Tucked into a small strip mall, I was not prepared for what was waiting behind the doors at Mamma Toledo's! Pies, pies and more pies! Any kind of pie you could want! We typically ordered the mini pies because they are perfect for sharing. Our favorites are the key lime, coconut cream, banana cream, triple chocolate, chocolate peanut butter and lemon meringue pies. I've purchased their quiches for a few brunch dates and they are always a hit. I really don't think there is anything at Mamma Toledos that isn't a delicious masterpiece! read more

Love those pies! Great spot with super friendly service and a cozy atmosphere. Definitely try the cherry pie it's the best. read more

See all

Great pies! Savory and sweet! Great place to pick one up for dinner if u don't feel like cooking.

Dropped in and purchased a chocolate cream pie. Crust was awesome, filling did not taste very chocolatie, and the consistency was very thick and firm, not smooth and creamy. Possible too much cornstarch. The whipped topping was wonderful. Sometimes things happen. Reply to your reply. Yes I know we have had it before and it was wonderful. We will be back. read more

Amazing pie spot happened to come in today and the AC was out was also informed that you'd have to call ahead for a full lemon meringue pie as they are made to order (just fyi) They do ask for a optional tip They have an array of pies from chicken pot pies to actual pies (no pizza pies lol) at least from menu looking lol. But I will say this is the 2nd best pie I've ever had I'll definitely re do my review when they have the ac fixed to actually enjoy it fully cold. Key lime crust was a pleasant surprise in it you'll have to try it to understand but it was great single small pies are 8$ which isn't bad considering the effort that's put into these. read more

See all

I went over there to try one of their breakfast items and to get a pie cause they had a special. I was not impressed. I got a biscuit sandwich and it was the worst thing I've ever eaten. It's very like processed. Did not taste like a good biscuit or like egg it was one piece of bacon in it, and it was like processed cheese. I had to throw most of it away. I bought a pie. It tasted good except the crust was not very good. It was definitely not Crisco kind of crust and they said they used Crisco. I prefer butter crust and would pay more for it anyway I will not be back. Seems like a popular place, but I don't know why. The pollen was kind of expensive. read more

Not sure what is going on with Mama Toledo's but the chicken pot pies we had were not good at all, the crust tasted off. And the desert pies had a different flavor to them. Maybe she got a new cook or switched her vendor, or switched from butter to lard, but if I had never tried her pies before and this was my first time, I would not return. I'll give it one more try, but this was extremely disappointing for the price. For someone who specializes in pie, I would think the pie would always be spectacular. read more

Ordered a lemon sour cream pie for Easter and grabbed a peach crumble mini pie when I picked it up. The peach crumble was great. But, the lemon sour cream was AMAZING! similar to key lime but lemon and not as dense. Will definitely be a repeat customer here on out. Really glad to have found this place! read more

Bought the Strawberry Rhubard pie, Potato, Bacon, & Cheddar Quiches, and the Spinach, Mushroom, Feta Quiches for friends. We enjoyed the quiches. They also have mini pies available if you just want to try something. read more

See all

My rabbi, his wife, adult daughters recently came back from a cruise with Covid. Via her website, I ordered a pickup of one of her large decided to drop off a bacon, potato, and cheddar quiche to drop off at their home. We dropped it off this past Tuesday, at noon. Mamma and her crew had baked it fresh that morning and it was still warm when we picked it up. Today, only 48 hours after delivering this quiche, we got sent this picture. There aren't any crumbs! These people aren't big eaters...they're skinny. And there were only two of them. And they're recovering from Covid, which probably zapped their appetites. If this picture doesn't convince you to go to Mamma's, then nothing will. And that's so sad for you...and you shouldn't be sad. Be happy and go to Mamma's! read more

Mamma Toledo's The Pie Hole - Empty pie tin - Bakeries Near Me - Phoenix, Arizona

Pecan Pie was miserable. This place thinks it's a bakery? Learn how to make a pecan pie, which was $8 for a small. It was watery and not tight and wasn't close to a real pecan pie. Bunch of amateurs here and no parking spots in the tiny lot either. read more

Mamma Toledo's The Pie Hole - Lousy pie - Bakeries Near Me - Phoenix, Arizona

See all

I love a good pie. We usually go to a different pie place but we didn't like the menu and it was undone birthday weekend. He wanted a lemon meringue pie and so we found mamma toledos on Reddit and decided to give them a try. Holy guacamole am I glad we did! The lemon meringue pie was one of the best, possibly the best one I've had. And the key lime pie I got, it was the bomb! The crust was so good! It wasnt graham cracker crust but like some caramel and nut crust. The strawberry rhubarb was pretty good, the crust was great but I feel like it could've used some lemon, just something to brighten it up a little. Overall, this was a really good find and I'm pretty sure this will be our new pie place because the prices are pretty reasonable! Also the service was great! There weren't any lemon meringue pies on display and our son was upset. However they had just finished making some and it made him so happy. He said it was the best birthday pie he's ever had! read more

Mamma Toledo's The Pie Hole - Strawberry rhubarb pie - Bakeries Near Me - Phoenix, Arizona

Best everything!!! Best pie ever.... But wait chicken pot pies are mind boggling !!!! Must must must!!!!

