Lucy&#x27;s Pizza

(26 reviews)

5.7 mi

Stopped in to eat a 16" pie and ended up ordering another to go!…read more Great pizza, nice, clean and friendly. We'll definitely be back!

I'm not gonna waste my valuable and valiant time because this joint is clearly deleting reviews…read more Not even in the underworld would Magherita Pizza have this good of a Yelp score. I seriously wonder how this spot stays open. $7 slice which whatever is obviously ridiculous but ya hope maybe it'll be decent. Oh my goodness. Lord hear our prayers. For what did I do to have to be exposed to this disaster of a disaster? Disastrous. Again. I'm going to be briefer than a bucket full of piss. I believe that this sauce cooked on the stove top. I believe they don't have access to any utensils, and so to stir the sauce they used their feet. I actually think they stuck their foot into boiling sauce. Dirty and gunky feet. And then they leave it going all day until it's as funky as it could possibly be. Unredeemable - But this review will be deleted (I presume). And I hate doing this to local biz but at that price point this one deserves the lauding of hate.

See all

Frankie’s Pizza & Pasta

(14 reviews)

0.8 mi

Extra large slices of NY Style pizza for $4 - crispy thin yet cheesy and foldable. Has Grande high…read morequality mozzarella and a nice tangy tomato sauce. Recommended.

Very good pizza and pleasant service! Ask Frankie about the picture on the wall. Mushroom pizaa was…read moreexcellent.

Inside

Chkn scarp and marsella

See all

Front

Capri Pizza & Pasta

I arrived with high expectations, anticipating a well-crafted sandwich, but unfortunately the…read moreexperience did not live up to its promise. The most notable issue was the temperature inconsistency: while the sauce was pleasantly warm, the chicken cutlet was noticeably cold, giving the impression that it had been prepared long before service and simply assembled upon ordering. This contrast significantly affected both the texture and overall enjoyment of the sandwich. I am willing to give the establishment another opportunity in the future, but on this visit, the quality fell well below expectations. As it stands, I would rate the sandwich a 2 out of 5 stars. If management is reviewing customer feedback, I would strongly encourage ensuring that chicken is prepared fresh and served at the proper temperature. A sandwich is only as good as its ingredients at the moment of service, and customers should not receive chicken that appears to have been sitting out awaiting an order. Fresh preparation would greatly improve the overall dining experience.

Meh. The salads have gone way down hill lately. Not fresh. Greens not cold enough, over-ripe, mushy…read morepears. The menu still says candied walnuts while they've not served any for many years. "We're out of them today". hmmm, right, yet selling at the candied walnut price. You still have to check when you pick up your order that they haven't stacked the salad right on top of a hot, cooked item in a closed bag....unless you like warm, wilted greens.

Spacious dining room

See all

Pizzeria Baci

4.6

(34 reviews)

6.6 mi

We used to love this place but they are so inconsistent and pricey for what you end up with. The…read morelast 2 pies were the last straw. Too small, too expensive which we would have dealt with but when you cheap ingredients and 2 pizza's so bad we threw them away...we're done! At least for a few months until we try again because when they give it their all-it's really good!

BEST PIZZA E V E R !!!…read more Crazy! I'm 84 yrs old and have been a pizza lover for ALL those years. Some good, some bad and some were like a bad excuse for what Italian pizza is supposed to be. I have had almost every pizza that Baci Pizzeria in Montrose Nay, has to offer to date, BUt just tried for the first time, the Detroit Classic version! I fell in love!! You have got to try this robust and crispy version of the Sicilian deep dish pie! Outstanding! Couldn't be better!

Round pie with soppressata, red sauce, mozzarella & hot honey

See all

Capriccio

4.2

(95 reviews)

2.7 mi

The BEST pizzeria. Great pizza consistently, great food and restaurant items too. Pretty and clean…read morenew location with good service too! I have been patronizing this family owned pizzeria since I was a kid and will continue to do so for as long as possible. Worth ordering from over other spots! Trustworthy and high quality local fan favorite.

