The most delicious valentine day cookies! Individually wrapped not to sweet, perfect size. I will definitely try again. I recommend and will need to visit, the cookies were a gift. read more

Sweet Stuff Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - New Albany, Indiana

Great service and delicious cake! Called same day to see if they had a chocolate cake available for pick up and they did. Reasonably priced, Very delicious and moist! Would recommend again. Curious to try more cakes. read more

Sweet Stuff Bakery - German chocolate cake with ganache - Bakeries Near Me - New Albany, Indiana

I ordered a cake for a coworker who loves brussel sprouts. Sweet Stuff Bakery went above and beyond to make my vision come through. In addition to the cake making a visual statement, it tasted so incredibly good. If I am ever back in Louisville I will make a point to order another cake from them. Totally in love. read more

Sweet Stuff Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - New Albany, Indiana

See all

my husband and i came in to order a last minute cake for a pregnancy reveal. it turned out very cute and was delicious! exactly what i was hoping for. everyone was very helpful and made the process quick and easy for us. :) i've tried their donuts as well in the past and would definitely recommend them. i'll be excited to return to try some more goodies! read more

Sweet Stuff Bakery - custom cake - Bakeries Near Me - New Albany, Indiana

Sweet stuff bakery has become my official go-to bakery since working in southern Indiana. I'm lucky enough to receive sweets as a gift on a regular basis due to the nature of my career, so I've had my fair share of sampling from Sweet Stuff. I'm also going through Sweet Stuff for my wedding cake toward the end of the year and I have no second thoughts about it. Every dessert I've had from Sweet Stuff has been absolutely decadent. From the Halloween cookies, to the Valentine's cake pops, to the wedding cake samples. Everything has tasted phenomenal and has looked impeccable in terms of presentation. Even the donuts are cute! These are the desserts that I imagine fairies and princesses indulging in, except you don't have to be a mythical creature or royalty to get in on these tasty treats. Sweet Stuff is always my first recommendation to anyone for desserts. read more

Sweet Stuff Bakery - Some cake pops from Sweet Stuff! So many different flavors, velvety texture, and super cute :) - Bakeries Near Me - New Albany, Indiana

See all

Great carrot cake. We buy one every year to take to thanksgiving dinner. They are so moist and tasty.

Great selection and excellent desserts! Always a real treat to have any of their cakes, pies, cookies, etc. The staff is great and will always help you out when you need something fast. read more

Great people to work with! Ordered a carrot cake and service and quality was very, very good. I really enjoyed the inside of the store; made you hungry and craving for other stuff. Definitely will be back. read more

Have only been once but the yellow cake with chocolate butter cream frosting was the best slice of cake I've ever had (and I've had a lot lol). Frosting was so buttery and sweet and the cake was super moist (sorry if that triggered anyone). read more

Sweet Stuff Bakery - Yellow with chocolate butter cream, yum! - Bakeries Near Me - New Albany, Indiana

Absolutely loved have Sweet Stuff Bakery do our wedding cake and grooms cake!! Robin was absolutely lovely to work with. They were very flexible and extremely reasonably priced!! They provide you a fresh top cake layer on your one year anniversary read more

Sweet Stuff Bakery - Groom cake - Bakeries Near Me - New Albany, Indiana

See all

Delicious sweets. Can't go wrong with the cheesecake and cookies. They can make any colored cookies if you have an event.

We love sweet stuff. The cup of leftover cake crumbled up and mixed with icing is the perfect way to test out all of their cake flavors. We've gotten a few whole cakes from there and some donuts and they are always so good. read more

Always fantastic They made a great cake for my mom's birthday Pink flamingos on top pink cake with white icing read more

We have tried their donuts, puddings, cakes, muffins, etc and we haven't found anything that isn't amazing! I would especially recommend their banana hummingbird cake and chocolate croissants. They have a lot of variety and the staff is always happy to answer questions. We're obsessed. read more

Our family had a Zoom birthday party for my grandson. His mother, my daughter ordered chocolate cupcakes with caramel icing for all participants. My daughter delivered (contactless) cupcakes to every household. Prior to these cupcakes, we've ordered numerous layer cakes from Sweet Stuff and every cake has been awesome. I'm happy to report, their cupcakes are every bit as good as their layer cakes. The cupcakes were moist and very tasty. The caramel icing was delicious without being too sweet. As an added bonus, Sweet Stuff does curbside pick up! Sweet Stuff is our family's go to for cakes and now cupcakes too! read more

Sweet Stuff Bakery - Hummingbird Cake with Cream Cheese icing - Bakeries Near Me - New Albany, Indiana

We recently used Sweet Stuff Bakery for our 25th Wedding Anniversary Party (Vow renewal). They we're great to work with and provided several samples of the variety of cakes that they offer. Everything was seamlessly completed with delivery to our venue (Huber's Winery Plantation Hall). They we're spot on with the finished decorations and used the same flowers that matched my bouquet. read more

