Lighthouse Restaurant

3.8 (687 reviews)

PriceySeafood, American, Bars

Closed • 4:00 pm - 10:00 PM

Updated 2 months ago

Add Review

Call

Directions

Website

Lighthouse Restaurant Photos

Lighthouse Restaurant - Brussels Sprouts - Seafood Near Me - Cedar Lake, Indiana

Lighthouse Restaurant - Seafood Near Me - Cedar Lake, Indiana

Lighthouse Restaurant - a chocolate cupcake with a candle on top - Seafood Near Me - Cedar Lake, Indiana

+431

Lighthouse Restaurant - Outdoor dining - Seafood Near Me - Cedar Lake, Indiana

Lighthouse Restaurant Popular Dishes

Lobster

10 Photos64 Reviews

$6.50

Lobster Bisque

5 Photos39 Reviews

$20.00

Crab Cake

10 Photos46 Reviews

Lighthouse Restaurant menu photos

Menu photo 1 Lighthouse Restaurant Cedar Lake, IN

Menu photo 2 Lighthouse Restaurant Cedar Lake, IN

Menu photo 3 Lighthouse Restaurant Cedar Lake, IN

Menu photo 4 Lighthouse Restaurant Cedar Lake, IN

Menu photo 5 Lighthouse Restaurant Cedar Lake, IN

Menu photo 6 Lighthouse Restaurant Cedar Lake, IN

See all

LIGHTHOUSE RESTAURANT ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?

Inside

40 Photos

Outside

103 Photos

Moderate noise

Dogs allowed

Outdoor seating

Happy hour specials

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Lighthouse Restaurant

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.

Start your review...

Browse more easily on the app

Reviews With Photos

Meg S.

We had a great experience here! Our server was fantastic, the food was delicious, and we felt most of our needs were adhered to. The restaurant sits right by the lake, and it's absolutely beautiful. We had a great view, and enjoyed ourselves throughout the night. My only caveat is that there were a few things we felt were a little underseasoned, but that didn't take away from the experience at all. Would definitely come back for special occasions

Abigail Q.

The wedge salad is heavenly. The pasta is mid. The seafood is disappointing. Service is attentive.

Jason L.

Came back to the Lighthouse for dinner and ordered the Brussels mac & cheese and the Wagyu burger. The Brussels and mac & cheese were excellent -- rich, flavorful, and definitely worth it. Unfortunately, the burger was mediocre at best. It didn't come close to competing with Bugaboos down the road, which also serves Wagyu burgers but executes them far better. Really disappointing considering the expectation. That said, the view is still fantastic and remains the highlight of the experience.

Gisele G.

Always excellent food, delicious Margaritas and a perfect sunset. Always love the time we spend at the lighthouse restaurant'

Strawberry torte dessert special (after we ate half:)

Everything was perfect, starting with our favorite server, Kelli! The crab cake appetizer was amazing. Hubby's steak could be cut with a fork and my shrimp special was delicious; however, my favorite part was the wedge salad. The hubby loved his lobster bisque too. We split the dessert special, a strawberry mascarpone torte. It was so huge we couldn't finish it. It could have fed 3-4 people. The hour drive from Illinois over rolling hills and past beautiful fields makes a fantastic experience!

Blake B.

I have now had the pleasure of Dino g here several times and I can say with confidence that this is such an amazing find in NWI. The views, the menu options and the fine dining feel without that fine dining process tag is amazing. Each time my service has been fantastic with helpful and pleasant servers and the drinks are always done well, I can never have just one! Making a reservation is simple and parking is plenty. My favorite menu item remains the crab cakes but I've also had the fish tacos.

J R.

The special today was a great sunset view and grilled bone-in pork chops with baked apples, absolutely delicious! Tiffany was attentive and fantastic!

See all

Nick L.

1 year ago

We LOVE this place soooo soooo much! It's our spot! Not often do you get a beautiful view, great food, and the best customer service! We request Kelli as our server every single time. She is wonderful and makes you feel like you've known her for life! Also, the best crab cakes we've had! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Vicki L.

7 months ago

Food was awful. Quality significantly decreased! Service poor! They need better cleaning staff! Best to eat somewhere else!

Business owner information

Christopher P.

Hello Vicki,…

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 1

Jeff B.

1 year ago

Morgan was our server. What a great addition to the staff. Very tentative, great serve , great food. I highly recommend Morgan as a server. I'd use her as a role model for training. Thank you Lighthouse for a great experience. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Elizabeth S.

Elite 26

237

421

4 years ago

Amazing views, The service was wonderful, quick and very attentive. It was a packed house and our server was still very attentive to our table. The ambience was wonderful. The only con I would say would be my daughter's grilled chicken was a little rubbery. It's also not something that's typically on their menu and they just did it for her because she's a pretty picky eater. It still would not make me not eat there again and I actually look forward to a night with just my husband and I. My husband and son had steak and they both were wonderful dishes I had the walleye and it was amazing, my other daughter had the fried chicken sandwich and it was really good, the calamari was wonderful and we also had the chocolate cake and the chocolate chip skillet for dessert and it was great. read more

Lighthouse Restaurant - Grilled chicken sandwich - Seafood Near Me - Cedar Lake, Indiana

Lighthouse Restaurant - Steak Diane - Seafood Near Me - Cedar Lake, Indiana

Lighthouse Restaurant - Macadamia Crusted Walleye - Seafood Near Me - Cedar Lake, Indiana

Lighthouse Restaurant - Sirloin - Seafood Near Me - Cedar Lake, Indiana

Lighthouse Restaurant - Mac & cheese - Seafood Near Me - Cedar Lake, Indiana

Lighthouse Restaurant - A scoop of chocolate ice cream - Seafood Near Me - Cedar Lake, Indiana

Lighthouse Restaurant - Warm Chocolate Chip Cookie Sundae - Seafood Near Me - Cedar Lake, Indiana

Lighthouse Restaurant - Lighthouse Chocolate Cake - Seafood Near Me - Cedar Lake, Indiana

See all

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Christopher W.

