the food and service was amazing I can't recommend it enough. Overall the vibe and hospitality was…read moreimpeccable 10/10

The service is very good, water glasses are constantly filled and plates cleared quickly. Been…read moretwice and have tried different dishes, everything was good. The restaurant is pretty inside and very lovely outside on the water.

TLDR: LI outpost of a popular Italian chain from the city. Prefix lunch is priced well but portions…read moreare a bit on the smaller side. It's small but nice in here, had always known about Il Mulino but just recently tried it. Got two prefix lunches. They provide a complimentary bread basket with focaccia, some parmigiano and zucchini chips. Starters we chose beef carpaccio and octopus. The carpaccio is classic, pounded thin, shaved parmigiano and a lemony arugula salad on top. The octopus is tender and served with pickled onions and a frisee salad. Mains, did the lobster ravioli and the steak frites. Large size ravioli but three pieces, so they do go quickly. The lobster is mixed in with the ricotta which is quite soft. The steak portion was decent but keep in mind also a $10 add-on. Cooked a bit more well than I'd like but the sauce was good. Desserts were a panna cotta and flourless chocolate cake. The panna cotta has a more bouncy jello-like consistency. Chocolate cake was good. Not bad options for a PF lunch but definitely standard menu will add up fast.

Four years ago my husband took me out here for my birthday. We did Sunday Supper, which was just…read morelaunched I believe. There was a small parking lot and upon entry parts of the place was still under renovation. Since we had early dinner there were families dining and the place was overall empty. Our server was knowledgeable and was upselling alcohol to my husband. When he told the server he wanted ginger ale, the server stated that they did not have ginger ale so he had to settle for a glass of wine. We ordered from the Sunday Supper prix fixe menu. We received complimentary bread, salami and zucchini. For the appetizers we ordered the eggplant rollatini, mussels and minestrone soup. For the main entrees I ordered the ravioli al porcini with truffle and veal marsala. I loved the ravioli with truffle. Portions were small. Dessert was served with a sampler of cake slices. I would definitely love to return especially that their prix menus have been expanded but unfortunately they do not have the items we ordered in their current prix fixe menus.

Five of us were there on a Wednesday for dinner and were able to order off the $40 three-course…read morespecial menu, which was more extensive than others we've seen. Like most three-course special menus, there are upcharges for various selections. Sometimes in retrospect I regret ordering three courses because a single entrée is sufficient. That was the case here because I was almost full after eating their chopped salad appetizer and the heated Italian bread and butter that preceded the entrée. I was surprised because an appetizer salad is often a small or medium sized plate, but here it's a full sized platter. Also, I ate it all, when I could've taken home half. Ditto for my entrée, their chicken marsala. I know that some of our friends purposely take home half of everything, so they get two meals out of one order. My decision, however, piggy as sounds, was that one of their included desserts was the tiramisu, which I have trouble resisting ... to the point where I try to sample them in as many restaurants and bakeries as possible, as if someday, somewhere, I'll submit an article on the subject ... "Tiramisus of Long Island and NYC." The food and service were very good, we had a large round table in the back, that made it easy for us to talk, a nice tablecloth and thick napkins, but I've had better tiramisu. A free glass of white or red wine came with the special, but I didn't like mine and should, like my son, have gotten a diet Coke instead (a permissible substitution). The parking situation was a minor hassle in that there was no valet, and while a sign in front of the restaurant suggested parking in the lot across the street, when we went there, the signs said that after 5:30 PM they'll tow you away, so we found a spot in the neighborhood and walked a few blocks. We'd be happy to go back, although there are Italian restaurants just as good that are closer to where we live. This Matteo's was half way between where we five reside, and convenience matters, especially on a weekday night.

food service hospitality ALL EXCELLENT !!!…read morebrian u are the best - thank U for the last-minute table at one of our favorite spots !!! see u soon

What a turnaround! My prior review was from 3 years ago when the restaurant was called Sandro's and…read morebefore the renovation. We would not have come back except we had plans with friends who wanted to meet here. So glad we did! My main complaint before was the acoustics. The renovation with added decor to dampen noise did the trick. I didn't even notice that the restaurant was full. We ordered different dishes and ate it family style so got to try a few different dishes. I didn't order so don't know the specific names but we shared a salad, a spicy calamari, egg yolk ravioli, black linguini with seafood, catfish, and a veal parm. I especially enjoyed the ravioli. Flavors were nice on all the dishes. I don't know if it was the company but I didn't notice a lapse in service. The servers were attentive. The parking was still ample. I'm glad we came back and a little regretful that we waited so long.

