Really good pizza! A little salty for the Greek goddess, but still enjoyed it. The pizza is a nice crisp thin crust and the small is the perfect size for one person, or an appetizer size to split. The interior is very sparse in regards to decorations but still not bland or overly cafeteria like. Service was as quick as it could be for pizza baked to order. Not overly warm friendly couple working, but not cold either. Worth a revisit if looking for good pizza in the main drag. read more

Martolli's Pizza Sisters - Greek Goddess. - Pizza Near Me - Sisters, Oregon

I'm the one who doesn't eat onions. I have been a regular customer at Martollis for quite a few months now. They have great pizza. Last night I picked up my usual large pepperoni for the family only to find tons of red onions on it. I explained I wouldn't order onions as I am allergic to them. The woman at the counter came back with, "there's onions in our sauce." Perhaps I should of have explained more on how red onions rip up my stomach and cause digestive issues but I thought the word 'allergic' would sum it up without going into detail, my bad. She argued with me about the onions before finally offering to remake the pizza. When I got home to my guests who were looking forward to pizza night, I was so embarrassed by how burnt the pizza was. You win, but you also lost a customer. I hope burning my pizza on purpose was worth it. But hey, at least you got another bad review. To the woman who works the front, lose the attitude and get yourself some valuable customer service skill. Seriously, the way I hear you speak to patrons and the way you spoke to me last night, I'm shocked people still order from you. read more

The crust is crispy and hand tossed the sauce is good. The cheese pepperoni and olives match very well no too much not too little .It was not busy so we got our pizza really quick. They also have the dippin dots . Cute little place off the strip in Sisters . Price is not too bad. I would recommend checking them out if you love pizza. read more

See all

Inconsistent....makes HUGE mistakes and blames you...and to rectify those mistakes, THEY BURN THE SHIT OUT OF YOUR PIE! Keep relying on tourists and you'll never make it here. Take the locals seriously and be successful. Right now... Domino's would blow you away! read more

Martolli's Pizza Sisters - Their idea of customer service - Pizza Near Me - Sisters, Oregon

Great pizza! Meat lovers and my daughter got a gluten free pepperoni. Both were great. Staff was amazing! Stop by and give them a try when you are in Sisters! read more

Martolli's Pizza Sisters - Gluten free pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Sisters, Oregon

See all

My husband and I stopped in tonight on our way home to the valley. We've never been before but we will certainly be back. We got the chicken bacon ranch pizza and it was the best pizza I've ever had. The crust is to die for and they don't skimp on any of the toppings. We will come back for sure! read more

Good food and friendly service here. Tons of by the slice options, don't judge me for the pineapple on pizza! read more

Martolli's Pizza Sisters - Pizza Near Me - Sisters, Oregon

They messed up my order last week. Instead of offering to make it better they didn't. Very rude of them. Then this week I show up at 7:30 on a Saturday for take out and they said they're closed. Hours state 8pm closing. Who does this on a Saturday night. Screw me twice but never a third time. No more business from me read more

excellent pizza with tasty and generous toppings making a small perfect for two hungry adults

Great pizza for lunch!! Wife and I stopped for lunch and we were very happy. I would stop again.

Honestly the best pizza I have ever had. The service was amazing, not too busy. And they had gluten free pizza slices as well! Did not take long to get the food, and the garlic knots are worth a try. The place is not huge, but it has good vibes. The pizza is very greasy though. The slices are very big though, so come here when you are hungry. 10/10 Fire pizza. read more

See all

My three positives and a negative because the world needs more positivity: + plenty of choices for pizza by the slice (it was a Wednesday though the week of the Sisters outdoor quilt show) + the cheese is a solid New York style thin crust + the recommendation to add Mike's hot honey was solid - $1 for the honey seemed a bit deer read more

Martolli's Pizza Sisters - Classic Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sisters, Oregon

Caesar salad dressing was tasteless. I had to make my own when I got home. Seems a bit$$$ too for some romaine, a slight sprinkle of Parmesan & croutons. Pizza was okay. Pesto sauce was barely visible. It was one of the main ingredients. Paid extra for tomatoes & extra garlic, again very scarce. I miss the old thinner crust too. I was giving it another chance but I think it failed especially for the price. read more

The pizza was expensive but great. Staff was not personality +. The ambiance is typical pizza joint. I was freezing the whole time but others seemed to be okay with the temps. I would eat the pizza again but as take out. read more

Hand tossed with overflowing toppings! An amazing staff! Super clean! Wish we had found this gem sooner. read more

Food was delicious and they accommodated our group of 20 with kindness! The staff was epic!

