I needed to have a catalytic converter replaced. I went to pick up my vehicle, walked into the…read moregarage with a check in my hand. Talked to another person about getting my car, instead of saying hi can I help you, he said " NO CHECKS ". Had no idea so I paid with a credit card only to find out that there is an addition 3% charge on top of it. I had diagnostics done at 2 different places prior. The car was running fine when it was dropped off. I start the car and discover that the engine is running rough, and the check engine light is still ON! Was told that the problem was an ignition coil was bad. I didn't get more than a few blocks from the shop and a pry bar extension fell out from under the car! Now I have to spend more to fix the issue. Would not recommend to anyone I know. Highly Disappointed!!!

From the owner: Small up and coming auto and collision repair shop with 20+ years of experience here for all your…read moreAuto & Collision repair needs.

I had an excellent experience here. Walked in to get a pre-purchase inspection for a car I was…read morebuying down the street. The receptionist was kind, the inspection was quick, and the detailed report was thorough and helpful. When I got in the car, there was a bag of cheez-its and a note on the dashboard, which was a nice touch. Wish I lived closer to use their services for future maintenance.

Great service. Great crew. I had them work on my cars in the past. I moved out of the York area…read moreyears ago. Drove back to York just to have Fadeley's service my Honda. I find Fadeley's to be honest and fair and of course friendly which is why I came back. Thank you Bret.

My 2018 F-150 quit on me about 1/10th of a mile from Complete Auto Repair & Service. I was able to…read moreget it started and avoided having it towed by going there instead of my usual repair shop. First time I'd been to Complete Auto. They were outstanding! They let me know it was going to take some time to ID the issue and fix it. They helped me find a rental car. They kept me informed of progress. They explained the options and downstream implications for each one. My truck runs like it's brand new. They talked to me like they knew I could understand what they were saying. And I didn't need a second mortgage to pay the bill. They get my vote for auto mechanic for life!

I first used Complete Automotive Repair and Service for routine service on my 2022 Subaru Outback…read more They did PA State inspection, brake flush and CVT Service. Every step was documented (with photos). The price was very reasonable considering their level of professionalism and their obvious attention to detail. Las week they did the Inspection on my 2025 BRZ. It was fast, efficient and fairly priced. To be honest, they have a "Boxerhead" on staff (who drives a mean little WRX) and that added to my comfort level. Blair is the service manager and he is a genuine gearhead. He spotted the mods on my Outback and we spent at least ten minutes laughin' and scratchin' and talkin' about sway bars and such. I can't say enough good thing about this place when it comes to Subie service.

We love Joe and his wife. They're always so kind to the Hanline family. They always give us…read moreamazing, affordable service. We come to them for all of our services.

Can't thank them enough for being open and able to get an inspection done during this pandemic…read more One less thing I need to stress over. Greatly appreciate it and glad I was able to support my local business.

Great service. Courteous staff. They replaced my tire the day after Thanksgiving in less than an…read morehour. Alan L.

I have to admit I haven't driven the car (Volvo C30) yet but all seems OK. I went there with this…read morecar because I got tired of the Volvo dealer giving me a list of unnecessary repairs and/or replacements as long as my arm every year. Last year when I went for inspection I was given a list of recommended items which totaled over $1200. Brooks/Huff looked at the car's age and mileage and realized that a 15 year old car that has only a little more than 43000 original miles isn't driven hard and even the rear brakes that the Volvo dealer said "last" year needed replaced were OK due to limited use. A car I replaced during the last year had many visits there during the years I drove it and they did a great job every time.

We were on the way home from Maryland and traveling through PA in a heat wave when our air…read moreconditioning died. We drove to Monro and even though it was so busy Kevin got us in right away and saved the day. The customer service was great, and they fixed our air conditioning in less than an hour! Kevin also gave us water bottles because of the heat, so it was a great experience and everyone there was so kind and helpful! Highly recommend. Good people at this place.

These guys are great, personable, professional, polite and thorough. They care about the…read morecustomer, want to provide top notch service, and save you time and money.

Friendly people and great service. let me know everything that was going on and loved the pickup…read moreafter hours they have lockers To get your keys.

The employees are so nice here, quick to respond, very trustworthy and won't try to bs you. Highly…read morerecommend.

I've taken all my cars to Andy's since I've moved into the area. He and his team are always honest…read moreand fair, and Andy never pressures or upsells you. If a repair has to be done now, he says so. If it can wait, he doesn't twist your arm to fix it immediately. Very budget conscious. It's rare to find an auto mechanic you can trust. Andy and his team are terrific.

Andy's automotive is hands down the best you will ever find! Friendly staff with every visit…read more They are honest and fair with pricing! Love them

Great service! Had a check engine light that 3 shops could not resolve. Witmer was able to find a…read morerubbed through wire that was causing the issue the whole time!

This was my second visit to this shop. I had a good experience with my inspection last year, and I…read morewould absolutely make that known if I had received the same level of service this time. Unfortunately, that was not the case. I recently brought my 2008 vehicle in for an oil change and tire rotation. Immediately after receiving it back, the shifter felt rough and misaligned in a way it had not before the service, and it gets stuck. Because the issue appeared immediately after the vehicle had been in their care, I contacted the shop and reasonably expected them to inspect it as a courtesy before asking me to pay approximately $120 for a diagnostic evaluation, which they required. I was not demanding that the shop automatically pay for a repair, nor did I expect them to diagnose an unrelated shifter problem during an oil change. I simply wanted them to investigate a new issue that appeared immediately after their service and determine whether it could have resulted from how the vehicle was handled under their care. Instead, the owner's response focused on the vehicle's age, mileage, unrelated recommended maintenance, and prior hood damage from a deer accident that occurred in 2018. None of those things explain why the shifter suddenly felt different immediately after the service. The response also unfairly suggested that I was only trying to obtain a free repair and refused to consider any other possibility. That misrepresents both my concern and my intentions. I had planned to return for the other recommended services, including the state inspection, until this happened. Had the shop simply inspected the concern and handled the situation professionally, my review could have been very different. I have no problem acknowledging good service when I receive it, as shown by the fact that I returned after my first visit. This was my experience with Witmer Auto. Rather than investigating a legitimate concern that arose immediately after service, the business shifted the focus toward unrelated issues and made assumptions about my motives. I will not be returning and believe other customers should be aware of how concerns may be handled when something appears wrong after service. Update: After I raised my concerns, the business contacted me by voicemail at approximately 5:07 p.m., after closing. Later that night, at approximately 11:55 p.m., the owner sent me a private Yelp message accusing me of planning to "defame" the business, stating that I was "making a fool" of myself, and telling me, "Call me tomorrow or my attorney will be calling you." I found this late-night communication hostile and intimidating, and it further reinforced my decision not to return or negotiate.