EASILY the best pizza in Greensboro! Very consistent with great flavor, crispy crust and clean restaurants.

Mario's shows you what portion control is NOT. I ordered a 24 inch pizza and for some reason didn't expect it to arrive needing its own zip code. HUGE, cheesy, classic pizza. We also tried the baked ziti, which was also a huge portion size and massive hit with my kiddos (always the toughest critics ). We had it delivered but it was fast. Will have to go try it in person soon! read more

Mario's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Greensboro, North Carolina

See all

I ordered the chicken parm & spaghetti. It came with salad and garlic bread. The plate was Hugh! The food taste delicious. The salad & bread was really good too. I usually just get pizza but this was a great change. The service was with a smile. The restaurant is also very clean. read more

Mario's Pizza - Chicken Parmigiana - Pizza Near Me - Greensboro, North Carolina

A coworker and I decided to order takeout here during our lunch break and the food did not disappoint! I ordered a cheese slice (with an added broccoli topping) online through their website for as soon as possible. I was quoted that it would be ready in 15 minutes. The website was very easy and accessible to use. We got there a few minutes early to check-in and our food was still being prepared, but it was ready for when we were quoted. Cashier was very nice and the location seemed very casual, but clean. My slice was absolutely giant (it comes from their 24 inch pies) and filling. I thought it was pretty affordable at $4, but they do charge $1 per topping for anything more than just the basic cheese slice. My coworker ordered their toasted ravioli and I tried it as well. The ravioli was perfect. They have daily specials available that are great to check out too. I definitely will be back because this was such a good weekday lunch spot! read more

Mario's Pizza - Cheese Pizza Slice (add broccoli) - Pizza Near Me - Greensboro, North Carolina

Love that they sell pizza by the (giant) slice! Also tried the garlic knots, which were very reasonably priced. Great solo dinner!

Best NY style huge slices or pies. Tastes just like being on a street in NYC. Wife had a Stromboli which was also great. Tried the white pizza as well, great but could use a tad bit more flavor. Food: 5/5 Service: 4/5 Ambiance: 4/5 read more

See all

Ate here for lunch yesterday because it was highly recommended by a coworker. I ordered the Italian Sub and my son ordered spaghetti with meatballs. Our order came quickly, however, it was not good. The sub was dripping grease with every bite which made the bread soggy. The spaghetti and meatballs were bland. Prices were decent but food was below par. I have had their pizza in the past which was pretty good so maybe they need to stick to that food item alone. read more

See all

This place has the best calzone I've ever had. They even went above and beyond to allow me to add extra toppings when they typically don't.

Scooped up some slices this afternoon. Still bomb. Still freaking delicious. Still the same consistency of flavor. Spaghetti was amazing. Ordered it twice in 2 days for the 1st time ever. Only thing is they forgot my side salad! No big deal I'm fat and don't eat salads anyway. Ha! No seriously I love this place and it's my go to in time of need for Italian bc they actually use garlic in their sauce. read more

See all

Great food, great service, New York Style pizzeria ambiance! Highly recommended! Mario's has been a staple for my family since being a regular at Tony's (same owner) near Camp Lejeune. Semper Fi. read more

How can you not love NYC style pizza slices the size of your head. Great service and many other Italian dishes like calzones, Stromboli. Tiramisu and my favorite fried ravioli. read more

Mario's Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Greensboro, North Carolina

Kalamata olives! Creative yummy toppings, cauliflower crust available. I can't wait to try the cauliflower crust! read more

I was in the mood for Pizza after watching all the ads on TV and I hadn't tried Mario's before and it was the closest shop near me. I was seated immediately because it was just after the noon rush. My order for a small pizza and drink was taken and arrived in a timely manner. There were only two other tables utilized thus the sound level was good. The dining room was also very clean, especially because it right after lunch so that shows their attitude towards keeping the place inviting. The pizza sauce was very good, and there was plenty of pepperoni and sausage, but the pie should have been cooked a little longer because the crust was not very crisp. The service was ok, but not sure how it would be when the place was busy. The servers probably wouldn't be using their phones. I enjoyed the meal, but it doesn't make me want to go back soon. Maybe it's me but the pizza shops in my area are not as good as I have other places. read more

Good pizza. I'll go again when I'm in that area and in the mood for pizza. But the sauce and crust are not as good as it is at another place I go to. read more

Mario's Pizza - 10" Pepperoni, sausage, ham, bacon and onions - Pizza Near Me - Greensboro, North Carolina