My husband and I bought a personal size key lime pie. I was not expecting the level of deliciousness that little pie delivered. The crust had a great flavor and texture. The key lime filling was win too! The perfect blend of tart and sweet and the smooth & creamy texture to enjoy in each mouthful! Another terrific pie from Mamma Toledos which is definitely worth the drive! read more

Good pecan pie. And, good customer service. If I'm in the area again and wanting some pie, I'll definitely hit this place up. I'd love to try their savory quiches and other treats. read more

Great food, great service ,and great atmosphere definitely recommend checking out if in the area ! Worth the drive if you are traveling

The worse experience ever. Used to like this place, not anymore. Workers are rude & sloppy. You don't get fresh pies, & if you have the pies to go, you are not getting fresh, you don't know what they do. Referred a person, got the pie to go & it was awful. The guy refused to help her. Never got a receipt, he was rude. Place is not the same at all. read more

See all

Stopped in and picked up a mini- mixed berry pie to complement a nice dinner I was fixing at home. This was delicious. The berries, the crust- YUM! Also got a couple frozen pot pies one green chili and 1 chicken. Had these a couple days ago and the chicken was delicious but the green chili lacked the normal robust flavor it has always had. I've eaten these for years and enjoyed but hadn't for a few months. They have a beef pot roast one now as well which is on my list. The young gentleman in the front was helpful and courteous as well. Definitely a gem here in North Phoenix. read more

I tried the chicken pot pie, which was delicious and a pecan pie. If you're looking for pie, whether it's Slim and meringue pecan pie that's a good place. read more

See all

Holy pies galore! This place has any pie that you crave. They even have breakfast pies! Service was quick and friendly and the spot was small and cozy. This trip we got a mini chocolate cream pie and mini key lime pie. The chocolate was creamy and had good flavor but not one of my top choices. The key lime was tart and fabulous with a delicious crust. It was perfect. I definitely want to stop in again for breakfast and coffee in the future! read more

See all

The peach crumb pie is absolutely delicious!!! Great friendly service. Nice atmosphere.

On a lunch break & super stoked to try this place b/c I'd heard so much about it. If I've said it once, I've said it a 100xs on here! My great grandmother owned her own bakery in New York & we come from a family of bakers who love baking cookies, cakes, & all kinds of pies. Everything from scratch, always. I ordered the mini chicken pot pie for a quick lunch & was thoroughly disappointed. Why? * The inside was mostly potatoes w/ carrot & no chicken chunks at all * There's more crust than filling * The crust itself tastes weird, as if it's flavored with that fake Butter flavoring; many people probably love that but I'd rather have the real subtle flavor of butter or sometimes pie crust is a combo of butter & shortening * It was $10 for this lunch that didn't satisfy - I'm happy to pay for a quality product but this was not worth it Perhaps their sweet pies are better? read more

Mamma Toledo's The Pie Hole - Chicken Pot Pie w/ some strands of chicken! - Bakeries Near Me - Phoenix, Arizona

Brought home 4 mini lemon meringue pies and an apple pie. We won't go back the crust were inedible on the lemon meringue. Ate 2, threw 2 away. Apple pie was stuffed with thinly sliced apples but was dry as he'll. There should be some moisture in the apples. Very disappointed. How do operate a "bakery if you can't make an edible crust? read more

Mamma Toledo's The Pie Hole - Bakeries Near Me - Phoenix, Arizona

See all

I went here a couple weeks ago while I was staying on that side of town! I got biscuits & gravy, a mini coconut cream pie and a strawberry rhubarb pie for my stepdad! Everything was wonderful. I will definitely be back! read more

See all

I'm a picky critic as I come from a long line of southern cooks who are amazing pie bakers. We ordered the chicken, beef, and green chili pork pot pies. All were fantastic! We also ordered an apple, strawberry fields forever, pecan and sweet potato pie. Had a big family lunch and everyone raved. Not to mention, the owner is as sweet and friendly as she is beautiful. Such a great experience and Phoenix is lucky to have her. read more

See all

Food was freaking delicious! Got the green chili breakfast burrito and a breakfast pie, so yum! And we had a nice chat with Tanya the owner to learn her story. Ambiance is basic. They are cool if you get a coffee next door and Serafina and bring it over, and Serafina is cool if you bring Mamma Toledos food to their place. What a great local business!!! read more

Visited this lil pie truck at the Arrowhead Farmers Market. Ladies were friendly and I knew what I wanted. I had been eyeing this shop for awhile so I was excited to finally try it. I got the key lime pie. First, this is the perfect size! Enough to satisfy that craving! The key lime was tart but not too much, perfectly tangy with enough sweetness. I loved it! Also loved the graham cracker crust! (Wish the crust went up the side but just a tiny gripe) Will definitely purchase again and can't wait to try some other flavors! Support small business!! read more

Mamma Toledo's The Pie Hole - Key Lime Pie - Bakeries Near Me - Phoenix, Arizona

See all

Their potato curry pie is delicious. Their quiche's are also delicious both the spinach and the bacon.