My wife and I chose Capriccio for an no fuss dinner. The service was good aswas the quiet…read moreatmosphere at an early dinner. The meal, well 2 out if three ain't bad..... The Calamari was nice and freshly served and the Eggplant pizza was well enjoyed. My favorite item (Sausage Calzone) was a disappointment, as it came out late and as I was trying to eat it, the slices of sausage were falling out. It wasn't until 1/4 through the calzone that I realized that the cheese wasn't melted through (essentially a ball of cheese instead of a slurry).

Chicken fingers w/French fries

See all

Cheesy garlic bread with sauce on the side

Tutto Italia

4.8

(22 reviews)

4.9 mi

THE BEST!! In the world and I actually wish I was being dramatic. I have never had such good food…read more Frankie is the BEST. Such a hard worker, personable and truly cares about making the best pizza every single time. Consistency you wouldn't be able to find anywhere else in the tri-state area. 11/10 recommend 110% worth traveling hours for Again, not exaggerating. It really is just that good!

Pizza made by a trained Pizzaiolo - only the finest and freshest ingredients handled with time and…read morecare. The results are the BEST pizza you will ever eat. We had the pie with fresh mozzarella and strips of baked salami with fresh basil. He also has vegan mozzarella cheese placed on a small pie with hot spicy peppers on his signature imported tomato sauce. Delicious. Just a perfect bite.

See all

Ossining Pizzeria and Restaurant

I ordered a large plain cheese pizza pie to pick up for my elderly 92 year young maternal aunt who…read morelives in Ossining. The guy was nice enough over the phone taking my order. He said 25 minutes. At around 25 mins he called me back ( I hadn't arrived at the pizzeria yet to pick it up) informing me that the pie was ready. I thought that was a very nice way to follow up with me. The pie was $18.99. The pizza was solidly good. Good mozzarella cheese to Tomato sauce ratio. It was well cooked not doughy and it was okay. I'd give it a 6 out of 10 for overall taste. Ambiance nothing to write home about. Typical pizza parlor with a few chairs and tables to sit and eat at. And there are tables in chairs where you can sit outside ala "South of France" (tongue in Le cheek) Buon appetito!

This is a "know what to get" kind of pizza spot. Their chicken rolls are amazing. The pizza has…read morebeen inconsistent, once I asked for a meatball slice and they should have said they didn't have it but instead they just cut up some meatball on top of a plain slice - not appetizing but I appreciated them trying to accommodate my request. Great parking and easy pickup.

Sad meatball slice on the left and delicious chicken roll on the right. I always ask for an extra sauce for the chicken roll!

See all

Buffalo chicken pie

Donato’s Trattoria

4.1

(55 reviews)

1.8 mi

There's a sign inside the restaurant that reads, "Come As You Are." Don't worry about dressing…read moreup--just show up and enjoy the food. I joked that meant I could arrive in my birthday suit... my wife quickly corrected me. It was just the two of us tonight. The place has a very cozy atmosphere with both tables and takeout, but the takeout side doesn't take away from the table service at all. I had the Shrimp Francese with lemon and white wine sauce--six very large, juicy shrimp over angel hair pasta. My wife ordered the Eggplant Rollatini. I usually make sure we order different things because she rarely finishes hers, which means I get to try it... or enjoy it the next day. Our Irish waitress was very nice and attentive. Quaint, comfortable, and consistently good--this neighborhood Italian spot has definitely earned a permanent place on our repeat-visit list.