Our old tried and true, has become a total disappointment. They've changed the recipe. Our favorite cheese pizza, once a zesty thin crust is now too thick and the sauce tastes like ketchup. The cheese is even off. I was already put off by the addition of a tipping system a few years back (I make my own drink, clean my own table and bring myself my own food.. but sure. ... let's pretend you deserve an extra 20%) Now they want to add MORE money for paying with a card (hello!! That's a business expense sir) I will be sending a note to the IRS to audit that particular expense in their returns I think I have to find a new spot. read more

Mario's Pizza - 24 in pizza - Pizza Near Me - Greensboro, North Carolina

Best Pizza I've found so far in Greensboro wings are also good nice and meaty. I got delivery and everything came hot and was delivered in a timely fashion. read more

Yummy pizza! We get the worx and the vegetables always taste super fresh. The garlic knots and ranch are pretty good as well. Definitely worth a try if you're looking for a new family owned pizza spot! read more

Not sure how this place doesn't have an overall 5 stars. I always pick up food to go and it's always ready, fresh and delicious. The location always looks super clean and is very spacious. I am going to try to keep eating my way through the menu, it's just so hard to try new things when you don't want to move on from the last! read more

See all

As I continue my quest for New York style pizza, I stumbled across Mario's - the New Garden Road location. The pizza was thin and crispy. Crust & sauce needs work. They offer individual slices which is great & they were traditional NY size. But they did not have some classics like white pizza or garlic knots. The staff was helpful and courteous, decor was cute, menu is extensive & the restaurant was very clean. read more

See all

We Ordered a daily Special - Large 1 topping Pizza and Garlic Knots. The pizza was delicious as I remembered. The garlic knots I believe they forgot the garlic. Not the garlic knots I remember from Mario's at the Tanger Outlet in Mebane. read more

Absolutely delicious!! Salad was chilled and fresh-pizza was hot and ample toppings-fast service, friendly staff! Clean dining area- very please will dine here again, highly recommend. read more

Mario's Pizza - Absolutely delicious!!! - Pizza Near Me - Greensboro, North Carolina

Mario's has the best foods. From Pizza to salads and sandwiches. Everything is always fresh and hot. Always made to perfection. The pizza has thin crispy crust with the right amount of sauce and cheese and if it's toppings well Mario's has them all. There are so many types of pizza just ask they. Will make it. read more

Mario's Pizza - Large cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Greensboro, North Carolina

Had a very nice and scrumptious pizza with the husband for lunch. Service here is always fantastic and their pizza is top notch. They are doing a surcharge at the moment of 10% if you don't pay cash so bring cash because it's worth it to pay cash like we did. Everything that came out of the kitchen looked amazing and as always it's our favorite spot for pizza! read more

Ate there last night, December 20th, 2023. My daughter got the meatball sub and found 2 hairs on the top. We took it back and he made her a new one, but after that, you lose your appetite . Maybe they should think about wearing hair nets so this won't happen. read more

I've had nothing but good experiences from this location. The pizza is consistently good, all staff are courteous, and helpful, and the dining area is kept clean despite high "traffic". One negative is the price. Mario's is slightly more expensive than pizza of equal quality. They are even offering a cauliflower crust 10" pizza, which is fantastic when I'm on a low carb diet (currently). Can't tell the difference between the Cauliflower crust pizza, and their regular pizza crust, which makes me question how much cauliflower is actually in there. Wish they would post nutritional information somewhere. If Mario's keeps doing what they are doing, I'll keep eating them pies! I diet so I can eat more pizza. It's a vicious cycle! The struggle is real. P.S. I haven't strayed far from the pizza, so I can't speak about much other food they serve. read more

Mario's Pizza - Cauliflower Crust Pepperoni Pizza (really good!) - Pizza Near Me - Greensboro, North Carolina

See all

I ordered a chicken parmigiana sub. There was a lot of sauce and cheese, but there was only a little chicken and it was heavily breaded.

By far the best subs in Greensboro! Also they have awesome pizza. Tonight I tried the chicken Parmesan it was also amazing! read more

Mario's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Greensboro, North Carolina

Hi, my name is Janice and I'm addicted to Mario's chicken parmesan! I've never had their pizza because the first time I visited, I had the chicken parm and haven't looked back since. I love their sauce, the chicken is not overcooked, the cheese is melted just right on top and the spaghetti served with it is cooked perfectly every time. It comes with a side salad and garlic knots. The salad has tomatoes, cucumbers, olives, red onion and shredded mozz, on point, a great salad. The garlic knots are good if you're a bread eater, I'm not so much but it's nice touch included with your meal. At less than $13, a bargain for sure and I get two meals out of it. I promised myself I was going to try their pizza next time. We'll see :-) read more

Mario's Pizza - Excellent Chicken Parmigiana with a great side salad! - Pizza Near Me - Greensboro, North Carolina

