Magic Bagels

We ordered a few sandwiches this past Sunday and they were absolutely delicious. The BLT was packed…read morewith bacon. So good! Can't wait to come back!

The service was Fast and convenient, I ordered their cheese, egg and bacon and it was very nice.read more

BEC on an egg bagel

See all

Bagel Express

3.5(43 reviews)

0.1 mi

This has easily become my go-to bagel spot, if I want a solid bagel weekly I can count on them…read more The food is always fresh and delicious, and they have so many options. What really keeps me coming back though is the staff. Everyone is always so friendly, welcoming, and genuinely nice, which makes a huge difference. If you're in the Valley Stream area and looking for a solid bagel or quick breakfast definitely check this one out.

I am very sick from your store I was fasting all day I told myself I would go to your deli and get…read morea wrap three hours later I was puking my brains out .you need to do better. I will never eat here again....

Outside

Front

See all

BE

LA Pizzeria & Bagel

4.1(18 reviews)

1.4 mi

Absolutely excellent…read more I catered my baby shower from here and let me tell you - I eat A LOT of bagels. I travel to great lengths for good bagels. This spot has some BOMB bagels. My experience with catering was wonderful. The owner is very nice and really cares to make you happy. We obviously catered bagels, lox, whitefish, etc, but also got pastas and salads, as well as pastries and fruits. The presentation was lovely, the price was great, and the service was amazing. 10/10 I will cater from here again. Well done!

I was there today. The Spanish guy who took my order charged me $3.75 EXTRA for putting ONE thin…read moreslice of tomato, three small pieces of an onion, and a few pieces of lechuse on a baguette. He first told me the sandwich is $10.00 and when I saw thr bill and I asked him why the extra charge he said because of the vegetables. That I could get a tiny container of potatoes salad or cold slaw. Where do they serve a tuna sandwich without anything on it??? When i asked him to put the 1 slice of pizza and the French fries together in a small box, he ignored me and proceeded to give me the Pizza in a brown bag and the fries in a brown bag. Only after my telling him again to put them in a box did he do it making himself like I am the one that is crazy. I walked out paying $25.00 for a plain slice of pizza, a small regular fries, and a can of seltzer. I find the prices to be outrageous and the service to be bad. The boss was standing next to the Spanish guy and didnt even look to see what was happening. Mind you, I spoke to him in perfect Spanish (I am a latina jew) but it was aparent that it was not a language barrier. I shall not go back there. The boss would do go to read this review and check on his workers. And maybe give good and enough food for the prices he charges.

See all

Roma & Ray's Italian Bakery

4.6(32 reviews)

0.8 mi

Lucky to live only a few minutes away ..fresh Kaiser rolls and semolina ..they also sell all…read moredifferent kinds of bagels and bialys ..

Bread is always fresh and delicious and plenty of it and they also have some muffins and cookies…read moreand cake cakes, which is wonderful

Old school

See all

Kaiser rolls Plain

More Than A Bagel

4.3(13 reviews)

1.9 mi

Fast frendly service. Excellent products very clean. Easy parking inexpensive sorry not open on…read moreSunday

Gonna say it was one of the top 3 bagels I've eaten on Long Island. Friendly service, mentioned my…read morewife who is a regular and they gave me a free bagel right out of the oven. I like that their bagels have holes. Holey Bagels! Place is spotless. Fantastic. Cash only keeps the prices down.

Front window

Fresh Fresh bagels and more

See all

Lots of room

Gotta Getta Bagel Of Woodmere

4.2(54 reviews)

2.4 mi

When coming through the 5 Town area of Woodmere on Broadway - and wanting to check out the local…read morebagel shops - Gotta Getta Bagel is sitting pretty with a nice spot on Broadway. Do not be fooled by the quiet exterior - once inside, it's clear everybody is here. Lots of small wood tables to enjoy breakfast or lunch or a snack. They have delicious bagels and do have the Bagel snob required Everything Flagel. That was easy. Sliced with a 1/4 of whitefish to go. Whats nice is this is busy enough to guarantee the white fish is fresh. Not all locations can sell enough to not make you worry- not the case here. People were picking up sushi to go.. smoothies, and the standard salads, bagels, coffee and tea. Would be my go to if/ when here more often.

