Amazing customer service!! I ordered a napolitian pizza to go and it was spectacular it hit the spot. The capers and anchovies were balanced out well. I will definitely be going back to dine in! read more

I am not sure what happened here, maybe I was burnt out on good pizza, but when I came to Macoletta, I was expecting something of great quality, considering the reviews. The service was really good, we sat down immediately, and we were offered drinks. The space was nice, somewhat quiet for a Saturday afternoon. We ordered a custom pizza, Kalamata olives and mushrooms, and even though the ingredients were good, the pizza itself was not amazing. Maybe I messed it up with my selection of toppings, then again I don't think so. I just wasn't thrilled. read more

Macoletta - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Ordered a pizza through Uber Eats. After about an hour of waiting I called to find out what was going on with my order and was told the delivery person had been in an accident. Oh no, that's terrible. Feeling very sorry, I agreed to wait another 30+ minutes for them to "remake" my order. When it finally arrived (at ~11pm, not 9:15) it was cold, not prepared correctly, and, worst of all, TASTED LIKE CLEANING PRODUCT!! I'm assuming they were remaking it while cleaning the kitchen at closing?? Whatever the reason, it was inedible. Fine. I called them and asked for a refund. The very nice guy answering the phones said they would issue it right away. That was 9 days ago. I've called three times since to ask where my refund is and keep being told it's handled. It's ridiculous, but on principle I want my money back. read more

Genuinely so confused on the good reviews. Sat in for dinner on Sunday night and service was horrible with a confused waiter and only one person cooking in kitchen - took an hour to get four small pizzas. The crust and toppings of pizza were good but the bottom of each one was so soggy you had to eat it them with forks read more

Macoletta - (SM) Mushroom - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

I was pleasantly surprised by Macoletta. I'm so used to restaurants by the waterfront being blah. But this restaurant was warm and cozy, the pizza was outstanding, and the service was wonderful. My son loved the pizza too. I can't wait to come back! You've definitely changed my mind on Neapolitan style pizza. read more

Can confirm that they have amazing gluten free crust! On top of that the owner is so kind and enthusiastic about the food and clear about allergies. The gluten free crust does take a little longer to bake but not so long that it's uncomfortable. Make a reservation because it is a small shop and cozy but the staff is courteous and will leave you alone at you catch up with loved ones! read more

See all

Really delicious pizza here! Outside seating is avalaible too. I brought my pup and the nice server brought water for me and a water bowl for my pup. Caesar salad was good but basic. The dressing was drizzled over and it was not tossed. However I really enjoyed the pizza. I got the Diablo which comes with peppers and honey. Not too spicy. Would recommend! read more

Food was delicious, we tried two pizzas and the homemade meatballs. Everything was full of flavor. The meatballs were so moist and amazing. Highly recommend! We came on a Sunday and street parking wasn't too bad! read more

Macoletta - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

We came in at happy hour time (until 6 PM, discounted house cocktails and wine) on a Thursday. The drinks are on POINT - I got a spritz ($16 normal, $9 HH). and it was so refreshing on a warm summer day. Onto the food - Caprese Appetizer ($16) - this was just okay. The tomatoes were flavorless and the mozarella did not seem like the fresh kind. Then we ordered two small pizzas - the Margherita ($18) and Diablo ($21). These are perfect Neopolitan Style pizzas - with a fluffy chewy flavorful perfectly charred crust, thin layer of sweet sauce, and milky cheese. We ordered both pizzas thinking we would have leftovers, but ended up crushing them both completely. Partner said that "it was the best pizza I have ever had". The owner (I think, this is who we talked to throughout the meal) is clearly super passionate about his business - he sat us right at the bar and gave us top notch service and information about the restroom. Their $85k pizza oven is imported from Naples, Italy and cooks their pizza in 100 seconds flat. The interior is cute. Overall, a stellar Neopolitan Style pizza experience in New York. read more

See all

Yum, yum, yum! Macoletta knows how to make delicious pizza!!! We ordered a large half-in-half pizza with margherita on one side and bresaola stracciatella on the other side. The margherita side was very good - the tomato sauce is simply lovely. The bresaola side was packed with flavor - the bresaola was smothered in stracciatella and sat on top of the argulua and light tomato sauce. The crust was fresh and delicious and perfect for soaking up all the left-over sauces on your plate. read more