1 year ago

We had a birthday dinner here with our son. The atmosphere with lakefront view and nautical decor was nice. Steaks on par with high-end restaurants and the service was great! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Erika E.

278

1 year ago

My mom and I love going to lighthouse! The food is always top tier and we love the vibe of restaurant- it's right on the water and you can sit inside or outside. The service is incredible-- ask for Kelli! She goes above and beyond for her guests. We can't to return! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Louanne C.

1 year ago

Kelli was one of the best waitresses we have ever had. She was bubbly, and funny and had a smile on her face the whole time she Was doing her job. Very helpful with our food choices also. Definitely waitress of the year Award !!! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Roxann P.

1 year ago

Food quality was great but the service was outstanding, started at the bar with Nikki who made us feel welcome and then during dinner with Kelli our server making every effort to make the perfect meal! read more

Lighthouse Restaurant - Dandy and me - Seafood Near Me - Cedar Lake, Indiana

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Carolyn K.

1 year ago

Enjoyed a wonderful lunch with family for an anniversary celebration! Food was delicious and Kelli is fantastic!

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Trisha S.

1 year ago

The food was amazing and our server, Kelli, was outstanding as usual. I highly suggest if you are in Cedar Lake, Indiana you make reservations at the Lighthouse and ask for Kelli. read more

Lighthouse Restaurant - Delicious! - Seafood Near Me - Cedar Lake, Indiana

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Genesis M.

Elite 26

310

329

1104

5 years ago

First I want to say it was such a nice surprise to come here and immediately be reminded of a seafood restaurant I've been to in San Diego CA. You walk in and you are able to see the lake in the background which is enormous. I came here for my mother in laws birthday dinner and Ryan did an amazing job taking care of us. The place was packed so I'm glad we had a reservation 2 weeks in advanced. A must try are the crab cakes! I am a lover of crab cakes and these did not disappoint! They have the right amount of spice as well. I had one of their specials that included 2 small fillets. Asparagus in a mushroom save with cheesy scalloped potatoes. Wow was that delicious! It did take some time to get the food and drinks because they are understaffed which makes sense. Despite the wait everything was delicious and can't wait to come here again and see how it is in the summer. read more

See all

Helpful 4

Thanks 0

Love this 2

Oh no 1

Wallace J.

10 months ago

Went here for a late lunch/early dinner and was so pleased. First time here and from the moment we walked in everything was great. Our server, Kelli was excellent and the other staff were equally great. Food is very tasty and the portions are ample. All in all, I would recommend the Lighthouse to anyone looking for an exceptional dining experience. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

J Y.

10 months ago

Kelli made our first trip here amazing. Her and her college she sons work here. She takes do much pride in the food and the place. She gave us recommendations that were soooo good. Lobster Bisque. Crab dip. She brought us ice cream for our anniversary and kept our drinks full. We will be back. Great food, great staff and beautiful view of lake. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 1

Penelope C.

1 year ago

In order to write this review, I am forced to give it one (1) star. We were at Lighthouse Restaurant on 4/18, to celebrate a birthday. Our server, Annette, was great. We sat in the back with the view of the lake. The food was not. It must have been an off day for the kitchen? How? Our reservation was at 5:00. The restaurant opened at 4:00. We started with a couple of appetizers. Calamari - over fried and bland. My niece's filet was ordered medium. It arrived well done. My nephew had French onion soup ... bowl was hot, the contents inside, was not. He ordered his steak medium rare, requested sides to be seared. It was not seared. It didn't look appetizing. I ordered the Frutti di Mare, asked for garlic and easy olive oil instead of red sauce. It was very bland and there was so much olive oil, I wish I had paper towels to drain it. This was such a disappointing visit. We should've kept our reservations at another restaurant. We come here a 4+ times a year. We won't be coming back for a long time. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 1

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Rick C.

Elite 26

222

2 years ago

Excellent service, food was great and the view outside by the lake watching the sun set was perfect. This place is definitely worth a visit. Reservations recommended though. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 1

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Eric J.

1 year ago

Taylor was fantastic!! She made our dinner extremely enjoyable and had great recommendations on food. Customer service is so important in the restaurant industry and Taylor definitely excels at her trade. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Daniel W.

455

3 years ago

Great experience! Gluten free options and amazing views of the lake! We had Ribeye and Sea Bass. Both were awesome! read more

Lighthouse Restaurant - Deserts - Seafood Near Me - Cedar Lake, Indiana

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 1

Oh no 0

Robyn W.

Elite 25

356

429

538

3 years ago

Food is perfect. Ambiance perfect. A great spot for a night out... Even better in the great summer weather. I had the encrusted fish dish which was super delicious. We sat beforehand and listened to music by the water. Cocktails were super good too...I had the sage blueberry old fashioned. Very good There was a bit of a hiccup with our reservations and seating and it took a while. We were pretty hungry but got to enjoy the nice view and music. If you're wondering about your place on the waitlist, I recommend checking because it seemed they thought we were seated and asking got things sorted. We would have enjoyed the beautiful patio better had we gotten cocktail service like others were getting. The menu and host stand is apparently different on the patio vs. indoors even though you make reservations in the same way. Overall an enjoyable night with a few kinks. Could be a 5 if they got those things worked out! Will definitely give it another try! read more

Lighthouse Restaurant - Great views from the outdoor patio - Seafood Near Me - Cedar Lake, Indiana

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Teresa P.

2 years ago

Best Key Lime Pie martini! Morgan's recipe has 8 ingredients! The best!!! Great sunsets! Great music on Wednesdays!! read more

Lighthouse Restaurant - Morgan's Key Lime Pie martini! - Seafood Near Me - Cedar Lake, Indiana

Helpful 1

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Laurie H.

