This is one of our go to spots for good pizza near by our place. Whether it's a party we host or just a lazy dinner cause we don't feel like cooking, Mario's never disappoints. Their pizza is delish and love the crust. My partner loves their marinara sauce! I've been wanting to try more of their specialty pizza, like their Bianco or spicy buffalo chicken. We also grabbed garlic knots and their onion rings on the side, too. The garlic knots were pretty good but it was lacking more garlic to our liking. As well as the onions they're delish! Love the light, crisp batter and can taste the sweet onions. read more

See all

Mario's reminds me of the old school neighborhood pizza joints that you'd find in NYC & NJ. Even the interior reminds me of that. The food is not fancy but it's good, well made & plentiful. My spaghetti & meatball dinner was pretty good & the portion was huge! It came with garlic knots & a side salad. Service was efficient & no nonsense. If you want pizza by the slice, their slices are huge & really good too! read more

Mario's Pizza - Spaghetti w/Fresh Tomato Sauce with added meatballs. This came with a Garden Salad & Garlic Knots - 3 Piece * - Pizza Near Me - Winston Salem, North Carolina

We came to Mario's after an afternoon full of sun and swimming for a slice of their amazing pizza. We ordered and within minutes we had our plates. The slices were falling off the plate they were so huge!! We opted to sit outside as they have three outside tables. There is quite a few places to sit inside as well and the parking is abundant. read more

Mario's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Winston Salem, North Carolina

I've never been to any Mario's location but let me tell you, the Hanes Mall Blvd location did not disappoint! I got the Tuesday Calzone special and my add in choice was the crumbled sausage. The sausage pieces were big, juicy and slightly spicy, the cheese combo of mozzarella and ricotta was out of this world. The crispy, baked to perfection dough was LOADED. There was no hollow space, it was full of deliciousness. I took half home and it reheated in my toaster oven really well and was just as tasty. It came with a side of marinara and it was heated. I'm always surprised when a restaurant gives you marinara right out of the refrigerator. Ick! My sister got the steak and cheese and she said it was also delicious. The staff were all very nice and helpful. read more

Mario's Pizza - Calzone special with sausage - Pizza Near Me - Winston Salem, North Carolina

Ordered take out for my father in laws birthday because Mario's is his favorite pizza. He's from NY and swears it's the closest thing around. We got half sausage / half pepperoni, olive, onion and a side salad. Their side salad has all the goodies on it and it was yummy. The pizza was delicious and I'll be back for sure. We ordered online and process was easy. I was able to walk right it and get the pizza. read more

See all

First time to this location - cheese slice, 10 inch Bianca and 2 fountain drinks $25. Took about 15 minutes for the order and was cooked with care. Fast location next to target. Pizza slice for $4 is huge - daughter's face lit up. They do have Cheerwine here and sprinkle cheese in a shaker. Good stop. read more

See all

The food was greasy and had a bad odor to the ham and cheese. The pepperoni was burnt. Overall I was upset for this to be my first experience here. The cashier is standoffish and the manager just protects his kind. Very standoffish people. The inside of the restaurant smelled good but the rest was disappointing. Thanks read more

Food is fantastic. Their service incredible. I would recommend Mario's Pizza to anyone who loves pizza.

This Mario's at Hanes Mall is great. Head and shoulder's above the others. Friendly servers. Neighborhood place. Pizza is NY Style. Ingredients Impressive. Other menu items look good as well. read more