Food is great. But service is Slooooowww. And there is no warning. We waited 1 hour 15 mins for two pies. It was really something I've never experienced before. read more

Good food, service and ambiance! Definitely would come back! They have a rating of A. read more

Macoletta - Same - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Decided to stop by this place for pizza. The pizza didn't taste bad. However, on my second slice there was a long piece of what was either hair or fabric fiber. My drink had fruit flies in it. I did get a new one after speaking up but I never said anything about the pizza because I was exhausted about complaining . When I went up to pay I even seen some fruit flies flying around, waiting to fly into somebody's drink. Overall just needs to be more sanitary. read more

Macoletta - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

The food is delish!!! We had burrata / calzone appetizer along with the meatballs. Both were fantastic. The sauce is light and flavorful. We also had the eggplant and cheese pizza which was full of flavor and the crust (which I usually don't eat) was both crunchy and soft on the inside and worth every bite!!! Will definitely return. We ate there. read more

The food here is amazing, I really enjoyed their pizza. Victor was our server and was extremely attentive , on point and sweet.

This place is great, and a bit of a hidden gem in the neighborhood. My family and I love the pizza and salads, and I especially appreciate how nice they are when I come in with my son and his friends most weeks after Skateyogi (located upstairs). The meatballs are a hit with the kids as well. Service is always fast and friendly. Also a fantastic option to get pizza for a picnic in the park. read more

Macoletta - Pepperoni Pizza + Caesar Salad - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Well, it would be a sin to visit NYC and not get a pizza! Macoletta had great reviews and wasn't bored down with 2 hour lines like some other places. So we have Macoletta a shot! As we entered, we were greeted by a very friendly server who immediately sat us. He followed up with taking our drink orders quickly. He explained the menu to us, being it was our first time there. He misunderstood my stepson, thinking he wasn't going to eat, and bright him out a few lava cake! When he realized it was a misunderstanding, we had a good laugh. We ordered a meat lovers pizza and a pizza with lamb sausage and baked tomatoes. Both were delicious! Now, being from Chicago, we, of course, were not picking their pizza, lol. My meat lovers were large in size for 2-4 people, while the lamb sausage pizza was a smaller size for 1-2. Considering most Americans, I'd say the sizes are appropriate mostly for the lower end of each estimate. The large might eb ok for 3, but 4 would be pushing it Each pizza tasted very fresh. The sauce was delicious but wasn't spiced up with as much garlic, oregano, etc, that achicago pizzas are accustomed to. That being said, we really enjoyed each pie. It wasn't the traditional huge fold up NYC pizza slices, but the flavor was there! The over the top friendly service, great pies, and no wait made this an excellent choice for us! I know it's NYC, but it did seem a little pricey for 2 pies, but our taste buds were left smiling! If I could give 4.5 stars, I would. It's definitely worth dropping, by, and ordering a pie! read more

Macoletta - Small but very nice pizzeria with smooth jazz playing softly as you dine. - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

This place is amazing!! We were hungry after pickleball and stopped by here and it did not disappoint. We ordered two large pies and it was enough for the 4 of us. We also had the peppers and peas and those were absolutely amazing too. The pepperoni was def my fav as it also has honey in it and gave it a nice sweet touch. If I am ever in the area again playing pickleball I would def come back! The servers were very attentive and refilled our waters and the seating area is pretty spacious read more

See all

Came here after a long run and was seated right away on a Sunday afternoon. Popular spot for families with children, and between 4-5 tables and just one waitress, service felt a bit slow. Indoor dining is a bit dark, but nice and clean interior. The pizza however was AMAZING. Dough was chewy, the balsamic reduction is delicious. Highly recommend the stracciatella pizza. SO GOOD! read more

Macoletta - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Had a great experience at Macoletta. The vibe is super cozy, staff is all super friendly, and they have great music playing overhead. The food was phenomenal! Wood fired pizzas and delicious meatballs! Definitely recommend! read more