See all

Service was excellent and the apple pie was absolutely delicious. It got a 10-star rating from my granddaughter who is quite the aficionado for apple pie ratings. read more

Always come here for birthday cakes and seasonal cookies. We especially love the double chocolate cake! They also sell cake portions in a tub when you want a quick fix but don't need or want to buy a whole cake! Find those in the front case. read more

New to the area, and this was a welcomed surprise to find on a weekend morning walk to grab a coffee. Delicious doughnuts and turnovers. Will definitely be back. read more

My husband and I recently moved here, and have been to this bakery many times. However this last time, someone obviously was not wearing a hair net as we had a hair in our cake. Completely unacceptable read more

Sweet Stuff Bakery - Hair in the cake in circle - Bakeries Near Me - New Albany, Indiana

I am officially obsessed with their strawberry cake and cupcakes! In my opinion they have the best in the area. I live in Indy and every time I make the trip home to see family in southern Indiana I make it a point to pick up some strawberry cupcakes. They usually have them made and they are always delicious! read more

Love this bakery. Quality Fresh product always. I was turned onto Sweet Stuff a few years ago when they had a booth at harvest homecoming. I first tasted the huge oohey gooey cinnamon rolls and fell in love. That is usually what i get from there. The cobblers are wonderful. Just recently purchased a red velvet cheese cake for about $28. Very good. The caje was the bottom layer and cheese cake on top. Very dense cheesecake. Im always willing to try new deserts. Next time... I got my eye on a peanut butter cake. Yum! read more

Sweet Stuff Bakery - Donuts - Bakeries Near Me - New Albany, Indiana

See all

Seasonal Christmas cookies are adorable and prepacked up for holiday events. Icing is not too thick, this makes the even more tasty. Lots of pies in the case, lots of cake slices and so much more. Nice gem located downtown with reasonable prices and worth every calorie. read more

Oh my goodness the cakes! Pretty and tasty. Christmas bakery goods are out of this world. Staff friendly and helpful.

I ordered a cake for my son for his birthday and asked for it to be made to look like a Pokémon to fit the theme. Sweet Stuff Bakery said "I got you" and went above and beyond! The cake is gorgeous, we got so many compliments on it and let everyone know Sweet Stuff made it! But best of all, it tasted amazing! We will continue ordering our cakes from here, thank you! read more

Sweet Stuff Bakery - Eevee Pokémon birthday cake - Bakeries Near Me - New Albany, Indiana

Amazing job for my son's first birthday party treats. The cakes were so cute and they were delicious! read more

Sweet Stuff Bakery - Amazing job for my son's first birthday party treats. The cakes were so cute and they were delicious! - Bakeries Near Me - New Albany, Indiana

In the midst of the quarantine, I decided I needed to grab some sweets for some friends. Are bakeries deemed essential? YES! Thankfully yes! I called around, perused some websites and landed on Sweet Stuff in New Albany. They have their typical menu as if the quarantine wasn't going on and can have it delivered or pick up/carry out. I ordered two boxes of Easter cookies and three cake in a tubs. The Easter cookie boxes came with an assortment of treats that were beautifully decorated in vibrant spring colors. I cannot comment on their taste as I gave these sweet treats to friends for their neighborly efforts in mask making. I also gave one cake tub to a friend for their birthday. The other two were shared and were divine! The fudge frosting was sweet and rich; like fudge. Not buttercream which amazing. (Not a fan of buttercream!) The Orange Dream cake was very good too. I believe there are a little heavy on frosting. Who says there's too much frosting? The cake was moist and sweet. Very tasty. We actually ended up saving the frosting to frost cookies. My experience was so positive, I put in a second order for the Easter weekend. Staff were kind and efficient. read more

Sweet Stuff Bakery - Cookie box assortment - Bakeries Near Me - New Albany, Indiana

How I stumbled upon this gem long ago is quite the story. I was working with my boss at my employer back in 2008. We were going to accounts together and she wanted something sweet. I really didn't know the area well so I suggested Dairy Queen or whatever wastight in front of us. She however had a better idea and directed me to Sweet Stuff Bakery. It was their old location in New Albany, but the welcome feeling you have going in remains in their current location on Spring St. I fell in love that day and have been going for cakes cookies and other treats ever since. This is the only bakery I could find that makes homemade banana cake instead of using flavoring. All the cakes I've tried have always been so delicious and perfectly moist. I love the butter cream topping that just melts on your tongue with every bite. The doughnuts are also very tasty and cookies keep me coming back every time. If you need a cake for a special event they can accommodate you. I've had all kinds of special designed cakes made for different family celebrations and Sweet Stuff has always done the best job with perfecting my design requests. read more

Delicious bakery. The gateau's are out of this world. Excellent cupcakes, cookies, etc. Friendly and helpful workers. Cute shop as well.

