1. Matthew's Hallmark Shop

0

Poughkeepsie, NY

Cancel

Open app

Search

Matthew's Hallmark Shop

2.3 (4 reviews)

Services - Matthew's Hallmark Shop

Gift shops

Cards and stationery

Matthew's Hallmark Shop Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Matthew's Hallmark Shop

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

12 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 3
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Helpful 4
Thanks 0
Love this 3
Oh no 0
Photo of S W.
0
1
0

2 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Am F.
0
62
3

9 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Matthew's Hallmark Shop

You might also consider

Sierra Lily - All you want from ALEX AND ANI is here!

Sierra Lily

(18 reviews)

$$$$

A unique Gift Shop that smells divine. You can find a wide assortment of beautiful, handcrafted,…read morejewelry, arts, mid to upscale, accessories, household items, and clothing. If you're bored with online shopping and can't find a decent retail shop nearby, check out Sierra LILY. Keep your eyes open because there is so much to see. Give yourself at least an hour to browse and they do encourage browsing. Friendly staff, the owners, lovely and well behaved lashed dogs are welcome. They have a beautiful pet Parents section, including handmade treats, accessories, and more. And you won't get bored no matter what the season because the inventory is constantly being updated and changed. If you find something you love, buy it because it may not be there tomorrow. The value for the shop is in the experience and the quality of each purchase that you make which will become a family treasure. Jessica is always smiling and so helpful!!

I happened to be in Poughkeepsie for an dr appt and I remembered a store I had shopped at in the…read morepast, Sierra Lily. I decided to drop in because there were a few upcoming birthdays I had to buy for, and they have such a great, varied selection of gift items. I bought several things- a piece of jewelry, sweet treats and a gorgeous handbag- so I was done with shopping for three special people in my life, in one place! The team there is very helpful and they even gift wrapped everything! I'm so glad I remembered they were there! I will be back again. Thank you, ladies!!

Dreaming Goddess - Spiritual bath

Dreaming Goddess

(38 reviews)

$$

I LOVE THIS STORE!!! Seriously LOVE IT! The people who work there are wonderful! Rhianna is so…read morewarm and so knowledgeable! I love watching her LIVE shows on Facebook and finally went to the store and I'm hooked! I know I will be back again (and again). I love collecting crystals and found so many that I love in her store. I literally went in to pick up a couple of items and left with a bag full of treasures that I made me very happy! They carry everything you could think of from cards to crystals, to beautiful jewelry, candles, clothes, and just about anything you could imagine. So uplifting! I could easily spend a couple of happy hours there! Love the location too! Next door to a great coffee shop, a bakery, and tons of wonderful restaurants. My friend and I literally made an afternoon of our visit there, with a great dinner around the corner (thanks to Rhianna's great recommendations)! I can't wait to go back!

Owner likes to complain to Yelp when Yelp reviewers post true things about their experience with…read moreher and/ or her business in general that aren't positive, and then she gets Yelp to delete the reviews she thinks are most going to deter people from coming to her store. Owner replied to my first review I posted this week by denying our experience at her store, gaslit me and told me she was going to ask Yelp to delete my review because it was damaging to her business. Sounded like she was having a melt down over the truth getting out. I noticed after that 3 people conveniently posted on the same day positive reviews when her listing on Yelp never gets too many Yelp reviews in a short amount of time, let alone same day. Very Interesting. She must've told her employees, friends, clients and/ or followers about my review and asked or manipulated them into to feeling bad for her and going in to leave more 5 star positive reviews to boost her rating back up. Owner is damaging their own business by how she treats some people as if they're more trusted to shop there than "others" who look a certain way. Take some accountability and deliver a better customer experience to ALL people who come in and haven't done anything wrong, especially repeat customers.

Matthew's Hallmark Shop - giftshops - Updated November 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...