Cozy local dinner with great food and service. We have been here multiple times and never had any issues. For the most recent visit, we arrived after 8pm and the restaurant was very quiet. Our food came out relatively fast. I loved the mashed potatoes with gravy included with my pot roast. They were perfectly warm and comforting. You also get a dinner roll with your entree and a choice of two sides. Pricing is fair. For our two meals, our total came to a little over $30 with tax. They also offer homemade desserts in a display case which looks very enticing. We will have to try the desserts next time. read more

See all

Really positive environment. I met a friend for breakfast here and had an excellent time catching up. The food was great and the service was pretty attentive. There were a couple times we could use a top off on the coffee or water but for the most part we were well taken care off. I would definitely visit again. Recommend the cinnamon French toast! read more

Always wonderful food and service! A definite step up above your standard diner fare. Cleanliness is clearly a top priority as well.

The food selection is very good. The quality of food is very good. The quantity of the food is also very good, you get a nice amount. The service is good the servers are there quick with the coffee and refills. Everyone say hi making it a nice place to visit. The place is clean and the bathrooms are also clean. A nice family restaurant to enjoy a meal. Prices pretty good too for the amount of food you recieve. read more

The food was good for diner food The waiter was very friendly and helped with a problem with the meal.

Visited with my family only one time. A nasty old man in the next booth was making derogatory comments that were directed at us. It was embarrassing and upsetting to my 90 year old mother who was with us. Wish management would have intervened and asked the bully to leave. We did not feel safe there. We will never go back. read more

Very good old-school family restaurant, situated a little out of the confines of Rochester and it's suburbs. It's a welcome jaunt, esp. since too many local diners have curtailed their hours due to staffing shortages. If you're hankering for some classic diner classics, you'd be happy with the food and the service at Macedonia Hills. A solid four stars ! read more

Very good food and service there people are also very friendly there. Very peaceful place to sit down the the fam and have dinner

My brother-in-law and I ate here for the first time (lunch). I am very impressed with the menu, facilities and food quality. I had the French dip and it was great. Loads of tasty roast beef and more au jus than I could use. Nothing was included with the sandwich for $9.99. My brother-in-law had a western egg sandwich which I believe was good. He had pie for dessert and said it was very good. I had baklava which tasted great, but the pastry was very firm and I had to resort to a knife. The staff was friendly and efficient. Our server, Brandie, could not have been nicer. read more

Let's start with service which was poor at best. We sat there with no drinks for at least 15 mins. I had the Cuban sandwich with baked beans and potato skins for appetizer. The pork on the Cuban was mostly all fat and the beans were room temperature at best. As far as the potato skins they were so greasy I had to stop eating them. I won't be back there!! read more

Macedon Hills Restaurant - Potato skins - New American Near Me - Macedon, New York

See all

Nice diner with professional servers and all the typical Greek diner fare. Friday fish fry is outstanding.

Service was beyond disappointing- if you can even call it service. The beef barley soup was ok, the toast- well you can't do wrong with toast but the rest of the meal - fatty, flavorless, and not up to any standards- let along high ones. So disappointed, have heard great things about this place but right away it was a huge letdown. read more

Food is decent but nothing spectacular. Slightly overpriced, (2 pancakes $6.99, cheese omelette $8.99, fake butter) but, what isn't overpriced these days! Coffee cup gets cold because refills are slow coming. A local hangout so it stays in business. read more

Usually visit there every week with my car buddies and random dinner,lunch or breakfast with the family. Food and service are consistently good and always great specials. Feel lucky to have this great option right near home. read more

Today is National Daughters Day and I decided to treat my daughter, live-in School of Ministry student, and wife to dinner here. Our family loves coming here and have done so for over 15 years. The food is excellent and the service quick and friendly. One of my wife's go-to meals is the Cobb salad which is a generous size and filled with fresh lettuce and vegetables. I order the stuffed meatloaf with pesto sauce and it is fantastic! The cheeseburger soup is to die for as well!!! Highly recommend this restaurant! read more

Every single person here was so nice, the food was so good, the restaurant is very clean, and the service was super fast. My avocado egg sandwich was awesome and hubby's turkey and dressing were wonderful. Our waitress was funny and sweet. Lucky us to have found this place. We will be back! read more

Macedon Hills Restaurant - Turkey dinner with sides - New American Near Me - Macedon, New York

See all

Our new go to joint for a full breakfast. Standard selection of breakfasts like eggs omelets, and cakes. They do offer some specialties such as stuffed Nutella fresh toast and fruit topped waffles. Service is fast, the food comes out hot, and equally impressive the cost is reasonable. read more

the cheese was white and the burger was brown with some pink in it I don't know what it was but it was scary AND THE HONEY MUSTARD WAS YELLOW like what in the world I hate this place read more

