I have eaten here a couple of times over the past few months and words do not describe what you experience here. To be clear, I doubt people think "Winsted CT" is a foodie destination, but if you stop at Mario's Tuscany Grill, it will be from that point forward. Starting at the top, there is plenty of parking on the street. This area of Main Street Winsted is actually ok for a little walk on the sidewalk. Once inside Mario's, the staff is very warm and friendly, showing you to a table quickly. The dining room has ample space, you do not feel crowded. The menu is amazing, on previous visits the Seafood Combination and Chicken Milanese is simply perfect and delicious with an ample portion! Here's where it gets even weirder and BETTER. If you visit their Facebook page, you see pictures of amazing platters of food. YET!, that isn't on the menu. So I asked the very friendly waiter, "how do we do these platters?".. He simply said, tell me what you want! My friend and I collaborated, and said "start with steak gorzonzola".. Ok, then what? "Well Some Clams", "how many?" Me: "I dont know,a dozen?" "that enough?", Me: "No of course not" Waiter: "What else?" Me: "well, some scallops, some shrimp, and more clams".. Waiter replies, "Ok, we'll make it nice" .. "Nice" has to be the understatement of the year. This platter comes out, Steak Gorgonzola, flanked with 18 clams, half a dozen scallops, grilled shrimp, asparagus, Caprese tomato salad.. it was unbelievable.. Everything was cooked to perfection, the presentation was absolutely outrageous, and it was incredibly delicious!! Not sure how far Winsted is from your house, but it's an hour from mine and worth the ride!! You have to visit this place.. read more

Mario's Tuscany Grill - Incredible Platter! - Pizza Near Me - Winsted, Connecticut

Mario's in Winsted is one of those rare restaurants that doesn't just feed you -- it adopts you. The chefs, the owners, the servers... these people make the place feel like home in a way that should honestly be studied by scientists. If comfort had an address, it would be Mario's. We always kick things off with a small pizza for the table, because that's the law here. The bread and tomato relish? Should be sold by the gallon. I would pay an irresponsible amount of money for it. If you know, you know. Last night's table lineup was elite: * One of us ordered the veal Neapolitan -- fresh, tender veal in a vodka sauce so good it should have its own fan club. * Another went for the penne alla vodka with shrimp and scallop, which was hands‑down the best dish of the night. The seafood takes an already top‑tier vodka sauce and somehow makes it even better. As a Jersey boy, I don't say that lightly. * I decided to go rogue and step outside my usual penne vodka or steak. I wanted veal parm. I've never had anything fried here besides the calamari (which is amazing), so I figured: why not? Here's the plot twist: The veal parm was the only dish I've ever had at Mario's that didn't hit the usual Mario's standard. The veal itself was totally different from the fresh, delicious cut in the Neapolitan, and the breading had a little... funk. Almost like it had been prepped ahead and picked up a freezer‑burn vibe. Not bad -- just not Mario's‑level magical. But here's the thing: One imperfect dish doesn't change the fact that Mario's is one of our all‑time favorite restaurants. The atmosphere, the people, the consistency, the warmth -- it's all unbeatable. We love this place and will absolutely be back, probably embarrassingly soon. Mario's is home. Even when one dish misses, the experience never does. read more

See all

Wow it's like walking into Italy ! What a beautiful restaurant and the service and food are just as exceptional. Chicken parm, bolognese, meatball appetizer, pasta fazule all excellent. Staff is on the mark too. Highly recommend! read more

See all

We came here for a late lunch/early dinner on Saturday. Very pretty inside and the staff is very nice. There was some confusion with their dinner special menu and the waitress kept coming back to give us the updated one. It got her frazzled. So, my friend waited a very long time to get the glass of wine she ordered then finally reminded her of it after we received our appetizer. The appetizer was a daily special of Hot Antipasto consisting of stuffed mushrooms, baked clams and mozzarella sticks. All Delicious. We also had this lovely bread and this tomato relish kind of sauce on the table. We really liked that too. For our entree we shared the Shrimp and scallops in a vodka sauce. It was really good. I'd definitely come back here when i'm in the area again. read more

