Food was AMAZING!!!! Pizza was freshly baked, hand tossed & cooked to perfection!!!! The cheese…read moresticks are definitely that!!! Cheesy!!!! Food came out fresh & hot. 10/10 recommend to anyone in the area.

Came here cause we heard reviews about this pizza ordered a pepperoni pizza first, it had the right…read moreamount of pole of cheese, good amount of pepperoni on top in different layers of flavor, which were greatly appreciated. We also ordered the loaded potato pizza I'm not gonna downgrade because it wasn't what I prefer. It tasted exactly what I was supposed to do with the potatoes, bacon cheese and ranch on it just not something I would order again with my pallet but again great texture, size of pizza, as well as flavor combinations would eat at this establishment again only downside is walking in there is not a very upliftingvibe and there was only one gentleman working and he did not seem very enthused to be there did enjoy the different TVs seating could be better. Our bench was actually broken on the booth, so we sunk almost a foot when we sat down.

Such an amazing hole in the wall place! Absolutely delicious and service was impeccable! Avery,…read moreKylie, and Rachel are some fantastic gals. My husband's airborne instructor told the guys to skip Dominos and have actual good food. He was definitely right. Definitely a must have spot! Seating is a bit limited but they are happy to help a group find/create space to accommodate dining in.

First time here and the pizza did not disappoint! It was as delicious as anticipated and we lucked…read moreout with getting seated at a table upon arrival. Both pizzas came out within 30 minutes, the staff and customer service were great! Can't wait to come back!

Very good deep dish pizza. I really enjoy the taste of their sauce. I plan to go back to try more…read moreitems soon!!

Nancy's pizzeria…read more Never in my lifetime did I expect to give a pizza place an undisputed 4 star rating, yet here I am wondering if I should round it up to a 5. To preface this review, I've had many a slices of pizza from all over the country (New York, Chicago, New Jersey and Connecticut to name a few). I've eaten at places where the wait is an hour long due to their reputation. I've grab pizza from one pizzeria and subsequently grab pizza from their competitors down the street for a side by side comparison (Frank Pepe's and Sally's Apizza). The scope of reach for these taste buds don't stop there. Italy has blessed me with fine dining of their finest 'za. So call my tongue promiscuous when it comes to cheese slapped on a crust, I know my pizza. That being said, the south is known for many things (good and bad) with pizza being in the latter. Yet today, today, I stumbled upon a potential shift in the tradition of southern states' notorious letdown in pizza quality. Nancy's gets a solid 4.4 stars from me putting them in competition with some sit down restaurants I've attended. Not only that, I drove nearly 40 mins back home, blowing red lights and hitting speeds upwards of 85 mph so that the "goods" would still be warm. To my surprise not only was it warm, it was hot to the touch. Now does the credit go to the driver or the stores expert packaging this remains a mystery. Now, this pizza for all the good does have one trade-off that can't go without being noticed: price. Save some money in the piggy bank for this one cause it was nearly 30 smackaroos. Is that high in absolute terms, yes. But when you look at relative terms considering the style of pizza deep dish, this is standard. All in all, I shall return.

I moved to Columbus recently and have been disappointed by the Asian cuisine offerings. However,…read morethis was a solid calzone, and I say that as someone who grew up in the northeast (NY) and who has high standards for pizza and calzones in general. I think the only improvement could have been the addition of ricotta. I assumed that a cheese calzone came with ricotta but that wasn't the case. It was still really delicious and I would order again.

The pizza is absolutely incredible!! Be prepared for a wait because it's fresh! We sat at the bar…read morewith a beer during the wait and there was incredibly friendly service. There's some pool tables also. Bathrooms could use a clean tho. Overall great experience. Don't live in the area but I'd come back for sure

Customer service was amazing here Lots of seating inside…read more Some seating outside The pizza had a good flavor to it. The sauces can also help with more flavor Cool spot on Broadway in Columbus Lemon pepper wings were so so

