4++ as a food tourist, I read somewhere that I needed to try some burgoo (a thick stew consisting of meat and vegetables that originated in Kentucky). The location I originally planned on visiting (closer to Whiskey Row in Louisville) literally closed a couple of days before I came into town. Not a big deal. I found this location and it was on the road and on the way of my drive to Indianapolis. When I walked in, I was greeted by the friendliest person and was seated in a booth. My server came over and I apologize, but I forget the young lady's name - I think it was Chloe (or Zoey?) - but she was just so attentive and pleasant. I ordered the (brisket) sandwich and burgoo combo. It came out pretty quickly. The burgoo was a good 'stick to your ribs' type of dish and the sandwich was tasty. There are two types of BBQ sauce on the table to add to the sandwich depending on your preference. Really solid meal overall. A lot of food for a reasonable price too! I got a box for most of my sandwich so I can enjoy later that evening. The service style here is a full service sit down restaurant, but vibe is still pretty casual. Feels like one of those restaurants where you don't want to cook, but you want a delicious hot meal that won't break the bank. Although I was here by myself, this place looks like it would be great for groups and families as well. read more

See all

Tonight was our Monthly Gideon Dinner Meeting with 13 members present. Hannah was our friendly, knowledgeable server. There were many different items ordered. I didn't hear any complaints. Food and service is always excellent. read more

See all

For the longest time I thought mark feed store was a supply store. No one I knew had ever been at the time. Once I started working at my current job was the first time I went there for lunch. I will say good brisket each time. And the fries and very good. On my stress day I'll pop by just to get fries with seasoning. read more

Walked in the place a carry out order. The sweet kiddo at the counter was awesome! Personable, knowledgeable, and very helpful. Food came out quick and hot. Unfortunately, the food is just not good anymore. Ordered the pork, slaw, & potato salad. The pork was moist but the taste was just not enjoyable, at all. I've given this place a few tries, but won't be visiting again. It's a shame because the service is always fantastic. read more

The fried pickles people...get the fried pickles! I could eat them for my entire meal. Prices have went up like everywhere put the staff is as friendly as ever. I was a little disappointed about the skimpy meat on the ribs but am told the potato salad is a must. read more

Restaurant is located in a business strip near Kohl's store off of Charlestown Road. Plenty of parking. Noise level is mild to moderate with the sealed concrete floors and a full house amplifying sound. Food is consistently good and, even though I'm tempted to try different items, I always seem to repeat the pulled pork sandwich (tender morsels on a bun and seasoned perfectly) and a plain baked sweet potato (melt in your mouth candy-like goodness). Service is also consistently fantastic. Terrific value and top quality dining option. read more

See all

Can always count on the New Albany Marks Feed Store to deliver amazing food and even better customer service. Our go to's are the brisket and smoked turkey and the best pasta salad and potato salad around. That's not even a debate at this point. We rarely eat in but they always have lots of staff and a great ambiance inside. read more

Mark's Feed Store - Smoked lb of Brisket 2 lb of Turkey Qt Pasta Salad Qt Potato Salad - Barbeque Near Me - New Albany, Indiana

See all

This has been a favorite for our family for years. However tonight they dropped the ball. They were more concerned with closing and cleaning than the quality of the food they were serving. The food was cold and old. Yes we arrived at 8:40 but they set us and I would expect the same food quality and if I got there at 7pm. If not then don't seat us. read more

The food is always good here, and service with a smile is typical. If you're in the mood for bbq, Mark's is a good choice. Don't forget the Texas Toast! read more

Came into town and decided to eat here. Staff was fantastic and the food was amazing. Those fried pickles!!! Definitely will come back next time I'm in town read more

Had this place on my go to list, but not after tonight. Super slow. waited 25 minutes for pick up past the time that they quoted me online, but was told three times it's almost done. The food was good, cold. Maybe new cooks or management, but they were off tonight. read more

Live in Indianapolis and heard good things about Marks. Have been there twice when we were in The Louisville area. Both times the service was prompt and friendly. Food arrived within 10-15 min. Really liked the servers. Wife had ribs which were very good to excellent. I had the brisket which I would rate as very good. Cole slaw here was better than most. Will definitely be back read more

Food tastes great and the service is outstanding The homey atmosphere makes it a pure joy to dine there read more

Ordered fish sandwich and it wasn't cooked all the way threw. Rest of order wasn't right. I asked for ribs and said ribs, I ended up with pulled pork. Im happy everyone is happy with their food, because I will never spend a dime there again.​ read more

