In town for the 2026 Hot Rod Power Tour and stopped here with the crew for some pizza. Initially we were a lil concerned because the place although open was empty but to our surprise The pizza was amazing - Thin crust, plenty of toppings. Perfect crunch on the crust. We ate 2 large pies and were very happy. If you're in town you must stop by and give it a try. read more

Luigis Italian Restaurant - Pizza - Italian Near Me - Mattoon, Illinois

I have eaten here many times! The one thing I love about this place is the food is ALWAYS sooo yummy! The bread is homemade daily and there is nothing like it. The wait staff are always helpful when I'm stuck on what to order! The restaurant is really nice and has 2 different areas to eat in. You can also order carry out and enjoy at home! read more

Well, let me start by saying, this is not the standard. I would have given five stars (at least 4) any other time we've been here. We have probably frequented this establishment about 25-40 times. Over the years it's been solidly standout. However, today was the exception. I will say it was a bit busy, but no wait. Most of the tables were full, but we got seated right away. Service was a bit slow to start but that's understandable, as it was hopping. After the initial meet the server, she was quite timely. However, still love the place, and everyone has off days. The pizza wasn't as good as usual, either. However, we'll be back, of course. read more

Luigis Italian Restaurant - Simple dining room, clean. Adequate wall art, very dark colors and low lights. - Italian Near Me - Mattoon, Illinois

I am a high school track & field coach that was down in Charleston a few weeks back. We've bent coming to your restaurant for roughly 4 years now. We love the food, service & atmosphere. Stella & Kirsten were amazing! However, this most recent trip I was extremely disappointed with whoever the gentlemen is who takes reservations and answers your phone. I made reservations at least a week out, called to confirm on 3 occasions prior to us coming down to no avail. When we arrived he didn't have my party listed or he gave it to some other party. Then the guy disappeared. He was extremely unprofessional. In all honesty we probably won't come back for what it's worth. read more

Very good food, quiet atmosphere, downtown location. I will be back next week. I had the Marsala

No. Just no. We went here a handful of years ago when it opened and it was okay. Today we decided to go back, but it'll be the last time. The atmosphere is very dark, and it's off putting how poor the interior of the room we were seated in looked--tables stacked upside down on other tables, piles of chairs blocking a door, and wall decor that looks like someone went garage sale shopping. The bread was over baked. The salad with house dressing was the best part of the meal. The meals LOOKED great, but did not taste good at all. I had Chicken Capelini--the texture of the chicken was like overly cooked pre-boiled chicken that was thrown in a pan to brown it. It somehow it managed to be dry and rubbery while floating in a sea of thin broth. My husband's veal was not a cutlet as one might expect, but rather bits of some kind of beef that I strongly suspect were not veal. The damablanca sauce was also super thin with no hint of the usual brandy or Cognac one would expect. It basically tasted like watered down Alfredo sauce. read more

See all

Solid food and service with very reasonable prices. Would most definitely come back! Great place for conversation read more

Really fresh good pasta and sauces! Fresh baked bread too. Everyone was very friendly and happy we stopped.

Amazing food, staff was great, very clean, sits in downtown Mattoon. So check out the down town area as well they have other little shops after u eat. read more

The food and service are both phenomenal!! My favorites are Spaghetti and Lasagna. I have yet to be able to finish it all at once. The bread is made on site. The icing on the cake is the Dean Martin and other great singers in the background. read more

This place was very simple. Nothing that stood out to me. The bread was nice and warm though. Def needed the butter to give it some taste. I had the spaghetti and meatballs. It was very average. Other folks in my group enjoyed it excited for one. Not sure If they were having a bad day, but if I ever come back here. I will go ahead and give it a try. read more

Stopped in on way home from Chicago to TN. Our server was very friendly and courteous. Great garlic bread and our entrees were out fast. Recommend the pasta trio! Prices were very reasonable too. read more

I ate here about a couple of months ago and I got the chicken parm. They did not disappoint. The service was great and the staff were friendly. The ambiance was welcoming and seems very elegant. It's definitely a great date night spot or for the Italian lovers just visiting town. read more

I had minestrone soup with chicken yesterday. It was very flavorful, hearty and full of veggies and chicken strips. Service was good and friendly atmosphere. Reasonable prices. Keep up. I plan to go again to enjoy lovely dinner. read more

I stumbled upon this place while I was at the state track meet and boy was I impressed!!! There was a nice ambience to this establishment and it seems impossible to have a bad time there. The service is outstanding and the bwead was phenomenal. And don't even get me started on the Tiramisu: NEXT LEVEL! read more