Great food, great service, very generous servings. Loved the minestrone and pasta primavera!

The sweet marinara sauce is the perfect complement to the top notch meats! The customer service is amazing too. read more

Martolli's Pizza Sisters - The outlaw supreme - Pizza Near Me - Sisters, Oregon

Every year when we come to Sisters for basketball games we order pizza for the teams. They are timely, well organized, and courteous. On top of that the pizza is delicious! Thank you for your service to the teams traveling through! ​ read more

Food 6/10. The pizza was very greasy not much distinguishing flavors, the pepperoni was mid. cheese was good mozzarella. Almost zero red sauce, only located by the crust. Crust was nice, crispy, floppy, but held shape when folded. It's also $1 for every extra sauce, which kinda pricy. Service 3.5/10. Cashier had an attitude for no reason. Literally took the money and gave us no information. We waited for ~35 minutes even though we were the only ones there. We had to bus our tables too even though it's stupid expensive. Ambiance 7.5/10 no good pizza smells inside, which gave off bad vibes. Pictures and tree designs on the lights were a plus. Bathroom was disgusting and wafted into the restaurant. Really expensive and is lucky it's the only pizza restaurant in sisters read more

Quality ingredients, excellent crust, loved the hot pepper infused honey. Definitely will be back. read more

Martolli's Pizza Sisters - Outlaw Supreme Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sisters, Oregon

Pizza is good and plenty of toppings too! Staff has always been friendly. I do recommend them.

Just remember that Sisters is a small beautiful little town with huge quantities in every aspect of what life has to offer. A close little community with huge hospitality. Ok so another place I stop by when I'm in sisters oregon is this little pizza place with a very big pizza. To me pizza is all about the crust. Anyone one can make the top of the pizza taste good but If the crust is hard or soggy then the pizza isn't any good to me. You can order a slice or the whole pizza. I've had them both ways and ate it all and I was like over full. They are friendly and the Salad's are good. So far I've eaten all of the salads I've had there. Another place to stop by and eat good pizza, salad and cheesy pizza balls. read more

I so recommend it! The pizza is so good and fresh. Lots of varieties. The cheese bombs are super good too.

The pizza has good flavor. However, the whole pizzas are undercooked. The staff at the counter are rude, and seem as though they would rather not be working. read more

I had to pre trip a bike ride in bend but found a camping spot in nearby Sisters OR. Didn't really have time for a big dinner so I stopped at the first pizza shop I walked past. I ordered a small with extra cheese and Italian sausage. I provided pictures but maybe I should not have. This pizza wasn't that easy on the eye. That being said,the first bite quelled my initial disappointment. Flavors were all there. Sausage a little spicy. That was nice. Plenty of cheese and the sauce was not over the top. Definitely will come again. read more

Martolli's Pizza Sisters - Sausage and extra cheese - Pizza Near Me - Sisters, Oregon

See all

OMG I am the biggest snob of pizzas !!! The pickle pizza was literally the best pizza EVER! (You need to love pickles - but all you baby daddy's out there better buy your mama one ). Pepperoni- awesome (I save one bite for that ) cheese bomb was bomb and the garlic knots were sooooo yummy !!! It's worth a trip - out of your way. I'm not kidding read more

I was craving pizza the day I was taking a class over at the quilt shop in town and found out that this pizza shop was just a short walk across the street. The service was very friendly and the pizza was delicious. Loved it. I'll be back. read more

Love the cheese stuffed dough balls. Pizza is always good. Love sitting outside and enjoying the ambiance of Sisters

I'M not a huge fan of pizza and very picky when I do eat it so 4 **** is lotsl We order white saucy veggie. it was Sooo good!! we have it game nine read more