My husband and I and a dear older friend of my mom's made a reservation for 6;30 Pm…read more She lives nearby in the assisted living at the Kendall. She highly recommended this restaurant. We had travelled all the way from Tuckahoe, New York, We were kindly seated and was warmly greeted by a nice waitress named Irene. I had a nice shrimp dish with a side of broccoli. My husband had a delicious Chicken Scarpariello dish. Our dear friend had a delicious house salad and pasta with clams. The portions were ample and delicious. The ambience was terrific. and cozy. I give the establishment a Five Star plus rating and review. Happy Dining! Do not Pass go, Go direct to Donato's Trattoria. Signed a happy customer. As a sidenote, I hear they have a bustling pizza business. They prepare and serve all types and specialty pizzas to fit your individual taste ! I heard Sundays and Saturdays during the day are very busy days at Donato's! ; so please call ahead for your take out order today or fine dine it , stay casual and or eat in ! There is ample parking as well on the street and close by. Phil the owner is pleasant , cordial experienced, professional and a great host ! As well.

Sunday Sauce

See all

Pizza and wings

Beekman Ale House

I know this place already has a huge ego from all of their excellent reviews but I have to give…read morecredit where credit is due. The chicken vodka burrata pizza is to die for. Vibe is dark and loud. Unless there's a hidden upstairs or back room, seating is limited which is a problem when the pizza is this good. Meatballs as an appetizer is pretty much the only non-pizza thing to get here and those are solid as well. Service was good and pricing is fair for the quality of the food!

Recommended by a server at a new local restaurant. hhe was well versed in food. His comment was -…read more"I'm not from the area but I stopped in at Beekman Ale House...the best thin crust pizza I've ever had" Next day here we are, walked in, there were three seats available at the bar, grabbed all three so that we can have some breathing room. The place is not big but packed, we must have lucked out. The noise level was through the roof - LOUD is an understatement. Every table had at least one pizza 'stand' The menu is limited - 4 starters, 4 salads, 11 pizzas and 1 Pie of the week - (add ons available, pies 12"), oh and 1 desert. On Tuesdays Detroit style pizza - THE END. We ordered the Bianca - Sausages, Garlic, Broccoli, Baby Kale, Cremini Mushrooms and Mozzarella. It took a while but well worth the wait. The pizza was delicious - thin crispy crust, it was like bitting into a loaded crispy, chewy 'potato chip' Very reasonably priced Will be back One star off for room temperature red wine

Super cool window displays.

Meatballs

See all

Euro Pizza

Family-owned & operated

Established in 2008

Takeout for a group lunch. Everything delicious and on time just as ordered. In the area it's…read moreprobably best pizza. Crust is crunchy.

I waited 40 minutes for my order when it was ready the entire time. 7 people behind the counter and…read morenot one doing their job. One girl was digging her hand in the pepperoni and eating while another guy played with his phone then proceeded to touch food without washing his hands. Disgusting. Should definitely be inspected.

Layers On Layers Of Pure Comfort! This Classic Meat Lasagna From Euro Pizza Is Perfectly Baked! Highly Recommend!

Penne Pasta We Use De Cecco, Our Tomato Sauce Is Made At Briarcliff Manor Using Mutti Plum Tomatoes. Baked With A Premium Wisconsin Cheese.

See all

Euro Pizza In Briarcliff Manor

Brothers Fish & Chips

This is one of the most inventive fish restaurants I have ever come across. The chef is from…read moreGuatemala, and the food reflects a fusion of great technique, great ingredients and a twist from his heritage. We eat regularly, but also have gathered a group of friends to try the seven course menu. This really showcased the kitchen. Can't recommend this place highly enough.

