1. Madalyn's Fine Jewelry

0

Saint Augustine, FL

Cancel

Open app

Search

Madalyn's Fine Jewelry

4.5 (17 reviews)
Ultra High-EndJewelry, Jewelry Repair, Watch Repair
Open • 10:00 am - 6:00 pm

Services - Madalyn's Fine Jewelry

Jewelry cleaning

Jewelry redesign

Jewelry repair

Madalyn's Fine Jewelry Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Madalyn's Fine Jewelry

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration
Photo of Pamela R.
34
151
30

7 months ago

Business owner information

Photo of Jamie D.

Jamie D.

Thank you So Much! we truly appreciate you!!

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

27 days ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of M D.
0
9
5

10 months ago

After another local jeweler held my watch for two weeks for a battery replacement, Madalyn's turned it around in a day. Excellent service.

Business owner information

Photo of Jamie D.

Jamie D.

Thank you! We appreciate your business

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

1 year ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

2 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

5 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of S K.
0
6
0

3 years ago

Jami was fantastic! Needed to add links on a watch .. was in and out in 5 minutes.. they have stunning pieces .. highly recommend :)

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

3 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

4 years ago

Fantastic staff, so helpful and friendly. Beautiful store and well stocked. They make you feel like family.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

12 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of J B.
0
11
0

12 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Ask the Community - Madalyn's Fine Jewelry

Review Highlights - Madalyn's Fine Jewelry

“After another local jeweler held my watch for two weeks for a battery replacement, Madalyn's turned it around in a day.”

Mentioned in 3 reviews

Read more highlights

You might also consider

Nettles Fine Jewelry - Gorgeous citrine earrings

Nettles Fine Jewelry

(26 reviews)

I am so very pleased I found Nettle's Fine Jewelry and wanted to share our experience!!…read moreSince our very first visit, we were treated like family and felt completely confident knowing we were in honest, knowledgeable, and caring hands. The team takes the time to listen, explain every detail, and never once made me feel rushed and my emotions throughout the process were so gently respected. Their integrity, patience, and attention to detail made the entire experience stress-free and meaningful. The quality and craftsmanship of their jewelry is absolutely beautiful and was finished long before I had hoped which was a very nice surprise. We are incredibly grateful for their exceptional service of the entire team- the friendly and helpful employees - we had the pleasure to work with Clay, Darcy, Joy, Joanne, and others I can't recall their names- We absolutely recommend them without hesitation.

Customer service was horrible. I got a quiet 'hi' when I…read morecame in from the back of the store. Not once did either sales woman come out from behind the counter to acknowledge me. I could hear their conversation as I looked at the merchandise. I walked around and looked at all the cases. I was the only customer in the store. There were a couple items I went back to that I'd like to have seen. I wanted to see I she'd notice and come over. She didn't. By this time I was mad at the lack of customer service these two women showed. I shouldn't have to call over the sales person in a high end jewelry store to look at the merchandise. They need customer service training. Having sales staff hang out behind the register is one of the worst bad habits an employer can allow. Very disappointed.

JR Benet - Manmaids for days...

JR Benet

(20 reviews)

JR Benet offers something different than other shops on St George St. You can always find that…read morespecial something that is unique and unlike anything else that anyone else may be selling. Plus, a lot of the jewelry is one of a kind, so you don't have to worry about someone having the same thing for that unique look you desire. Personally, I love the Firefly collection. You can Google it to see the line, and you'll clearly see only "1" is available if you shop online. But come in person to JR Benet, try it on...and you'll fall in love with "it" or several pieces. Prices are fair, and the staff is always super friendly. It's easy to find and right on St George St. For you uniformed military and retired folks, they give a discount with proof of ID. Woot! I appreciate it, and it makes me buy more (yikes!).

I LOVE this jewelry store! They offer an enormous variety of affordable merchandise. Furthermore,…read morethey have some really unique styles. In the past, I've purchased two bracelets for myself and gifts for others. All of us are very content with the quality of our pieces. I am very mindful of how I store my jewelry so I keep my pieces in their perspective pouches. Needless to say, I haven't experienced any issues with discoloring, tarnishing, et cetera. The store's layout is interesting. I enjoy the massive interior case that mimics a bar as the salespeople are behind the counter. It's is very well organized with the jewelry sectioned off by color, theme, etc. (ex. dolphins, pearls, silver, and so on). In addition to the interior rectangular showcase, there are separate display cases where shoppers can peruse and touch. The staff at JR Benet are extremely friendly and accommodating. My friend and I shopped in January when we went to see the holiday lights and we spent a lot of time looking and trying on the merchandise. They were so patient and never made us feel rushed. We both left with jewelry for ourselves and others. It was a pleasant experience and I'm excited to return later this month when I'm in town. Be sure to checkout the manmaids above the counter when you checkout.