Let me start by saying this was hands down one of the most exceptional dining experiences I've had…read morein a long time. From the moment we walked in, the hospitality was truly next-level. The ambiance was warm and inviting, and every single person from the host to the bartender to our server and everyone in between played a part in making the night feel special. The attentiveness, professionalism, and genuine kindness did not go unnoticed, and it set the tone for the entire evening. We were first greeted with warm bread and olive oil, which was absolutely delightful and the perfect start. Our server, Paulino (I hope I'm spelling his name right), guided us through the menu with such care and knowledge, which made the experience even better. We started with the mussels Bianco and baked clams both were outstanding, easily a 9/10. Fresh, flavorful, and perfectly prepared. For our entrées, we had the branzino and a pasta dish that was nothing short of amazing. The attention to detail like freshly cracked pepper added right at the table made everything feel elevated and thoughtfully done. To end the night, I mentioned that my mom had just passed her real estate exam and that we were celebrating her. They went above and beyond by bringing out an apple crostini with a candle, which was such a thoughtful and memorable touch. And yes, we devoured the entire thing. It was that good. Truly a 10000/10 moment. What made this experience even more meaningful is that it came after a long, stressful day at the ER. Walking into such warmth, care, and genuine hospitality meant more than I can put into words. Thank you again for the incredible service, attentiveness, and overall experience. I truly wish I could remember everyone's names because each person we encountered was a pleasure. Please let them know my mom and I are so grateful. We dined on April 3rd around 9 PM, and it's a night we won't forget.

Came here for a plain slice and a fountain coke for my birthday lunch, a throwback to my youth…read moregrowing up in Queens. This slice is just like the one near my old neighborhood. Everything came together so well - the crust, the sauce, the cheese. It was a perfect birthday lunch. Even had a good conversation going with the owner about some well-known pizzerias in Queens. NOTE: cash only, there's an ATM machine in front

6-15-25. My first time here. Was in the neighborhood and a…read morequick Yelp search revealed Villa Milano had some good reviews. Decided to give it a try. Chicken Marsala slice was excellent.....good amount of chicken with lots of mushrooms (just the way I like it). Also had a plain ol' regular slice which was also good. Guys behind the counter were very good. They were patient with customers and did a nice job of explaining their specialty slices on display to a few customers on line while my pizza was being heated. Inside is nice.....plenty of seating for the pizza portion of the restaurant.......and in the back they had a dining room with table service. I'd have no problem returning when in the area again.

they have outdoor and indoor seatings. You can order by single slice or by pies. have pasta and…read moresalad also. rosemary garlic wings were good.

The service was quick and friendly, no issues whatsoever. The ambiance was chill, no long line or…read moreloud people. The pizza was good, tasty and not too oily. All three slices plus a selzter bottled water came to $26, so it was pretty pricy.

I start with the service -one of the owners Troy introduced…read morehimself and was very warm and made sure we were taken cared of -our waiter could not be more attentive and friendly Then the food -we ordered half portions (good move) coz servings are big -baked clams and calamari for appetizers -seafood pasta and chicken franchaise -all 4 were delicious The ambiance -mature/upscale -black and white -clean -very good crowd and vibe -noise was was energetic and not very noisy -brick wall outside the window on the side was a nice touch so that you don't see that you are looking at a residential side street in Albertson -toilets were clean Price and Value -for the size of the portions and the quality of the food you are getting the price was very fair and great value I highly recommend this place and will come back again. BRAVO to the owners and management