We've dined in and used take-out before, great food and service is why we come back. Tonight there was a problem. I ordered on line since we are 200+ miles from home. I went to their website and placed the order. At the restaurant they didn't find me, but said I had placed a Grub Hub order - NO WAY! And they said the 20% tip didn't go to the restaurant, plus Grub Hub added 10% per item. I contacted Grub Hub, they claim the tip goes to the restaurant, but the added cost is for their service - RIP OFF! So IF you order on line read the small print so you don't get taken. The restaurant said their site is "Toast", so maybe try that. And, in my opinion BOYCOTT Grub Hub! read more

Tasha was fantastic. Food was subpar, and disappointing. Was excited to get to come here this evening and felt horrible for dragging my family here for dinner. read more

This was probably the best food I've had in my entire life. I ordered Brisket on a bun with onion straws and coleslaw and it all was superb. The brisket just melted in your mouth and was so flavorful it didn't need anything else! Our server was kind and helpful. It's a nice place. Definitely recommend! read more

Mark's Feed Store - Brisket add bun with Cole Slaw and Side Onion Straws - Barbeque Near Me - New Albany, Indiana

Stopped by for lunch. Service was very good to be short staffed, and the team worked together. The place was clean. The meat was good, not dry. Had the pulled pork, no gobs of fat, which is an A++++ for me. Sweet potato fries were great. Spouse had the rib combo. Stated everything was okay, didn't care for the cut pork pieces, but all in all, we can't complain. May stop by if out this way again. read more

It's been a decade or two since I ate at a Mark's Feed Store. My daughter & I went here for lunch on a whim & was pleasantly surprised! The food was great - especially that baked potato perfection. Loved the slaw & couldn't finish my sandwich. Shawn L. was our server. He did a great job keeping our drinks filled & checking in on us without hovering. We'll definitely be back. read more

Let me start by saying food was 5 stars all around! However, our server Tasha, was not. My mom and I stopped in for Louisville burger week. The burger was delicious! Pickles and onion straws on top with the perfect amount of Mark's bbq sauce. I had a side of sweet potato fries which were perfectly crisp. Check in to yelp and you get a free slice of buttermilk pie. Flaky, and oh so gooey. Delicious. Unfortunately, our server was so rude. I watched her literally toss a side of ranch on the table next to ours from our table. She was curt and tended our table, but not an ounce of friendliness at all. The manager did stop by to see how we were doing, which we appreciated. Sadly the service took away from the quality of food. read more

Mark's Feed Store - Burger week burger! - Barbeque Near Me - New Albany, Indiana

Dry, not much meat, not enough smoke, sauces taste like corn syrup. Mac and cheese had no firmness and was mushy. It's just ok food. I wouldn't call it good bbq by any stretch. read more

It's a nice place for barbecue if you feel like that for lunch or dinner I thought their onion straws were a little greasy but they tasted good so it's not a place to go on a diet read more

BBQ is good, service is good Wish they had a few more options for sides Go there quite frequently and never leave disappointed read more

Terrible terrible terrible, I had the absolute worst brisket sandwich of my entire life on March 3, 2024. Unbelievably dry and tough. It was about 530 PM and not very busy I believe the brisket must have been cut at the lunch service and kept under a heat lamp all day. That's the only way I can conceive that it was able to get that dry and hard and chewy The individual strands of meat were actually like fibers. the bread was also dried out. It was literally almost inedible and unchewable. Marks feed store should be ashamed and embarrassed to serve a product that incredibly bad. read more

We were happy to find Mark's has embraced curbside service. We ordered lunch today and the service was great and cheerful! If I rated only the curbside experience it would be 5 stars. We both had ribs with a side salad and potato salad. Most all my family are big fans of Mark's potato salad, we love it. Once again the potato salad was delicious. The salads were pretty standard fare, but we felt the portion was generous, especially for take out. The ribs were a mix of pretty good and not so good. The thicker ribs were good, however the ribs at the end of the rack were thinner and cooked to the point of resembling jerky. The last couple ribs at the end were so tough and dry they were almost unedible. We are fans of Mark's, and due to their embracing curbside service, we will make them a regular stop for lunch. read more

If you like a laid back atmosphere and great food then Mark's is the place. Consistently serving some of the best barbecue in the area. I love the pulled pork brisket sandwich topped with a pickle and onion. The sauce you choose is on the table, be forewarned the hot sauce is precisely that...HOT! You'll need water (not soda) to calm your palate. Your sandwich is served with fries and the portions are great. They have my favorite fried pickles and some of the best potato salad I've ever eaten. You can order a large meal if you are hungry, it'll come with three sides or you can go bigger and order combination platters. Great ribs if you want to get messy, good ribs should require lots of napkins, Mark's has a whole roll of paper towels at the table, that's a sign of goodness! It's a great place with a friendly staff. They have carry out if you'd rather take it home and catering if you are having a event too big to worry about cooking. You cannot go wrong at Mark's...and the kids love the place too! read more