Overpriced and very underwhelming. Ordered a bagel with butter, and another with egg and cheese, an…read moreapple juice and one passion fruit tea for $25 . The egg sandwich came with complimentary egg shells throughout the sandwich making it inedible. Waste of money and food

See all

Bagel Boss

2.7(130 reviews)

1.5 mi

Employees are awesome! Very courteous and welcoming! The owners are amazing and eager to please…read moretheir customers Food is good and prices are very reasonable I have been going to bagel Boss of Hewlett, New York over 20 years and I will continue to go for another 20! Thank you!!!!!!!! Randy & Donald are the best! Paulina

I wish I had read these reviews before. Actually went there visiting from out of town. A friend…read moretook me there just from knowing it not necessarily having experience with their bagels. The bagels are heavy, very heavy. The muffins were quite aged, not fresh at all. My salmon lox sandwich, I asked for schmear & they put a whole regular amount of cream cheese. The salmon was very little. I highly regret the amount that I ordered there for family and frankly today the next day my stomach is quite in a tizzy.

Crumb Cake

See all

Mold from bagel boss

Bagel & Bagel

3.8(5 reviews)

1.5 mi

This bagel spot is small but they make the best BLT I've ever had and there coffee and egg platters…read moreare the best. Bacon is crispy to perfection. The only downside is they close by 2pm. Get there early it's worth the wait because then lines be long in the morning.

WOW Some of the…read moresoftest bagels I have ever had. Advertised as hand rolled and fresh - I believe them There aren't many bagel shops in Elmont, so I really appreciate that this one, probably the only one on Dutch Broadway, is above average. A Ham Egg & Cheese on a roll came was $4 with free coffee (I think the coffee is free before 11am). BTW, they have Black Diamond Coffee, which is one of my favorites. A few delis and diners on Long Island carry this drip brand and it is so addicting and smooth. I always get a refill when I can. It can be somewhat packed in the morning, but they're solid.

Fly-By Bagels - TWA Hotel

3.3(6 reviews)

4.1 mi•JFK Airport

If at JFK this is the best bagel place. The surroundings are beautiful and it's nice to get away…read morefrom the hustle and bustle of JFK.

We felt soooo lucky to have found the TWA Hotel Food Hall; for so many reasons…read more We had landed and our bags were missing. So there we were stuck in the baggage area of JFK until the next flight came with our bags(about 4 hours). We asked around about a place to lay down or grab a bite and one lady that worked there said "try the place upstairs in that little elevator." it seemed like an odd thing to say, and it sorta was, but we squeezed in this small elevator to see what was upstairs. We exited the elevator to this amazing place that seemed surreal. there was a long white tube walkway that was brightly lit. It brought us to... the TWA terminal! it was AMAZING! It was redesigned to look just like a 1950's terminal but with a little panache to it as well. It really is hard to describe how beautiful it all was. As our sleep deprived trio wandered about we made it to the food hall that had the bagels and muffins. The food looked so good, and was. But again we had almost no sleep so we were biased. We were able to get a little sleep too so the place seemed amazing. To think, if we hadn't missed our bags, we may have never discovered this incredible spot that turned out the most interesting part of the trip!

Twister baby.

See all

Retro

Crown Deli

4.1(28 reviews)

0.7 mi

I love Crown Deli. Their breakfast is so comforting, they have great beverage options, and their…read morepizza is pretty good! The staff is kind and VERY fast. You can't go wrong with this place.

Food is great; DOORDASH usually comes still hot…read more I'm not giving them five or four stars because every time I ask for a modification they don't read it.. even if I offer to pay more. Who wants an egg platter that has no cheese you don't even have an option to add it. You don't have a place to add it for extra and when I asked for you to charge me more you still don't, literally happened three separate times it's pretty stupid. Inside is nice but don't typically go in just get delivery.

Sandwiches and Pizza Menu

Desserts, Salad, Hot Food, Burgers, Burrito Menu

See all

BECheeeeeese

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

5 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Abdullah A.

0

1

0

3 years ago

The tall Pakistani boy that works there is so attractive, he's always gets everything right and is very funny with the customers, I especially enjoy the way he jokes with the tall Columbia's boy with glasses, they make such a good duo!! Overall a *MAGICAL* experience read more

Mindy O.