To say this restaurant's location and exterior is unassuming is very much an understatement…read more Inside, it is beautiful and has a wonderful ambiance. It was most unusual that our party of four all ordered the same. We started with a special app - Fried Shrimp & Calamari. Soo Delish! We followed with the signature dish, Cod Fish & Chips. I have had this entree in, I'd estimate, 50 restaurants, including several in England where I think it originated. NONE even come close to here! Oh My - the two big, thick pieces of lightly battered fresh cod fried to perfection! Flaky, moist and delectable. It just doesn't get any better! Wow! The fresh, hand-cut thick fries were again fried to perfection. Golden crispy on the outside, moist and tender on the inside. I don't know what their secret frying technique is or the type of oil they use but the flavor is light and delicious. Even their homemade coleslaw tastes like they just made it - so fresh with a little tang - Mmm! We ended with a very unique lemon flan, even though we all said we couldn't eat another thing. Overall, portions are generous (we took home some left overs!), service staff were friendly and attentive, and the Owner & Head Chef, Elmer came out to check on us and tell us some of his culinary encounters with blue fin tuna. Fascinating! A most enjoyable meal and experience. If you've never been, What the heck are you waiting for!

Jackie & her colleague were great hosts and mixologists We had strawberry pisco sours which were next level

Tequilas

See all

3 Westerly Bar & Grill

My friend and I had a great experience at 3 Westerly. Ella was our server, super attentive and…read moreconstantly checking in on us. Food was amazing and service was fast. Their manager Fabian came over to make sure we had everything we needed. And we HIGHLY recommend the Cookie skillet. Top tier.

The location is absolutely breathtaking, which sets the scene for the amazing food and drink. The…read moreambience and proximity to the water connected to this beautifully maintained area and restaurant is worth the trip alone. The food is reasonably priced for the taste and quality, servers are nice, and the bar is extensive. 5/5 star experience. Our new favorite local restaurant. Could not ask for a better spot!

Our favorite cocktail - the Paloma

Cake Table

Tempura Dragon Roll

See all

The Boathouse

Disclaimer: I always give my stars rating based on the type of restaurant, so I rate a Michelin…read morestar differently than a great hang place. We were heading up to Croton-on-Hudson for a show and none of the restaurant options were looking appealing. We wanted something with a view of the water since it was the first truly Spring weather day we'd had this season. I saw that the rating for this place wasn't spectacular, but loved the photos and decided to read recent ratings, and we decided, even if the food is "meh" at least we'll be outside by the water. The Boathouse did not disappoint. The host who seated us was friendly and enthusiastic. Our server was everything you want in a server: Friendly, Confident in making suggestions, Attentive without being pushy or annoying, and just an honestly great man who was so fun to chat with. We both just had mains: Husband had the seafood gumbo. Wow! So packed with flavor, and yes, the spice hit you on the back end, but SO yummy. Packed with seafood and sausage, rice that wasn't gummy, and I am sorry Tom Colicchio, the okra was delicious! The "slime" that we all fear had more of a velvety texture that was not off-putting at all, and the flavor was really unique and enjoyable. i had the Shrimp Luciano. Five jumbo shrimp without a hint of vein or shell, sautéed in an egg batter that crisped at the edges. The sauce...omg....so flavorful. I find so often that chefs add too much of spice and herb but not here. It was well balanced and so yummy. If I wasn't in public, I would have licked the plate clean! Oh, and it came with green beans, one of my least favorite vegetables because again, I find so many just over cook and over season. This were lightly sautéed so they had a fresh from the garden taste and a perfect snap to them. Garlic mashed potatoes...made with red bliss...had a sweet element, not sugary, but there was a flavor were just couldn't identify....maybe a hit a nutmeg? Regardless, they were heavenly. Then we made the decision to share a slice of the crème brûlée cheesecake. We didn't have room, but our "neighbors" at the next table said we had to try it...so we did. WOW! This was not your typical heavy overly sweet cheesecake. It was light, had specks of vanilla, a very thin lovely crust and the taste....sooooooo good. The wine by the glass choices were great: $12 for a wonderful glass of Albariño?? It was so crips and light and perfect with my meal. Husband had an IPA...we think it was called Maine Lunch and it was also delightful. I will note: the tables are NOT on the dock. They are a ways back but the water view surrounds you. I saw some tables set up right by the dock edge near the water and apparently they have a bar and music there once it gets warm. If it wasn't a 2 hour in traffic drive, this would be our new regular haunt. For now, we will have to make excuses to go up this way!