I have never been to a Marios (discovered it is a local chain). There is a place in the resturaunt landscape for places like Mario's, strip malls is just about right. This one is in a bustling stretch of stores along what passes for a busy road in nice little Winston-Salem. The ordering was the first note of concern. The young man working the register (who should usually be the QB of the shift, was more likely a rookie long snapper). The poor lilttle fellow had challeneges communicating, and definetly difficulty relating back what was being said to him. My wife got an italian sub, onion rings, and a drink. The managers special is a sub, a side and a drink. What actually happened was two seperate transaction and us spending $3 more than what should have happened. I ordered a chef salad (this is important later, hang in there) with Ceasar dressing. I also got a slice of "NY style" pizza. The slice was huge, which should be a good thing, but actually in this case, not its best feature. My wife said the sub was "edible", nothing memorable about a lunch meat sandwich on a generic roll. That is not the best praise for a $9 sub. My pizza was NY in the same way that I am Charles Barkley "style", I am tall, brown, bald and have a bit of a belly. The slice was bland, cheese got gummy and the wrong kind of stretchy by the time I finished the slice. The crust texture got worse with each bite was well. I reached into the bag for the salad figuring that would redeem the meal. To my dismay...a plastic container full of romaine, croutons, and parmesan slivers. In MD we call that a Ceasar salad. So chef became ceasar because of the dressing...long snapper stikes again. This place clearly strikes a chord with the local population they serve. That is good for them, I wish the chain and this location success. They will have to do so without our participation. I don't mind a $30 lunch for two, used to it, that's about normal these days. However that price point, the average food, and the mistakes/ordering chaos make it hard for me to think I would ever allow myself risk this place again. We were in town for Army vs. Wake, this was easily the most disappointing meal of the weekend trip. read more

Mario's has been around forever, and their pizza is always delicious. It is just about the best place to get a traditional New York slice in Winston. Not much else to say, if you want a traditional New York slice go to Mario's. read more

Mario's Pizza - 15" New York Style Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Winston Salem, North Carolina

Slice of pizza, a side and a drink can never go wrong for lunch. Served hot and it all tasted delicious! Service was quick during lunch hour which is always a bonus. Pizza slices are big so unless you are hungry, don't let your belly talk you in to two slices. Enjoy your visit and leave satisfied! read more

See all

I got a Stromboli with spinach, mushroom, and sausage. It was what I expected; nothing less, nothing more. It was fresh and hot. And the staff were exceptionally friendly, caring, and energetic. This is a nice place to go if you're craving some quick, reasonably priced pizza and whatnot. read more

Mario's Pizza - Stromboli - Pizza Near Me - Winston Salem, North Carolina

They left our salad and dressing out of the bag and refused to refund us bc it was part of a combo. They offered us 1.50 in cash in which we would have had to drive over to pick it up. read more

I was amazed at the quality of pizza and food Marios has to offer. The pizza sauce is delicious and fresh. The appetizers we had jalapeño poppers and fried mushrooms were tasty and the ranch dressing dip was tasty as well. The 10 inch pizza is enough for two people. I had the pepperoni and could only eat 3 slices. The restaurant is shiny and new and was very clean. The staff was friendly and accommodating. I will return to this restaurant as well as use takeout. Cannot say enough good things about this restaurant, I was impressed!! read more

So glad Mario's is right near my work! Their pizza is AMAZING! They have the thin crispy NY style crust... The kind you can fold in half and eat like a real New Yorker. I got the 1 slice, side and drink lunch special and with tax it came to $8. Not knowing ahead of time how big the slices were, I almost ordered 2. Boy, I am glad I didn't... They have the BIGGEST slices I have ever encountered! I actually had to get a box to take home about 3/4 of my slice bc my side salad was filling in itself!!! LOVE that their fountain beverage machine has ROOT BEER! I feel it's somewhat hard to find root beer around here. You won't even BELIEVE how big some of their pizzas are! I've never seen anything like it. They are literally the size of a table. It's nice that they have indoor and outdoor seating too! Can't wait to have my husband try Mario's! Will definitely be back!!! Maybe tonight?!?! read more

Mario's Pizza - Lunch special. Slice, side and drink came to $8 - Pizza Near Me - Winston Salem, North Carolina

We stop in for lunch ordered two pizza slices, house salad and 6 wings. Menu has other options available. Offers inside and outside seating. Nice size pizza slices lots of options to put on your cheese pizza at .50 each. We enjoyed our lunch. read more

Mario's Pizza - Pizza by the slice - Pizza Near Me - Winston Salem, North Carolina