This is actually my hometown diner! Ownership changed hands a year or so ago and the new owners are doing a great job! The food is always good! Very consistent! Fun and friendly staff! The pancakes are amazing and my absolutely favorite!! read more

This is one of my favorite diners. Great breakfast specials and coffee, comfortable like home especially with the girls. Had lunch there today. Went with the hot turkey sandwich. In house roasted turkey not deli meat. Strange bright yellow turkey gravy but was very good. Hubby had turkey club made with the same roast turkey. My only complaint - they make excellent biscuits and gravy but only in the winter. They need it year round! read more

Best Breakfast food ever. Very clean. Great Service. Very accommodating staff. Always check out the daily specials for some interesting food! The coffee is great too! read more

Macedon Hills Restaurant - Western Omelet with the biggest home fries I have ever seen. Cooked extra crispy! - New American Near Me - Macedon, New York

Diner Reuben test resulted in blah. Tough, dry, thick, stringy meat. Bread sogged out by the kraut. The scene is just ehhhhh.

We have been going here for years. The food and service is amazing, and what makes this place special is the decorations throughout the seasons/holidays. It always stood out to me as a kid. The menu changes a bit at times, and it's exciting to try the add-ons and changes. I love this place, and always bring guests here. read more

Last night we ventured out in the biggest snow storm we have had thus far. It was one of those nights where you just don't want to drive too far but you are already on the road so why not go out to eat? I passed several dining establishments with empty parking lots on our drive there- not surprising... What idiot would be out driving in that kind of a storm besides me? Well me and the 50 other cars in the parking lot of Macedon Hills! I was shocked to see such a crowd on a night that was so bad you were risking your lives for bacon and eggs.... or chicken parm.... whatever it was that drew them there they couldn't be stopped! I ordered a fish fry- it came with soup and a salad. The soup was a Manhatten Clam Chowder and the salad was a simple garden salad with ample dressing on the side. I was quite pleased with the fish fry- it was very meaty, extremely large in size and fried just right- not too oily and just the right amount of crunch. I don't usually eat fish, after having been vegetarian for so long I am finally eating animal protien again. This was a nice revisit to the land of "meat" (well, fish anyway!) Both of my kids chose the Chicken Parm that came with loads of garlic bread, pasta, and a soup or salad. They ordered the Italian Wedding Soup and they were humming in delight. My husband got the goulash. He is particular about his Italian foods as he grew up spoiled by his mother's cooking. The dish did not disappoint. It too came with a soup and salad. Next came my mother who ordered scrambled eggs, toast, and a giant amount of homefries that could have fed an entire family was just as please. The Bomber Sandwich was on my father's plate and nothing was left at the end of the meal... even though he kept saying that there was too much food on his plate. He left a very happy man. Another successful family dinner at Macedon Hills... on a night that we should have arrived by sled. Well worth the dangerous trek out! read more

Not what it used to be. This was my favorite place to go awhile back. I had changed jobs and missed going there for meals. A friend told me it has changed (not for the better) and I have since changed employment again and I am now closer. So the last Saturday and today I gave it a shot. Not impressed at all. All the wait staff are just about gone. They have raised the prices and cut the portions. I ordered my eggs over easy and it arrived (after seeing it sit for several minutes) with one egg smashed and hard and the other over hard. If I was not in a bit if a rush I would have sent it back. The pancakes were ok and what home fries I had (small portion) were decent. As for the wait staff the one younger brunette has been ther awhile and she is good. And one mature blonde who waited on me last week was attentive and good. My waitress at the counter was mediocre at best. I miss the old restaurant for sure. I won't be going back unless I hear things have changed for the better I am sorry to say. read more

Server could careless about service.. burnt burgers no refills. Just sad. For over $60 lunch it would have been better to go to McDonald's down the road. Never again. Have been there for breakfast but today was cause for us never to return. Three tables were seated after us. One table received food, ate, paid , then left before ours was even ready. read more

Macedon Hills Restaurant - Bacon cheeseburger - New American Near Me - Macedon, New York

See all

The food was average. Nothing special at all; one of the only spots in town. The service was terrible. Waitress was so consumed with her conversation with a customer that she forgot about her two other tables. Wouldn't go back but if you're hungry, it's edible. read more