The food here was awful. The pasta was extremely watery and flavorless. The bread was plain. I enjoyed the stuffed mushrooms only because the sauce tasted like my favorite soup from the grocery store (it tasted too familiar). There was also a bunch of random chairs and tables stacked where they seated us; not very eye appealing. I will definitely not be coming back here nor will I recommend this place to friends and family. I'm honestly shocked they're still in business. read more

Luigis Italian Restaurant - Italian Near Me - Mattoon, Illinois

Luigis is a local Italian favorite in Mattoon, IL. They provide free homemade bread rolls, which are pretty tasty. It's even tastier when dipped in their Olive Oil, Garlic, and Basil sauce (aka "OGB"). If you're a fan of raw garlic and bread, then make sure you order the "OGB" cause you won't be disappointed. Their pizza is alright, could be cooked a little bit more as the dough in the center was not as crispy. Kids spaghetti was pretty much standard and generic. Next time, I plan on ordering an entree dish. For the longest time, they only accepted cash, but they now accept credit card. read more

See all

Horrible. The food was awful. I could only eat a few bites of my spaghetti with olive oil & garlic. There was no taste and it was so mushy the noodles were sticking together. The waiter brought out warm rolls right away, but they were completely dry and tasteless. I never turn down bread but these were inedible. So sad read more

Solid enough Midwest red sauce joint in a cute old downtown. Hey some lunch while your charge your car for free at LIFT.

If you live here you may already know about this place, but if you are traveling on I-57 or if you are stopping for the night in Mattoon, IL, then get you a little cash and get ready for a treat. Yes, you need cash because the sign on the door still says "cash or check only " when we ate there in July 2018. The bread that came out after we were seated was a little stale and chewy instead of the soft bread we've gotten at many Italian restaurants these days, but it just didn't matter once the entree was presented. Luigi's knows it's way around a variety of sauces and I can't imagine any of them will not be a delight. We tried two: Tortellini Alla Panna in a cream sauce with a touch of marinara and Chicken Albanese in a brandy cream sauce and they were both very rich and so delicious. The salad that is included with the meal was fresh and I enjoyed their house dressing. Menu prices seem very reasonable with many choices at $10 and a lot of others at $12-13. The portions are generous and my wife blew my mind by taking about half of her Tortellini Alla Panna back to the hotel and reheating it in the microwave the next morning for breakfast! I think she really liked it. The interior is comfortable with booths and tables. Service was very attentive and friendly. Parking is curbside as they are located downtown. If I lived here this would have to be a regular weekly treat of exploring all that their menu has to offer. read more

See all

Wonderful Food, Wonderful Service, Wonderful Atmosphere. We were here last year & Luigi's was the must stop for us this trip. read more

See all

Wonderful pasta & bread! Always yummy and filling! One of my favorites is the chicken minestrone! Love the staff! read more

Food was decent for local Italian. Plain salad but good dressing. Flavorful pasta. Good, warm rolls. Well made tiramisu. Coffee came half way through dessert with no cream until after. Very strong smelling cleaning solution -- overpowering end of the meal. Waitress did not clear a single plate until we had a small mountain of dirty plates stacked up on half the table. read more

There was no Mario. How am I supposed to enjoy so classic Italian food without Luigi's right hand man. My ex-wife always hated comping here so that automatically makes it one of my faves. read more

Luigis Italian Restaurant - Italian Near Me - Mattoon, Illinois

Good Food. Stopped on our way from Kentucky to illinois. A little off the high way but worth it. Fast Service! Pizza delish! read more

Everything we had was amazing! Portions were very good and the flavors were incredible! I'm not normally a huge Italian food fan but could eat this once a week. If you're ever visiting the area, like we were, you HAVE to eat here. read more

We stopped here for a late lunch and the food was fantastic! DH had spaghetti with OBG and I had Chicken Piccata. My only complaint was a little too much capers, but I just ate around them. The salad was fresh and crispy. Both pasta dishes were hot. I got a Tiramisu to go and it was divine! The bread here is to die for! We will definitely go back. read more

Food and service were excellent. Very accommodating for our large group. I had beef ravioli, salad, and bread. All were delicious.

Excellent food pleasant staff Would highly recommend them If you want great food and service. read more

The pasta & their sauces are 10/10 the pizza is good too. They also have excellent service!