Mario's Tuscany Grill - Interesting tomato relish kind of sauce with bread. - Pizza Near Me - Winsted, Connecticut

See all

This is an incredible place! Right from the moment you walk in, the staff makes you feel like family. After moving to a town in Massachusetts about half an hour north of Mario's, we were thrilled to discover this restaurant since we came from an area known for outstanding dining, Mario's keeps up to that standard. The staff, the food, and the overall atmosphere are fantastic! I can honestly say I recently enjoyed one of the best meals of my life here; they never let us down. I can't say enough good things about this place, a must try!!! read more

See all

Food quality / price (value) 10. The atmosphere is "high end" Italian with a large, well appointed bar, and several beautifully decorated dining rooms. The exterior of this restaurant belies the wonderfully designed and decorated venue found within. Brothers Sonny and Harry have been operating this restaurant for more than 25 years, and are obviously dedicated to it's continued success. We sat at the bar - a beautiful formal presentation with a comfortable library-like feel. Our server/bartender Tracy was attentive and informative. The menu is filled with classic Italian dishes, and the descriptions tease the palate that is looking for quality. Our meal began with homemade bread and a homemade salsa for dipping that was unique and fantastic! I had the Chicken Saltimbocca with a rich, brown gravy, that was presented beautifully and served hot. The wife had Chicken Artichoke special, also presented beautifully and also very flavorful. The highlight of our experience was when we split the Limoncello Marscapone Cake, very unique and incredibly good. I will return just for this dessert. The food was fantastic,vthe service was great, and the atmosphere is beautiful! Don't let the exterior of the building affect your decision to eat here - you won't be disappointed! Also, a great date place to impress your current flame. read more

See all

What a great meal we all had, party of four and all enjoyed our meals I had the chicken parmigiana with vodka sauce and ziti which was excellent. We sat in the bar area and service was excellent. We will be back. read more

1st Timers to Mario's Tuscany Grill in Winsted this afternoon (although I did get a takeout cheese pizza from them about a year ago, I was very underwhelmed with that pizza, needed to be cooked longer. It was just not up to my standards in a state known for its pizza). We started off with a fried calamari appetizer -- it was good. My wife had some white sangria, she wasn't impressed, the drink lacked any fruit pieces in it. LONG wait for our entrees to come out. So long, that a table nearby that had been seated at the same time as us, had already eaten and left before our meals finally arrived at our table. When my wife cut into her Peppercorn steak, she realized it was undercooked, so they took it back to the kitchen. When it came back out, it was perfect, one of the best steaks she has ever had. The sauce was also outstanding. My Salmon ala Mario was "OK", I'll be honest, I've had better salmon at other restaurants. All in all, I'd say we were a bit disappointed with our experience at Mario's Tuscany Grill this afternoon. But that's not to say we wouldn't go back, if my wife had a hankering for a Bangin' steak, I'm pretty sure she'd want to go to Mario's. Next time though, I'll order "something Italian" and see how it goes. Will write an update when that happens. read more

See all

I wrote a review 3 years ago, 5 stars. I'm way over due to write another one. I grew up in NYC a few blocks from Little Italy. I had many favorites. When I retired and moved to Winsted, I tried all the restaurants. Mario's is still my #1. My dad was Gen. MacArthur's personal chief and my uncle was head chef for the Child's Rest. Chain. I wish they were around to go to Mario's. Keep the GOOD food going!!! read more

we have been going here for 20 years and you can't get any better. I feel like it's equal to the Italian restaurants in New York.

These people are extremely overpriced, especially on their beers. How do you leave the bartender a tip when the friggin price of the beer? Already 10 bucks or more and they don't even have that much for choices on their menu. read more

The beef here is top notch, better than any other USDA prime i've eaten... these guys know what the hell they are doing.