Toppings were good, crust could use some adjustments. Salad wasn't fresh for the cost plus they only gave 2 small dressings, then wanted to charge me .25 for each additional container after spending over $100. Staff was nice, tight inside to sit and eat. read more

Service was good. Nice person working hard in a hot kitchen. But friendly. I wanted the food to be amazing, but it was average at best. The pizza was so oily it was dripping, sauce was sparse, pepperoni was very thick sliced which is not my favorite. Unfortunately, for the price, it was not good enough for me to go back. I can get an average pizza at Dominos for a third of the price. That being said I don't like dominos very much. I was hopeful, with that Italian name, but ultimately let down. read more

The pizza here is so good!! Reminds me of New York style pizza for sure, lots of flavor in the sauce. It's cute inside too and they have dippin dots :) read more

Martolli's Pizza Sisters - Margherita Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sisters, Oregon

See all

We enjoyed our veggie pizza. It was flavorful and the crust was good. They have several veggie pizzas to choose from. We are a little disappointed though coz they don't have any chili flakes or Parmesan cheese that pizza places normally have available. Hopefully it was just for that day. We'll comeback whenever we are in the area. Worth trying again! read more

Martolli's Pizza Sisters - Pizza Near Me - Sisters, Oregon

Good pizza and salads for our labor day weekend dinner! For three people, we got one large salad, one small salad, and one medium size pizza. Their salads were so yummy! We tried the Mediterranean caesar and house salad with a balsamic vinaigrette, mmm!! Our pizza came out about 10-15 mins after ordering and had the crunchy get chewy crust that my husband and I are always searching for. We love thin crust pizza and this pizza met our expectations. Our "samoan" pizza had pepperoni, Italian sausage, pineapple, and ham. Their outdoor seating is on the main Street that runs through Sisters and it was nice to have a dog water bowl provided for our dog to drink from while we ate. Service was friendly, make sure you bus your own table! I'm glad to have tried another place in Sisters since I pass this town often from Eugene to Bend area. read more

See all

I've never left a review but this is the best pizza I've ever had, better than my mothers back home. I'm a total food snob and this place has my heart. Sauce is rich, cheese has flavor and good texture, loaded with fresh properly cooked toppings and creative combos are available on the menu. The price is a huge steal and the portions are huge. The crust is perfect, right amount of crunch and density. Not to mention, these people put so much love into their business and a ton of effort. They really care about their product. read more

Martolli's Pizza Sisters - Cowboy Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sisters, Oregon

It was pure love that was put into this simple pizza that we had. cheese and a pepperoni pizza both were excellent awesome just simply beautiful also they had a little snail twist garlic bread that we tested it to was a thing of love passion this is my new favorite pizza place read more

Martolli's Pizza Sisters - Awesome Pizza eaten by the EastCoast Pizza Snob! Cole gives it a 10 and me ... well, it's the best, forget about it! - Pizza Near Me - Sisters, Oregon

My family and I have been going to Martolli's for years and the pizza has always been consistent, reliable, and incredibly delicious. The crust is phenomenal and the flavor is top notch. They really know how to make a good pizza and timing of when the pizza would be ready was perfect, literally slicing the pizza as we walked in to pick it up so it was super hot and fresh. Would always recommend. Thanks Martolli's read more

Martolli's Pizza Sisters - Half Ponderosa and Half Veggie Pesto Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sisters, Oregon

If you're gluten free, don't bother! We paid $18 for a "small" pizza which was truly just the size of a personal pan pizza. There are two stars because the pizza was good but unfortunately, we left hungry. Also, as you can see, the toppings were kind of just thrown on there. For $18, they should offer something more. It was a complete waste of money. The small cheese pizza (gluten) was good, though our kids complained because the crust tasted like saltines. It was also teeny. I highly suggest buying their pizza slices for kids. You'll save money that way. A small for $12 was about the same size as two of their $3.50 slices. If we hadn't left feeling ripped off, I'd recommend their pizza. Now the ice cream place next door is great! It was a bit pricey but when you ask for one scoop it is the same size as two scoops. Also, their ice cream is delicious! read more

Martolli's Pizza Sisters - TINY gluten free pizza - Pizza Near Me - Sisters, Oregon

Delicious gluten free pizza and even better service!!! Would most definitely revisit and come back for more!!