We used to love this place but they are so inconsistent and pricey for what you end up with. The last 2 pies were the last straw. Too small, too expensive which we would have dealt with but when you cheap ingredients and 2 pizza's so bad we threw them away...we're done! At least for a few months until we try again because when they give it their all-it's really good! read more

Pizzeria Baci - It's supposed to be a Margherita pizza but this had cheap yellowed cheese on it. That's all I ate and threw the rest away. - Pizza Near Me - Montrose, New York

See all

Fantastic white pizza and so many specialty slices were available. The prices are reasonable. I took a menu to check out the entrees. Great vibe, great staff and great food. read more

We visited this place on our way back from Untermeyer Garden. On our way back we were hungry and found a pizza place that was close by. When we got there it looked pretty busy and people had already made take-out orders a couple of hours ahead. The chef was accommodating and he made our pizza in 20 minutes. It was fresh and so delicious. The crust was just perfect. read more

See all

Serious pies. Inside out box. Best around, not particularly close.... Call early to place the order read more

Pizzeria Baci - Pizza Near Me - Montrose, New York

I have been a pizza snob fanatic for so many years it's unbelievable. I know pizza. The pizza here is not good it is off the chart ridiculously amazing. Was there with friends over the weekend got four pies three of them were home runs one was a triple. This guy knows what he's doing! Off the charts! Worth going out of the way. This is a No Frills place sure it's a BYOB but you better also bring your own cups! read more

The best pizza around. The Avenue J and the chicken all vodka pizza are my personal bests but have never had a bad pizza. One is better than the other. No slices. Chris also does weekly outdoor dining with local bands weather permitting and the proceeds go to a local charity. He is good person, a great chef and the sour dough crusts are amazing. read more

This is probably some of the best pizza I've ever had in my life. The dough and ingredients is just next level. A must have. read more

See all

Every once in a rare while, if you look long and try hard and get very lucky, you might find something so exceptional that it changes an entire genre. I did. It's name is Baci Pizzeria. And I don't think pizza will ever be the same for me. The pizzas here are like nothing you've ever had. They're all made with a high-hydration sourdough and allowed to rise far longer than usual. Those long, slow steps take extra time and effort, but help create an unusually flavorful dough that moves good to extraordinary. That seems to be how pizza begins at Baci. We tried two different pies this trip. A basic round pie with soppressata, red sauce, mozzarella, and hot honey. Plus a Detroit style square with prosciutto and arugula. There's no question we'll be back for the others and whatever may pop up on their Special of the Week menus. There is absolutely nothing basic or ordinary or standard about this round pie. The crust is fairly thin, a bit chewy, and flavorful enough to be its own happy event. The red sauce is reduced almost to a jam, pushing the sharp acidity of the tomatoes toward an intensified umami lushness. The result is incredible and I haven't even finished my first bite. Top that deliciousness with a bit of mozzarella and just enough hot honey to announce that this is something different and the results are somewhere between WOW and WONDERFUL. As I said, like nothing else. The round pie looked a bit small at first and the toppings seemed minimal. And yet this may be the most opulent slice of pizza I have ever eaten.... Until I got to the Detroit square.... That lush little Detroit square is the pie I want to take with me to eternity. Only an inch or so tall and barely five inches wide it may seem small at first glance. Don't be fooled. All the goodness has been condensed into this astonishing little masterpiece. The dough takes center stage here and prosciutto adds a richness that's balanced by the sharp tang of arugula. That's the key word here I think - balance. Every tiny addition adds to the whole without overpowering it.... The result is stunning. For now, Baci is takeout only. Order online first or expect a longish wait - this really is the antithesis of fast food,. Long lines haven't started yet but I suspect that'll change as word gets out. The small room was already stacked floor to ceiling with empty pizza boxes waiting to be filled. I joked that it looked like enough to last a long long time. "Oh no," said the young man folding and stacking the boxes, "they'll be gone by tomorrow...." read more

See all

The pizza here is the absolute best, better than any I've eaten in NYC. It's worth it to call early to make sure you get a pie, especially on Fridays. We wait all year for the wood-fired pizza served outside on nice days in the spring and summer, it's BYOB and the personal-sized pizzas are insanely good. Chris works really hard at making the most amazing pizza around and it shows. We love their whole family! Do yourself a favor and make this your new go-to pizza spot. read more

I love their pizza, but it's very frustrating to be hungry and half to wait 3 hrs for your order. I'm calling since 3pm and at 3:45 I'm told they're booked. A loyal and disappointed customer. read more

The food is excellent. It's a takeout only restaurant. Open from 4-9 PM except for Mondays. We ordered the eggplant rolatini. It was amazing. Absolutely delicious. The tomato sauce is perfect. Also had a small Margherita pizza. Such a nice thin crust. Again, perfect sauce and crunchy crust. Excellent food. read more

Will put Baci up against any pizzeria in the tri-state area. Basically a one-man shop slinging quality pies using the freshest ingredients. Highly recommend their Grandma or Detroit specialty pies, and the Sicilian may be the best I've ever had. Their more classic pies are fantastic too - classic New York-style cheese or pepperoni pie, Avenue J, and more. Each order from Baci makes my whole family smile. A must-order if you're in Northern Westchester! read more

Went in only after reading bad reviews. Now I'm a customer till he kicks me out... Some of the best pizza around with the best ingredients. Will be going back for more. read more