0

8

2

2 years ago

Horrible customer service Milk left out on the counter not refrigerated. The bagels and food were overpriced. I will not be returning

Erin O.

9

40

1

11 years ago

best bagels around. even better than some of "the best" I've had in brooklyn. been coming here forever.

Joanna M.

0

68

38

13 years ago

great place

Danielle A.

141

2

0

14 years ago

:-)

Magic Bagels - bagels - Updated September 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Valley Stream, New York Coffee near Magic Bagels

BEST of Valley Stream, New York Things to Do near Magic Bagels

BEST of Valley Stream, New York Restaurants near Magic Bagels

BEST of Valley Stream, New York Breakfast near Magic Bagels

BEST of Valley Stream, New York Pizza near Magic Bagels

BEST of Valley Stream, New York Desserts near Magic Bagels

BEST of Valley Stream, New York Cocktail Bars near Magic Bagels

BEST of Valley Stream, New York Parking near Magic Bagels

BEST of Valley Stream, New York Shopping near Magic Bagels

BEST of Valley Stream, New York Thrift Stores near Magic Bagels

Best of Valley Stream

Things to do in Valley Stream

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Magic Bagels also viewed

Lynbrook Bagels

3.3

(119 reviews)

I was really looking forward to a good bagel so I stopped in here. Unfortunately the bagel lacked…read moreflavor and taste no different than the bagels you would get at a Dunkin' Donuts. Also I informed them that I have an allergy, and although a small oversight she cross contaminated. Thankfully I purchased a dozen so I grabbed from the bottom of the bag and didn't make an issue out of it. Very little wait time. It's very clean inside and I would like to say it's stroller friendly and handicap accessible.

Been wanting to stop in for a while so went to grab a bacon egg and cheese on an everything bagel…read morewith a small iced coffee. How can that possibly be $16?? A $2 up charge to add cheese?! I mean the bagel was good but I don't think anything can justify that price. To ask for a tip after was diabolical too can't lie

My Three Sons Bagel Cafe

4.0

(112 reviews)

Had a toasted garlic bagel with scallion cream cheese and lox salmon. Pretty tasty…read more Service was fast and pleasant, place clean and inviting as always.

One of the best sandwiches I've ever ordered!!!! When I tell you every bite was so tasty and…read moredelicious!! I have also passed by this area so much times I didnt even realize the store was there (Honestly speaking). Great service all around from taking my breakfast order to my coffee order! The truffled croissant is a must try! Can't wait to go back!

Will’s Bagel Cafe

4.1

(28 reviews)

We love this local bagel store - hot fresh bagels & fantastic bagel sandwiches. Eggs are prepared…read morefresh for each sandwich - I get my eggs scrambled and hubby gets his over medium so the yolk can soak into everything. Delicious! I also had their vanilla yogurt (not on the menu but it's in the case) - they don't make it but it was sweet and tangy and it's a large serving. They do make the rice pudding (also in the case) so we'll have to come back for that. Parking - there is a tiny lot (4 spaces?) behind the store and on the street in front and on the side. Entrance is accessible. There are a few tables inside, but we always get everything to go. Staff are friendly and efficient. Love this place!

First time going there. Bagel egg and sausage and cheese was delicious and fresh…read more Actually couldn't finish it being was so.packed. Definitely this is my place for bagels since moving in the area. The young lady at the counter was extremely cute and friendly

Bagel Express

3.5

(43 reviews)

This has easily become my go-to bagel spot, if I want a solid bagel weekly I can count on them…read more The food is always fresh and delicious, and they have so many options. What really keeps me coming back though is the staff. Everyone is always so friendly, welcoming, and genuinely nice, which makes a huge difference. If you're in the Valley Stream area and looking for a solid bagel or quick breakfast definitely check this one out.

I am very sick from your store I was fasting all day I told myself I would go to your deli and get…read morea wrap three hours later I was puking my brains out .you need to do better. I will never eat here again....