I have eaten at Macedon Hills many times and it always seems hit or miss. There is absolutely NO consistency with the food or the service. The only thing with consistency is the soup...which is akin to a thick porridge or gruel. The spaghetti sauce, in my humble opinion, is way too sweet. I have many other complaints about the food that I could put in this review but I will spare you the details. The food is not the real reason I am writing this review. It is the terrible way this restaurant is being managed. You see, up till now, I could deal with the poor service and the mediocre food. You get what you pay for right? I have seen the customer base of this restaurant slowly decrease over the past year. Is it the poor service? The quality of the food? Hell, maybe it is the increasing competition moving into the neighborhood. I have no idea. One thing I do know.... the only response I have seen from management is to raise the prices of their food! What kind of logic is this? I don't have an MBA from one of those fancy Ivy League schools but I am smart enough to know you don't raise ticket prices to board a sinking ship! That is a rash decision by an inexperienced manager! Let me give you a bit of friendly advice. Start by asking yourself, why you are losing customers! NOT why you are losing money! Once you figure it out you can start to fix it. Raising prices is not the answer. In fact, it's a sure fire way to drive customers away. I should know, I am one of them. read more

This place was very good and friendly, but due to Covid it has since closed down!!!!!

I have been going to Macedon Hills for over 15 years, and the quality has dropped to unacceptable. Most of the food is from frozen packages or a box, and the service is mediocre at best. Today was the day to let others know. Breakfast included eggs over easy. The cook translates this to one broken hard cooked egg fried with edges crispy. The home fry recipe is surely potatoes warmed through with paprika and grease. One of us ordered onions with home fries. This was the above with onions sprinkled on top. One of the kids ordered corned beef hash, which was out of a can almost warm. It is quite apparent that Orange marmalade is not the preferred jam of their customers. Thankfully we could remove 17 of these little squares of undesirables to get to the one lonely grape. Too bad there were 4 of us. read more

Macedon Hills Restaurant - Weekend Special #4 - New American Near Me - Macedon, New York

First experience of many at the Macedon Hills Family Restaurant. When I first got there, the blonde hostess appeared to give me a look of contempt. However, I'm a patient man, and thing smoothed out. A cheerful, smiling Sasha waited my table. I was put at ease w her warm demeanor. Service was attentive and snappy. I had the clam chowder, Tuna salad sandwich(she made sure I didnt mean Club), and coffee. All were quite delicious! Couldnt see giving a lousy $2 standard tip for excellent work, so I gave $4 on a $12 tab. Servers have to eat! I go the route often. I/we will be back! read more

We still love coming here. They have FANTASTIC specials for breakfast and the food is good. It's not gourmet or anything but it's good diner food :) read more

The new menu has improved this already established restaurant significantly; excellent variety, some creative items, good presentation, and most importantly delicious! Our waitress was friendly, quick, and attentive, as always...it's not often that you see an establishment make sweeping improvements to its menu and food quality, and the prices are very reasonable! read more

Ive been here for breakfast a number of times now, and would go again. In the area, its a solid choice for diner breakfast food.

Good food, good prices and the biggest piece of veal parm ever! :)

Have always had great food and service here but the fish fry was the bomb! Will be going back again soon.

About average, though they have the best turkey sandwiches. Real turkey right off the bird, no weird processed stuff. Their fries are pretty good, too - crinkle-cut like from Tom Wahl's or other "old-fashioned" restaurants. I've also had their bomber steak sandwich, which was not really my thing, but tasty nonetheless. Their fried clam basket was just alright. They also have some good, but not cheap, cake. About four bucks for a slice. After paying like 8-9 bucks for a sandwich and fries, it can get pricey. Plus tip. They do have a list of specials that are a buck or two off the normal price, with a good variety to choose from. Their everyday selection includes the basics like appetizers (chicken fingers, quesadillas, etc.), salads, soups, sides, and then has dinner entrees (steak, ham, ribs...), seafood platters and baskets, a few Italian dishes such as chicken parmesan and a few pastas, a kids section, lots of sandwiches, and pretty much whatever you might want for breakfast. Service is decent, sometimes a hostess or waitress is a little cold, but never anything more. Some of them are quite friendly and attentive. Location is easy to get to, right off Route 31, and they have plenty of parking. Gets more full during the usual meal times, but generally not much crowding. Overall, good place for a nice, relaxed meal once in a while. read more

Very poor service had to catch to waitress to place order had to get our own silverware after asking waitress for it. Food was very slow coming out. Food was fair. read more

I like this place the food is really good and cheap plus their breakfast burritos rule!

Local stable diner for many years. Food always good. Today it looks like they have changed the menu a little. Had eggs with avocado. Would have liked a little more avocado but it was great. read more