See all

It was really good pizza but I wish they had real Canadian bacon. It's ham instead. I don't know, is that a southern thing? I'm kind of a stickler. I love pineapple & Canadian bacon pizza, but I don't really like how thick ham usually is. Think I've just been spoiled! Still really enjoyed their pizza so I'm leaving a 5 star review. read more

Great pizza good costumer service I met MIKE THE PIZZA GUY SO IT WAS A GOOD TIME I will be coming back pizza was awesome

Mario's never disappoints. They have the best Philly cheesesteak I've ever eaten. One night my boyfriend ordered me one and of course he ordered it wrong, we got there around closing time to pick it up and I told them that I didn't want it with lettuce tomato and mayo. The grill was off. But they were caring enough to make me another one- the way I wanted it. Now that's customer service. Thanks Mario's! read more

Mario's Pizza - Cheesesteak - Pizza Near Me - Winston Salem, North Carolina

See all

The absolute best pizza place in Winston. I love how they stay true to NY style pizza. This is how pizza should taste & look, slices larger than your hands which have to be folded in half to even fit in your mouth. If you have room for dessert, a must try is their limoncello cake & cannoli take me back to my NY day. 5 stars easily. read more

Mario's is one of the best New York style pizza places in Winston-Salem but I don't usually come here for the pizza. I come for the Chick-O-Philly served "Mario's Way". If you've never tried anything but the pizza from Mario's you are missing one of the best sandwiches in Winston. This sandwich is so good you will crave it! Everything about it, from the crusty warm toasted roll to the gooey cheese and the tangy oil and vinegar make it so perfectly delicious I could just eat one right now! Anyway, they also have other good things but for me, the Chick-o-philly sandwich is the only thing on the menu. read more

Mario's Pizza - Chicken Philly Mario's way - Pizza Near Me - Winston Salem, North Carolina

Food is pretty good but I gotta give only 2 stars because if you buy a kids meal to go for your little one at home, you're not allowed to have the drink that comes with it. And they don't discount the meal for not getting the drink. They have to see the child, even when you're picking up food for the entirely family to take home, in order to give you the drink that comes with their meal. I thought they were joking, but they're not. read more

Yes, absolutely yes to this delicious pizza! We got the massive 24"er and it was so worth it. The sheer size of this thing is kind of awe inspiring and comical at the same time. Def worth a visit. read more

Great pizza at a fair price with friendly staff and convenient hours. Always welcoming when we come to pick up our to go order and the waiting area is nice and clean. read more

I was able to put in my order online and pick up my order in 25 minutes. The pizza was good overall. The cheese to sauce ratio was complimentary and the dough itself was very good as well. I would order from here again if I was in the area. The restaurant is located within a shopping strip with easy access to parking. read more

Mario's Pizza - Black olive pizza - Pizza Near Me - Winston Salem, North Carolina

See all

This is a great location if you want pizza while you are shopping. The restaurant is small but the service is fast and friendly. They have some awesome lunch specials. I ordered a slice of cheese with a side of mozzarella sticks. Both were hot and tasty. The tea was good as well. read more

Mario's Pizza - lunch special - Pizza Near Me - Winston Salem, North Carolina

I've always spoke highly of marios. It reminds me of the NY street pizza. But, with that being said, the Clemmons branch did no justice today. The zucchini was overdone, the wings overdone, the pizza, well underdone. At least the taste was there. But, all fail. Please address this. read more

When I saw this saying "authentic NY style pizza," I had my reservations. First off, lots of people claim to have this in the South but it doesn't measure up. Second, I live in NYC, have a spouse & in-laws who are Italian and have had plenty of authentic Italian food. While I'm not the pizza connoisseur my spouse is, I have been able to taste the difference in foods prepared by Southerners vs. NY Italians despite growing up in this area of NC. Anyhow, decided I'd try it for the Yelp review and while I always have reservations when anyone claims something is "authentic" for an area their restaurant is not located it, this place wasn't bad at all. They had garlic knots on the menu (a delicacy I've only seen in NYC & Long Island) and the cannoli was consistent with what I've had in my region. My slice was also good & standard with the size of a NY slice, though a tad pricier than what I've had in parts of Manhattan (nearly $3.00 for a slice of cheese). Overall, if you miss NY style pizza & cuisine, I've found this place wasn't a bad substitute. In closing, let me state for any local residents that the definitive BEST NY style pizza is & always will be in NY. End of story. read more

