I'm writing this review from Longtable because I'm so dang excited to tell everyone how fabulous this place is top-to-bottom! The food!! Holy smokes. I had the smoked trout salad and farro side. So much flavor and texture in both. Farro was cinnamon/fall-esk, but savory - exactly as was described to me by my server/cashier. The salad was a touch heavy on the dressing, but when it's green goddess, you drink it up. Good portion of trout and the goat cheese brought it home. I loved shopping for my own beverage. A little unorthodox, but sometimes seeing and touching the can/bottle helps. It's well organized and a wide variety. Can we talk about the service?! Patrick was incredibly knowledgeable of the menu and very patient for a first-timer like me. My food came out incredibly fast, and again - the taste! If I didn't live in Indianapolis, this would be my jam every week. read more

Nice selection of beers and wine. We had soups and a Charcuterie Board. The chicken Tortilla soup was of the chain. Patrick our bartender and the entire staff were friendly and knowledgeable. Really enjoyed the the whole experience. read more

See all

This seems like a good place to come and hang out with friends. They have a wide variety of choices and decent prices. read more

Longtable Beer Cafe - Bars Near Me - Middleton, Wisconsin

Do not go here if you have celiac. I was excited to try this place with a dedicated fryer that they were very intentional about being gluten free (or at least understanding what GF means). I ordered a GF burger but when the server came I didn't get a chance to double check if it was GF before they walked away. So I took one small bite and noticed it didn't seem right. I checked with the cashier and he said "nope looks like you got a regular bun, I could grab you a GF bun." I explained I have celiac and I can't just exchange the buns, but he seemed clueless. I will not be returning. read more

Longtable has such a good vibe! It's about as close as you can get to a beer hall in the Madison area, but much like its name describes, has long wooden tables and very cute string lights to complete the ambiance. There are an assortment of games to choose from to play as well as a huge refrigerator wall of different beers from throughout the world that you can choose from. There is a gigantic assortment of drinks to choose from - I ended up trying a Chile Guava Apple Cider the other day, which was very fun and tasty. The guava was subtle but definitely noticeable and the chile part really came at the end where you could feel it in your throat. Longtable also has different beers on tap that you can choose from, as well as typical bar foods such as burgers, fries, and cheese curds. In fact, Longtable recently made the list for top 10 cheese curds in Wisconsin based on EatStreet's Curd Nerd reviews! I haven't had a chance to try these yet, but definitely will the next time I am in the area. Middleton has really grown with its restaurant scene and personality over the last couple of years and Longtable is a wonderful addition. They also offer free parking in a certain lot so check in ahead of time if you are interested and want to avoid the 2 hour parking outside! read more

Overall, a great addition to the Middleton area with a unique proposition as a beer and sausage lovers mecca. It's sort of a DIY place where you order upfront, food is brought out and you go back up to counter if you need anything else. Our group did try three different items (2 sausage and 1 hot sandwich) along with the cheese curds and each needed more seasoning. We were sad to see that salt and pepper weren't supplied on the tables, which only works if an establishment is putting forth well-seasoned dishes consistently. The cooler of beer is a wonder though. read more

Wonderful location with classic vibe. Woodwork delivers atmosphere that makes this a true natural neighborhood experience. Wish I still lived here as this would be a regular spot. read more

Longtable Beer Cafe - Bars Near Me - Middleton, Wisconsin

I came here for a very specific purpose and had a crappy time. Apparently this place was bestowed an accolade by a local news agency as having the 2nd best cheese curds in Wisconsin. As a passionate curd fan my family sought out this destination in honor of my dedication to cheese consumption. Beers were drank and only curds were ordered for my party of six, as our purpose was streamlined and focused. I felt like the place was cool and had the potential to easily pull off my expectations. Dang, what a blow. Our curds were nothing more than hollow shells of thick, greasy, breaded, lifeless hulls of emptiness. There was no evidence that the cheese ever existed. We stuck to our guns at the hopes of redemption and got a manager to bring us a new order. However, we only received one new dish despite having two bowls of disappointment. The next order showed some improvement, yet minimal, and we couldn't help but sulk. The managers solution? He offered us his business card with a voucher for one free cheese curd on a future visit. How is this a resolution? By offering us more of something that we don't like? AND the offer stipulates that we return again on another occasion! They must think we're dumb. But, maybe we are because we paid for an embarrassing product and they got our money. I guess the biggest conundrum is who in the heck thinks these curds deserve touting? How embarrasing for their Wisconsin street cred. read more