We dined at Mario's Tuscan Grill during a visit to CT. Finding the restaurant was serendipitous, as it was close to our lodgings. We were greeted warmly by the hostess and seated promptly. The atmosphere was intimate and welcoming. I ordered the Clams Linguine, with white sauce. The portion of clams was very generous and the white wine sauce was mild but flavorful. A homemade Italian Dressing on crisp salad greens was a very nice introduction into the meal. My wife had the Chicken Oscar, also very well presented and prepared. A lava cake dessert topped off the evening. In short, the food was excellent! I awarded 5 stars, but that is rounding from an overall impression of "4.6". Our waiter was just a bit slow, and slightly inattentive. Looking around the dining area, this was not the norm for the staff. We just got the "relative short straw". I would highly recommend this dining experience. read more

Back in August of 2025 we reserved the restaurant for a large party for lunch after my Uncles funeral. The owner was supposed to come and open the restaurant for us but he and the staff were a no show leaving 30+ people standing on Main Street in front of an empty restaurant. My Aunt tried to contact the owner (the reservation was made with him) to find out why nobody was there but was unable to get in contact with him. Hours later he called her back only to say there was a "family emergency" and that's why nobody was there. Nobody believes that story. If that were true where were the staff? Is the restaurant not capable of running if he isn't there? Using his logic, he had time to call all the staff and tell them not to come in but wasn't able to contact us and tell us he had to cancel? Instead of admitting that he screwed up and never made the reservation to begin with he proceeded to tell this outlandish lie. What was supposed to be the celebration of a wonderful mans life turned into a disaster. Instead of getting together and reminiscing all of our great memories of my Uncle we were frantically making phone calls in hopes that another restaurant could accommodate us. Luckily the Tributary was able to take on our entire party with zero notice and it went without a hitch. I used to like Mario's but after this situation I will never go back there. I still would have been upset, but had he told the truth that he forgot to put the reservation in I would have been more understanding. Instead I'm left with this sour taste in my mouth of an owner who obviously cares more about his own pride than admitting to making a mistake. read more

Was left stranded along with 30 other ppl outside their business on the sidewalk after making reservations for a reception following a funeral service back in August. Finally decided to write this review because to this day it still leaves a bitter taste in my mouth, and no restitution of any kind was ever offered or made to the grieving family. Owner stated he had a family emergency, yet he couldn't make any other arrangements for restaurant staff to meet us? No attempts made to call us?? He also never answered his phone while we were frantically trying to figure out what was going on. Will never eat at this establishment again, let alone trust them to host any kind of important gathering. Buyer beware if you ever reserve the restaurant or hire their catering services. If they have no qualms with abandoning an entire grieving family, would you really trust them to serve your birthday or wedding?? The silver lining to this story.. the Tributary was able to accommodate all of us last minute. The owner called her family in to help last minute to prepare all the food. Now this is a family business I will give my money to. Too bad for Marios. They lost over 30 customers who still live in the area. Now that is poor business. read more

Had the Lobster Ravioli. Very good sauce and could taste the lobster ( not always guaranteed with some other places "Lobster" dishes)! Spoke to the owner when I arrived to pick up my order and he was very nice and wanted to make sure I was happy with everything. When I come to visit CT, I always have at least one meal here. Good food with good service and a nice place to dine. Recommend for anyone looking for a place to eat in Winsted. read more

Mario's is one my very favorite restaurants. It offers traditional, but also unique Italian dishes that are delicious and comforting. The entire restaurant and their staff are very welcoming and kind- the Italian decor and vibe is cozy. The food is very good! I've had a variety of dishes over time- some of my favorites are the Salmon ala Mario, Lobster Ravioli, and Chicken Neopolatana. The best appetizer by far is the Spedini! Get it! You'll want to lick the bowl. The dishes are also always beautiful and good portions. The service is always wonderful. read more