1 year ago

Had a lovely dining experience tonight.Friendly staff,beautiful atmosphere overlooking the lake and food was delicloud.Our waitress Kelli was so attentive and personable it felt like we were old friends!I highly recommend this dining experience,you won't be disappointed. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Erin B.

1 year ago

What a wonderful location!! We had a lake view and our server Kelli was 5 star! We had the 12 oz filet and Lighthouse Oscar. Cooked perfectly and don't skip the wedge salad!! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Tricia H.

2 years ago

The atmosphere and wait staff were excellent. Something wrong in the kitchen though when 2 entrees arrive 15 minutes before the other two. Not good. Food was good but not knock-your-socks off. My salad and soup were meager for the price. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 1

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Alex B.

203

1 year ago

I eat at the Lighthouse often and this was my first bad experience. The lobster bisque was very watery and broken. I also unfortunately had to send my salmon back because it was raw. I do think this is a rare case because my experience is normally great. Just unfortunate for the amount of money spent. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

George J.

1 year ago

Fantastic meal, ambience and a wonderful server in Kelli, who made the evening all that more memorable!

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

John M.

11 months ago

Food was amazing but it took us 45 minutes to be seated and we had reservations so I'd say be patient it's worth the wait

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Amanda S.

11 months ago

We came here for my birthday and we were definitely not disappointed. Our server, Karen, was the absolute best there is! She went over and above to make sure that the experience was top notch and I couldn't be more grateful! The food was delicious and the live music was fantastic and I appreciated the birthday tribute. All in all, it was a super special occasion and I would highly recommend The Lighthouse! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Joan G.

1 year ago

Excellent cocktails with a marvelous view of the lake. Wall-eye was exceptional. But the best was our server, Kelli. She was fabulous

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Isabella G.

2 years ago

Karen, whom I affectionately call Renee Zellweger, is one of the best waitresses at the Lighthouse Restaurant. Her friendly asmile make every dining experience exceptional. Karen's recommendations are always spot-on, and her warm, personable nature makes us feel like valued friends. Dining at the Lighthouse is always a treat, especially when Karen is our server. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Aleta B.

1 year ago

Went to The Lighthouse last night with our best friends. The food was delicious as always. We had the perch and shrimp this time. Our server John (Jonathan) was exceptional. He was attentive, personable and helped get us moved to a bigger table as my husband is in a large power wheelchair and the table we had was too small. Remember, this was a crowded Sunday evening and he handled the transfer with ease. I highly recommend The Lighthouse and John! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Margaret S.

1 year ago

Always Amazing! Olivia was a wonderful server. Thanks so much! Will be back for sure :).

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Austin B.

1 year ago

Great service from Jonathan. Nice ice cream surprise for our anniversary. Great views and live music.

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Tom A.

1 year ago

Ambiance is great both indoors and outside on the patio. Food is always excellent. And service is outstanding, especially Julia, our most recent server. Highly recommend. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Loretta F.

1 year ago

Everything was great! I truly enjoyed absolutely everything I want to thank Megan tonight for her excellent service. And Kelli for exceptional service on my birthday dinner night! ! These 2 ladies epitomize what real attentive service is all about!! I'll always come back . read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Cindy W.

1 year ago

The food was great! The view of the lake was beautiful with dinner. Olivia ( Olive Oil ) made wonderful suggestions and she was very knowledgeable about the food. She was a very courteous server and we will return. We are Cedar Lake residents and have been here a few times prior and this was the best experience yet. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Mike B.

1 year ago

Dined last night, Kelli was our server and she was great. We will definitely be back again soon .

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Aynslee P.

1 year ago

Kelli is absolutely amazing. I would recommend her 100%. My boyfriend and I went here for the first time for our anniversary and she made our experience incredible. not to mention the food is amazing as well. thank you so much Kelli! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Tina S.

1 year ago

My son and I went for dinner on a busy Thursday evening. Our waitress, Kelli, was fantastic and everything we ordered tasted delicious. She really went above and beyond to make sure we had a pleasant dining experience. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Joe S.

1 year ago

Came here for dinner to celebrate a birthday and it was truly amazing. Food was great and Bella did a great job! We'll definitely be back very soon! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

tricia m.

1 year ago

My husband and I celebrated our 34th anniversary last evening and Lighthouse provided a unique peaceful dining experience overlooking the lake. Michelle, our server, was fantastic! Providing us with continual beverage refills without asking or interference. The food was delicious: from the warm bread and butter to the crab dip appetizer, to the carefully crafted fresh salads to the entrees of fall off the bone ribs and crab cakes with corn salsa, they were all delicious! The ambiance was really nice and wait staff were quick to clear emptied dishes. Only one minor flaw was a multitude of flies throughout, but that is not the fault of the servers or cooks! We will be back! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Joe D.

2 years ago

My Wife needed a night out and I chose The Lighthouse. We started with a few drinks in the bar where the drinks were well made and hit the spot. when we got seated we went back n forth on entree ideas and decided to get the Macadamia crusted Walleye and the Steak Diane and share. I asked our terrific server ( Brooke) if the fish could be cut in half and she replied no problem. The small Caesar Salad wis tasty as was the Lobster Bisque that we get cravings for. When the mains arrived they had split the fish and Sweet Potato and plated separately which made our sharing easier ( the steak came in two filets). The fish was fantastic, light,delicate and very good with the coating. The steak was amazing, it truly was melt in your mouth quality and very delicious. We finished off with a few Chocolate Martinis which were a perfect dessert. Our Server Brooke was very attentive, offered great info about the menu and made our night truly special. We'll be back! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Back

Page 2 of 18

7501 Constitution Ave
Cedar Lake, IN 46303
Directions
(219) 374-9283
Call Now
Visit Website
http://cedarlakelighthouse.com/

Full menu

Hours

What time does Lighthouse Restaurant open?

Lighthouse Restaurant opens at 4:00 PM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday and Friday.Lighthouse Restaurant opens at 12:00 PM on Saturday and Sunday.

