My family and I eat here regularly. My daughter would tell you they have the best pizza in town. To me, everything I've had on the menu is delicious. We frequently use one of their coupons to get a combo meal of some kind. The antipasto salad is splendid and definitely go with the house dressing. The cheese breadsticks or cinnasticks are tasty. I thoroughly, thoroughly love their subs. The pizza sub is as pleasant to the pallet as nectar for a hummingbird. The pizza though. Oh the pizza. A sweet sauce and they don't skimp on the cheese. Need to feed a crew? Go with the jumbo which is like a sheet cake of pizza because, well, it's pizza and not sheet cake. It does have a little bit of seating but no servers per se. The people tossing your dough are going to bring it to you. And that might be the best part: the family who owns it. The family is faith filled and it shows in all they do. It comes out in their food. It comes out in their service and they treat you like you are valued part of their family. Few places in Upper Sandusky can match the love and customer service this place delivers. read more

Aggressively average. Just leaving a review to combat the unwarranted enthusiasm of others. To be fair: I did not eat the pizza, so maybe that's the attraction. I had a sub. My wife had a fold over. You could do better at home or an upscale cafeteria. My Italian sub was served with mayo on the side and topped with some kind of store bought salad mix. The people are very kind. read more

THE SAUCE IS AMAZING!! This is one of my favorite pizza places. It's carry out only, so don't plan to sit down. We have tried most of the specialty pizzas and all have been good. Our favorite is a veggie junior jumbo with extra sauce and stuffed crust. A great value and really good pizza. The crust is more of a doughy style. read more

I have had the pleasure of eating a few things at aj's their jumbo pizzas are def suitable for a family or a group of friend... what I really want people to know though,is one specific time of getting food from there... I did a pickup order of pizza and I think some cheese bread for my 5 yr old grandboy's birthday with his mom, mommy brie,little brother Dee,meemaw(I'm meemaw lol)and his peepaw... which everyone enjoyed( even some of my coworkers lol..plenty for everyone and very good)!!!! So I went in to get the food and never had been in there before... it was cozy... and really the 5 stars is for the woman who cashed me out and gave me my order!!! It's unfortunate that I didnt even catch her name because she was so welcoming and just a lovely lady read more

We got a Jumbo pepperoni and it was enormous. We should have stopped there, but I'm glad that we didn't! We also got the Buffalo Chicken with stuffed crust and that may be my favorite pizza now. Everything was soooo good. We will definitely go back to A.J.'s when we are in town again! read more

Today was my first time ordering from A.J.'s Heavenly Pizza and I must say it's probably my favorite place now... The pizza is awesome and the delivery was fast.. The driver was great and our pizza was hot and delicious!!!! We will most definitely be ordering from here again.... Thank you very much and please thank your driver for being so polite... :) God Bless read more

After driving from 6+ hours from Chicago we ended up at this tiny restaurant. It's not much of a sit-down place since it only has 3 booths, but that does not lower the quality of the food. The pizza took no longer than 5 minutes to come out once ordered, and it was DELICIOUS. It was not nearly as greasy as other pizza places and the workers are very nice! I now have a place to come eat if I ever pass through Upper Sandusky again. read more

A.J.'s Heavenly Pizza - I was so hungry when I came here I forgot to take a picture of the whole pizza. It was amazing - Pizza Near Me - Upper Sandusky, Ohio

Great place to order dinner from. Everything is always hot and fresh - not a common occurrence today. The staff is always extremely friendly too. While you could order from a "chain ", I'm a huge fan of supporting local businesses, and this one deserves it on several counts: Value Quality Service I suggest giving them a try if you have not had the opportunity! read more

one of the best pizzas I've had since I moved out to Ohio crust was freshly made it had the perfect amount of sauce on it cheese mix was very good there just was nothing wrong with this pizza read more

Very good pizza & excellent customer service! We called on a Friday night and even though they closed at 11:00 and we couldn't get there until 11:00, they still took our order. We ordered thin crust and although it was crispy, it had a good chew and was flavorful. The pizza had just the right amount of sweet pizza sauce. If we are back in Upper Sandusky again, we will definitely be back. read more

We have been loyal customers for over 10 years, and I am so sad to say, I am not so pleased with AJ's in Upper Sandusky anymore. The toppings are so sparse! You can see the bread through the top of your pizza in many places. I have had to add more cheese and pepperoni and other things to our pizza after I have brought it home. I am so hoping to get what I paid for, but this is not the case anymore. I have kept ordering, hoping that it would be different, maybe it was just a one-time thing. But it is constantly low on toppings and cheese. Please bring back the toppings! I want to support your business! read more

Had a meatball sub today for lunch. Loaded with meatballs. Bun was freshly baked. Excellent taste. Delivered with a smile.

Great pizza from a place with friendly owners! Sometime I have ordered my pizza for pickup just so I can go inside and smell the aroma of the cooking pizza. The sauce has the right hint of sweetness and they don't skimp on the cheese. The jumbo is great if you're feeding a crowd. Be sure to ask about any deals or combo specials when you order. read more

Had a pepperoni and sausage pizza with cheese bread. It was fantastic and crispy. The cheese bread had a sweetness to it that made it irresistible. It came out piping hot, which made it difficult to eat because I was in that super hungry stage; the mouth burn was totally worth it! read more

Best pizza in town hands down if you have a choice of what pizza place in upper this is the place to go

My kids and husband order pizza from here all the time! One time I called back after ordering 10 min later to fix an order! And they fixed it without a peep! Customer service is outstanding! All around good place to order from. I will have to warn you though dining area is super small so if you have a big family or party don't plan on eating in..who cares though the pizza is to die for! read more

Best pizza and subs in Upper Sandusky. AJ'S is are go to pizza place. Food is great staff is always friendly Very supportive of upward sports also. read more