Delicious wedding cake! Thanks Aliyah ! She made us a delicious buttercream and lemon curd cake.

I want into, the bakery, to order a strawberry buttercream cake with strawberries in the middle I paid $178 for this cake. For Thanksgiving , so fine there was only about three or four strawberries in this whole cake After calling the bakery, I was told to take a picture of the cake and email it. I told the gentleman Jerome that works there. No, I was not doing that because she should've told me from the door. She wasn't able to make the cake my suggestions don't waste your time going or ordering anything because she's gonna do what she wants to do and you know what as us trying to support our small businesses they have to support the community just as well When you pay for something you're supposed to get what you want. This will be my last time ordering at that location.. I will put zero stars read more

I've been coming to make my cake for many years. My usual request are cakes for occasions. To date, cakes I've ordered have always been ready on time and the recipients of those cakes were always satisfied. The buttercream is thick and sweet and cake is dense and fluffy. You definitely get what you pay for. read more

See all

Disappointed with the NSA Apple pie & pound cake... Taste it and tell me what you think? I know you all can do better with classics or send the baker back/to school... I'm not going to talk about what it taste like, the quality or post pics with hopes that this constructive criticism leads to improvement. I've had items such as cookies, pies and cakes from here years ago and it was very good, I don't know what's going on now. I wanted to satisfy a crave not waste money. I will probably try again in the distant future after I watch the reviews. Service was as expected, the location is in a prime location, nice intimate ambiance, a couple of seats to dine in. Make Harlem Proud! read more

I truly love Make My Cake bakery first time I was 22 years old ever since I tried the buttercream cakes I have been in loveeeeee !!! Cant wait for this year birthday cupcakes!! Chantol! read more

Out in Harlem on a lovely rainy day and stopped in to explore. So happy we did. My daughter got a slice of red and white which is a layer of red velvet and a layer of vanilla. It was delicious. The service was great and there is a cafe attached that has coffee beans you won't find everywhere else. When the weather permits, you can enjoy your goodies at the tables outside. read more

See all

In totatal disappointment once again. A friend of mine ask for details on a cake and the employee was kind and took her order properly, however they meaning the manager and baker chose to do it there way. The Rude and nasty attitude in the Adam Clayton store is contagious and its affecting there baking as well as their customer service skills. The new employee did her job 100% if I were her I would quit. 2nd time with bad experience last time personal this time friends and family. Get it together. read more

Ordered the red & white cake yesterday. Normally don't make reviews but the cake wasn't good I'm just reviewing so we can do better. Cake was like frosted cornbread. Caveman raven,docs, Crumbl hands down!! read more

They're an easy Four Stars once you eat their cookies! Make My Cake has the best selection of cakes that you can purchase by the slice. The price keeps going up but it's definitely worth it. I have to get mine too take home. My daughter gets hers to go too. It's a rare treat I'm sad to say. I love the cookies the best because I can eat the cookie on the way home. The bag was so cute I saved it!! We have a location closer to home. I definitely stop in for something special no matter which location I'm near. Customer Service is always tops! Support your local small businesses..... read more

See all

Service was good, but cupcake's could have been better in that the strawberry cupcake was just strawberry frosting with plain vanilla cake No filling, the lemon cupcake had lemon filling but the frosting wasn't lemony enough. The red velvet cupcake was good but tasted more chocolate and the frosting wasn't cream cheese it was plain vanilla and the butter chocolate cupcake was plain cake with chocolate frosting was good. They were good cupcakes just was expecting them to WOW us but didn't. The setting inside the place was nice. Overall the prices were reasonable. read more

Cupcakes. I was very excited to get these cuk cakes. They looked delish. When I got home make some coffee and was ready to go. When I took a bit they were dense and dry. Not sure if I had a bad batch or they are just dense and dry. Totally disappointed . I also got a peach cobbler, it was more pie then cobbler. It was ok, nothing to brag about. It was missing something, like lemon zest. It wasn't balanced at all. Oh well. Red Velvet Cupcake Lemon Butter Cupcake Double Chocolate cupcake Chocolate Butter Cupcake read more

Make My Cake - Red Velvet Cupcake Lemon Butter Cupcake Double Chocolate cupcake Chocolate Butter Cupcake - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Large double chocolate cake was delicious & absolutely gorgeous. It had a shimmer on the frosting that made it super cute & gorgeous purple sugary edible beads. read more

there's nothing like Harlem on Sunday morning. stopped in for a slice of sweet potato cake, and it was good. hadn't had it for awhile. service was quick. thx mmc read more

Aaliyah is so wonderful and that sweet potato pie DAMN! so so good. I'm enjoying living in Harlem so much. A breath of fresh air to walk into different businesses and the owners are employees are so friendly and sociable. Real different vibes from Manhattan and Bk let me tell you. read more

The cakes are unmatched! Fresh, fluffy, and divine. The woman who wears glasses and answers the phones could stand to acquire a more polished customer service approach, but the gentleman was very kind and professional. I can't decide whether the vanilla or strawberry cupcake is my favorite, but I look forward to the next time they can "make my cake." read more

