My family and I eat here regularly. My daughter would tell you they have the best pizza in town. To…read moreme, everything I've had on the menu is delicious. We frequently use one of their coupons to get a combo meal of some kind. The antipasto salad is splendid and definitely go with the house dressing. The cheese breadsticks or cinnasticks are tasty. I thoroughly, thoroughly love their subs. The pizza sub is as pleasant to the pallet as nectar for a hummingbird. The pizza though. Oh the pizza. A sweet sauce and they don't skimp on the cheese. Need to feed a crew? Go with the jumbo which is like a sheet cake of pizza because, well, it's pizza and not sheet cake. It does have a little bit of seating but no servers per se. The people tossing your dough are going to bring it to you. And that might be the best part: the family who owns it. The family is faith filled and it shows in all they do. It comes out in their food. It comes out in their service and they treat you like you are valued part of their family. Few places in Upper Sandusky can match the love and customer service this place delivers.

Aggressively average. Just leaving a review to combat the unwarranted enthusiasm of others. To be…read morefair: I did not eat the pizza, so maybe that's the attraction. I had a sub. My wife had a fold over. You could do better at home or an upscale cafeteria. My Italian sub was served with mayo on the side and topped with some kind of store bought salad mix. The people are very kind.

Very clean. Lots of variety on buffet. Salad was fresh. Dough was soft and very tasty. Especially…read moreappreciate evening hours for buffet on Thursday & Saturday.

I'll take a pass on this place!…read more I'm not a huge fan of chain pizza restaurants anyway, and this place reinforces that sentiment. The pizza on the buffet is dry and looks like it's out of a box. It has a cardboard taste to it. It can be compared to CiCi's buffet- a good place to take kids if you're strapped, but the pizza is nothing to rave about. This location is clean, and has plenty of space. There is no service, becaus eyou help yourself. There are much better options for pizza in U.S., so maybe you should try those?

Would love to see you guys offer delivery or offer your menu on Door Dash. I'm disabled and unable…read moreto do takeout. That said we did try the BBQ a few months ago and it was delicious.

Good food. Definitely worth a stop in. I've never had any problems from here! The nachos are always…read moreexcellent.

Very good pizza, as well as the Stromboli, waitress was exceptionally nice ! Try it, you will like…read moreit !

Never miss opportunity to go here when in town. Such great homemade Itialian…read more Here are a few of our favorites

Found a hair cooked into my pizza. Happened to my friend a…read morefew days ago too. Same colour hair.

Had not visited a dominos for a while, and had a coupon. Therefore, decided to give this location…read morea try. Ordered online and specified the time I would be picking it up. Surprisingly, they had everything ready and the quality of food was fresh and hot. While not a regular to dominos, I would certainly try them again in the future. I felt the quality of ingredients was high and the product was made as ordered.

Driving back from MI, heading home to NC. We HAD to stop in and grab a pizza from Casey's! We…read morestopped at the one, most on our route. DO NOT let the 1 STAR review fool you!! Highly recommended!! 1) Super Clean Bathrooms 2) Clean and clear aisles 3) Friendly staff 4) Amazing pizza like always 5) We hope to get Casey's in NC soon, we've reached out to corporate. CORPORATE!!! If you are reading this; we want to shot out to Tara!!! Awesome attitude, friendly, caring, made me feel welcomed, great with people, good multi tasker, y'all are lucky to have her employed with your business.

All their E85 nozzles are broken and have been for a week. They have not fixed any of them in over…read morea month. They overcharge for everything so they could easily afford to fix them if they were not greedy. Their prices are higher than anyone else in town for gas. Their inside prices for food and beverage are close to 50% higher than any other gas station. even their ice is a dollar more per bag than all other gas stations. They are greedy and don't keep up on their proper maintenance. In due time their gas station will quickly degrade because of their lack of maintenance and customer service.

Charging more than what they advertise selling prices for potato chips from Ballreich to 2.49oz bag…read morecharger to 2.99 lie and say their was price went up will remove sale sign the come back next two day sales prices still up. this places went downhill since they lost previous manager Joey never will recommend it again. Customers need to start watching what they are charge.

From the owner: We are a Gas Station/Convenience Store. Diesel, Gas, Kerosene, Cigarettes, Beer cave, pre-boxed…read moreand ready Pizza by the slice, Hot and Cold Subs and specialty sandwiches ready to Grab n' Go!, Customize your food at the free Condiment Table, Lottery, ATM, Ice, & more! We get compliments all the time on our nice, CLEAN Restrooms!

Worst service I have ever received at any restaurant. I get it. It's not fine dining, but why act…read moreso irritated when customers come unto your store during normal hours? I went in at about 20 minutes until 3 p.m. on Monday so I could get some drinks and a snack for my children so we could watch the eclipse. I was greeted by a very annoyed, very pushy worker who was outside in the parking lot. She barked at me that she was closing the store soon for an hour to watch the eclipse, too. So, I went in and was talking with another woman behind the counter while the parking lot woman came in to yell at me that I was not to bother the other woman.... Okay. Finally, acting very frustrated, she took my drink and my couple cookies and churro order acting like she couldn't get rid of me fast enough. Then she yelled from the counter that I couldn't park in her parking lot. That I had just the time I needed to eat the junk food and then leave. I am so sorry to have so badly annoyed this worker who was under such stress for standing in an empty store in the middle of the afternoon. It was my fault for coming in when I saw the store was open. Not to worry, I will never bother this restaurant again and see that anyone and everyone I see will avoid, at all cost, this store as well. We just can't expect the employees to do their job under stuch ridiculous conditions as being open in an empty store on a beautiful Monday afternoon. This particular employee gives customer service a black eye. What a pathetic waste of money.

The local Subway on Wyandot always goes above and beyond…read more Keeping it fresh is key fir any subway! Thank you to the staff and the sandwich artists!! Becky Blocksom!!