See all

Looking for good bites that are local to you? Check this place out in Winsted. We love coming here for some pizza, wings and calamari. The calamari is always cooked to perfection and this time they had a calamari puttanesca special which we had to try and we are so happy we did, it was quite honestly the best calamari I've ever had. The wings are also just as good, we order them extra crispy and they are perfect every time. The wings are a great size and the meat isn't fatty which is a huge win in our book. The complimentary bread and sun dried tomato oil they have is really what brings us back every time. I wish I had the recipe, quite honestly. And of course the delicious pizzas they serve. The crust is exactly what I'm looking for when I order a pizza and it's hard to find in this area. Whoever serves us when we come here is always kind and very quick. Our drink is never empty and there is always food on the table. What's also nice about this place is the option to sit at the bar with whatever sports games are on or being able to sit in the dining room for a more formal experience. Can't wait to come back! read more

See all

Service...non existent. Oh, there they are. Yes, we are ready to order everything. "Do you have any questions?" No. We'll have.... And it arrived, and the evening was fantastic. Just because of Mario's. read more

The Alfredo was oily but still okay. Service was kind but forgot my root beer. Cmon man. Not the root beer. (Which after asking I did get) Cheesecake is the reason it is 4 stars not 3. The ambiance is something that is useless to even point out. If a restaurant has good service and good food but looks like garbage I DO NOT CARE! read more

Porterhouse steak special was fantastic. With sauces grilled mushrooms and onions. Ordered medium rare an cooked perfectly. Great bartender and service. read more

Absolutely amazing place. The food is some of the best I've ever eaten, they don't disappoint. The pricing is also very reasonable for the food that you get. Some personal favorites are the chicken piccata, stuffed mushrooms, and penne alla vodka. The service is also outstanding. Staff makes sure everything is going smoothly and doesn't fail to provide you with everything you ask for. Aside from service and food, the mood that Mario's holds is amazing. Whatever part of the building you're in, you always feel comfortable and delighted. Not to mention how the owner often does his rounds to great guests, further ensuring that you feel welcome to the environment. read more

Great restaurant the food is absolutely phenomenal and the service is 5* The owners are hands on and oversee the entire operation read more

See all

This is a lovely and elegant place on the main street in Winsted, CT. The food is excellent and so is the service! Mirela and Mubera were fantastic, as was Carson. One of the owners, Harry, even came to our table and spoke with us for a bit! Stop in sometime! You won't be disappointed. read more

My favorite place in town for a great italian dinner I always get the penne alla vodka, one of the best I've ever had! The servers are always super lovely too, very nice and inviting and the inside is always very nice. Recommend 10/10!! read more

Mario's Tuscany Grill - Penne Alla Vodka - Pizza Near Me - Winsted, Connecticut

Great food and service. And Tracy's bloody Mary's on Sunday go twice a week. it's the local Cheers

Very disappointing dinner experience at Mario's. Service has gone completely downhill - waited over 2 hours for entrees. Calamari appetizer is just previously frozen rings. Won't be back again read more

So my office once again had another party catered this time it was by Mario's as you can see by my pictures people started to dig in before I had a chance to take some great pictures! But I have to say the food was absolutely amazing The salad was delicious it was very crispy and all the vegetables were crispy and fresh there was also blue cheese crumbles on the side and an amazing balsamic vinaigrette that they also make in house. The chicken piccata was probably one of the best chicken piccatas I have ever had it was just enough lemon just enough capers and the chicken was cooked to perfection and I'm really big on the way chicken is cooked. This dish was absolutely perfect. They also brought us complementary Italian bread which was amazing I used it to dip the extra lemony sauce it was so yummy and the bread was so fresh. Next on to the rice this usually isn't on the menu but one of my co-workers was adamant about getting vegetable rice and thank God they did because it was absolutely amazing and kudos to the restaurant for making the rice special for us. Last but not least the seafood raviolis they were so yummy they were stuffed with a crab meat stuffing and topped with a vodka cream sauce. OMG I probably could have ate the whole entire tray this dish was so good. I personally can not wait to make a trip to this restaurant to dine in because if they're catering is as good as the restaurant it's going to be another five stars for me. I would absolutely recommend Mario's! read more