What time does Lighthouse Restaurant close?

Lighthouse Restaurant closes at 9:00 PM on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday and Thursday.Lighthouse Restaurant closes at 10:00 PM on Friday and Saturday.Lighthouse Restaurant closes at 8:00 PM on Sunday.

Mon-Thu 4:00 PM - 9:00 PMFri 4:00 PM - 10:00 PMSat 12:00 PM - 10:00 PMSun 12:00 PM - 8:00 PM

Payment methods

Does Lighthouse Restaurant take credit cards?

Yes, Lighthouse Restaurant takes credit cards.

Food & Alcohol

Does Lighthouse Restaurant have catering options?

Yes, Lighthouse Restaurant does have catering options.

Does Lighthouse Restaurant have a drive thru?

No, Lighthouse Restaurant does not have a drive thru.

Does Lighthouse Restaurant have a happy hour?

Yes, Lighthouse Restaurant has a happy hour.

Does Lighthouse Restaurant serve alcohol?

Yes, Lighthouse Restaurant serves alcohol. Full Bar

Indoor Amenities

Does Lighthouse Restaurant allow dogs?

Yes, Lighthouse Restaurant allows dogs.

Does Lighthouse Restaurant have TVs?

Yes, Lighthouse Restaurant has TVs.

Outdoor Amenities

Does Lighthouse Restaurant have bike parking?

No, Lighthouse Restaurant does not have bike parking.

Does Lighthouse Restaurant have outdoor seating?

Yes, Lighthouse Restaurant has outdoor seating options.

Does Lighthouse Restaurant have parking?

Yes, Lighthouse Restaurant has parking options. Private Lot Parking

Other Amenities

Is Lighthouse Restaurant wheelchair accessible?

Yes, Lighthouse Restaurant is wheelchair accessible.

Does Lighthouse Restaurant allow outdoor smoking?

No, Lighthouse Restaurant does not allow outdoor smoking.

Does Lighthouse Restaurant have free WiFi?

Yes, Lighthouse Restaurant has free WiFi.

From the Business

Specialties

Lighthouse Restaurant in Cedar Lake, IN offers an exceptional fine dining experience specializing in premium steaks and fresh seafood with stunning waterfront views. With 15 years of culinary excellence, we serve prime rib, filet mignon, fresh catch of the day, and lobster tail in an elegant atmosphere. Our luxury hospitality services include personalized event planning, custom catering solutions, and exclusive venue services for weddings and corporate events. Enjoy private dining experiences, signature cocktails, and our renowned Wine Wednesdays. We accept all major credit cards and offer dine-in, takeout, and reservations.

Ask the Community - Lighthouse Restaurant

Is The Lighthouse still serving Brunch on Sundays?

No. Lighthouse now opens at 11am on Sundays and features a couple of lunch menu items that are not on the regular dinner menu.

View question details

Does anyone know who the GM of the business is?

Shane Keeton.

View question details

Has anyone ever heard of gratuity being charged on an upgraded chair for an event? I'm actually speaking of a venue that does weddings?

Yes. Second City charges a premium price for "RAIL SEATS" which have an un-obstructed view of the show. Not unusual at all.

View question details

View All 4 Questions

You might also consider

Town Club Tavern

4.7(6 reviews)

0.9 mi

Fun place!! Everyone was very friendly including the owner Candy, bartender Brittany and Josh. My…read morehusband and I had a great time here.

Best Steak Sandwich In Northwest Indiana. Try it You will like Medium Rare!…read moreWill not disappoint.

Photos

Yuengling & Fireball 3$ Combo !?! @ Town Club Tawern . 13111 Lake Shore Dr, Cedar Lake, IN 46303

Main bar

See all

Lake View @ Town Club Tawern . 13111 Lake Shore Dr, Cedar Lake, IN 46303

Hunley's Bar & Grill

4.5(17 reviews)

1.2 mi

•$$

Good food and nice selection of beers, friendly staff, food specials during the week, in cold…read moreweather the homemade soups are tasty and hearty, local bar with a great outdoor deck area when the weather is good

1/2 price on all food is always a great day. I don't drink anymore so I'm all about food nowadays.read more

Photos

Hunley's Bar & Grill . 13115 Lake Shore Dr, Cedar Lake, IN

Inside Hunley's Bar & Grill . 13115 Lake Shore Dr, Cedar Lake, IN Cool !

See all

Yuengling Lager & Fireball @ Hunley's Bar & Grill . 13115 Lake Shore Dr, Cedar Lake, IN Cool !

Reichert's Tavern

5.0(3 reviews)

4.3 mi

Great little tavern. Perfect stop when you're out to get a beer. We love it. I recommend.read more

I've been wanting to stop in this place in the old village of Brunswick for some time. Yelp…read morereports this as closed, but it's open and the hours on this page are accurate. I finally made it here last night. Brunswick is an old German settlement that was founded in the mid 1800's. It's about two miles west of Cedar Lake/US 41, along 133rd/135th Avenue. The tavern sits at the southeast corner of 135th and Calumet Avenue. You can tell that the building is very old, but kept in very nice condition. We arrived around 6:30 PM, came in through the back door and settled up to the old bar. The owners were watching TV at the bar, waiting to serve those who came in. The menu is very simple: a good selection of domestic bottles (Miller, Bud, Coors, etc.) and a few imports (Grolsch, Warsteiner). The owners were very nice and we talked about the history of the tavern and Brunswick. According to the owner, this has been a continually-operated tavern since 1856, when it served as a stop for stagecoach travel. The tavern was very clean and had a lot of neat, old swag including a vintage Old Style light fixture. Beers were reasonably priced. It doesn't appear they serve anything but bottled/canned beer and lemonade, but definitely worth the stop for a cold beer. I'll be back next time I'm in the area!