See all

Have ordered takeout from here and was pleasantly surprised! The pizza traveled so well and wasn't soggy at all. The crust was perfect and the toppings were fresh and flavorful. Definitely a go-to pizza delivery spot for us! read more

Top Five Things the Manager at Macoletta Does NOT Know: 1. A Pizza Place Should Smell Like Pizza, Not Clorox *If the smell of food is competing with the smell of chemicals, you're overdoing it. 2. If You Can't Accommodate A Customer, Just Say Sorry * Asking to switch tables when the place is empty is not too much to ask. It's a simple request. This should not ruffle your feathers. Just politely decline. 3. A Free Round of Drinks Goes A Long Way. *It's an easy way to make things up to a disappointed table 4. There's A Time And Place For Everything * Don't like a negative review? DO: Respond on Yelp! That's a built in part of this forum. DON'T: Wait for their friends to return and make a hot fuss. 5. Feedback is Data. * When customers take the time to offer a review, it's because they care. You should also care enough to consider their point of view. Maybe do better. Good luck read more

Pretty good pizza and drinks! My date is italian and it got his stamp of approval. I think my only feedback is I wished they dimmed the lights or choose a different color of lights for nighttime. It's a bit too bright/giving fast food restaurant vibes rather than rustic cozy pizza and bar vibes ykno? read more

Overall, this is a great place that I'd come back to. The service is nice and the interior is beautiful. The bianca and the algerino were 5/5's. The garlic in the bianca made it pop and the tomatoes in the algerino were fresh and a great pair with the lamb. I thought the festa di formaggi was a bit too much cheese and heavy, but if you love cheese, it may be a hit for you. Will definitely be coming back to try some more pizzas. Highly recommend when you're in Williamsburg. read more

Macoletta - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Hands down the best gluten free pizza I have ever had! The crust actually had some fluff to it and the texture was very similar to flour crust. The service was also great! When I had a gnat land in my drink. He not only replaced it but topped me off when I was halfway through the replacement. It's a small place so I recommend making a reservation but it's well worth the wait! read more

Ordered for take out here. Got 2 pizzas (Cara and Bianca), pita and cannoli. Pizzas were okay; the Bianca was a tad too salty. Cara was basically a salad pizza. Originally ordered a gelato but they didn't have gelato so they substituted with the cannoli. Since this was a pickup order, it would have been nice if the restaurant had handles on their bags. The day was pretty windy so carrying 2 paper bags on top of the pizza box was quite inconvenient. Or they could have consolidated into 1 bag instead of 2, the pita wasn't even hot. read more

See all

A small, charming neighborhood spot in Brooklyn turning out beautiful thin crust pizzas. Attentive service and a relaxed vibe. read more

Macoletta - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Went here for a pizza making class for my sister's birthday. The owner is so kind and passionate about what he does. He is also very knowledgeable. Before the pizza class started, he gave us a good informative presentation about the history of pizza, the origin of Macoletta, and the important ingredients! The drink was DELICIOUS as well. The pizza class included 2 drinks and I got it twice. It was the Where's Walid-O. The experience itself was great and the pizza was DELICIOUS. Would definitely want to visit their other location to sit down and dine. Would recommend! read more

See all

Wonderful pizza and even had gluten-free crust available for my little one! Service and food were impeccable. Will definitely be back! Thank you!! read more

The dough here is so chewy it just melts in your mouth. I came here for the lunch special $12 pies. Everything fantastic. Aperol spritz, meatballs, Margherita pie, and I ordered a Bianca to go when I was done. Super close to the park, great service, quiet afternoon. DON'T WAIT too long to go here!!! As soon as it's nice out I expect this place to get busy busy!!! read more

See all

We had the mushroom pizza and added pepperoni (pep fanatics) and it was great. The pizza would have been tasty even without the peps. Service was great, the waiter was really kind to us and personable. The vibes were chill and relaxed. The waiter said they have a location in Astoria that's a bit bigger so we're excited to check that one out. Will definitely be back! read more