You don't get to a 771 day streak on Duolingo like I do without learning a few things...like "baci" means "kisses" in Italian...and I need to get out more. Finally a pizza place to brag about in Northern Westchester! This was my first time visiting Baci, and both the Ave J and Clam pies were outstanding. I'm already counting down the minutes until I can try more from the menu. Quality fresh ingredients, and an amazing thin sourdough crust. Friendly staff and not to mention really neat sports memorabilia on the walls too. Ordering was easy as (pizza) pie. The place opens at 4, but phone lines open at 3. Call ahead with your order and pickup time, and voila! ("Voila" means "there you have it" in French. I wonder how you say "I crave the acceptance of others" in French ) Anyway, if you love pizza you've gotta try this place out! read more

Pizzeria Baci - Clam Pie - Pizza Near Me - Montrose, New York

See all

Will not be back - did not enjoy one thing about this pizzeria. Food came out cold and flavorless

Chef Weisman broke away from pizza today (Monday), he offered us a taste of his trattoria fare. It was first rate. The quality and preparation of the meal is just you would expect from someone who uses only the finest ingredients in his pizza. I hope he continues this trattoria endeavor as it is a special treat for all who come to enjoy this chef's offerings. read more

Up there with some of the best pizza in NY, definitely lives up to the hype. You can taste the difference in the fresh ingredients, perfectly cooked. read more

Worst pizza I've had in a while! It was burnt the only thing edible was probably the Coca-Cola, and that's not even really edible! Owner is horrible and harasses local businesses nearby! read more

Just as advertised Perfect pie cooked perfectly Highly recommend to anyone trying to fine a good pizza in Westchester read more

8.5 - Montrose/Buchanan is not worthy of this pizza. This pizza belongs on the LES or West Vilage. The dough is on another level than anything you will find in westchester. Light, crispy, airy & chewy. Try it. Thank me later. Put some RESPEC on their name! read more

Pizzeria Baci - Large Avenue J pie. - Pizza Near Me - Montrose, New York

See all

I'm so upset it took me until now to find this place since I'm moving away in a few months! Until that time I'll be a repeat customer! Called around 3:15 and took me about 3 tries to get through and successfully place my order for pickup at 5:15. I arrived by 5:20 and was on my way with my 3 freshly wood fired pizzas by 5:25. Now, the pizza. Amazing. Soft, fluffy, like eating a cloud. Sweet tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, basil all high quality ingredients used throughout. Vodka sauce and spicy roni pies were a nice twist. Literally ate our pizzas for 3 meals straight and planning a return order next week! read more

baci makes the best pizza, og, margarita, vodka, buffalo chicken, it's all good, it's the dough.

This MF is a genius of dough. Probably the best pizza dough I have ever eaten. He is a yeast maestro. If he burns out of pizza, he needs to start with bread. Holy f** Christ. We just finished our pizza and are now going back to Montrose to get another. I lived in Ossining when we were the pizza mecca. No more, there is no doubt that Baci beats anything in Ossining, Gleasons, the Parlor, anyone. Come here now, you will not be disappointed. read more

Pizzeria Baci - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Montrose, New York

We found them on Facebook after a raving review on a Facebook page. I had to try it since there are many places that claim to be brick oven when they're not. Baci is a brick oven pizza place - FINALLY awe found out brick oven pizza locally. We had the pepperoni with the hot honey on top- wow it was to die for Give them a chance and you'll become hooked too read more

I wish I had more hands to give this place 4 thumbs up! I've ordered +/- 20 times over the last year or so and it's awesome every time. Yes they get busy (as you should expect for a place with really really good food) but it's just the chef and a young lady at the phones and register. Just order ahead and don't worry about it. Detroit-style pizza is a sleeper. NY is as good as it should be. The list goes on and on and on.... Side note: top 3 best chicken parm sandwiches around (I'm rounding up by 2), they do it on a toasted and buttered focaccia bread. Amazing. I tried the NY style Buffalo chicken and added pepperoni tonight. 6/5 stars. Should be on the menu. ‍ read more

Pizzeria Baci - Tastiness - Pizza Near Me - Montrose, New York

See all

We picked up pizza, salad and tiaramisu last night for dinner - what a surprise. Probably one of the best pizza's we have had and the tiaramisu - out of this world! We highly recommend it! We are foodies and make our own. This was the best we have had in this area. read more

Been living in northern Westchester now for over 15 years and have never had a piece of pizza up here that I've been impressed with. Every time someone suggested some place different, we get excited and try it, but end up disappointed. Until today when we stumbled upon Baci. It's clear from the first look and subsequent bite that this is not your average pizzeria. You want a quick boring slice, go somewhere else. You want to enjoy something special that's clearly made with love and the best ingredients, go pick-up a few pies at Baci. read more

We ordered the truffle pizza and the Detroit omnivore. Both were incredibly delicious and fresh. We will definitely be back!

Di Fara's on the Hudson Exceptional pizza with no frills atmosphere. I've been to many of the north East's top pizzerias and inhave to say this place is the best pizzeria in northern Westchester and it's not even close. For the most part pizza in this area is an affordable hot food. There are many decent pizzerias in the area but this is the only one that is exceptional. I still enjoy other pizzerias, many with great staff, and good food. That said Baci's has the best food. When I walked in I could tell right away the place was legit. Not just from the memorabilia from world class pizzerias but it had that vibe that lets you know it's going to be good. Don't expect a high end ambiance. This is low frills and about the food. I have to be honest, maybe a little too much salt for my taste, that said, who the fuck am I to give this guy notes? Biggest room for growth to me would be moving to a space with a bar. This style of pizza is crazy good bar pizza. read more

Honestly one of the best pizza places ever. Absolutely amazing. I had the deep dish margarita and it was delicious.

This is by far the best margarita pizza I've ever had. The chef, Chris, personally makes everything and is a perfectionist :) Order early because it gets busy. read more

Had dinner at the Trattoria last Wednesday night with 6 other people, what a fabulous meal we all had! The atmosphere was so comfortable and elegant! Will definitely be returning!! read more