We were in the area and looking for a place to get a quick bite, this place is so cute , small but…read morethe service there is extremely friendly and efficient. We sat at the bad and had an amazing experience . The food is so delicious and very well priced as well . Overall a great experience , the only bad thing was the bathroom , not very clean . It's an issue that needs to be corrected . We plan on going back but I hope the bathroom is a bit cleaner next time .

Boat bar with rum punch cocktail

Boathouse steamed Clams

See all

Melike

(92 reviews)

0.2 mi

Loved loved loved everything we tried! The owner was super attentive and the place has definitely…read moreimproved since the first time we visited a few years ago. Definitely going back. Want to try their Iskendar kebab.

wanted to try this place for a while. very cozy authentic restaurant…read more started with order of baba ganoush . kinda bland and too much smoke also sigara borek. was kinda soggy and bland. i ordered lamb shank. wow it was cooked perfectly fall off the bone. it was amazing. wife had adana kebab she loved it. nicely grilled with fresh rice. really authentic fresh homemade food prepared good. great waitress enjoyed the place

M Mixed Cold Appetizer Plate

Interior of restaurant

See all

Doca's Restaurant

My favorite Portuguese place in Westchester…read more Make sure you get the clams and shrimp in the wine sauce.

Tried this spot with family and it did not disappoint. The appetizer bread was great and the pork…read moreand clams dish was amazing. The cauliflower in the dish was probably my favorite part. Such unique flavors and textures. I loved this dish

See more unrecommended reviews

The bar

Clams in garlic sauce

See all

Leftovers

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

25 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Walter J.

20 days ago

No idea who owns this place, but might wanna remind the employees there to refrain from political discussion in the workplace in earshot of customers. Here's a direct quote that I overheard While two employees talked about the president..." "You know what I like about Trump? He pisses off people I don't like." So, who exactly are these people that you don't like? The Black and brown people in the very community that you're serving? Democrats? The LGBTQ community? Or all of the above? I get it. Free speech, etc., etc. but free speech doesn't mean free of consequence and the consequence on my end is that I will never order from Lucy's again. read more

Kid Food Guides O.

11 years ago

We are six and seven year old, Food and Culture Guides from the Ossining Summer School Enrichment Class. We wanted to taste Italian food and Lucy's was fabulous. The restaurant is beautiful and has great seating. We loved the warm and delicious garlic knots. The staff was very friendly. We will definitely be visiting again! read more

Fern G.

12 years ago

Great place, right across the street from Ossining High, guaranteeing that every high school student has been at least 100 times. Good pizza, good garlic knots, good prices. To really cheap out you can even request bread and sauce. So delish. A great pizza spot for downtown O-town. read more

Jess M.

11 years ago

Love their pizza! I've heard people say they didn't like Lucy's but all I can say is that they don't know good pizza! Now to be fair, I've only had their plain cheese pie and garlic knots so I can't speak to their other topping pies. I'll definitely be getting my pizza from here again. read more

Jayde S.

16 years ago

Been to a few pizza places in Ossining and Lucy's is by far the best. The pizza is good, but what sold me is that they are super-friendly. I would avoid during school hours as once I went and the place was teeming with high school kids. read more

Neil G.

10 years ago

Excellent pizza, I'd say the best in Ossining. I tried it for the first time a few days ago and I was very pleasantly surprised. I'm very particular when it comes to pizza and this place did not disappoint. The decor was also very nice. read more

Natalie F.

173

10 years ago

This is my go-to pizza place. Their stuffed pizza are phenomenal and something not every pizzeria has. I love the garlic knots, i get them every time i go in. their plain pie is the best! the prices are ok and the pizza is great read more

Mrr G.