If I take a trip down memory lane, Make My Cake's design really got a hold on me. My twin sister and I had just finished having tea at Serengeti after a long exercise session over on the East side. Backdrop is cute with Pinks and Browns. Shelves are stacked with old-fashioned knick-knacks. Glass shelves and pastry stands full of Sweets. Display looked decent and decided on keeping it simple with a cookie each. Taste was o...k- but really- nothing off the wall. It was a nice little trip. And Make My Cake has a cute style going on......but it's not as good as I thought it would be. read more

Make My Cake - Mmmmmm... - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Visiting from out of town from Ohio. Was getting my nails done 2 doors up and a lady came in saying she got pound cake from this bakery. This is in the Harlem area. Nice little shop. 2 employees were working on boxing a huge birthday cake so they called someone out to help me and others who had arrived. I ordered 1 coconut pecan cookie, 2 slices of pound cake and got the last cinnamon roll. Also got hibiscus sweet tea. Service was good and the staff were nice. Hibiscus tea was delicious. The cookie flavor was good but the cookie itself was dry and crumbly. The pound cake was on the dry side and in my opinion needed salt and vanilla as there was not much flavor. I'm going to have to add ice cream for more flavor. Plan to heat the cinnamon bun and have it for breakfast tomorrow. I would try another cake flavor and hope it's better than the pound cake. If not, I wouldn't go back unless just for the tea. read more

I have gotten several items including the Red Velvet cake, cupcakes, and the key lime pie. This week we had the double chocolate cake and it was a huge hit. A guest even texted me about it afterwards. Highly recommend. read more

Make My Cake - Double chocolate 8" cake - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

I know everyone in the area goes crazy about this place but I don't get what's so special. Don't get me wrong, their baked goods are delicious but they have the same prices as elite bakeries like magnolias and other bakeries in midtown. There's no reason the slices should be $6 past 110th st. Was actually really shocked at that. There's not much variety is what you can order by the slice or just as a snack. Would like to see more cake slice options available. This bakery is a small shop, barely noticeable but is indeed delicious but not $6 a slice delicious. read more

I tried the lemon cupcake, yellow cake with chocolate icing and cake with strawberry filling. All were excellent and I will try to stop here to try a different slice whenever I am in Harlem!! read more

So I went back today and got the half red velvet, half buttercream cake and it was PERFECT. It has buttercream and cream cheese frosting. I definitely rescind my comment about flavors not being unique, this was so simple yet so brilliant. Once again I had really excellent customer service and the people were extremely kind and helpful. I would love it if they had a cake rewards program read more

Make My Cake - Red velvet and vanilla cake with cream cheese and butter cream frosting. - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

This is probably my 3rd time at this shop. If I want Make My Cake I would go to the 116th st location. However I live around the corner and wanted something tasty quick. Went in around 530pm. There was no line, no customers. An older women came from the back she looked tired and over it. Asked what I wanted, bagged it and told another associate to ring me up. Ordered a carrot cake, took it to go. When I got home I ripped it open to devour, but it wasn't that great. kind of dry, not really sweet. And left a bad after taste. Possibly an older cake. Either way I ate half, saved the other half for later. But ended up throwing it out. I've ordered other desserts from here before so I can't count this place completely out. Plus the owner is super sweet. But I do think this particular location needs a revamp & quality control. read more

See all

Happy to visit this location over the years! Service was quick and pleasant! Cakes and cupcakes are out of this world! Love the new location. Pricing is awesome no complaint! Looking forward to my birthday cake from here :)!!!! I got the chocolate in chocolate cupcake slice delicious read more

Went to location during business hours and it was closed. Actually went to both locations during business hours and they were both closed. Unsure if business is still open. read more

The coffee is absolutely amazing, the staff is professional and courteous. I will definitely recommend all My coffee lovers giving this place a try. read more

It's very dangerous that this bakery delivers slice of cake to my house. They always deliver quickly. Make sure to order earlier in the day as they stop delivery by the evening and run out of flavors. I recommend the lemon cake. I've also had the strawberry cake, but that one was a little too sweet for me (and I like sweet). This is definitely the best cake place in the area. read more

Make My Cake - Butter Cream Cake with Lemon & Lemon Frosting - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

Such a cute local bakery, honestly one of the best slices of double chocolate cake. Unfortunately freshness is an issue sometimes, and happening more frequently. This is the third time I've purchased a croissant that is too old. The dough is no longer soft and buttery. I hate leaving bad reviews, but this needs to be checked, has also happened a few times with the cinnamon rolls and cake slices. Quality is incredibly inconsistent. I hate purchasing food and having to throw it away. BUT when they are fresh...amazing. read more