Great pizza! Picked this place on a whim, and was not disappointed. Also had the toasted ravioli and fried mushrooms. Service was fast and friendly. We called ahead and it was ready inside of 20 minutes. Upon picking up our food, had to add 2 cannoli to the order. These were the bomb! read more

Mario's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Winston Salem, North Carolina

See all

There are quite a few pizza places to choose from, but to me they all fall short except for Mario's. I feel this is the closest thing to true New York style pizza around, the cheese is the best and the sauce is excellent. It isnt too doughy like most places. The slices and pies are huge. Mario's is the only pizza place I eat at these days. read more

The service is very poor. I came in and stood in line. The Door Dash person steps in front of me and I explain that I was next. The cashier not only skipped me after hearing this, to gIve the Door Dash person her pick up order, but then held a whole conversation while I waitEd. I left and when I called to complain the manager said, "I don't know what to tell you."....answer is you apologize to the person who took the time to come to your restaurant and has spent money there for years. read more

I have been eating Pizza from Mario's for years. This location has gone way down hill. Being Italian from up North, finding this place "years" ago helped my missing home. But, they have left the art of pizza making to employees that have no idea. WE ORDERED A SIMPLE PEPPERONI PIZZA TO GO. WHICH HAD "NO TOMATO SAUCE"!! PLUS THEY GOT RID OF THEIR LEGIT MOZZARELLA FOR A "CHEAPER" VERSION!!!! read more

I am from NewYork City and this place serves authentic New York pizza. Not only that, they have a New York Pizzeria vibe, including the red, white and green wax paper drink cups. When I saw "Pizza by the slice" in the window I knew I had to check this place out. I had a plain slice, a side salad and a drink. You can get that for $8. The slice is gigantic and has the crispy crust and great cheese and sauce flavor of a true NY slice. The salad was ok, iceberg lettuce with some onion and peppers. Couldn't resist a cannoli for dessert and it was really good, also. Shell was fresh and crisp. Filling was excellent and they put an extra shot of it on the outside. Why only 4 stars? I'm pretty stingy with stars. 4 stars means it really good, check it out! read more

Mario's Pizza - Cheese pizza, side salad and drink - Pizza Near Me - Winston Salem, North Carolina

See all

Good quality food! Amazing staff. Very clean and organized. We love the pizza and wings here. Can't wait to try other food here.

Ordered takeout from Grubhub this evening. 10" gluten free pizza and couple of side salads. The gluten free pizza crust was excellent. Just the right amount of toppings and the crust was excellent. I will definitely be ordering this again in the future. Thanks so much Mario's for exceeding my expectations! You Rock! read more

I went to this place super pumped to have New York style pizza, but I think I overhyped myself for it. It wasn't bad but not great. The service was fine and prices were good. With that said it was the closest thing to NY style pizza in the area and I wouldn't definitely go back to give it a go! read more

I came in to pick up a takeout order. None of the employees were wearing masks in the kitchen and in the 5 minutes I was waiting I saw an employee touch/move the pizzas with his bare hands at least 3 times read more

If you want the best pizza, marios is the place to go, the pizza is always top notch when i get it and Mario himself is the best in the business, if you want your moneys worth you gotta go to marios pizza you won't regret it! read more

I was so happy to see this location after a bit of holiday shopping in that plaza. I thought I was going to have to go over to Cloverdale, forgetting they had a location here. This location is much smaller than their location on Cloverdale, but the food is the same deliciousness. When it's lunch time I always go for their slice of pizza, side salad, and drink special. It is pretty cheap and a ridiculously filling lunch for the price. I usually have leftovers since the pizza slices are so large. The service was friendly and really efficient as well even though they were in the middle of a lunch rush on a Saturday. When I am at this side of town, I would stop in again for lunch for sure! read more