Photos

Located on the SE corner of 135th and Calumet Avenue, in the village of Brunswick

Inside Reichert's, at the bar

See all

Summer fest 2012

Bugaboo's Bar and Grill

2.8(121 reviews)

1.0 mi

•$

This was my second time coming to this restaurant, and it was definitely an improvement over my…read morefirst visit when I wasn't really impressed by the food. The service has been a bit of a mixed bag both times. While the staff is friendly, the check ins themselves are okay. This time around, the food was much better. I really enjoyed the burger I ordered, and our appetizer was great too. They also have a fantastic outdoor patio that is easily one of the best parts of the experience. My main hesitation is the price point. It feels pretty pricey for what is essentially bar and grill food. Our bill came out to over $100 for just one appetizer, two beers, one kids' meal, and two sandwiches. For that price, I'm not entirely sure it's worth it for me to come back for a full dinner a third time. That said, I would absolutely come back just to hang out on the patio for an appetizer and a beer, or hit it up if I'm using the water equipment rental next door!

I honestly don't even know where to start with this experience at Bugaboo's…read more The food came out wrong the first time, and when it was brought back out, there was hair in my food AGAIN. Not just a tiny strand either -- I found multiple hairs in my food. I've attached a picture because I couldn't believe what I was looking at. At that point, I was completely disgusted and had absolutely no desire to keep eating. When you go out to eat, especially somewhere that isn't exactly cheap, the LAST thing you expect is to find someone's hair in your food. Having it happen twice is beyond unacceptable. It completely ruined the meal and honestly made me question the cleanliness of the entire kitchen. The drinks were okay, the service was okay, but nothing about the experience was what I would consider top-notch. The prices were way too high for what we received, and there are plenty of other places where you can get better food, better prices, and much better overall service. And to be clear, this is not directed at the bartender or waitress personally. They were doing their jobs, and I have no disrespect toward them. My issue is with the overall experience, the food, the quality control, and the fact that I paid good money for a meal that I ultimately couldn't stomach because I was so disgusted. Finding hair in your food is gross enough once. Finding it again after the food was corrected is absolutely disgusting and something a restaurant should never let happen. Unfortunately, this was a huge disappointment, and I definitely won't be rushing back. There are better options out there that are cleaner, more reasonably priced, and provide a much better dining experience.

Photos

Parking

Marg flatbread - real good!

See all

Outside patio view

The Sandbar Grill

3.7(123 reviews)

0.8 mi

•$

Great food at great prices. I really enjoy breakfast there-…read more I wish the AC was a bit better on those very hot days-

The cutest little spot with the SWEETEST service…read more This place is a whole vibe. There's outside seating if you prefer. Where you can dine with your toes in the sand. We went later in the evening and it was gloomy so we chose to sit inside. Our server. I think her name is Riley... so cute and so personable. She deserves a raise for real for real. The food was great and my company was also phenomenal. I got the Sandbar BLT. It's a blt WITH an egg. So much yumminess. My chica got fish tacos and sweet potato fries. The regular fries- good. Sweet potatoes- also good. It's was just a great little experience. There is a lot for parking.

Photos

Outdoor patio

See all

Pan Fried Blue Gill

The Hill Tavern

4.0(2 reviews)

0.6 mi

Great pizza. Thx Marie, for the delivery. It was a great day on Cedar Lake! I'm looking forward to…read morethe next trip. The pipe " tour. I will pick up pizza from the Hill any time! Great pizza' Ty

Wolf's Kitchen began cooking here tonight, and if you are in Cedar Lake it is worth a visit to have…read moreChef Andy's food. Tonight's special was cheese-stuffed, bacon-wrapped bratwurst. So GOOD! Friends ordered burgers & were just as happy with their choice. Tomorrow is Taco Tuesday, but I am heading back Saturday for the brisket mac & cheese! I have had brisket in some fancy (& not so) BBQ places - Smoque in Chicago, Hogly Wogly in CA - and can tell you Andy's brisket is The Best. Ever! Don't go to Hill Tavern for the atmosphere. Dive Bar describes it best. But clean (save for the smoke I took home in my clothes & hair) with friendly staff, you won't mind the decor once you start sampling Wolf's Kitchen's menu.

Photos

See all

Awesome! Pizza

Town Pub

3.3(4 reviews)

5.3 mi

lazy bitch of a worker was sitting down on her phone not doing a thing. had an attitude the whole…read morenight.

It has a pretty good atmosphere... There are jukeboxs, darts, pool tables & plenty of places to sit…read moreand socialize. They do offer a daily drink special, so be sure to check those out. Don't be surprised if a fight breaks out on the weekend; it usually is pretty packed. I would suggest dinner before you go ;-)

Photos

See all

The Dam Bar & Grill

3.9(75 reviews)

2.9 mi

•$

I found this little spot on my travels and it was absolutely a great find! I happen to be lucky…read moreenough to be there on their bluegill special night so I indulged maybe even a little too much on some pan seared bluegill. The atmosphere was very welcoming most of the people there were locals who treated me like one of their own. I look forward to frequently stopping by any time I'm in the area.

We had 5 at our table for dinner. First thing we noticed was the many fruit flies at the table. We…read moreplaced our order. First two dinners came out. Then 5 minutes later, the next two. The waitress said she would bring the fifth as soon as it was done. It was pasta with two breadsticks. The four of us were done eating and the pasta meal was brought out 10 minutes later. We were done eating. I pointed out that one breadstick was very browned and hard. She should have never brought it like that. I ordered the coconut shrimp which was clearly from a frozen box. Butterflied with a coating of no coconut and very flattened. Not worth $23. I expected the pretty shrimp they advertise in their Facebook pictures when they have $1 shrimp days. Coated whole shrimp with coconut in the batter. Very disappointed in so many ways.