The bread is amazing!! I love their knots. I had a spicy shrimp pasta dish and it was great! My kids love their spaghetti and meatballs. I love eating here. read more

Once again, outstanding service and food. Small issue getting in due to sidewalk construction, but they are open and parking in the rear. Hands down the best Italian food anywhere around. I've not been to Italy, but I can't imagine the food being any better. High ceilings do make for a loud room, but not terrible. Like everyone, they were short handed, but the service couldn't have been faster. Constantly concerned about our experience and food, not to the point of pesky. You really need to try this place. read more

$40 for food that was inedible. The spaghetti with oil and basil was swimming in oil. The salad dressing was literally just straight balsamic vinegar. The pasta primavera made my companion sick. The service wasn't great either. read more

Unbelievable! We thought we give it another try. Bad choice! When you enter, you are welcomed with a terrible smell of musk. They had one waiter who basically done it all.. he run his bottom off. I ordered spaghetti and meatball my husband veal,mushroom on linguine with a wine sauce creamy supposed too. We both had salad. My spaghetti was a five out of ten.. by a.n Italian sauce in store and dump on your noodles. My husband's food looked look me a watered down version of nothing.. the price was outrages . Sorry, Mattoon needs something to be proud off, this is not a place where you get food to satisfy .. the bread is the most valuable item they have. If you want Italian go to Angelo's it's much cheaper . Sorry Luigi's .. you need to have reliable people in the kitchen, more waitstaff on the floor if you want to be successful . Being there six years you should know better.. I was told their been a family emergency in Oklahoma. Here is my take on this. If you don't have enough staff close down a day.. put a note on the door.. don't allow those who really do not know anything about food etc to run your restaurant.. read more

Overall wonderful experience. You wouldn't know from the street that this place has the best food in Coles County, maybe more. It's pretty sparsely decorated on a concrete floor. The harried young lady who took care of us really was an all star on an understaffed crew. My wife and I shared side salads and bread with the OGB sauce (olive oil, garlic, and basil sauce, which includes onions and bell peppers) as a first course. Such a simple, seemingly obvious to make bread sauce was amazing. They nailed it. Savory, peppery and acidic with capers, a tinge of sweet from the peppers, I want to recreate that. Doubt I'd get anywhere close. My wife had chicken parmigiana as the main course and I had their Bellissimo special that you'll find up there in the pictures. Wherever their sauce recipes came from should be in the sauce Hall of fame. They are unbelievable. Light enough, but it brings the rest of your food together in an awesome way. My wife and I were both blown away. The portions are large and you can take the rest home for seconds, which should be mandatory. Only gripe- they don't have a full bar. Just some beer and house wines, and that was really the only missing part of the experience. We'll be back just for the sauce. 5/5 read more

Luigis Italian Restaurant - a plate of spaghetti and meat - Italian Near Me - Mattoon, Illinois

BRING CASH OR CHECK - no joke. There's a sign on the door and ATMs inside in the place in case you forgot. We walked in Friday night and the place was dead. The gluten feee was decentish - I had the gluten free shrimp Alfredo however the Alfredo sauce was runny as oppose to thick and creamy. The Italian sausage appetizer was good but a bit too salty. Too much salad dressing on the salad. Peg, our waitress was nice but another waitress had an annoying cackle. read more

Where to start...Luigi's is one of our absolute favorite places to eat, whether it is just two of us, or an entire crowd. They service is outstanding, everyone is always friendly and efficient, the food is amazing, like a little glimpse into the flavors of Italy. No matter what you order on the menu, it will be a winner. Even something as mundane as a cheese pizza is out of the world. And the bread and the OGB olive oil (you must ask for the oil) is totally AMAZING. I could make a meal out of the bread and that heavenly oil. Their house dressing is a tomato based vinaigrette that is delicious. A little bit of sweet and a little bit of heat. I would highly recommend this place for lunch or dinner. ALWAYS a top choice! read more

Fool me once, shame on you... Our second time here, same poor result. The Good: The free bread. The Bad: Flavorless, dismal main courses. My wife's veal was gray & rubbery, resembling liver or other indeterminate organ meat. My pasta sampler tasted like overheated frozen food. The Ugly: Christmas in March? Christmas music playing, waitstaff that are untrained, aloof & seemed to wander a lot. Second time here, our visits were over a year apart; same consistently poor results. Fool me twice... shame on me. Stouffer's frozen anything is easily better than this stuff. We won't be fooled again. read more

PHENOMENAL.... SUPERB..... STUPENDOUS..... NO REGRETS.. DO YOU GET THE HINT? They ONLY thing bad here is the exit as you do eventually have to leave! Look, if you believe Olive Garden is true home style Italian cooking just stay out of here.... However, if you want a rib sticking and hearty meal then wander on in and ready for a bit of heaven.... The house made rolls are spectacular... the salads and soups will leave you speechless.... the house made pasta and light hand on the ingredients remind me of meals in Italy in days gone by..... leave room for desert and definitely leave a DECENT TIP cause these hard working folks will NOT let you down... read more

Good food, big servings. In a cool downtown space next to the Mattoon mural wall and small park. They have parking in front and in back and are always clean. read more