Probably won't find a family from Ohio stopping here on the way home from the Zoo! Very, Very, Local. 99% of the customers probably stopped for a beer, found good food, and keep coming back. One of the best, non-advertised low-key Tenderloins in the city limits. ( or is Shadeland Dr. the city limit)? am no way connected to, have been employed by or know the owners of any establishment that I decide to critique. My opines are genuine, and come from my lips, tongue, stomach, brain, then from brain to finger to tiny keyboard on phone. AND I am a better Restaurant/Bar/Gaming/Customer Service consultant then writer, so, if you need honest, to the point help, email me. read more

Food is amazing. Order online pickup at the door throughout corona pandemic. Supper our local Eastside business.

The Mutt is a fantastic bar of Eastside Indy. I enjoy having a drink here with coworkers, family, or friends. The food is one of the best parts. I'd say my favorite dishes would be the Thai chili shrimp tacos, the fish tacos, and the boneless wings. Try the regular buffalo or the sweet chili sauce on the wings. The only reason why I wouldn't give this place 5 stars is that service is sometimes very slow. I've sometimes waited up to 40 minutes for a waitress to come back to my table, which makes it difficult if you need another drink, or to be somewhere, and want to pay your bill. read more

After growing up in the burbs of Indy you become accustom to these great hole in the wall bars that offer local music and loud neighborhood friends. I'd heard of Manley's through some friends so when their band had the opportunity to play here we joined them for my pop's 72nd birthday weekend! The atmosphere of the bar was fantastic with all of the murals dedicated to the firefighters. The food was a mix of typical bar fair and a step above. I had the North (side?) wrap... I think it was named something to that effect. It had an avocado spread and bacon in it. That topped off my choice! It was a really good wrap for a bar like this! And the homemade chips were the best that I have ever had! My parents shared one of the pizzas. I wonder if it was a store bought packaged one due to the fact that they found a piece of plastic in it. Though the server said she would do something about it; she didn't. I found this somewhat appalling. Though the server was good with everything else we found this to be quite disappointing. Rating would have been higher if she had done something! read more

This is a great community bar with really good food. The service is friendly and familiar. I will keep coming back!

Manley's is a classic neighborhood bar - it's nothing fancy,with standard bar food, but they have a decent beer selection and the servers are friendly and quick. It's a roomy place and I appreciate the good-sized outdoor patio. All in all, it's easy to feel comfortable at Manley's. Just throw a black bean burger on the menu, and this would be five stars in my book! read more

We went here for lunch on a Tuesday. We waited 1 hour and 10 minutes for our food and were told it was going to be another 10-15 minutes. Had to leave. read more

Service was pretty good, only forgot 1 thing all night and still got charged. Quick to bring drinks, the atmosphere is open space- very eclectic crowd. read more

This place was solid. Great corned beef sandwich called the Molly. Good beer selection and prices. Music but you can still talk! Pull tabs if you want to gamble. Our waitress was blond don't remember her name but she was nice and accommodating. I don't live near here but would come again to meet family and friends! read more

Always my choice when I get to pick where we eat! Large menu to choose from and everything is so good. There have been maybe 2 times where the food wasn't quite as good as normal, or not as described on the menu but it's always when there's a different cook. They have great pizza, sandwiches, salads, wraps and burgers. The crowd can be a bit, let's say, clickish. Overall I love the atmosphere and they do bring in some great entertainment. The building is in some need of renovation (especially the bathrooms) but in an odd way it adds to the charm. Overall I always choose the Mutt over a chain or higher end restaurant any day! read more

Food good..service slow..kinda pricey for atmosphere/ambiance.

An excellent place for for bar food that far exceeds expectations. Each time I dined have found the experience memorable and prices reasonable for portions served. Definitely have this on my short list of great local establishments for lunch or dinner. Try it and I am sure you will be pleased with the choice. read more

This is a great hangout bar, with a lively Friday night atmosphere. Tonight there is a great cover acoustic co we band, which is a frequent occurrence. Highly the potato skins to go along with a few cold beers. They are thin, but not too thin and crispy. Overall I would sum it up as Great food. Great music. Great company!! read more

My wife and went their last night--first time. We had heard they had good Tenderloins!. Nice place, good atmosphere. A little loud, but it is a "bar". Food was good, service was good. Based on what waitress told us, Sunday evening is the time to go if you don't want to be part of a big crowd. We will be going back! read more