Oh my goodness, the least I can say is that this place was amazing! Took my grandmother here and it was the first time for the both of us and we loved it. We both got 10' inch pizzas and a drink and it was less than $30. The pizza spoke for itself, you could tell it was fresh dough and fresh ingredients, pizza sauce was amazing and both the pizzas were cooked to perfection. I've been in Greensboro for 5 years now and I'm so sad I had never been here before! Will definitely recommend to friends and will surely be coming back. read more

The hardest aspect for most restaurants, especially small chains and locals, is to be consistent, in both quality of product and service. That evasive goal was pointed out again today with my experience at this pizza restaurant. I called in a 2 pizza order at 11AM, and was told they would be ready at 11:30 when they opened. I arrived at the appointed time, and after a 20 minute wait (50 minutes from time of order), my order was ready. When I went to pay, I discovered they had placed the order for 2 15" pies, not the 2 10" I clearly ordered. Already late I paid and left - a $20 order having become a $40 order. I was told the reason the order was not ready was they had to make the "Company Pies" first (the ones they serve by the slice) - a heads up on that would have perhaps be nice at the front end of the order. When I said that was simply not acceptable, I was rewarded with a blank stare, and no sorries of any description. Neither pizza was at all good - the Veggie was soggy and undercooked - simply awful fare. The other pizza was ordered with extra cheese and extra pepperoni because they skimp on both items on their normal - if there was in fact extra anything on the pie, I failed to find it - at least this one was almost cooked thru. I have been picking up pizza here for several years now, on almost a weekly basis - that will obviously not continue. There simply are too many choices out there to put up with such shoddy service and quality. I have never, never understood why restaurants don't understand that - the most important customer is the one already in your place because they want to be there - and you blow it with unsupervised, uncaring employees. read more

Tried again to see if it changed but nope Still horrible staff at checkout Pizza was cold and cheese was hard I think I got someone's order that didn't show up . read more

Much appreciated Take Out. 2 Chicken Parmesans, Lasagna, salads, garlic knots, extra Parm packets. Everything was expertly packaged for takeout with zero mess! Staff very high spirited given the times. They're keeping up with the social guidelines of no more than 10 customers at a time, sanitizing as they go. And of course, take out and carry out only. Thoroughly enjoyed the food- great value- and good folks! Thanks so much for a night off cooking! read more

Mario's Pizza - Chicken Parmigiana delicious - Pizza Near Me - Greensboro, North Carolina

Awesome pizza highly recommend. A lot of options on sizes but I keep it basic with the pepperoni sausage combination. Didn't disappoint!

I went here with family a couple of days after Christmas, and we all loved it! Mario's has the good, New York Style pizza. My family ordered the largest pizza available, and it was almost bigger than the table! I kid you not. Look at my pictures! It fed 7 adults. I ordered the meatball parm sub, and that was amazing as well! The meatballs were very good, and the sub bread was nice and crispy. It came with a side, which I was not expecting, and I chose the mozzarella sticks. They were crispy and good, and there was also marinara sauce that came with it. The service is always very nice. Even though we ordered such a big pizza, it didn't take too long to get our entire order. The restaurant itself isn't too big-probably around 12 booths for four people, and two tables, but there is a good rotation, so every time we've been, we've always been able to grab a seat. If you're in the area and looking for some good, real pizza, definitely come here! read more

See all

When I moved to NC, I fell in love with Mario's. They make one of the best cheesesteaks in town in addition to having good pizza. However, skip forward a few years and their food is a toss up. I seem to only be able to get my cheesesteak the way I order it about half the time. Now I only go there when other people want it. read more

I got some takeout a last week. I'm trying to get caught up on my reviews. I got the chicken parm. It was terrific. The salad I got was not so good lots of lettuce stalks. I will be going back to try something else read more

Love Mario's but my last few takeout orders for pizza were botched. The first was a half and half one topping pie that ended up with them putting two toppings on one side with the other just cheese. Tonight I ordered a pie with sliced sausage as a topping but got the crumbled abomination most places here serve. I actually called ahead this time rather than do it online like last time and stressed that I wanted sliced. What a shame. read more

The service here is fantastic and the young man at the front register is super sweet. Can't go wrong with Mario's- always great food. My favorite is the pepperoni pizza & the Italian sub! read more

Food was delicious, reasonably priced and ready quickly. Highly recommend for a casual Italian meal.

We tried Mario's on New Garden on a whim and we love it! It's become our "go-to" pizza place. We've tried pizza, strombolis, and subs so far. All delicious! Lots of foot traffic and sit down patrons and yet we always receive our order in a reasonable amount of time. We enjoy coming here. read more