Macoletta - Mushroom pizza - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Went here after work and had the meat lovers pizza which was pretty damn good. Our waiter (forget the name) was cool and knowledgeable. He even advised me on wine when I was unsure what to drink and he knows his pairings because I do drink wine often. Nice spot just wish it was a bit bigger but that shouldn't stop you from getting some of the pizza. read more

So I was lately coming to this place after my skateboarding that's well where it's right next to and this place is really good for some reason and the pizza I like it so much and the lemonade is so delicious. I just can't tell how good the lemonade is and it's the best part to! read more

What a gem! My boyfriend took me here for a pizza-making class to celebrate our one year anniversary and we had a blast! The owner, Walid, is super nice and super passionate about pizza. He started the class with a small presentation which showed how knowledgeable and genuine he is about what he does. I definitely will consider this as a birthday party idea with friends. For the class, we made a Margherita pizza. Although we did not make the dough from scratch, you are able to shape it and toss it out into about a 10in circle. Walid was very informational and took his time when going through each step. When we tasted it, it was some of the best pizza I've had. It has the perfect amount of chewiness and crunch to it. The taste was balanced equally and no ingredient was overpowering the other. Was definitely impressed by how fun, educational, and delicious this class was! The class also comes with two drinks so I got "Where's Walid-o" and a glass of their newest Cabernet and both were excellent and not too strong. At the end of the class, Walid made us a Nutella pizza which was delicious - not too sweet, not too much bread or Nutella, and just the right amount of crispy crunch to it. Thank you so much Walid, we can't wait to come back to try the other pizzas! read more

Macoletta - Margherita from Pizza Making Class - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all

Macoletta was everything you want from a small NYC pizza joint. Attentive, friendly service. Perfectly prepared pizza with some unique options. And a drink menu that offered multiple options, depending on your mood, that satisfied for taste first. My wife and I shared the Diablo. I am usually one to seek out spicy foods, while my wife is not. This was a great win for us both because the pizza was spicy, not for the sake of being spicy, but for the accompanied flavor. My wife got to enjoy a flavorful pizza without having to pant and chug gallons of water. Will definitely make this a part of every trip to Williamsburg going forward! read more

I LOVE this restaurant. My family and I have been ordering from here since they opened, and they've never failed us. The place itself is warm and cozy, and the owner is so sweet. Two of our family members are Celiac, and this place is SUPER celiac friendly and DELICIOUS. The food does not take long to be made and the service is awesome. Overall, we've had great experiences with Macoletta and the food is stellar. If you're in Williamsburg and looking for a nice place to get a pie of pizza, try it. read more

An incredible pick for Neapolitan pizza!! Crust was perfect, sauce on the Margherita was amazing, would definitely come back again read more

Macoletta - (SM) Margherita with Buffalo Mozzarella - added mushrooms - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

Ordered the Diablo pizza - it was a 12 inch pizza and was absolutely incredible. It was my girlfriend and I so it was the perfect size and it was delicious. I'd be lying if I said it was my #1 pizza in all of NYC but I will definitely be back there for it. Honestly don't think my picture does it justice. The spicy pepperoni was, Calabrian chili, honey, and tomatoes were the perfect combination that I've never actually had on a pizza before. We started with the Caesar which was a normal Caesar. Slightly underwhelming in terms of appearance but the taste was there. Also got the eggplant parm which was very good as well. If you're thinking about coming here I would highly recommend - the I'm only going off of a one time visit but that pizza was incredible. I'll be back. Ambiance and service both were great. read more

Macoletta - (SM) Diablo - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

They waited over 90 minutes to cancel my delivery order, claiming that they didn't have any couriers to make the delivery. In Beyonce's year of the internet, I call bs. There are literally tons delivery drivers sitting outside of restaurants waiting to take orders. read more

Looking for pizza we could eat indoors out of the heat. Luckily, Macoletta popped up & it was close by. Wasn't busy, that's always scary, but glad we stayed. We shared 2 small pies between 3 of us, Margarita & a Tallegio w/caramelized onions & sausage. The crust was perfection, chewy, crispy & light, no flop. So good. Service was so nice. So many great pizza options in Williamsburg, will have to add to my rotation. read more

Macoletta - Sausage caramelIzed onion - Pizza Near Me - New York, New York

See all