all I can say is thank God I live an hour and 15 minutes from Tiffin! I went to college in Tiffin and I lived off of Napoli Pizza. That was 20 years and 70 pounds ago. If I lived in Tiffin, those 70 pounds would be right back because I would stay at Napolis picking up fold overs. I was in town visiting my mom last night and for old times sake, decided to pick up a cheeseburger fold over. It did not disappoint! It was ready very quick. I picked it up, they are so generous with the toppings and the cheese. It still looks and smells exactly the same when you walk in there. There's a convenience to ordering delivery, but picking up yourself just ensure you get a perfectly piping hot meal. One more reason to visit my mom, definitely needed it read more

The thick crust Jethro pizza is fabulous! 2 people and took half of a 12 inch home. It was delicious.

Ok, ok, ok... this is very good pizza. My pepperoni and anchovy was prepared perfectly. More than adequate toppings with a grsat bake. Square cut pie here, but the crust is just-right with great edge. My server, with the magenta hair, was attentive and pleasant. The chef, with the ginger hair, was studious and attentive to their tasks in the kitchen. Large windows give a great view of the activity and goings on in the secret baking enclave... Always nervy in a new pizza joint, and I am dazzled here. As usual, your mileage may vary. read more

Napoli Pizza - Pep and 'chovie excellence! - Pizza Near Me - Tiffin, Ohio

The pizza is good but they have by far the best fold overs in town that you can get, I highly recommend any of them, you won't be disappointed with them. read more

Fast, friendly service. Our first time and it was worth writing about. Started off with cheesy bread sticks. Next, hot ham and cheese fold over and ended with a 14" meat lovers pizza. Left overs for sure. Would recommend Napoli Pizza. Decided not to take pictures because the pictures posted was exactly what it looked like. Thank you!! read more

The food was amazing and the delivery driver was super friendly. We will definitely order from here again.

I love Napoli Pizza. I've loved it since I was a kid fifty years ago. The food is just as good now as it was all those years ago, and prices are still reasonable. If you want same-old same-old pizza, go to Little Caesar's or Domino's. If you want a taste of Tiffin that you can't get anywhere else (and a place where they still throw the dough in the air), you have to try Napoli Pizza. read more

Excellent pizza and foldovers! A great locally owned pizzeria ! They have a smorgasbord on the weekends that is very tastey and fresh. read more

There is something about those square slices that make my heart happy. I had Napoli Pizza last night for the first time in 5 years last night while I was in town visiting my friends and family. The gentleman who took my order on the phone was patient and answered all of my stupid questions and I was greeted in a friendly manner when I picked up my pie. I was a little disappointed in the garlic bread, but this is a Pizza joint and not a garlic bread joint, you know? Can't wait to get Napoli's Pizza again when I'm back in the area! read more

Great staff, the owner is a family man and treats his customers that way. The ham and cheese foldover Is a must try, this is what they are known for in our town since I can remember, food is always fresh inside or delivered they make it right if there is ever an issue. if you come through tiffin try this family pizza place for sure. read more

Never cared for their pizza, but I like a lot of their subs. They have a very thin crust pizza, and I've always preferred thicker crusts. And I don't really like their pizza sauce either. I've met plenty of people who swear this is the best pizza Tiffin has to offer, but I disagree. read more

I've gotten Napoli's only a handful of times since moving here 2 years ago but they are one of the better priced & more friendly places in town. The food is fresh & good portions. read more

"Great little hole in the wall" Stopped in while in Tiffin for a local festival.Sauce was fantastic, hand tossed crust and plenty of toppings. Price right and will return! read more

The foldovers here are famous; and if they're not, they should be. Thick greasy cheese and mayo on the ham and cheese. Delectable.

Excellent pizza from a small town Pizzeria, great prices and friendly service. I suggest the pepperoni and Italian sausage.

Great little local place. Try a fold over

I get Napoli's about once a week! Whoops :) Love the pizza and the staff is very friendly.

I'm from California and this place is super yummy! The best meatballs and pizza sauce I have ever tasted! And they have fold overs which is the best invention ever! I come here everytime I'm visiting! read more

Not a good review. The pizza is great, but the service is horrible. Twice now they've forgotten to put my order in. I almost always pick up, to save time, and have waited over an hour to receive my pizza. It's a shame, because I love the foldovers, but someone needs to learn to run this business. read more

LOVE the foldovers- Taco foldover is my favorite! :) Not a "high class establishment" but then again, how many pizza places are?! The workers are always very friendly. read more

We ordered pizza and my aunt went to pick it up. She asked when it would be ready. The girl at the counter was very polite and said about another twenty minutes. A man from behind the counter yelled out to her that "We have been very busy. You can take it or shove it!". Since then they will not answer the phone when we call. read more

We were headed back from Cedar Point when we decided to stop and find a place to eat in Tiffin. We decided that we would stop at Napoli because it was the closest to our location at the time. When we pulled into the parking lot we noticed a buffet sign on the door. When we walked in, there were only a few people setting. My wife decided to head to the bathroom before we sat down. When she came back, she said the smell on the walk back was one of the worse smells she has ever encountered. We still decided to eat here. We decided to go with the buffet to try a little of everything they have to offer. When we walked to the buffet they only had pasta and salad out. I got a little of the lasagna and rigatoni. The lasagna was just ok. It was 4 layer's with just sauce and the top had cheese and a very little bit to sausage and mushrooms. The rigatoni was mush. Very over cooked. Not good at all. Finally they brough out a pizza and garlic bread. I had the pepperoni and it was just ok. My wife had the pepperoni with mushroom and a piece of garlic bread. She said the pizza was just ok. The garlic bread on the other hand, she took one bite from it and spit it out. It was french bread with a lot of butter and a lot of garlic salt. GROSS! The fold over was brought out next. I dont know how much cheese they used on the top but it was more than needed. I didn't try it but my wife did. She agreed that there was too much cheese and it was "slimy". In her words, "Just not good". This is a place that I will never go back to. read more

Had the buffet. They only put out cheese pizza and cheap pasta. Place was dirty and smelled funny. I saw a guy in kitchen wipe sweat from face and pick his nose then resume preparing food. What more can ask for read more

I used to live in Tiffin,Ohio back in 1996-2001, and was a big fan of Napoli's foldovers. { especially the taco fold over} I since then have relocated to Wisconsin, and we have nothing in comparison to Napoli's in the city I live in. { and I even live in a city of 93,000 people} read more