Mark's Feed Store - Barbeque Near Me - New Albany, Indiana

Honestly was not a fan. The chicken tenders look like fish sticks and they don't taste that great. The place is clean. The people are friendly. read more

My family and I end up here about once a month. It's a nice place to stop for lunch or dinner, and they have some good items. The lemon pepper fish is good, although I could see how some people might think it's a little too salty. Sweet potato fries are good. The potato salad and chicken pasta salad are two must-have sides. The sweet tea is some of the best around. They have several awesome desserts, my favorite being the buttermilk crunch. It's basically a sundae with a piece of buttermilk pie crumbled in vanilla ice cream, drizzled generously with caramel. The side salad is simple with cheese, tomatoes, cucumber, and dressing, but it's always great. The onion straws and fried pickles are both tasty appetizers, although sometimes they are a little greasier than I prefer. One night a week kids eat free, and another night they offer free dessert. My main complaint here is lack of consistency. The two main entrees I eat are the barbeque cheeseburger and the ribs. Sometimes the burger is cooked perfectly and is really juicy, other times it has been dry. The ribs are the same way, sometimes they are very tender and great, other times they are chewy and overcooked. The pulled chicken and pork are usually good but definitely need sauce. My mother-in-law loves their brisket, but it's a very lean brisket and I personally find it too dry. Overall, nice place to enjoy a meal, and we will be back. read more

Several visits inside. Now using curbside, supporting local businesses and planning on bowls of great burgoo tonight. Corn muffins excellent and soup is always spot on. Brisket is amazing but could use some bark. Love the honey wings, BBQ and baked beans are excellent. Extra tasty spot!! read more

Mark's Feed Store - Honey Wings, to go! - Barbeque Near Me - New Albany, Indiana

This place is *IT*!! I ordered the Lemon Pepper Fried Fish sandwich and was SO pleased! I also had a side of green beans, baked potato, and a brownie. The portions were fantastic and I absolutely loved the flavor. I ordered from them off DoorDash and was so happy. I plan on reordering very soon. The flavor and texture of the sandwich was spot on. I really liked packing the baked potato with butter and sour cream which was provided. The green beans had been soaked in brisket and even had small brisket bits in it. The flavor was unforgettable. read more

It was not too busy at 8 pm on Friday. I order the burgoo soup and the sliced brisket dinner. The soup was not good at all. It had terrible flavor. The waitress took care of that. The brisket was dry and did not have much flavor. I did enjoy the chicken pasta salad and the potato salad. read more

We ate here on a Saturday evening with a group of 8. We were seated immediately despite them being busy. Our server took drink orders quickly, delivered them and took food orders. The food was delivered and all was correct and mine was very good. I had bbq chicken sliders and they were generous with chicken. Baked apples were hot and very tasty. My sweet potato fries were good but could have been warmer. The service was excellent during our visit and the prices are more reasonable than many other places we've eaten at recently. read more

Order 2 lbs. Of pulled pork and 1 lb. of brisket Monday 8/26 for pick. Got home and the pork was extremely dry and over cooked. The brisket was more than a third of it was inedible fat. They are normally great not sure what happened.I tried reaching the manager several times and was told he would call me back and never did. When I finally reached him I was told grub hub would have to make amends to me even though I ordered off their web site for a pickup at their restaurant. I heard from a lovely lady at corporate HQ named Mary and she made everything rite. I returned to the restaurant today 9-11 and had a wonderful meal with my daughter read more

Without a doubt, it was the best brisket I've ever had Tremendous foodBarbqueBaby Back Ribs read more

My husband and I visited Kentucky/Indiana area from NYC for a theater conference. I researched a list of popular restaurants in the area and Mark's Feed Store popped up. Great prices. Here's what I ordered: Honey wings (5 stars) Ribs (4 stars) Baked beans (5 stars) Mac & cheese (3 stars) Cornbread (4 stars) Good food. Least favorite item was the macaroni and cheese, seemed more for kids. My husband has the BBQ burger and some of my food. My waitress was amazing and friendly. I definitely recommend! read more

Mark's Feed Store - Honey wings, baked beans, macaroni and cheese, ribs. - Barbeque Near Me - New Albany, Indiana