I arrived with a group of eight to have a good time. All was well until I dared to play a different genre of music than the constant country music that was being played. I made this selection about 1:30 a.m. That was enough to get the music shut off by employees of this establishment after they rudely insulted me and my choice of music. I will not be back after the rudeness and intolerance that was displayed by staff. After this, they started closing down when they are supposed to be open til 3 a.m. They were putting up chairs and getting rid of customers. To top it all off, just before I left I went ou the front door and I heard a waitress on the patio exclaim that someone had taken a crap on the patio. It wasn't me but I kind of wish it was now after my shitty treatment at this establishment. read more

Okay the tater tots are to die for, and they make a mean Reuben still an amazing place to chill and enjoy each other company

Great neighborhood hole in the wall with above average bar food, lg menu selection and up scale liquors available, do not go for any wine, it is not their thing. They do have bands on the weekends and have added an enclosed patio which is designated the smoking area. read more

The food is typical bar food...greasy and pretty standard. The waitress was very nice but seemed to be busy elsewhere and difficult to find. The band was ok but their music seemed to drown out much of their words. I had the loaded nachos. A lot of chips with very little other ingredients. My husband had the tenderloin and loved it. read more

I had never been to Manley's Irish Mutt before, but my friend from Ireland was playing music there about a week before Saint Patrick's Day, so we decided to go in and check out his set. Manley's reminds me of a locals only watering hole in the best way! The energy was great on the night we were there! Everyone was having a good time. Although we didn't get anything to eat that night (my husband had a diet soda and I had a pint of Guinness) there were people all around us that had a lot of good looking and smelling food! We don't get to the east side of Indy that often, but we will be going back to Manley's. read more

Been here a couple times the first time I met a friend there and got waited on had a very good tenderloin that was meaty and seasoned. My only issue was it literally took about 10 minutes just to pay my tab the bartender kept talking to her friends. I verbally asked to pay and after about 5 minutes I raised my hand like I was in grade school. So I haven't been in there for a couple months went back Friday since I was over that way and wanted a tenderloin walked in at 1:30 still had some people eating but not packed I sat at the bar there was 6 or 7 other people at the bar I sat down looked right at the bartender which was a different lady she never once acknowledged me I sat there and watched her fill our her football parlay card and give it to some guy then she collected from another patron still has not asked me if I want a beer or if I was eating she went into the kitchen came back out and started talking to the waitress on the other side of the cash register where now I can't even see her i counted off a full minute she never came over so I got up and walked out after about eight minutes they can kiss my ass. I guess you have to be in the click damn ridiculous and i tip well all I want is some damn simple service. You should always acknowledge a customer when they walk in terrible bartender. read more

One of the best and most consistent burgers I have had in a long time. Always a fun crowd and friendly staff. Bartender was pleasant and fun. Have been there several times and will gladly go back again. read more

This is still my favorite dive bar in the city. My former coworkers and I still love to gather here on occasion for a few drinks and some good food. Yes, some of the food is probably just fried from frozen, but with a few drinks on a Friday night, that's exactly what is called for. I love their Cheesy Breadsticks! They're cheese-stuffed breadsticks that you can dip in cheese sauce! I love bread and cheese so these are right up my alley. The tenderloin is very good, and Irish nachos are a big hit with a crowd. read more

We were coming home from the colts game and got off the interstate looking for a place to eat. We found this small bar. Our waitress was really nice and the food was great. They had big portion sizes too. Nice little place to eat if you want to get a little outside the city. read more

Great neighborhood bar. Good service. Megan is an awesome bartender and extends a warm welcome to all. Ever if she doesn't know you! They have great specials. read more

Loved it from the moment I walked in... Live music, great feeling.. Food was great, beer cold.

