Long time customer at both the BG and Findlay locations. Always love the stuffed breadsticks (chicken and cheese). Both locations have always gave the same great product and service. read more

I Haven't ever had a problem with anything excellent food service and servers and location is great

Tonight after our daughter's dance recital we celebrated at Campus Pollyeyes. The staff, food, and atmosphere was perfect for after the recital. I know others are also looking for a great place to go after recitals and Campus Pollyeyes was perfect! Thank you Campus Pollyeyes for going above and beyond. We will definitely be back! P.s. Easy parking, no steps, wheelchair accessible read more

Took a day trip too Carey Ohio and I the way back home we decided to stop for a bite. A quick search on yelp took to this hidden gem! Upon arrival we were immediately seated and helped. Our waitress (I wish I could remember her name) was wonderful! She recommended the special, large pizza with upto 3 toppings and 6 stuffed breadsticks with upto 3 toppings for only $25. She kept us posted on eta as they do take a little time to make. They're also known for their stuffed breadsticks. She let us split toppings on the pizza and recommended the chicken for the sticks... great recommendation! They were even delicious reheated the next day! We shared Smalltalk with our waitress who quickly became our friend while dining. Upon cashing out, she offered to split the bill and when we said 1 was fine she broke up what the split would be too pay it. Very nice. Needless to say, she more than earned her very generous tip. I will definitely come here again and probably every time I visit Carey Ohio for that matter. read more

Campus Pollyeyes - two pizzas stacked on plates - Pizza Near Me - Findlay, Ohio

THE CHICKEN BREADSTICKS, DEAR LORD! They are absolutely delicious. Don't sleep on the ranch, either! It's home- made, and is thick and extra creamy. The chicken breasticks are the perfect amount of dough and meat, and came piping hot, even as a take-out order. Also, don't forget that an order of sticks will feed nearly 3 people. They're absolutely monstrous! The staff was totally curteous, even though they had just opened the week before and were slammed. The company has a good-standing name in the BG area, so it made sense for them to spread their sphere of influence. Findlay should be a good market for them. There are a lot of pizza restaurants around here, but none of them stand out like Polleyeye's. It's a new twist on something old, and that's what makes it delicious! I highly reccommend this establishment. I've yet to dine in, and have not tried their pizza, so that's even more reason for me to return. read more

Their stuffed breadsticks are phenomenal! We usually get the pizza & stuffed breadsticks special. This is one of the most popular BGSU pizza joints, especially after Miles Pizza closed. read more

I know people rave about this place but I don't get it. We arrived at 5:30 on a Friday night and were seated promptly which we took as a good sign. Our waitress was right on getting our drinks but seemed annoyed that we had questions about the menu. We finally decided on the chicken breadsticks and a medium house special but wanted to swap the green peppers for banana peppers. An equal trade, right? Our waitress told us there were no substitutions which I thought was ridiculous because we weren't adding any toppings. I will admit: our waitress did go above by offering to bring a side of banana peppers which was appreciated. We then sat and waited...and waited...and waited. In fact it took over an hour for our food to arrive. I could see that if they were swamped but the dining room wasn't that busy although our waitress said the kitchen was backed up. When our food finally arrived it was breadsticks first which came out lukewarm as best. Seriously? We wait an hour for lukewarm breadsticks? The breadsticks were pretty good but not exceptional to me. Maybe that's because they weren't hot, I don't know. The pizza, however, although hot was pretty pitiful. The crust wasn't good, the sauce was marginal, and I think I counted two pieces of sausage on my slice. Nearly an hour and a half after arriving we were finally walking out with no intentions of returning anytime soon. read more

Have tried the one at BGSU and loved it. Today, decided to try this one in Findlay. Called in an order at 2:15PM and was told it would be ready in 30 minutes. Arrived at 2:45 only to be told it would be another 25 minutes because they hadn't started the order yet. "We've got a lot of food to make" we were told, so we left without our meal. It was a disappointment, especially after loving the one at BGSU in the past. read more

Yelp took away my five heart emojis...what else do you need in a review? Get the $25 deal - one large three topping pizza and 6 stuffed breadsticks with two toppings. If you don't get garlic butter then you didn't go to Campus Pollyeyes. #justsayin read more

The price on the large pizza and large order of stuffed breadsticks has increased to $30, but it's still a fantastic deal. Only mentioning it because other reviews mention $25. Our regular is the ranch pizza with extra cheese, tomatoes, and onions. Stuffed breadsticks with hot peppers and tomatoes. Come with a big family or a big appetite if you're planning to finish in one sitting. Plenty of food to have multiple meals for our family. On top of that the freshest ingredients out of any pizza place in town in my experience. Findlay has a lot of pizza places and Pollyeyes separates itself from the pack. read more

Pizza with plenty of toppings and great taste. Both the tomato sauce or garlic ranch sauce are good options. I haven't tried the breadsticks, yet, but they have to be as great as the pizza, so, they shouldn't disappoint. College oriented clientele, in my opinion. Still, menu works for everyone. read more

First time checking out Findlay's newest pizza place. We got the $25 deal which included a full order of breadsticks and a large 3 topping pizza. More than enough food for 4 people. Loved the breadsticks but the pizza was okay.. thin flor covered crust with bland pizza sauce. We will come back for the stuffed breadsticks though! Service was fast even during a busy lunch rush. read more

Campus Pollyeyes - two pizzas on plates - Pizza Near Me - Findlay, Ohio

My family had a pizza delivered well over one hour later than quoted. My family could live with that. Not the pizza we received however. It looked baked twice. Burnt and cold like hard cardboard. The delivery driver was very apologetic we tipped him well as this was not his fault. He said the pizza was still warm. We had to throw it away. Manager promised it was a staff issue and would send a coupon for a free pizza. That was over 1 month ago and we are still waiting on a coupon that never arrived. I don't appreciate being lied to. Findlay restaurant has really gone downhill. read more

As good as the BG location. Now we don't have to drive out of town for our Pollyeyes fix! Can't beat the breadsticks and there are some decent deals as well. If you haven't been, it's worth checking out! read more

I've eaten here 4 or 5 times since it opened. Outstanding food! The breadsticks are a must order. They are unlike anyone's and delicious. From the last two visits we ordered pizza. First thin then screen crust. Without a doubt the best pizza in Findlay! read more

Campus Pollyeyes - a man and a woman at a bar - Pizza Near Me - Findlay, Ohio

I heard a lot of great things about this place. I ordered two large three topping pizzas and bread stix and a few other items. I'm sorry to say my family and I were very disappointed. The food was terrible The service was great but the food was not good. read more

Food is good. Takes a long time from entering to eating. Least amount of time I've waited is an hour. Ordered breadsticks and pizza and they came out together. I'd rather have the breadsticks first. It's kinda the appetizer. Food good. Waits long. read more

This is probably my least favorite pizza place in Findlay. It is super expensive and not really all it is cracked up to be that's just based on personal opinion I do not see what all of the hype is. I hear the bowling green one is great but I don't see how. read more

Our food was burnt, was not happy about the customer service. The servers had a disagreement about who was gonna serve us. Just overall not pleased. I recommend one of the many other great pizza places in Findlay. I hear Dougie John's is really good. read more