Photos

See all

Buffalo Chicken Fries

Bennetts pub and play

5.0(7 reviews)

5.3 mi

We stopped in on a Friday night because we had a gift card, and we will be back! The service was…read morefast and friendly, the drinks were good, and the food was great! We got the Irish nachos and pizza. Both were spot on and made fresh

We went to Bennett's Pub this last Saturday evening with friends and had a Wonderful time. The…read moredecor on the pub side is Neo-Industrial with large tables and cozy chairs. There is also an arcade on the other side of the estab with a myriad of pinball machines and other assorted fun arcade games. The staff was very friendly and efficient; we received our food and drinks in no time. The food was surprisingly delicious for Pub fare - we had pizza, chicken wings and jalapeno poppers. All three were stellar and 'to die for' IMO. To top it off, a three piece band was playing that evening and the atmosphere was palpable. Where else can you go on a Saturday night in May in NWI and hear a bawdy rendition of Roxanne by the Police with the patrons singing along with the band ?

Photos

Current food menu ( just started serving food yesterday this menu will likely change over time)

Valentine Cocktails: Cherry Vanilla Espresso Martini (left) & Scarlet Kiss (right)

See all

Build your own pizza

Harry O's

2.9(71 reviews)

2.4 mi

•$$

The food was amazing and the waitress was stellar. Great menu with a lot of diner style options. We…read morehad the Italian beef and the grilled ham and cheese. Both were delivered fast and hot! They were also both delicious! The beef was tender and juicy and cooked perfectly. The grilled ham and cheese was toasted perfectly as well. The fries were fresh and crisp and golden too. The only down side they need to work on is the host area. They don't take names or keep a list and the place was very busy. They were taking customers out of order and had obvious preferences. That can be a bit discouraging and we almost left because of it. However, the waitress was fantastic and saved the day.

For what it is... a solid three stars. Just your average…read morecomfort foods made pretty well. The service is super kind and just yeah. I would totally come back. Happily. There is a lot for parking.

Photos

Homemade rolls

Lemon rice soup

See all

Awesome Roasted Chicken

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

136 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Roger L.

199

17 years ago

we gave the Light house a third chance and we were glad we did the service was very good and the hostess and front end staff were wonderful, no wait for our table at 5:30 on Fathers day great job! Food was great, only one item could better, when you make a crock of baked French onion soup you cover the entire to of the soup with cheese, that is why most people order it for the crouton and the cheese. other than that it was great, we ended the night on the lake watching the sunset and walking on the pier. a airplane was taking off and landing on the lake giving us all a show but the sunset was the real attraction. Fix the soups and pay a little more attention to cleaning the table as the guest eat and I will give you 5 stars plus. I order the stuffed shrimp with crab special and it was terrific. we ordered three appetizers, onion scoops, calamari and the flat bread pizza and they were also great. the new full service outdoor dining with the fireplace built in the tables looks great, we are going to try that next time. Thanks Lighthouse great job My daughter and her husband went to the lighthouse Friday 8/14/09 made reservations for 8:30. Got to the restaurant at 8:10 and checked in. noticed that the host was engaged in a slight argument about not seating a group, they were complaining because their name was crossed off the list and were never called to be seated. My daughter and her husband ordered drinks and went outside to wait, and wait, and wait. After 40 minutes my son-in-law inquired and was told that it would be "a few minutes." after another 35 minutes he inquired again and was told that he and his name was crossed off the list and he was already seated...WHAT....no...........no....! Finally were seated after over an hour wait and given a free appetizer. I called the restaurant for my kids because I recommended the place. I talked to a very professional young lady who informed me that they were aware of the problems and it had happened a couple of times that night. they said a manger would call on Saturday 8/15/09.....no call! I called back today and spoke to the same very professional girl who was shocked that the general manager did not call my daughter. She said that he will call today and she will call me back to tell me what he said and why he did not call. The girl that I spoke to on the phone twice is a true restaurant professional and has a great personality. I will update this review after the phone call... Oh by the way, my kids told me the food was good, not great just good........ If the manager calls we will try again with a larger group for my birthday....watch for an update. HERE IS THE UPDATE! 8/23/09-------went for my birthday, big mistake, once again the staff is very rude........they got their noses in the air because they have the business for now.......not for long. Manager called my daughter and told her they would comp. the appetizers if we came back for my birthday, so she made reservations for 9 people for today, 8/23. She was told in no uncertain terns that 3:00 was the only time that they take groups, (ours was 9) they will not take any large group after that. wait till business dies off on the winter they will beg to have groups any time. we arrived and were seated promptly, we were seated at two tables next to each other ( less than 12 inches away) one side was a long booth the other side was chairs. I immediately slid the tables together to have one long table and so we can converse, (it is very loud in there). then the waiter came to the table and said "you are not allowed to put the tables together, it is a danger to our staff and it makes it hard to service the table, as he was telling us that he started pulling the table apart. I said you got to be kidding me, whose rule is that? he sent a manager over to see me and see explained sarcastically that we violated a Lighthouse rule and the tables must stay apart, wow I was so embarrassed after she informed me of the violation. That alone will stop me from ever eating again at the Lighthouse. but the food is also a problem....French onion soup that is terrible, a floating piece of old bread with cheese on top...it did not even resemble Baked French onion soup, salads with old yellow lettuce and warm dressing mixed into the salad before it comes to the table....we thought it was someones garbage that they did not eat. appetizers were a joke, the onion scoops were oil soaked and contained the outer peels and the calamari was rubber and loaded with oil. Steaks were good, but not done to the correct ordered temps, pork chop was good but not worth the attitude of the staff............I would not recommend the Lighthouse to anyone, I hope a better place opens that knows how to treat customers read more

AR P.