See all

Service sucked our waiter seemed like he hated his life, my fish and chips was drowned in oil I physically had to dry it off with a napkin so it wasn't soaked in oil, the only redeeming quality was the cheese board but that took the least amount of effort. This place sucks don't waste your time. read more

Came to Longtable Beer Cafe for dinner on a Saturday night. The place was pretty busy. Like the name, all of the tables are very long, meant for multiple groups to sit at each table, in a communal style. First, you walk past a massive large self serve open cooler full of bottled beer. You pick what beers you want and take them with you to the cash register to order food. Then, you can seat yourself at one of the long tables to eat and drink. We got the cheese curds, which were basically amazing. This place had a pretty chill vibe and had garage door windows which can be opened up in the summer. I will definitely come back! read more

See all

Man was I excited for this place.. The concept seemed right up my alley, a large beer selection, seemingly delicious food options, a welcoming community environment that's close to home. I was sorely disappointed. Last night, my boyfriend and I stopped by for the first time, we were slightly surprised to see counter service only but didn't let that hinder our judgement. It was packed full on a Tuesday night, normally that's a good sign. Being so new I'm sure that's been the case for the past few months. Unfortunately, that's where our first annoyance arose, like I said, it is good to see a place booming with business but the acoustics were terrible. We could barely focus on what we were saying between the two of us. Those garage doors are going to be a life saver in the summer. Onto food and drink...we found a spot by the window, assessed the menu and made up our mind on food for the evening. We went with the meatballs, a spicy Italian sausage, a side salad and an order of frites with saffron aioli and curry ketchup, got two beers to pair. Our dinner was prompt to hit the table, we quickly indulged. The frites were first up to bat, they were enjoyable, the sauces were pretty good too. The meatballs came next, this is where the meal took a turn for the worse. The description sounded delectable, I was ready for an explosion of flavor. I'm aware that lamb can be dry, I assumed the yogurt sauce would moisten them up if need be. I took one bite and it was the weirdest combination. There was no depth, just bland and some overpowering spice. The meat was indeed very dry, dry and very bland. It seemed as if the chef tried to soup up the flavor of this lacking meat with what tasted like an offensive amount of ginger, turmeric or a similar spice. It absolutely killed my tastebuds. I love spice and flavor but this was absurd. It was completely inedible. I'm not ultra picky either, I'll usually try to at least finish something to not be wasteful but I simply couldn't. Another disappointment was the portion for the price, I understand lamb isn't cheap but three crappy meatballs for $12.50, man did that hurt. We were far to eager for the sausage to arrive, hoping that'd make up for the meatballs, it didn't. It had the same exact problem, bland as ever, with a similar flavor used, just not as heavily. The side salad was what it was, average tossed greens I don't have much to say beyond that. We wanted to tell someone of the heavy displeasure but felt awkward toting our food up to the counter while they were clearly busy. This is where I wish there was a server to inform of our issues, possibly allowing us to try something different. I really hope for the sake of the place that it was just an off day, someone prepped something wrong, I don't know. I hate to say it but this was one of the worst meals I've had in a while. I'd consider returning for the beer or wine, possibly a cheese or meat board. Other than that I was rudely turned off. :( read more

Longtable Beer Cafe - Huge bottle selection. - Bars Near Me - Middleton, Wisconsin

See all

First time here and will probably be the last. My wife was scolded for not stopping at the host spot to be seated... she missed the sign and there was only a couple of other parties there. Service was very slow and not very personable... didnt feel welcome at all. Food was okay but overpriced. Seating is very uncomfortable with picnic tables and metal stools. read more

I am only writing this review because of the server i had on my last visit. his name was John and he was the single best server i've ever had, anywhere in my life. I wish i could have him as my server at every restaurant i go to. I really hope that the management at Longtable, has also noticed this in him and he gets the treatment he deserves. John's attitude is what every person in the service industry should be striving to achieve. Thanks again John, you were awesome. read more

This place just popped up in the new construction behind the Village Green in downtown Middleton. It is a unique and very welcome addition to the area. The schtick is that they have several "long tables" to encourage a social and interactive environment. I stopped by to check it out shortly after they opened with some co-workers for some after work drinks. Overall very impressed. They didn't have A "happy hour" but you could do cheaper 9 oz pours, and find something budget friendly in their open cooler. They have lots of shareables (frites, charcuterie boards, etc) as well as salads and sandwiches. Clean, modern feel. Plenty to satisfy all of our different tastes ( sours, IPA, stouts, German biers, etc). My friend was beyond excited when he spotted a German beer in the cooler from an area he had just visited. Will be back! read more