Thank you thank you so much Mamma Toledo's for the delicious pies! I picked up the key lime and the mini coconut cream and they're phenomenal. Love the smell of the shop once you walk in, you know the quality is there. can't wait to come back and try some of your savory pies. thank you for being an awesome local business read more

Hadn't visited this place in a few years and it did not disappoint! We ordered 3 pies-pecan, raspberry cream cheese, and triple chocolate. They were all delicious. The pecan pie was in my opinion better than Rock Springs Jack Daniel's pecan pie. The gentleman that helped us was so friendly and helpful and even heated our pie for us. 10/10 recommend! read more

I wanted to like it so badly and rate it higher but I was just not impressed. We tried the coconut cream pie and the filling was good but the crust was so salty that we found it unpleasant. We also tried a slice of the chocolate espresso cheesecake, we were also not impressed, definitely more espresso than chocolate. It was bitter and the texture resembled more a cream pie than a cheesecake. They did have great customer service and I'm sure the flavors are a hit with lots of people, just wasn't for us. read more

My sister and her husband threw a southern bbq for family and friends last weekend. I went to Mama Toledo's for a key lime pie, they were sold out. Mama Toledo suggested the brown sugar peach pie. Can't get more southern than that, great recommendation. Everybody loved it. While picking up my pie I had the green chili burrito and it was excellent. The flavors of egg, green chili, meat and cheese were awesome. The tortilla might be the star of the show, so fresh and soft. Thank you Mama Toledo! read more

We went at about 3:00 PM and we were the only ones in the store at the time. The lady behind the counter was very sweet and fast with our togo order. They were out of the Apple Crumble, but the cashier packed a fresh one from the oven for me. Very warm and perfect with ice cream! The crust was slightly salty, but the pie wasn't overbearingly sweet. I'd come back to the Pie Hole again! read more

Mamma Toledo's The Pie Hole - menu - Bakeries Near Me - Phoenix, Arizona

See all

I've been going on road trips to Arizona for winter vacation. On the last trip I was hoping to try a peach pie at Mama Toledo's. The website indicated I should order online but online ordering was down when I tried to order. I emailed my request and was told to call in the morning to reserve a pie. I called a few times but nobody picked up the phone. I visited in the afternoon and they had run out of peach pies. Instead I tried a few other pies. Chicken pot pie had a crunchy crust and a balanced mix of chicken, carrots, and potatoes. Strong buttery flavor. Great tasting pie. One pie is the perfect size for lunch. Banana cream pie had a crunchy flaky crust. Loved the mix of flavors from the bananas, buttery crust, and whipped cream. Among the best banana cream pies I've had. I visited Mama Toledo's in 2019 and enjoyed her apple pie so it's likely the peach pie is good. Maybe I'll get one on my next road trip if the ordering system is fixed. read more

See all

I would not recommend. We left mentally disappointed and physically heavy. We tried the green chilli pot pie, which was so salty. Also tried the mushroom spinach quiche, which was just so bad that I couldn't bring myself to finish it. In terms of dessert, as tried the raspberry cream, which had a super artificial taste to it that it might as well have been from McDonald's. The key lime pie was the saving grace and is probably the only item worth having here. read more

We went to Mamma Toledo's for the first time today for breakfast, and it was absolutely amazing!!! The service was great, everyone was so kind and the bakery was really cute. The breakfast burritos were made to order which we really appreciated, as they were so fresh. What was even better was the pork green chili in the breakfast burritos.... SO YUMMY!!! 10/10 recommend!!! read more

The idea of this place is interesting but the food isn't anything to write home about. It's a cool little spot. Server was super nice. Coffee was decent. The environment is casual and relaxed. Wanted to like it but the pies were pretty bland. We had a party of 4 and all ordered different desert pies: coconut creme, chocolate creme, banana & pecan. The pie crust is pretty good but the pies themselves were light on flavor. There wasn't much taste to them. The person who ordered the pecan pie liked the filling well enough but not enough to lure us back. At $8/per pie I (sadly) would have recommend finding another spot for desert. read more

We stop in every couple of months and load up on the small frozen chicken pot pies and a couple of dessert pies. They are all so good! Honestly the best pies I've ever tasted. I grew up on homemade pecan pie and mamma Toledo's is the best (pls don't tell my mom). Also the brown sugar peach is omg. Service is always friendly. We always overbuy and they never disappoint. So good! Try it. You can have a slice inside too. You don't have to buy the store! read more

Cool place! Was in the area and had been wanting to check it out. It was hard to choose what to get. I was going to get a mocha latte but their espresso machine was broken so I got a chai latte instead with almond milk, very good! I got a frozen vegan red thai curry pot pie to heat up in the oven at home. I have to say, that was the only disappointing thing. It was weirdly sweet, no texture at all except mush and the crust. It tasted nothing like red Thai curry. I also got a peanut butter mini pie which was super delicious and I will totally be back to try other mini pies. Was pretty reasonably priced for all I got too! read more

See all

From the moment you walk in, you're greeted with the inviting aroma of delicious food and warm, friendly service. Every dish was absolutely outstanding. A five-star experience all around--I can't wait to come back! read more