274

11 years ago

Actually the best pizza in Ossining/Millwood/Chappaqua. Better than the pizza is the chicken ceaser salad, but who am I kidding, I'm not that healthy. The lasagna slice is my calling. read more

Aiden S.

14 years ago

Been eating here since I was 3. Now that I'm in Highschool I eat here almost every day. Barbecue slice is as good as it gets. Great service and all of the other dishes are great too. read more

Kristin T.

283

9 years ago

Lucy's pizza is THE best around, chicken parm, shrimp parm dinners or wedges are amazing, pizza is the best around! BBQ chicken pizza is my fave! read more

Mike C.

17 years ago

one of the best pizza in upper westchester. none better in croton ossining area oldest estab pizzeria in ossining very busy means very fresh read more

Alissa H.

5 years ago

Service is great , pizza they gave me tasted hard looked old as if they gave me what was sitting there for hours .

Daniel V.

241

15 years ago

Lucys pizza, oh does it bring back memories! Going to school n being able to get the best pizza in town!

Brayan S.

8 years ago

I like lucy's pizzait's a great place to get pizza in town and they should keep up the great work

Keva M.

2 years ago

I have loved this spot for over 35 years. Still delicious and the best pizza around.

Ginette B.

14 years ago

Good pizza. Fun to see all the H.S. kids come in after school.

Neil G.

9 years ago

Awesome place! Love the food, this is my new pizza place!

Walton S.

11 years ago

I love Lucy's pizza! always fresh, never disappointing!

Amanda Z.

Elite 23

147

300

514

14 years ago

Ordered the stuffed veggie pizza. It was fantastic.

kevin m.

16 years ago

Best pizza in Ossining hands down!!! Enough said

Lucy's Pizza - pizza - Updated August 2026

People who viewed Lucy's Pizza also viewed

Pleasantville Pizzeria

4.0

(43 reviews)

My favorite pizza by-the-slice pizzeria in Mount Pleasant. The taste of the condiments,…read moreparticularly the cheese reminds me of Joe's pizzeria in Manhattan. It's a straightforward, thin crust, New York style pizza slice. A little thin and floppy in the front, but with a solid stronger foundation as you eat towards the crust, which allows you to fold the pizza in half (as one should ;)) . The ambience feels like a city pizzeria as well. The owners are very friendly to myself and my little one whom they regularly show hospitality towards. Definitely a neighborhood staple for me. A couple slices of pepperoni and a Coca-Cola and you're good to go.

Food - 5 Star Service - 5 Stars…read moreAmbiance - 5 Stars The pizza, mans behind that counter, and the experience all great yall needa support ts

Arthur Avenue Wood Fired Pizza And Catering

(110 reviews)

•$$

JC from Westchester; first of all the woman woman there is not very nice, went in and my daughter…read moreasked for a slice, she didn't know they don't sell slices, woman there's never slices here in a very nasty way Pies are super over priced, myself or Anyone I talk to will go there, People in the real Arthur ave are nice Treat children nice Sir if it's the place next to McDonald's And next to liquor store on marble There was an older woman there on a Sunday believe me she was not very nice

Wood fired pizza is excellent. The service is excellent too. I like that the owner is a nice guy…read moretoo.

Lucio's Pizzeria

3.9

(76 reviews)

Lucio has the best people working for him. With Lucio the customer comes first. Is Lucio's pizza…read morethe best? I think it is. He keeps coming up with new types of pizza and they keep getting better. Im reading about the guy with the supposedly burnt pizza. Just bring it back. probably just looking for a freebee. Who doesn't like well done pizza? Then the comment about "communities behavior of color". Pleasantville is not a prejudice community and Lucio and his workers are not prejudice. So Raveen you didn't like your food. It happens. Life goes on. Try not to use the prejudice card. Just try... God Bless

I've been going there for YEARS. This is what I got after asking the dude if it was fresh...he…read moresaid 20 min out...sorry,, this is not 20 min out. It's a burned out bottom. Threw both slices in the trash. And I'm devastated about having to give this review...granted, I did call, and the owner answered after my 2nd call, (1st call, I was hung up one and I was NOT rude or nasty) I assume, offered to replace, however, I am not leaving my house again to pick up slices again after I specifically asked if they were fresh. Nor do I want to make some poor delivery guy deliver when I am NOT going to tip him. And, the prices have gone up...if I wanted burned pizza slices, I could make my own or buy frozen. It's just totally unacceptable. I will pay higher prices...I get it, but NOT for burned food that I cannot eat.

