Bland, doughy, floppy, bizarre sweet sauce, flavorless cheese…read more It's not even close to Detroit style. I don't even know what to call this.

AJ's is honestly my favorite Pizza place in Tiffin, but Reino's is a close second (but two entirely…read moredifferent styles, so not a fair comparison). If we're ordering Pizza on a Friday night, it's almost always going to be AJ's. Either the Jr. Jumbo, or if we're really hungry or have company, a Jumbo. I'm particularly partial to the Pepperoni rolls (highly recommend trying). Unfortunately, (just recently), I've noticed a decline in the consistency of the food. Sometimes it's great, which is what I've come to expect, and sometimes is just ok. I've also never been exactly "wowed" by the staff/service. This is just an observation, but a lot of the staff seems to be comprised of high-school or college age kids. I can say I don't recall EVER being greeted with a smile when picking up my order. It's almost always a young lady (different ones) who seem irritated that they're even there. Which is whatever... I just want my pizza. Just an observation though. I haven't been to the new location yet, so I can speak to the new dining area, etc. we switched over to doing delivery since we moved closer to town. Overall, highly recommend because generally the food is delicious.

Everything was absolutely amazing, we're 100% coming back to try everything on the menu, we started…read morewith a side salad, I didn't know a simple salad could be so perfect, the Nabolidon Old World Pizza knocked us out of the park with the freshness and flavor, the Cannelloni Florentine was spot on, the meat inside was very delicious and flavored amazing, the Cheese Ravioli was amazing it might sound simple but the flavors are incredible, HUGE loaded sub very delicious, we finished with the Tiramisu it's definitely something you don't want to miss out on, the portions are so big we had to take half of everything home, truly an amazing place, the atmosphere is phenomenal and the waitress who seated us was amazing at her job made us feel like we were at home, you can tell it's family owned and they make you feel like you're apart of it! I'd recommend this place to anyone

Nice little Italian place. Stopped in for dinner for night 1 of my 10 night stay in Tippin. I tried…read morea small thin crust pizza of their own design (can remember the name). It was very good and the service was excellent. I will definitely return between now and night 10.

all I can say is thank God I live an hour and 15 minutes from Tiffin!…read more I went to college in Tiffin and I lived off of Napoli Pizza. That was 20 years and 70 pounds ago. If I lived in Tiffin, those 70 pounds would be right back because I would stay at Napolis picking up fold overs. I was in town visiting my mom last night and for old times sake, decided to pick up a cheeseburger fold over. It did not disappoint! It was ready very quick. I picked it up, they are so generous with the toppings and the cheese. It still looks and smells exactly the same when you walk in there. There's a convenience to ordering delivery, but picking up yourself just ensure you get a perfectly piping hot meal. One more reason to visit my mom, definitely needed it

The thick crust Jethro pizza is fabulous! 2 people and took half of a 12 inch home. It was…read moredelicious.

Love the pizza but the price is always going up and down. I never know what I will be charged for…read morethe same pizza I ordered a week ago. Two weeks ago, I ordered the usual12 in pepperoni and double cheese. The menu read $12(plus the $1 card charge) making it $13, same price as the menu stated. Last week the pizza was $13, with the card charge was $14. My checking account was charged $14.56. Not a lot of money but if I was ordering a large amount of food, it could make a difference, plus I still balance a book, so it has to be precise, not just a guestimate. I just like to know what I am paying upfront, not just swipe and charge whatever. With that said, if you are the person that swipes your card and doesn't care, I have to say that they would be my go-to for taste.

GREAT subs & pizza & wings. I come here every time I'm in town. The food is ALWAYS AMAZING and…read morethe employees are very professional and helpful.

I've gone to Fort Ball many times and usually find good options in the buffet. The bathrooms…read morehowever are really gross and it doesn't appear that much gets wiped down, do the employees use a separate bathroom? I hope so, because I don't feel very clean after using them.

We want to thank the manager, waitress and cooks today who prepared the delicious buffet of Italian…read morefood/pizza/salad & exceptional service to our hungry team after playing Heidelberg. Everyone loved the food and appreciated you packing up extras for the 4 hr bus trip back to Indiana! This is a great business with exceptional food and service!!

Best ice cream around and the pickle pizza is a must!! We are happy to drive out of the way for…read morethis!!

The food was bad, service was slow, and it was overpriced. It doesn't look good on the outside.read more

Thank you yelp for leading us here!! We were coming to Tiffin and needed to get something to eat…read moreand aren't familiar with the area. The Swiss & Wesson burger was so good and flavorful!! The perch was cooked perfectly and was delicious as well!! Just a little dive bar with great food!!! If I ever come to Tiffin again I will definitely come back here!

While this is most definitely a dive bar it was amazing. The people were so friendly and the food…read morewas outstanding. We will come back for sure.

Yesterday (Sunday eve) I ordered 3 pizzas for my family. Today I packed up the leftovers and took…read morethe kids out, while handing out cold pizza I found that one, had multiple hairs in it. Not like I found 1 hair, but like each slice had a few, some long and fine like head hair and several short and wirey and pulled out by the root like.... like I don't want to imagine what I fed to my kids. Pic doesn't do it justice so I recorded a video of me pulling one of the hairs out of a cold slice, it is clearly BAKED IN, and tbqh I think the health dept needs to be called in. Absolutely disgusting, will never eat here again. Here is the video: https://youtu.be/vg-umoSChQI?si=q4D7Fj0GcU62ZO6i

I tryed the loaded pizza for the first time and I have to say it was delicious, on time and hot…read more When I am back in the area I will be definitely ordering from Marcos

Apparently there's a pineapple and ham shortage. Skimpflation has officially hit Domino's…read more Update: Ordered after saying I wouldn't do it again. Called to complain about them screwing up my pizza and spoke to the night manager. She was combative and disputed my claim that they messed up my pizza and never offered a refund or to remake the order, simply saying.. ok, have a good night. Is there no corporate training anymore? Unbelievable. Down grading my rating from 2 stars, to 1.

I know their post are old but I agree with sean and Adam. I worked there back when it opened and…read moreeveryone was great to work with, friendly and polite and always quick to lend a hand. And the food quality was great. Last month I went back because they need help bad, I had to quit after 2 weeks. All new employees with some management (not all) that treat there employees like sh*t, they complain when the phone rings with comments like "Oh my God would you stop f**king calling" or "f**king go away already". Management yelling at people for standing around when clearly working but says nothing to others when there leaning on the counters while on their cell phones in public view and the ovens are backed up. And also having music playing loudly during work hours that is not appropriate for business. And 2nd is product, they leave sauce and toppings out all night, They reuse yesterday product from the night before when it should be thrown out. Like the sandwich breads, why would I prep them in the morning and date them E.O.D. (end of day) only to come in next morning and there still using it. And when some of the pizzas are finished they have bubbles like most do but some are so bad that when cut the slices are so bad that it should be remade but they put it the box and serve it saying "if they don't complain then don't worry about it". Plus they touch the food with bare hands AFTER it comes out of the oven. Not to mention there were times when chemicals were left next to product. I would not recommend Tiffin Dominos to anyone as a place to eat or work. Very very disappointed.