10 years ago

Quick review: Great food, excellent service. Detailed review: I had never been to Lighthouse, but it was recommended to me by some locals to host a surprise anniversary party. I took their word and started setting up the party for 60 guests with Candice at Lighthouse. She was extremely helpful (and patient) especially with someone like me who doesn't set up these functions too often. I made numerous changes over the 2-3 weeks before the party date and she handled all my requests quickly and considerately. She responds faster to email than anyone I can recall. I got to one of the 2nd floor reception rooms just before the party began, and the layout and decor were just perfect - no customizing required. The view of the lake area was very nice, and that was in January. I hear it is gorgeous in Summer. Candice was not working the day of our party, but Kevin was there to manage the private parties. Honestly, I couldn't imagine a more accommodating host than Kevin and the rest of the crew that day. I botched some technical details regarding the slide show for the room (HDTV and projector) and Kevin put in the extra time to help me get our slide show on screen anyway. There was a wireless microphone provided for speeches as well, and we had none of the usual issues with unfamiliar sound systems. The mic worked well and the rest of the audio was set up just right - everyone could hear perfectly. We had some other unforeseen issues as well, but Kevin and the other staff handled everything calmly, quickly and with class (unfortunately I didn't get anyone else's name). I received a number of compliments from guests just about the service. Very impressive! And most importantly, the honorees really enjoyed themselves. We opted to give our guests 3 choices for a plated luncheon, and again, I got quite a few compliments from the guests. I personally had the chicken piccata which was delicious. As per Candice's suggestion, we went with an open bar option instead of the per-person package. Since this was an afternoon affair, she correctly advised that most folks either wouldn't be drinking or would have a small number of drinks. While money was not our top priority, it sure was nice to save as much as we did on drinks, and come in under budget. The draught beer selection seemed to be limited to a couple standards, but I don't know what bottles were available in the bar downstairs. I didn't hear any negative comments from guests about the selection though. The building itself has lots of wood and an overall nautical theme which is just clever enough without being kitschy. I can't comment about the restaurant food and service as we were in the upstairs private rooms, but if our experience was at all indicative of the regular restaurant service then I imagine dining at the Lighthouse restaurant must be quite enjoyable. As I mentioned, our final bill was quite reasonable even with the requisite 20% service charge, which they certainly earned plus an extra tip. Since I live on the north side of Chicago, I don't know when the next time I will be Cedar Lake, but if I have the opportunity I will certainly return to the Lighthouse Restaurant for dinner. read more

Dimitri K.

13 years ago

A mostly seafood with steaks restaurant on the southeast shore of Cedar Lake in Lake County Indiana. White tablecloths with a Ralph Lauren-like nautical decor. There is a spacious bar area for you to wait for your table, which we did, for 10 minutes on a Saturday night with 7:00 reservations. You need reservations here. We had crab cakes for an appetizer, which were the best I've had outside the state of Maryland. I had the Lake Perch. My wife had fresh Chilean Sea Bass. Our offspring had the small Filet Mignon 8 oz. & Jumbo Fried Shrimp, respectively. All seafood was fresh in taste & consistency, and my boy ruined his steak with ketchup, but ate it all fast. The service was quick. They were knowledge able and helpful with the kids, letting them walk out on the pier while me & my love ate our salads. During our stay, they did not rush us along even though it was very busy. The cost was reasonable at $160 for a family of 4. We don't really drink much of the alcoholic beverages, where restaurants make their killing. So, anyway, dress nicely but no jacket required. If you want a table on the glass you may have to wait awhile. There's no outdoor dining because of the problems that adverse weather would cause. We dine here a few times a year, it is an outstanding seafood restaurant. Highly recommend. read more

Romeo S.

9 months ago

I stopped by The Lighthouse Restaurant in Cedar Lake, Indiana, and honestly, this place delivered exactly what I was hoping for and more. The atmosphere is beautiful -- right on the water, relaxed but still classy enough that you feel like you're somewhere special. The service was solid from the moment we walked in. Everyone was friendly, fast, and actually paid attention, which is rare these days. Now the food... that steak was on point. Cooked perfectly, seasoned just right, juicy, tender -- everything you want when you're paying for a good dinner. You can tell they know what they're doing in the kitchen. The sides, the presentation, the whole plate just came together clean. It's the type of place you bring your family, your girl, or even business clients and feel confident they're going to enjoy it. The view over the lake makes the entire experience even better -- especially if you go around sunset. It adds a whole vibe that makes the night feel a little more special. Overall, I highly recommend The Lighthouse Restaurant. Great food, great location, great atmosphere. Definitely one of Cedar Lake's gems, and I'll be back for sure. read more

Rachel P.

8 years ago

This rating is not directed towards the food or quality of this restaurant. It is more so directed towards the employees and management of the kitchen. The employees here are not respected and are very much unappreciated. I wouldnt reccomend anyone to work in the back of the house of this facility. No matter how much work and dedication you put into this company you will not be granted the pay you truly deserve. The head chef Ken Mcrae is seldomly present, he doesn't take the time to build up and encourage his staff; when he is there it is only to criticize and point out flaws in your work. Recently one of the sous chefs had resigned and her position became open and instead of giving this title to someone who is deserving and qualified for it Ken deemed it wise to hire in Trey Matson for this position whom which mind you is a former employee who was fired years prior for sexual harassment. The lighthouse kitchen staff deserves better treatment and more recognition and last but not least a head chef that values the cooks who help make this steakhouse the 5 star restaurant it is. read more

Jackie H.

9 years ago

I highly recommend this restaurant if you appreciate a delicious meal and friendly service in a unique setting. The views of the lake at sunset were just beautiful. The hostesses upon arrival were friendly, Shane the GM was accommodating and made himself visible and available throughout our dinner. Nina was our server and she was not only friendly, but seemed to genuinely care about our experience. We have dined here before but tried some different dishes this time. The appetizer crab dip was delicious as were our main meals of perch and steak medallions. The vegetables and sides had great flavors and everything was cooked to perfection which is appreciated on a busy Friday night. Although it was hard to narrow down a dessert, the warm cookie with Fair Oaks Farm ice cream was wonderful. We can't wait to go back! read more

Joshua P.