Dino's Pizzeria

4.1

(79 reviews)

My go-to spot for Italian takeout is Dino's. The food is always consistent and the staff is always…read morehustling. My regular order: mushroom pizza with sausage, penne alla vodka (rich and creamy), and the spinach calzone. The spinach is sautéed in olive oil and garlic and it's incredible. Their pizza dough is just right-- not too thick, not too thin. Perfect every time. The ambiance isn't Michelin-star fancy and they don't have expensive bottles of wine, but that's not why I go there. I'm there for good food, welcoming staff, and true neighborhood vibes. I've cheated on them a few times and tried other places... but I always come back. And they always take me back.

Consistent and delicious!!! Great classic plain slice and awesome gourmet slices. Not overpriced…read more Kind staff.

Nonna's of Buchanan

3.3

(43 reviews)

•$$

This was the worst pizza I've ever had... $14 + personal pie with one topping, hard as a rock and…read morebarely anything on it. I won't be going back. Was recommended BUT not impressed at all.

We've tried everything from appetizers to pizza and pasta. I almost say this, but everything on…read moretheir menu is delicious and fresh. Their delivery service is too notch as well. Will always recommend!

Miraggio's Pizza & Pasta

4.2

(42 reviews)

This place was delicious, not greasy at all. Wonderful staff, they were very nice. The pizza was…read moredelicious and generous in size. Very clean inside and a lot of options.

ribs ribs ribs. place for ribs????…read more10,000% omg i love ribs and these fall off the bone!! ordered it with veggies what a healthy dinner lunch. i mean i will eat these for breakfast!! better than restaurant quality had a slice too. just amazing. why cant i get this in forest hills queens?? i thought we had the best but i was wrong. come get them

Main Street Pizza

3.7

(98 reviews)

My fiancée and I went here because we were on a budget after touring nearby Lyndhurst. It has nice…read moreclassic pizza place decor inside and there are 3 booth tables and 2 or 3 small tables with chairs The staff were all very friendly and welcoming. I had a slice of the meat lovers and my fiancée had a slice of the chicken bacon ranch. When I tell you this is the best slice of pizza I've ever had, I mean it, cause I've had NYC pizza and this was even better. The sauce was so flavorful, the meat on mine was so yummy, and I loved the crunchy thin ny style crust. And the price was actually pretty great! The pie was at least 12" diameter, so for 2 slices of a big pie, plus a 20 fl oz coke, 15 bucks and change is a pretty great price! All in all, we were very satisfied with our meal!

Not bad. Definitely coming back again. Also recommended this…read moreplace for people who like pizza 9

Irvington Pizza Company

3.6

(50 reviews)

The woman in the front is so kind and the staff is amazing. The food is out of this world. I would…read more100% recommend.

LOVE their pizza and their customer service. Family run and ownr is warm and caring for their…read morecustomers. Their buffalo chicken pie is the best we've had anywhere - be sure to specify that you want the Ranch dressing on the pie. Likewise, their Popeye spinach/white pizza is delicious, as is their mushroom pie. They also do garlic knots right - with olive oil and lots of garlic! I don't get the 1 star reviews - some are from before the current management came in. But there's no way this isn't a 4 Star minimum, and as per our rating, really 5 Stars!

Gerard’s Pizza & Pasta

3.8

(41 reviews)