Make My Cake - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

I'm highly pissed off with the fact the owner of the 125 st location has not bothered to respond to my customer complaint going on day four. Further more I'm disgusted the employees don't use any masks. I went in this place to pick up my cake I had forgotten the day before. Soon as I walked in and observed this cake sitting in a box uncovered as in not closed or taped down. Immediately said I hope that isn't my cake. Low and behold it was my cake, sitting there exposed to airborne dust, what ever germs the employees have etc. I'm asking the staff why is my cake sitting out it was suppose to be picked up the day before so why is it sitting out not even closed. The male employee catches a funky attitude and walks off, the female employee states "she took it out in the morning" my question was why would you take out a cake nobody called for and why wasn't it closed. At that point I didn't want the cake, so I took it home and left my info for the owner because I want my money back. And let's not mention the ugliness of the cake okay it was so hideous for 65.00 for this ugly 8 inch cake. As a business owner myself I will never go there again and will inform the schools nd community board about the unprofessionalism at this establishment. Board of Health require masks indoors are the exempt from the health codes. Truly pissed off this place is nothing like the other well established place the mother owns. This bakery is in a neighborhood where parent don't feed their kids gluten or dairy. So she will so how long her business stands, not to mention the fact they don't even wear mask during this covid period Sincerely, Grossed out and Pissed off Ms.Woody Juskimasflavas LLC read more

Make My Cake - The writing on the cake a 5 year old could have done. Just hideous for 65.00 - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

Very Rude staff. The latina with the sharpie eyebrows needs customer service training ASAP. Been coming to this company since it was on 110th and central park by the 2/3 trains. Never experienced this type of service I had today. Do they even want customers to walk in? Won't Be Returning. read more

This is a rush job, those t's should not have been crossed @ the top like that & never should the manager have told my daughter on her birthday that she could leave it the way it was before finishing her job after I paid you in full & gave you a time for it to be ready but you were a 1 1/2 late or better...then was very nonchalant about it. Do better, years I've been giving you business... it ends today! read more

Make My Cake - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

If I could rate negative stars...... What happened to this business? There are times that I could tolerate rude staff especially if the goods are worth me biting my tongue, but the quality of the baked goods at this establishment has declined terribly. Purchased their red velvet mini cheesecake today for 7 bucks . Horrible. I pulled away from this establishment a while ago and today I regret giving it another try. Black owned or not, I'm done. read more

They keep it safe in the store. No sitting inside. You must wear a mask and only a few people inside at one time. More importantly, they make the best cinnamon roll in the world. And the cakes are heavenly. Perfect to make a birthday special. Moist, tasty, not too sweet. If you know you need a cake, order ahead. Or you risk hoping they have some cakes in the afternoon. Excellent muffins and cupcakes, too. I have to stop myself from coming more than once per week. Now known as Ma Smith. read more

Make My Cake - Ma Smith on ACP - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

THEY ARE STILL RAGGEDY! So..... I go back again bc apparently I am an arsehole and a glutton for punishment. I walk in, of course I am not acknowledged because that is their style. Then finally one of the young women behind the counter with the nicest lacefront wig and face full of pancake make up on a Saturday morning assists me and smiles. I was like FINALLY! FINALLY! Then I ordered 2 cupcakes and when I went to pay, it all goes downhill. I get the price and I reach in my wallet for my card and miss pancake rolls TF out of her eyes. I am like, ok, let me just pay and leave. I walk a block away go upstairs, give my love a cupcake and as we both take bites.... BOOM! THE CUPCAKES ARE DRY AS F*CK! This is the last time. I swear. This time, for real. read more

Delicious desserts. My fav is their strawberry frosted cupcakes and slices. I love Make My Cake!

I purchased a banana pudding parfait today and it was delicious, but as I started to get towards the end of the dessert I discovered that I had eatten plastic. I am truly disappointed and disgusted. I have been purchasing from this bakery for years and I have never experienced this. I guess it is time to find another bakery. read more

Make My Cake - a hand holding a piece of cake - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Truly delicious! They have sinful $2 cinnamon rolls as big as your head that I know are going to be my new weekly treat. I also tried their vanilla/red velvet cake which has the perfect texture and icing/cake ratio. As a bonus, one slice is truly a serving of two desserts, so it's basically a constant BOGO sale. Support local businesses, and feed your sweet tooth, here! :D read more

Make My CakeII is a great bakery with delicious goodies I ordered 3 Red Velvet Cupcake, 1 Chocolate Butter Cupcake 2 Chocolate Cupcake and a Peach Cobbler, everything was delicious. I'm thankful they are on Grubhub although delivery took long no fault of the bakery everything was fresh and packaged well. read more

Make My Cake - Red Velvet Cupcake Chocolate Butter Cupcake Chocolate Cupcake - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Miss Joanne helped my design a cake for my daughter's bridal shower. It was gorgeous with custom details and colors. The guests raved about the cake. The 10 inch cake was tall and dense and could have easily fed a much larger group than I planned. But now we have leftovers to share! Thank you to Bake My Cake for helping to make the event a success read more

The best cake you'll ever have. I can't visit Harlem without stopping here for a few pieces of cake. Red velvet is the best. read more

Make My Cake - Lemon Butter Cake, Red Velvet Cake & coconut cake - Bakeries Near Me - New York, New York

Ordered a cake for a birthday and it was terrible. The cake used to be so moist and flavorful. This cake was dense, too much sugar in the icing. The coconut was falling off the Icing! I noticed on the door it stated something about a division of make my cake, maybe it changed owners and they don't have the rights to the cake recipe anymore. Won't be buying from here again! Don't waste your money! read more