Love there dump cups and cinnamon rolls dump cake cups are cups of cake icing and what ever filling in cake shaved in a cup it is yummy there cakes and cup cakes are so good too. read more

Best bakery hands down! From the delicious sugar cookies to their amazing cakes!! Customer service is top notch! They will always go above and beyond to accommodate their customers. Pricing is very reasonable. A dozen of round sugar cookies with icing are $6.50, with the holiday varieties being $7. Don't forget to try their "cakes in a tub". They are layers of cake and frosting. Several varieties! My favorite with white chocolate with raspberry. They also have donuts, slices of cake, and slices of pie. Everything in the store is delicious! read more

Sweet Stuff Bakery - Frosted sugar cookies. - Bakeries Near Me - New Albany, Indiana

I ran in and picked up a single layer Italian cream cake. It was delicious and plenty for a quick work party. Be aware- their premade pick up cakes like this are frozen! I drove around with the box open on my floor board with the heat on high for an hour so we could eat it at lunch read more

Not cheap, but so worth it. They made an incredible cake to celebrate my parents' 50th wedding anniversary. And I've enjoyed a lot of other things here over the years. This is a truly terrific business. Long may they reign. read more

I got the chocolate heaven cake in a tub & it is delicious!!! Plus it was only $3 for a pretty substantial amount of cake. I'll definitely go back next time I'm in New Albany. read more

Sweet Stuff Bakery - Chocolate Heaven - Bakeries Near Me - New Albany, Indiana

sheet stuff has by far the BEST German chocolate cake in the world! I love the icing and the cake is just the right amount of moist. They also have amazing cookies! The icing is a perfect mix of chewy/crunchy/etc. it taste just like royal icing but better! Also the actual cookie is soft and chewy with a little bit of crunch which is amazing because of the fact that I don't like hard cookies as much. read more

I tried some cake samples from this company at a wedding show and oh my God was I blown away. I called them today with a few odd requests and they were eager to help. So ready to tear into these babies when I get home! Worth the drive over the bridge for sure!! PS try the banana!!! read more

Sweet Stuff Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - New Albany, Indiana

See all

Sweet Stuff is truly just all around sweet! We booked them to do our 3-tier wedding cake plus groom's sheet cake for our big wedding initially planned for 7/3/21. They had a lovely complimentary tasting for us (bride, groom, and bride's parents) and everything was so delicious. Plus, they were the best value when all factors were considered like price, taste, design, delivery, etc. Then, the pandemic happened. Our big wedding is now 7/3/22 but we had a microwedding on our original date of 7/3/21. Sweet Stuff said they'd move our original contract no problem and then gave us a free signature cake for our microwedding! How wonderful is that?!? And when I had requests like "can the frosting dollops be placed in a way that tells us where to cut the slices?" they worked with me on that as well. Finally, the cake (and cupcakes we chose to add - those are HUGE) were so delicious and enjoyed by everyone. We can't recommend them enough! read more

Sweet Stuff Bakery - white cake & ivory frosting. Hummingbird cupcakes in front w/ red velvet & lemon in back; all w/ cream cheese frosting. July 2021 - Bakeries Near Me - New Albany, Indiana

Sweet Stuff Bakery made my husband and I's wedding cake and cupcakes for our rustic themed July 4th wedding. I was absolutely in love with what they provided me and grateful they gave me exactly what I asked for. Everything was delicious, beautiful, and might I add- affordable? Thank you Sweet Stuff for being apart of our unforgettable day. read more

Sweet Stuff Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - New Albany, Indiana

See all

We LOVE sweet stuff! While growing up in Floyd Knobs my family used Sweet Stuff all the time. My husband and I used to live down the street from the bakery and always got their double layer cakes for birthdays and anniversaries and we still use them even though we moved across the river. We love their cloud cakes the most! Chocolate heaven is our favorite flavor. read more

Thank goodness this bakery is not located in Louisville!! And that to get here requires a car. And a toll. Cause otherwise I'd be there everyday. Ive been eating their cakes and cupcakes and pies for a number of years and you simply can't go wrong. You can only go right because their cakes and cupcakes have flavor. And they are soft. And delicious. Two of our fav is chocolate, strawberry and orange dream. Oh my goodness that's three but they are amazing. I can't tell you how awesome the orange cupcakes are w cream cheese frosting. They burst w flavor and are amazing. The best I've had. They are simple. Sweet. Fresh. And must be ordered because they don't have them to sell in the fridge or cooler for walk-ins. Just typing this makes my mouth water. It's a short drive to New Albany and now that Market is two way street it's so easy to get there. Look for the purple trimmed building. You can't miss it. You don't want to. Oh, and the butterscotch pudding is to die for. read more

Sweet Stuff Bakery - Bakeries Near Me - New Albany, Indiana