Casual pizza spot where you can build a pizza to your liking or choose one of their specials. It…read morechecks all the boxes for me! There are tons of ingredients to choose from (including vegan cheese) and toppings are unlimited - even if you start with one of the menu pizzas, you can make as many changes as you want. Lots of room to get creative. They also have a range of sizes: the 7" and 10" pizzas are both suitable for one person depending on your appetite, and the bigger size would be good for sharing. It's not the cheap greasy type of pizza, so depending on the ingredients you choose, you can create a relatively balanced meal. There's also pasta and salad on offer, which I did not try. For dessert, they have a modest gelato selection too (6-8 flavours if I remember correctly, mostly pretty standard stuff with a few specials), which also seems pretty high quality. Decent beer selection with the basics plus a few craft beers. First visit (2023): Tried the Kickin' BBQ Peach Pizza, a summer special menu item, and got rid of the bacon, added peppadew peppers and basil. It was really good! I love the pairing of fruity and spicy so the flavours were right on the mark for me. I might leave off the peppadew peppers if I were to redo my order just to keep things simple since the ingredients that came with the pizza were already really flavourful, but they were still a tasty addition. I had a scoop of peaches & cream gelato for dessert. Very creamy, with swirls of real peach compote. Second visit (2024): Same quality as last year. I did a custom order with a buffalo sauce base, vegan cheese, and some veggie toppings. The vegan cheese is standard stuff, same as you can buy at the grocery store; slightly gooier than real cheese but works fine. My pizza came out delicious. The service is pretty fast for food made to order. The staff were friendly and seemed eager to help customers customize their pizza, so I didn't feel like I was a bother for modifying the recipe.

Wanted to order takeout pizza and saw how highly rated this restaurant is so I tried it. When I…read morecalled in I had to ask the gentleman to repeat the price because it sounded too inexpensive. I heard him right! When I arrived at the restaurant I thought I was in the wrong place. Definitely a hole in the wall Super friendly and by far/very far the best pizza in town.

Still the best pizza in town for the price! Paid $8 for a large pepperoni pizza and it was…read moredelicious!

Service was fine but this was the worst pizza I have ever had. Very soft flavorless dough. The…read moremarinara did not taste like marinara.

I gave this place a 2nd chance tonight but I will never do so again. Why did I just spend 24 bucks…read moreon a cheese pizza that tastes frozen? Its not even warm and the cheese isn't melted in the middle.

Johnny's New York Style Pizza was an excellent choice for our family. From the moment we walked in,…read morethe staff was welcoming and accommodating, making it easy to settle in with our kids. The restaurant is spacious, which made a huge difference for a family meal and gave everyone plenty of room to relax. The pizza was outstanding; fresh, flavorful, and exactly what you hope for from a New York-style slice. Most importantly, our kids absolutely loved the food and cleaned their plates without any complaints. Great atmosphere, great service, and great pizza. We'll definitely be coming back.

Johnny, stick to pizza. The pasta dishes were lacking flavor. I ordered Tuscany chicken and the…read morepasta was dry no sauce . On the other hand your pizza is outstanding 5 out of 5 stars

Good restaurant and nice atmosphere. The food was delicious and the service was excellent. Would…read moredefinitely recommend the pizza.

Sad. A mile from our hotel and a nice looking website. Apparently the corporate vegan menu doesn't…read moreextend all the way to Columbus. I was able to order a pizza with nondairy cheese, green peppers and Italian sausage. The green peppers were raw and the crust was only partially cooked and doughy. Not much luck with the beer list I was handed either. My third choice was available but not much to my liking. The server should have pointed me to the updated tap list on the screen to my left. Instead I felt rushed and ordered something I wasn't sure about. Second time here as we pass through Columbus yearly. Likely to be the last.

First time eating here and I give it a five star for service (Melody is great, attentive, and takes…read morecare of her customers). The hostess is so friendly and greets everyone with a smile. Ok the food? Excellent from the appetizers (calamari is spot on), cheese sticks and bruschetta were great. Love the crunchiness of the French bread. We had the chicken pesto and it was so delicious. Love the thin crust too. Very flavorfu! By the way I appreciate that the music was not so dang loud we could t hear each other talk. It was a pleasant decibel level And the music choice was perfect. We will definitely be back and I'll be bringing my work crew here for lunch. Pricing is good as week if you're looking to get bang for your buck. Good portions here as well. So trek on over and give it a try - you won't be disappointed!!

The pizza was fabulous and the bruschetta was even better. Great prices and quantity of food. The…read moreatmosphere was relaxing and the bartender/waiter was so friendly and warming. The Italian margarita he made was excellent. It's now one of my new favorite cocktails!!!