Good pizza - cheese and pepperoni are solid choices. Great chicken wings. Wish it was open more…read moredays.

Figured I would start with the lowest on the OBX totem pole. The pizza was average at best…read more Thankfully I have other pizza places in the area to recommend, bc this ain't it. The pizza felt low quality. High bread density, cheap sauce, and overall bland. If you live there and never venture out to any pizza beyond this block I understand the reviews. Otherwise, come on people?! Mediocre! Do not recommend. Venture out to Nags Head for far better options.

Pretty solid spot. Tried a sausage and pepperoni pizza. I'd get it again for sure. Check it out!read more

Great place to order pizza to bring back to your hotel. The order was ready right on time and the…read morequality was quite good. Was it NY style? No, based on this Brooklyn native's experience. But the crust was well done while still having sufficient flop. The sauce was savory and there were plenty of toppings.

Pizza was great. Dont forget to order the cheese bread its the best. Fast and friendly service!!!read more

Don't go anywhere else for your pizza in the area. Seriously, you want pizza, you're in Nags Head,…read moreyou have to order from only here. It is delicious. We ordered well ahead of time online, that way it would be ready for pick up as we passed by. After ordering, you will get an estimated time of when it will be ready. We were given a time and then made a stop before coming here. However, they are quicker than the estimated time. Which is a great thing, less waiting when you pull up, but not good if you get stuck elsewhere beforehand. Pulled in, right up to the window, let them know I had an order. Within seconds, my order was in my hands. The hardest part about this was the enticing smell in your vehicle back to your house. Totally takes over and your stomach starts grumbling. When we got back, we immediately opened up those boxes so the aroma filtered through the house. Each pizza was amazing. The garlic bread was amazing. The right amount of garlic that doesn't overpower. Then the pizza itself blows you away. Perfect crust, perfect amount of sauce, perfect amount of toppings. Made you go back for a slice over and over again. Then it doesn't hurt that there are personal touches to each box with a message. Each box has a message when you open. A nice touch from such an amazing place to grab a slice.

Great shrimp tacos, drinks are a bit sweet but the service is quick and helpful. The food is…read moreamazing. Fishing right off the pier is super cheap. Great vibes all around

The pizza was awesome and the owners were great. Incredible crust and fresh toppings. Could have…read moreused more cheese on the pizza. Cheese sticks were large and yummy! Very generous portions as well. Ambiance inside 5, outside 8. I would love to give them a 5 star review but I can't due to their pricing. 1 appetizer, 1 salad and 2 small pizzas, 3 sodas plus tip - $85. Pure insanity.

The best pizza I have ever had!…read more We ordered the Dare Devil Pizza, and it was absolutely incredible. The flavors were amazing, the pizza was cooked perfectly, and every bite was delicious. I've had a lot of pizza over the years, but this honestly was the best pizza I've ever had. If you're visiting Kill Devil Hills or anywhere in the Outer Banks, I highly recommend giving Dare Devil Pizzeria a try. We will definitely be back!

We we're in the Outer Banks and we have a regular pizza place that we like, but it was closed when…read morewe tried to order so I looked up other places that were nearby online and found this place. We ordered a basic regular cheese pizza to take back to the rental and watch a movie. My impression and my children's impression once we took one bite of this pizza was oh yuck. Since we didn't really have another option at that point other than chains, we ended up ordering in from Papa Johns instead. Not a great experience for us and we probably won't be back.

This was our highest bill of the week. We started with the…read morecrab dip and pretzel bites. The dip was good, I just wish the pretzel slices were softer or less toasted. My Bf really enjoyed his scallop dish! I thought the beef on the Mac and cheese was pretty good but the Mac and cheese itself tasty almost too floury? Not sure if that's even how they make it but the taste was just a little off. On other positive note though, My BF also got the crème brûlée and that was also pretty good. Lastly my strawberry margarita tasted good but I believe was $15!? And that's a little steep for me compared to back home. But we also didn't order drinks anywhere else in OBX so I'm not sure if that's the going rate. Plus, our waitress was pleasant and friendly.

Stopped in tonight for our last dinner before heading home on Saturday. Walked in and found there…read morewas no air conditioning and it was very humid inside...first problem. We decided to stay because the food has always been good. Once we got our meals, the flies started to show up...second problem. Food was good but come on, no air conditioning when it's 90 plus degrees outside. Oh, the flies. There were a lot of them. Hopefully this was an isolated issue with the AC and the flies.

Amazing food! Great service! Great atmosphere, island vibes. Definitely recommend the captains…read morecombo. will definitely return in the future!

Our first time here and we will definitely be back…read more Service was great. Food was AMAZING. I highly recommend the Krabby Patty. Atmosphere was great as well. We will be back!!

We had the pleasure of eating here for lunch today 8-23-26! the kids each had a slice of pizza…read more(very well portioned), I Had the Mahi Po-Boy and it was FANTASTIC!!! the sweet thai mayo was the best i have ever had, and the fried mahi was seasoned to perfection! My husband had the fried Mahi basket and He enjoyed it as well! 12/10 recommend eating here! We will be back

From Las Vegas, out here on vacation and man this place is definitely a go to!…read more I ordered the shrimp po boy sandwich and my lady got an order of chicken wings, let me just say the food didn't last 10 minutes IT WAS SOO GOOD! The sauce on the shrimp sandwich really brings it all together and the wings were perfectly cooked! I highly recommend American Pie!

Bartender was super friendly. I didn't get her name blonde curly hair. We went for a drink just to…read moreget out of the house. The drink was soooo delicious and refreshing. I wanted 5 more but then I wouldn't be able to adult if I did loved the place but definitely loud. If you're one of those folks that don't like loud places this isn't for you. If you don't mind it then stop in. We will be back to try the food next time

Crabby patties were undercooked, chicken sandwich was tough as a boot, Cilantro lime / Spicy Line…read moreSoyr cream was water, literally. Good drinks though -

We discovered Vinny's last year on our annual vacation and everyone agreed it was the best pizza we…read morehave had in the Outer Banks. Got it this year and it did not disaapoint.

My husband and I ordered pizza from here twice on a recent trip to Kitty Hawk. Highly recommend!…read moreDelicious pizza!