Sea Spirits Gallery & Gifts - beautiful wood carvings

Sea Spirits Gallery & Gifts

(9 reviews)

Sea Spirits Gallery & Gifts is a true jewel in the crown of unique and one of a kind establishments…read morein St.Augustine, Florida . There is truly something for everyone here in a multitude and variety of artistic jewelry, beautiful glass giftware, sculptures, and original paintings. The theme throughout this gift and Art Gallery is the ocean and its mysterious lure . Prices start reasonable, and collectors will also find one of a kind paintings to beautify their fine home furnishings. Owner Victoria is always warmly welcoming, as is the knowledgeable and helpful staff. This is one place in St. Augustine always to add to your itinerary as there are often new gifts arriving on a regular basis!

As a lover of all things in nature and in art, Sea Spirits is a gallery that never ceases to amaze…read moreme and should definitely be on your list of "To-Do's" here in Saint Augustine Their collection of Florida artists and coastal art work is absolutely stunning. Each work, a window into a variety of peaceful coastal worlds that one can take home. Not to mention, beautifully hand crafted jewelry, hand carved wood sculptures, and glass blown items that make the most perfect gifts for loved ones or yourself! On top of all the beautiful artwork and items in the gallery, the staff is there with a warm welcome, right as you come in, making you feel at home. So passionate and eager to share their love of art, information on the artists, as well as answer any questions one might have while browsing! Wonderful! Wonderful! Love Sea Spirits!!

Myers Jewelry and Gifts - He copied my ring EXACTLY! Now I can put my delicate ring in a safe place, and wear the new one without worrying about it breaking!

Myers Jewelry and Gifts

(10 reviews)

$$

This shop will hold a special place in my heart forever!…read more When I was shopping, my boyfriend stumbled upon this place and surprised me by getting my ring reshaped from its very smooshed oval shape back into a circle. He was chatting with Leonard about his projects, and having a good time distracting him from getting his work done, I'm sure, but Leonard was very nice and answered all of his questions. He told us how he makes jewelry and about his different tools, which was fun to learn about. While we were there, Leonard pointed out how delicate my ring had become over the years of wear. It was very thin and starting to separate in places, so reshaping it was tricky. He showed me under a microscope where the ring was worn down. My dad got me the ring in Mexico on my 16th birthday, and I've worn it everyday since then. I'm in my 30's now, for reference...it's been on my hand for over than half of my life. My dad passed away, so I need this ring to last. I asked if he could fix it, and he did me one better: he said he could make a mold of it and create a copy, but make it a bit thicker so it would last longer. That way, I can put my prized ring somewhere safe, but still have one to wear without worrying about it breaking. I just got the new ring back today, and it's absolutely perfect! Did I tear up when I opened it? Maybe.... Thank you so much Leonard! I will definitely be coming back. You've made my 2024!!! If you need your ring reshaped or want some custom or unique jewelry, come here!

Lenny went above and beyond for us! We were only in town for a short time and needed a ring sized…read moredown so Lenny fixed it up so quickly for us! He was very knowledgeable and friendly and may even ask him to do some custom work in the future! Thanks again my ring fits perfectly now!

Silver Feather Jewelry & Gifts

Silver Feather Jewelry & Gifts

(22 reviews)

$$

Silver Feather Jewelry & Gifts is a store definitely geared towards tourists. I mean this and no…read moredisparaging way, I'm a huge fan of Saint Augustine and this store was fun to wander around. As I said, this store is geared towards the tourism trade. But hey, I'm a tourist. I may live less than 2 hours away, but what I am here, I am doing the tourist thing. Silver Feather Jewelry & Gifts has a great collection of stuff for sale and I believe a lot of their sales come from an impulse purchase or just catching someone's eye and purchasing on a whim. In addition to their jewelry, Silver Feather Jewelry & Gifts has an eclectic collection of items that are bound to be at least Interesting and there is something there that you will find to be interesting enough to purchase. All in all, Silver Feather Jewelry and Gifts is a cool addition to the tourist part of Saint Augustine and made for an interesting place to visit. All in all, I will give them an overall score of five stars.

This is a gorgeous little shop with a lot of unique items. (It's worth pointing out that many of…read morethese stones could be purchased for a lot less in some of the shops up in the North Carolina mountains, but then again, we're a long way from the mountains down here.) We picked out a gorgeous butterfly pendant for my wife for her birthday. She loves it, and the staff here was helpful and friendly. We will definitely return the next time we're in St Augustine.

Madalyn's Fine Jewelry - jewelry - Updated October 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...