Longtable Beer Cafe - Finding a beer from a place you've recently visited! So happy! - Bars Near Me - Middleton, Wisconsin

This place is the best beer bar in Middleton. An unrivaled selection of cans and bottles and a well curated tap selection. The service is phenomenal as well. The beertenders are super friendly and knowledgeable, they all seem to enjoy talking about beer, which makes each visit fun. They also have fantastic events! read more

This place is wonderful! I am a Middleton local, I love that I can go here and always find something new to try. You walk in and the vibe is great- long wood tables/bar counters (and cool outdoor seating in the summer too). There is a massive wall of specialty/craft beers and wine. They have a food menu as well. A favorite item is the brisket sandwich. The frites are great and they have a selection of unique dipping sauces too- an order of frites comes with two sauces your choice. You also cannot go wrong with a few drinks and a charcuterie board here. They have a selection of board games on a cart for you to play as you please. Longtable does a great job of creating an environment that promotes community and connection. When I come here it is usually pretty loud, but only because it is full of groups of people having conversation with one another instead of on their phones alone. If you have never been this is a definite spot to try! read more

Travelling to the area for business and was not expecting a place like this on the trolley system for my hotel. I got the power bowl salad and a soft pretzel. The power bowl was packed with fantastic seasonal veggies. Justin took great care of me at the bar - super laid back. Quick service. Can't ask for more! read more

This is a very fun place - It feels like the taphouse version of Five Guys burgers and fries. Sausages / Bratwursts - Woohool! They use great seasoning and condiments and cook the meat very well Sandwhich plates - also pretty good. Salads - The smoked trout salad is pretty skimpy on trout and kindof short on toppings. I wouldn't recommend it. The "Curry Ketchup" available as a sauce with their fries is FANTASTIC. read more

Food was pretty darn good, but definitely pricey. We were not too thrilled with the beer selection though, but that might be because we're not into English or Belgium beers, of which Longtable had a bunch. We would definitely be back if the American craft beer selection were better, but the food alone isn't worth returning for. Fries are amazing though! Goat cheese puffs and wild boar sausage were also tasty. read more

Longtable Beer Cafe - Yummy, but small wild boar sausage with AMAZING fries - Bars Near Me - Middleton, Wisconsin

Great beer selection and good food. Service can be dodgy at times. Many times I've sat at the bar for several minutes with an empty glass waiting for another pour. If the beer selection wasn't so great I probably wouldn't have a reason to return. read more

Yesterday the host was so rude and demeaning with no patience! While we were deciding whether to carry- out, since there was an hour wait for an outdoor table, he deleted our foursomes' name from his iPod and refused to put it back in. We were not the least bit confrontational. We left. We found out this morning that our neighbors were there last night too. They had a bad experience as well. read more

A bit disappointed with my first visit. I ordered the hot dog. For $7 with a side it should be a big sausage or, better yet, two dogs (on 2 buns). I was still hungry after I was done. The place struck me as over-priced but seems to use very high-quality ingredients. I'll certainly give them another try sometime, but I'm in no rush. read more

It is a nice place and the food is good too, I liked their burger with sautéed onions and their sausages. I wish they had Stella Artois and Spotted Cow beers. I gave them 3 stars for the staff at the register, the times I have been there they seem irritated by customers. If you stand up right in front of them taking a look at the menu (which in my opinion it's kind of confusing) they don't even bother asking you if it is your first time there and helping you understand how the menu works. I had to ask a few questions and they just answer yes or no or a very short sentence. In other words, they don't go the extra mile to make you feel welcomed. Besides, it is kind of pricey so it is like a once in a while deal. read more

Ordered the Corned Beef and Cabbage special for St. Patrick's day. HORRIBLE! Not even sure it was corned beef. Tough and flavorless (all four 1/2x2" pieces). More like stale regular beef brisket. If this is typical of their food options, I'll pass from now on, thanks. read more