See all

Lately I've been on this thing for some really incredible, mind-blowing, mmm--mmm good fish sandwich in the Kentuckiana area. I've find a couple of places I'd revisit, so I thought I'd try Mark's Feedstore. Although its focus is BBQ, I heard they've nailed the fish sandwich. And I have to concur! I ordered the fish platter that came with two gigantic fish fillets and two sides. My sides were the baked beans, green beans, and the red potato salad. I also ordered the Buttermilk Pie since I've read great reviews about it. Fish Fillets - they were huge! The breading was very, very light and perfectly complemented the fish. The fish is also very meaty. Now...I personally prefer my fish to be fried a bit harder / firmer, but the way they prepared it was just as fine. I would definitely recommend and return for myself, but might ask to cook a little longer for my personal taste. Baked Beans - these beans had added meat, which is always a plus, and were flavorful. Green Beans - pretty tasty also. My mom ate them, so they had to be good. Otherwise, she would have pushed them aside with a quickness! Red Potatoe Salad - I really enjoyed this salad. It's a lot different to what I'm accustomed to, but its unique taste is a winner. It is mayonnaise based, but not as heavily as you might typically find. The best way I can describe it is that you really get the opportunity to taste the red potatoe with a hint of the mayonnaise base. With the additional seasonings included, the end product is simply delicious. Apparently this is a popular sell because it comes in a variety of sizes, which is clearly posted in their restaurant - see pics. While I was waiting for my to-go order to be complete at least two other customers came to pick up their call-ahead order of potatoe salad to accommodate large parties. Buttermilk Pie - it's a small pie, but considering how sweet it is I'd say that's a good thing. I've never had a Buttermilk Pie before or even heard of it. But it is quite delicious and very moist. Customer Service - excellent. The young lady that took my order was very prompt, forthcoming in volunteering helpful information while placing my first-time visit order, well-informed of the menu, and congenial. The young lady at the hostess stand was also friendly, congenial and talkative. The restaurant was "very" clean and had many dine-in customers and several pick-up orders. I'm glad I finally tried this restaurant. I've seen it many times during my travels over the past two years and although I've always been curious I never made the decision to stop in. So, thanks to my Yelp community I was influenced to finally put my car in park in front of their restaurant. So glad I did! read more

See all

We recently went to Marks Feed Store for lunch. There were 8 of us, 4 adults and 4 children. It was peak lunch time and the place was packed. Our name was immediately taken and there was bench seating in the wait area available. They told us the wait would be about 10 minutes and it was. We were seated in one of the larger corner booths. Our server was prompt in getting our drink order and also explaining questions we had about the menu options. We ordered the fried pickles as an appetizer. They were hot, crisp and came with 2 options of dips. The serving was large enough for all 8 of us to have several. The lunch menu offers some specials on barbeque sandwiches pork, chicken, or brisket(a little more for this) and 1 or 2 sides. Or you can get just the barbeque pork, chicken, or brisket without being on a sandwich. The barbeque comes plain and you have 3 choices of sauce to add. The barbeque is tender and good enough to eat without any sauce if that is the way you like it. They also have ribs, chicken tenders and fried fish on the menu but we all went for the barbeque. The side choices are, in my opinion, where their menu stands out. They have potato salad, baked sweet potato, sweet fried corn on the cob, baked beans, chicken pasta salad, baked apples, baked potato, cole slaw, fries or chips. I love the fried corn on the cob and the baked apples. My son-in-law always gets the sweet potato and spicy fries. When the server asked us about dessert, we were pleased to find out that it was "free" dessert day. I had the buttermilk pie which was very good. The kids had the ice cream sundaes. My daughter-in-law had the buttermilk crunch which came with ice cream, caramel and nuts. The prices were reasonable with lunch costing about $7.00 each. The service was good, the food was good. I highly recommend this place for lunch or dinner. read more

Food and service have been great every time I've gone there. Always order online and the process is simple.

The absolutely worst bbq I have ever eaten comes from Marks! I gave it a 2nd. Chance because my spouse said it was good in New Albany. Previously I ate at the E Town Marks - also very bad! We ordered a 6 rib plate and Brisket basket. My spouse had Mac n Cheese and slaw as sides, I had fried corn and green beans. Upon receiving my brisket I observed without tasting a dry burnt piece of flesh - yuck - I didn't hesitate and sent it back - if I had been the manager I would have been to the table to check out the challenges and the discounted the customer's ticket Nope - no attempt at customer recovery. The replacement - while not as dry (dried out) looked better but didn't taste any better. My spouse's ribs - dried out and disgusting Sorry Marks - you get low marks and no return from this foodie read more

My husband lives by their catfish dinner, which they no longer serve!! But we love all the food every ordered. They place is clean, friendly and nice setting for a family to enjoy. read more