A fantastic dinner we just had tonight!…read more We've returned several times since my last review, and the experience has been consistently excellent every time. Tyson, one of the owners, warmly greeted us upon arrival and kept us updated during our short wait. Even on a Monday evening, the dining room was already packed and buzzing with energy. Glenn, our server tonight, is always funny, personable, and wonderful. He made us feel right at home, as always. I had my usual favorite, the family-style Calabrian Linguine with garlic and oil, topped with toasted 4C spicy breadcrumbs. I had been craving it, and it absolutely hit the spot! Hubby ordered the half-size Chicken Dino with boneless chicken over escarole and beans, fresh artichoke hearts, and spicy cherry peppers. He loved it! I had some of the escarole, beans, and artichoke hearts, and they were honestly some of the best I've ever had. We even had plenty left over to enjoy the next day! What truly sets this restaurant apart, though, is the exceptional hospitality. Tyson, Matthew, Glenn, and the entire team genuinely make their guests feel valued and appreciated. John A., who served us a few months ago, even stopped by to say hello and made a point of saying goodbye when we left. Those thoughtful personal touches say so much about the kind of place this is. Excellent food, wonderful people, and truly outstanding hospitality. We always leave happy and satisfied, and we'll definitely be back soon!

5+ Stars! We stopped by today as a random choice for lunch,…read moreand didn't realize we hadn't been here for about 4 years! And the food and service is just as good as it's always been. First, a shout out to Danny, for his superb service and friendly, professional demeanor. And to our surprise, he was our server 4 years ago and remembered us! Now to the food. My Spaghetti with Lobster and Mussels, with a zesty and delicious Fra Diablo, was deliciously perfect! My wife had the Branzino entree, also delicious and perfectly prepared! Dessert was the smores sundae to share, a great choicee with some hot coffee. A perfect afternoon with beautiful lakeside seating. Thank you Danny and thank you to Gatsby's for a spectacular lunch experience!

I was truly stunned by our dinner at Gatsby's Landing. My family and I came in for an unassuming…read morebirthday dinner and we left with full hearts and bellies! They start you off with some warm buns served with honey butter and they were GOOD. So good that we asked for more and then tried to stop ourselves from devouring them before our food even arrived. For appetizer, we ordered the crispy calamari. The batter was very light and the calamari itself was so delicate and sweet. You can definitely tell how fresh the seafood is and that stayed true for the rest of our meal. For pastas, we got the spaghetti fra diavolo containing lobster and shrimp. Again, the seafood was fresh, sweet, and tender. The pasta was also a shocker, not only was it perfectly firm, it had such a nice chewy texture. You can feel and taste how homemade the pasta is. Next, the rigatoni eggplant was our unexpected favorite. The pasta texture was even better with the rigatoni shape and the eggplant was not even noticeable, it blended in so well with the sauce. The ricotta on top was the perfect creamy addition. For proteins, the pork chop was very tender and juicy. The sweet glaze wasn't overly sweet and it really complimented the savoriness of the meat. The brussel sprouts on this dish were also outstanding. I love when a restaurant doesn't treat the veggies as a side dish! The branzino was light and refreshing, it was a really great balance to the other saucier dishes we had. The service was extremely attentive and so friendly. They really took care of us and made sure we enjoyed our meal.

The best Italian restaurant in Port Washington. Freddy the…read moreowner of Toscanini,his very nice and friendly to all of his customers. The Ambiance is the most beautiful place, Service and the food are excellent.

This place is so wonderful. The food is outrageously delicious, fresh and flavorful. The service is…read morewonderful. The atmosphere is charming. This is one of our favorite places.

My friend and I had the three-course prix fixe lunch with a glass of house wine this afternoon…read more The service was outstanding and was definitely the highlight of our visit. From the moment we walked in, the manager welcomed us warmly, and the entire team was friendly, attentive, and professional. Our server, Edisson R. L., provided excellent service throughout our meal. I had dined here several times before, and I was pleasantly surprised that Edisson recognized me right away and greeted me warmly. That personal touch made us feel like valued guests. The food was flavorful, and we enjoyed most of the courses. My only disappointment was the portion size. Compared to the prix fixe lunch at my favorite Long Island restaurant, the appetizer and entrée portions here were noticeably smaller, even though the price was higher. While everything was tasty, I didn't feel the prix fixe lunch offered good value for the price. Overall, the ambiance was lovely, and it was a wonderful place to catch up with my friend. The outstanding hospitality and attentive service made for an enjoyable afternoon.

Ordered steak. Cooked to perfection. The sides are OK.... They lack flavor!!…read more Drinks are amazing. My favorite is the strawberry basil martini. Tasty and refreshing. Service is great and the ambiance is perfect for date night.