In a town where most restaurants fail before their 10th birthday, Macaroni is special. It is a very long runner here in Ashland, OR. Maybe 20+ years?
My family of 4, came in during the holidays, looking for delectable pasta or eggplant parm (a specialty here), and they delivered. This place is more than decent (3 star), it is YUMMY!
The ambience, is dark, and intimate, with pictures (paintings) depicting Italy around everywhere, it is a two room place and we were in the back which is a little dense. The seating here is dense because it is a rather small place with less than 20 tables, but it is comfortable enough. There is even booth seating (which most of us love!). On a busy weekend in Shakespeare time you should probably call in for a reservation which you can make on their website.
We got friendly competent service.
Most of all the freshness of my pasta was excellent. I had clams and sausage in a fresh pasta dish. Excellent flavor. All entrees, which are all under $30, except for the Ossobuco (veal shanks are expensive!), also includes a salad or soup. Good value! Their wine list is very decent, lots of good wine even for $25-35 a bottle in 2020. Again good value, when most restaurants of this quality are higher than that now for a bottle. They have a full liquor license, so order up, I think it will come from upstairs.
I give the food 4 stars and an extra plus (above 3) for the freshness and value, that I received this holiday 2019 night. Why not 5 stars? Well it is a very standard menu, innovation here is lacking, and overall it's just not that "rocking". People have complained, maybe stick with the easier stuff like pasta dishes and pizza, because amazing Ossobuco well that can be a bit challenging(?), or realize this ain't Florence.
Ashland struggles for great 5 star places overall. But Macaroni's is solid.
The other Italian place in town is now not as good anymore, per my Mom who is a resident of Ashland. Her friends complain about prices and overall inconsistency in execution. I think if you are in town, and a bit confused of what is "good", you best consider this place for a nice intimate Italian fare, close to the awesome Ashland plaza. And you can get out for under $100, with wine and a dessert.
It is a value, and who doesn't love classic Italian. read more