I have been to Longtable a few times. Their tap beer selection is wonderful and they also have a full refrigerated section of beers sorted by style that range from $3 to $20 (pay attention)! We went last night for beers (Oktoberfest - so good, $6 each) and two appetizers (pretzel and frites). Our total was $25. Very reasonable for the size of the beers and apps! I loved the frites. You get to choose two dipping sauces and they have about 6 homemade ones to choose from - we tried the beer cheddar and maple bacon aioli - yum! They have lots of community tables to sit at with inside and outside options. It's really lovely! read more

Excellent customer service and I highly recommend the brisket sandwich or brisket frites! They did not hesitate to honor the City Tin for takeout! They are also taking the risk of covid seriously with precautions to protect customers and employees. Also they have a HUGE selection of beers and you can get beer to go! We will definitely be back. :) read more

Do not get the cheese curds. They are super greesy!! And they don't have ranch. Gross. Beer selection was cool read more

Food was great... but the employees had the attitude that they really don't care.. Went to visit my brother who lives in Middleton and went there for lunch. Three of us they got there sandwiches after about 20 minutes and server said he would be right back with mine..15 minutes later I tracked him down and waited another 10 minutes for my sandwich, all I got was "oh sorry " 3 sandwiches and 2 beers $57 Will never go again read more

My first experience was not terribly positive. I ordered a very overpriced burger (the special). The meat was mushy and entirely without flavor. They charged me $2.50 for fries on top of the $12 for the burger. The fries looked seasoned but were bland, as was the dipping sauce. All in all, I would never go back for lunch but might try Longtable as a happy hour destination. On the positive side, it is attractively decorated and the beer selection looked impressive. read more

Great venue and delicious food (not to mention the drinks :) I personally love the pulled pork! read more

Nope. Looks cool, is well decorated, and a good concept. It's just not done well in terms of management in my opinion has a lack of warmth and fun. read more

Just had lunch here. I had the brisket sandwich and my girlfriend had the Italian sandwich, each of us also had one drink. Our total with a 20% tip, which I don't think you need to tip at this type of location, was $48. Brisket was good however prices were too high for the food and service. read more

Although it is a fast food format, our food took over an hour to come, was middling in taste, and the service wasn't any better. The brisket was very fatty, the pulled pork wasn't much better. Fries were just ok. The cheese curds tasted like the oil they were fried in and were over salted. Very disappointing experience. read more

Restaurant offers gluten-free options. Unfortunately, they mixed up my order and I did not catch the error until after I had eaten half my meal. read more

What a KILLER addition to Middleton! We love this place and have been three times already! Insane bottled beer selection, awesome rotating taps, and the food is delicious. The frites with house made dipping sauces are so good, the pork sandwich is worth every calorie, and the brats are so well done. Getting your own beer / counter service is a little different than what we're used to, but not a hindrance to enjoying this place. The only reason that I went 4 stars is that the acoustics in here are quite terrible...really difficult to carry on a conversation when they're busy. read more

A decent new option in downtown Middleton, which desperately needs more options. Have visited 3 times with friends each time. The duck salad is excellent - when they have it in stock, and the beer on tap has offered a very nice rotating selection. The brisket sandwich is tasty and savory, and the boards are nice selections of delectable morsels. There's only counter service, which actually makes it easy to get in and out without waiting forever for an overworked server. Downsides: if there are more than 10 people in the place, it's so loud you can't hear the person next to you scream bloody murder (acoustics are terrible). Some of the staff seems rather ... unenthusiastic about the idea of their food and service. The community burger is dry and unremarkable, and there's no hint of the promised green chile flavor in the sauce. And don't count on a "bowl" of soup being more than about a cup and half of food, or on the server to do anything other than drop it in front of you and spill it in the process before walking away sheepishly. read more

Longtable Beer Cafe - Bars Near Me - Middleton, Wisconsin

Really good beer selection. Food was okay. A person in our group ordered a side salad that was really small and left hungry. Would probably go back for beer and apps, but food was pretty middle of the road. read more

Went with my husband for his birthday. The drink options are spectacular but the prices are a bit high. Food menu is limited but good. Would definitely recommend checking this place out! read more

Fabulous new venue. Adding a much-needed local dining and beer option to Middleton/Madison, Longtable is the perfect place to dine and drink. The staff has been stellar since day one, and the menu is anything but lacking in both options and flavor. Enjoy the vast selection of beers to-go, and don't skimp on the goat cheese puffs! read more

Nice place to hang out with a group of friends. Like their concept and beer menu. Food was just ok. This was my first time there. Will definitely go back. Want to try their food again before writing a full review of their food. Cheese curds were good. read more