My Three Sons Bagels

3.8

(97 reviews)

Are you kidding??!! You gotta come here!! Three Sons bagel is a hidden gem. I was able to order…read morethru their website and was ready pretty quickly. When arriving, the pickup station is to your right next to the cashier. Staff were friendly and attentive. Inside was clean and smelled like a bagel factory. The sandwich I got was called the works which was egg everything bagel, smoked lox, cream cheese, capers, red onions, lettuce (originally comes with cucumbers) and a tomato. This sandwich was delicious for a bagel spot in Long Island. I'm definitely coming back here. This is a must try.

Busy bagel shop in Garden City. I walked here with my boo once and we treated ourselves to some…read moreyummy bagels. Happy eats!

Bagels Bagels Bagels

3.3

(8 reviews)

I love this place so much they have the best bagels in the woman inside are the nicest people ever…read moreif you start going a few times, they will remember who you are and greet you with a huge smile. It's definitely a quick pick up to go place, but they do have seating inside if you want to stay in. They are super fast and speedy with the orders. This place is awesome.

Super friendly fresh bagels and cream cheese on deck. Came here with my sister in law for the first…read moretime and it smells so good.

Grand Bagels Inc

3.1

(18 reviews)

Quick BECSPK .. IFYKYK! I enjoy my NY special delight on a…read moreroll with crispy bacon. Bread roll is fresh. Bacon cooked to my preference. Never an issue with my order. The bagels are also made to perfection. Price increased, and the rolls might have gotten a lil smaller but still tasteful. Dining area should get a lil more organized and cleaned up after each use.

My parents live in Baldwin and this has been my go-to bagel place whenever I visit them on select…read moreweekends. Largely, the bagels are very good! They're big, tasty, and an awesome consistency. The employees are very kind and wonderful, too! So why the three stars? While the place is good at executing a tasty bagel and the employees are great, I'm not a fan of being skimped on the cream cheese. While some places dumb a ton of cream cheese on bagels to the point where I have to scrape it off and toss out the excess, Grand Bagels takes the exact opposite approach: a thin layer of almost nonexistent cream cheese. The last three times I've purchased a bagel with lox spread (one of the more expensive varieties!), there has been a MINIMAL amount of lox spread on the bagel. And for $5.70, that is completely unacceptable. This is a fairly recent occurrence. The first time it happened, I ignored it and wrote it off as a fluke. The second time it happened, I was perplexed and thought, "okay... one more try?" Today, it happened again. I'm aware of the hack that it's often cheaper at bagel shops to just order a bagel, sliced in half, and a quarter pound of lox on the side. But that's not always practical when on the move. Photo below. Please do better, Grand Bagels!

Hand Rolled Bagels

3.9

(404 reviews)

I praise the bagel in this joint for the dense, classic chew that comes exclusively from…read morehand-rolling the dough. The shop experiences heavy morning foot traffic. Patrons frequently note that bagels are often pulled straight from the oven, arriving warm and soft. The shop earns high marks for affordability. It features an expansive deli counter packed with fresh spreads and solid breakfast. The layout is strictly a traditional, standard grab-and-go storefront. This shop serves a solid, authentic product for purists who value a dense hand-rolled dough over machine-cut alternatives.

Bagels are AMAZING. coffee is great. place is over priced,…read morebut food is good. anything BEYOND bagels... 9x outta 10 your order will be WRONG. tip. you should have a line for JUST bagels and line for cooked foods. why do i have to wait 40 mins for bagels you just throw in a bag, because you have the slowest employees serving hot food? also, i get the whole hiring teenagers, but someone has to be in the front managing. why have 20 employees work the front that can't follow directions? maybe supply pads, because they CANT memorize and order if their life depended on it.

Bagelville

3.6

(20 reviews)

Being new in the area I wanted to support a local business. When fresh, their bagels are delicious,…read moreinexpensive and generously sized. But twice I have gotten bagels that were apparently made yesterday. After buying bagels at 7:30 AM, we discovered they were not fresh because they crumbled when cut. When we called to ask when they were made because these were not what we were expecting, the response was surprising: "Nobody else has complained". If we've gotten the correct response, which would be bring them back, and I'll give you new ones. They'd have gotten a loyal customer.

The food is good, prices are decent however the drinks and chips are pricey and limited. The staff…read moreare nice and the place is clean. Overall a nice local bagel shop.

Barbara's Bagels

3.5

(71 reviews)