for a sandwich shop. But the best part is their LEMONADE... Buying it by the $8 gallon now... read more

Yum Yum Yum!.. I just picked up 2 BLT's since their so delicious with the Herb Mayo and a side of potato salad. I'll want another for dinner I'm a regular. Their customer service is so.... Great!. The 2 male managers are so... professional. James and I forgot the other ones name but while James was on the register the other manager took was outside going to each car to check and bring out their orders which made the line wrapped around the whole building disappear! Now that's great customer service when you care enough to get your customers on lunch in and out so they'll have time to eat. They've always had good customer service. The one in speedway is magnificent!!. And don't take my spot either read more

I just happened to pass by the Speedway area Saturday(11/23) late morning around 11ish. That's when I discovered McAlister's restaurant, and I've been saying for a few years there needs to be a McAlister's in the area. Since, the area has been growing from 2015-2019 Ross, T. J. Max, and Five Below in the area. Well, this McAlister's is bigger than the ones I'm used to going to. The first thing I noticed was that it's very spacious, so far everyone was pleasant, professional, kept coming by the tables checking on customers, and there are plenty of outlets at new restaurant tables. For, lunch I had the same thing as always when I go to McAlister's just spud with their cheddar jack cheese, bacon, sour cream, and butter on the giant spud. It was so delicious, hot & fresh even the last bite was still fresh and hot. Oh! I had one chocolate chip cookie along with the regular lemonade. I must say when the Indy 500 comes back next year it'll bring McAlister's at Speedway location BIG business since it's so spacious, in great booming location, and it's very close to the Indy famous tracks. Also, the new restaurant opened on Monday October 28th, 2019. read more

They knew I received a survey at the start yet no one came to my table to check on me or offer tea refill. The 8 kids behind the counter were having too much fun yelling over the loud music and laughing. Survey asked me if a manager visited my table while I was there. What manager? read more

When you order a bacon lettuce tomato and of avocado sandwich with no tomato BUT they decide not give you the avocado either for some odd reason Funnier is you order it through postmates because you are home sick and they tell you you can come down and get another sandwich if you want. I would a been there in the 1st place you morons if I wasn't homesick...UGH!!!!! read more