See all

Having grown up on NYC pizza, this is by far the closest you can get to that. After trying all the pizza places in the area (including Torrington), this is definitely the best by a landslide. read more

On a Sunday night everything within a 30 minute radius of Mario's seems to close before 8 p.m., leaving us with very few options for dinner. We were happy to discover that Mario's was still open until 9:30 and had a very nice and relaxed atmosphere. White table cloth tables, spacious booths, and comfortable space - perfect for a comforting Italian meal at the end of the day. The waitstaff was also very nice and accommodating. The only slight disappointment was the food. We ordered a shrimp and scallop dish atop penne as well as a jambalaya with shrimp, chicken and sausage. Both of the dishes were big portions and had tasty sauces, but there was very little seafood in them. The majority of the dishes were pasta or chicken. Overall, a comfortable and nice dinner - just wish the dinners were a little bit better. read more

Best Pasta Fagioli soup I have ever had. Never had a bad meal there. Sangria is also wonderful. Our favorite restaurant in the area!

The staff are always great, good ambiance and great food. Check them out if you haven't already.

The place to be! Great food and wonderful atmosphere. The brothers make everyone feel like family. This is our go to place on date night.

Fantastic food and attentive, accommodating and personable servers!!! The atmosphere was nice and quiet. Everything was very clean, too. My family has gathered here countless times and will continue to celebrate our special occasions at this restaurant... It is clear that all who work in this great establishment care about their customers and provide the very best of all services... read more

Warmly greeted by Sarah; and when I asked for a table versus a booth -- she was kind and gracious. Our server Al -- was the best of the best! Our meal was off the grid wonderful! Once again the Spedini was over the top exceptional, the calamari cooked to perfection. The two men had steaks; my husband the porterhouse special which was huge and he said delicious and perfectly prepared. Our nephew had the filet mike on and he said his was so tender and succulent. My seafood combination was oh so good; my favorite combination and with the pasta; I am always in heaven! While we were all claiming to be stuffed -- we made room for dessert. I had - just had to have tartufo. The dark chocolate covering with the dark chocolate ice cream was the perfect ending for me. My husband said the cheesecake delicious and the afagato for my nephew -- a perfect ending. You can never go wrong at Mario's -- the food is always perfectly prepared. And Al was an excellent server who made for a wonderful evening out. read more

Great food. Portions were large. Service was great. We went late afternoon on Saturday and enjoyed are meal and had great conversation with chef. Visiting area and would go back again. Neal. read more

A hidden gem!! We ordered take out for the family to celebrate Mother's Day. The food was cooked to perfection and ready within 30 minutes. We ordered 2 filet mignons (1 medium rare & 1 medium well), penne ala vodka & lobster ravioli. The prices were reasonable and worth every penny! The filet was the best we've had in a long time. The lobster ravioli had huge pieces of lobster with a delicious sauce and asparagus. All 4 meals came with a side salad & freshly baked bread. Can't wait until we can go back & dine inside. read more

First time here, and I was very happy! Clams casino was perfect, and the veal Milanese was delicious. Pleasant wait staff, and great atmosphere. Definitely will be back. My only suggestion would be to include pasta with most of the entrees instead of only some. read more

Mario's Tuscany Grill - Veal Milanese - Pizza Near Me - Winsted, Connecticut

Italian based restaurant with relaxed atmosphere in bar area and a more typical dining experience in table area. Friendly professional staff. Quick service but no push to go. Consider quesadillas for dinner. Martini poured to rim. Try lemon drop martini. Local and classic draft beers. Look to their specials. Crab cakes were large crisp on outside and steaming inside filled with crab. Sliced Italian bread for dipping in a tomato based spicy sauce arrives on table. If not ask for it. Kid friendly at dining area. read more

See all

A surprising find in Winsted! Hostess and servers were great, large portions and great cocktails menu. We will be back soon.