Comfortable Irish Pub with good food! We had the fish tacos (excellent) and fish and chips (good). Seems like a great place to hang out and eat with your friends! read more

This little pub is straight awesome. We walked in and sat without waiting too long before the waitress came. She was the only waitress on duty, but that didn't slow her down. We ordered our food and waited almost no time for it. I definitely recommend the tenderloin, but the Western burger is AMAZING. After two entrees, an appetizer, and two beers our bill came out to about $35. It was a great meal and we will definitely return! read more

My cousin was in town to visit before my Pops was headed into the VA (review already done - great peeps), hadn't seen him in ages so we went out for a bite and a couple pints. I can tell that this place has a good set of regulars and the size of the joint belies it is used often but not on a weekday at lunch (which is when we went). The Smithwick's was nice and cold and went down REALLY well, attentive bar staff and lots of TV's in the joint. Fresh on the menu was touted an Irish Stew, they "just" finished it. Well hell we said, we'll have that. Sadly what knocked a star off was the stew. The meat was tough as shoe leather and the broth/gravy didn't have a real good depth of flavor and I could taste the alcohol in it. Telling me it either had too much put in, or it wasn't put in soon enough. I get the feeling that instead of searing off the meat, then cooking the veg, adding in the liquid then braising the meat slowly at low heat for several hours, they just put everything in a pot and boiled the shit out of it. Too bad, because they kind of had the right idea with what was in it. All in all a good spot for a pint and if you like Notre Dame, even better ;) read more

Stopped here as part of a pub crawl. The interior was brighter and more open than I expected. We were only here for one drink and, of course, our group was a bit overwhelming but we were served as soon as we sat down at a table. It's a bit out of the way for me but I'd definitely go back were I in the area. Good selection although they only had Harp in a bottle, not on draft. Boo. read more

I went here because of high Yelp ratings, and because I try to patronize local businesses when traveling. Unfortunately, the service was so bad I have to give it just 1 star. The waitress messed up both my drink and food orders in multiple ways, and the 2 men uttering profanities over the video golf game didn't help with the environment. The Thai chicken tacos were pretty good, but I asked for no sour cream and got it anyway. It's really more of a barlike atmosphere, loud and charmless. Wouldn't consider returning. read more

Great local watering hole, good food and great prices, and lots of potential. But servers / bartenders are always overwhelmed. I know this is how they make a lot of money, but when I can't get decent service, it's disappointing. So we wanted to order dinner but the bartender was too busy. We settled the tab and left $3.00 when it could have been $20.00 had we been able to order dinner. Unfortunately, a diamond that's lost its brilliance. :( read more

I had a similar experience as Paul M. The place had maybe 10 patrons at 1:00 p.m.,when myself and a buddy sat at the bar to have a couple of beers.The bartender wearing an Ohio state shirt walked by us several times,without saying a word ,or even looking at us,as she talked to 2 guys sitting at a table.She then decided to come behind the bar and flopped menus in front of us,and started to walk away.We told her we just wanted a pitcher of beer,so she poured it and then gave us 2 room temperature glasses,when we know they have frosted mugs.We then told her we wanted to pay now and not run a tab,but she turned and walked away instead.We asked the waitress how much we owed,drank the beer fast,and left never to go back. read more

Great little pub. Excellent waitresses, excellent bartenders, good food, reasonable prices. Must visit.

Great food and service. We always sit at the bar and the patrons are always nice. I haven't had to deal with an annoying drunk yet. Food has really good flavors. Nice local bar. read more

Wonderful atmosphere and friendly staff. Known for their Irish edibles obviously, but in my opinion Chase makes the best Cuban sandwiches around!!!! Get it with tots. read more

I am giving "The Mutt" 2 stars only for one simple reason. There is a bartender named Brittany who is absolutely TERRIBLE! !!!! She has no skills or personality. She acts like she is put out to even assist with anything. Her apparel is absolutely disgusting, since she "works out" and looks like she just came from the gym.......I believe her face would crack if she smiled. Mike has and in her case hopefully will do better hiribg help. read more

This is an excellent bar! They have great food and wonderful service. I always get the Hoosier Tenderloin. I will recommend this place to everyone. It better to go during the lunch hours. It gets really busy at night. read more

Really enjoyed this little Irish Pub. Food was very good and the service we got from Nancy was excellent. When she found out we were first timers she sat down and told us all about the restaurant and area. The pork tenderloin sandwich she recommended was great! read more

Very good food! Wether it's appetizers, sandwiches or pizza, I've never had anything bad. The beer is cold so what else do you need?

First time here. Wife & I stopped in for lunch and was pleasantly surprised. Nice clean and well kept bar. Every employee we interacted with was friendly, courteous, and helpful. Tenderloin was excellent, fries hot, house made chips warm and fresh. From where I live this is out of the way, but I will make the trip back to try other menu items. Did really appreciate the wait staff's attention to our visit. read more