9 years ago

I had the pleasure of eating dinner at Lighthouse Restaurant last night. It was a great experience for several reasons. To begin, the service was great. Our server was friendly and always checking on us. The general manager also had a presence on the dining floor, he introduced himself and made sure our experience was exceptional. In addition to the service, the quality of the food was outstanding. The appetizers were outstanding, especially the crab cakes. My steak was delicious and prepared properly. The atmosphere was great. It's a busy restaurant but it didn't have that chaotic feeling. The view of the lake was gorgeous. The real bonus about Lighthouse is that it is a high quality restaurant located in Cedar Lake. I will definitely eat at Lighthouse again and I would recommend it to anyone. read more

Morgan N.

2 years ago

i visited the lighthouse yesterday to celebrate my partner and i's anniversary and it was just fantastic. great customer service from the start, everyone was extremely friendly and you were spoken to with respect. we shared the calamari which was pleasant, following with the half rack of ribs and a sirloin. everything was cooked to perfection. i do recommend getting the Cesar salad as it was so divine. the french fries were amazing and my husband loved the french onion soup. our drinks never went empty and we were checked on numerous times. the ambiance of the restaurant was very cozy with perfect lighting and a great view. we even had a kind hostess take pictures for us. i don't normally write reviews but i had such a good experience i had to share ! read more

Bud F.

13 years ago

Wow! Great views...great atmosphere. Reservations were easy...but definitely need to call ahead on Saturdays. Wish you could reserve a table "with a view"...but that apparently is not an option when you put in reservations. Would suggest you honor that request if its asked for...and be able to honor "first available" for all others. Really not a bad seat in the place...but the views are beautiful. The outside tables are awesome...as we were just there this past weekend. And the Bar that is made out of the vintage boat is impressive! Food is great, Service is good. Great addition to NW Indiana for sure....food, service and views make it seem like the North side of Chicago. We'll definitely be back. read more

Alyssa G.

1 year ago

I've been to this restaurant multiple times, and one of the main reasons I keep coming back is Kelli. She is an absolutely fantastic server who goes above and beyond every single time. From the moment you are seated, she makes you feel genuinely welcome. She always greets us with a warm smile and attentive energy that sets the tone for a great meal. Kelli is incredibly knowledgeable about the menu, quick with helpful recommendations, and always ensures everything is perfect--from the timing of the courses to checking in at just the right moments. You can tell she truly cares about the guest experience and takes pride in what she does. read more

Sally J.

13 years ago

I've been to this place three or four times. I recommend the Sea Bass...delicious! the service was Ok but not great, I saw a few of the bus boys goofing off and sitting at a table while they cleaned the plates off...just looked like they were being lazy when people were waiting on that table. The food is really good but a little expensive and the wait time to get seated was kinda long. definitely recommend getting reservations ...there is a few things not great about this place but the location and food make up for the bad things....I will return and do recommend eating here to friends read more

Peggy R.

8 years ago

My son and his family took me here for my birthday. I had never been here before but always heard great things. I ordered the Chicken St. Jacques, and my family ordered the Chilean Sea Bass, Salmon, Chicken Alfredo, and two of the kid's dishes. We also ordered appetizers (Spinach and Artichoke Dip and Brochette). We sampled each other's dishes and everything was delicious. I found the wait staff to be friendly and attentive. The service was excellent and the food was wonderful. I will return! Oh, and on Wednesdays, there are many wines at 1/2 price! read more

Christine F.

157

9 years ago

I came to the lighthouse with my great aunt who is 87 and she ordered the filet and I ordered the lobster. Each meal was fantastic but what the best part of the meal was our server Donnell. He was so knowledgeable about the menu and was very polite. Due to the fact that my aunt is older she's a little slow and Donnell was very patient with her to make her feel comfortable and at ease. Our meal was paced perfectly. I have not one complaint about this meal or the service, everything was wonderful. I would highly recommend asking for Donnell as your server! :) read more

Jeannine C.

1 year ago

We had such a wonderful 33rd wedding anniversary dinner. We were seated by a window over looking the lake. A beautiful view.The food and the drinks were incredible. The waitress was very pleasant and attentive to all our needs. The view of the lake, from our table, was breathtaking. We ordered Boneless Ribeye w/ onions and garlic mashed potatoes.The steak was so delicious it melted in your mouth. Everything was perfect. Thank you for the service. Our server was Kelli she was fantastic. Please ask for her when you make your reservations. read more

Cheryl R.

12 years ago

Lighthouse used to be my favorite restaurant. ..I would go at least once a month with friends and always had family parties there. The last few times I have been there. ..the food had been mediocre at best. The lobster bisque was awful. ..we sent it back! The service was terrible. ...the appetizers. ..salad...and entrée arrived together ..and the server was rude when we asked her to hold them. You still cannot beat the atmosphere outside in the summer. ...but I'm looking for a new place to go :( read more

Adam J.

1 year ago

Absolutely my new favorite restaurant in the Chicagoland area. It was our first visit - have always heard great things, but this surpassed expectations. Beautiful setting. Delicious food! Exceptional service from start to finish. Jonathan, our server, went above and beyond to make it the perfect celebration of our 20th anniversary. From the lady who greeted us at the door, to management, to even the people busing tables - we were impressed - and spoiled. Thanks for a great experience. read more

Wendy G.

9 years ago

We went there Friday the 18th of August it was very busy with a wedding and they seemed to have everything under control. The food was excellent , the manager came to our table and asked if everything was ok and he was so professional, the server we had was named Karen she was amazing she was on top of everything, she refilled our drinks when they were low, I cant say enough good things about the place, I cannot wait to go again I love the view too. read more

J G.

3 months ago

Karen IS The Lighthouse. Her LIGHT and presence can not be matched. It is no wonder she has been there 16 years. One feels completely at home the minute she takes the lead. Her heart is as big as Cedar Lake. Our first visit all the way from Naperville, Illinois was made complete. The food was top notch and seafood cooked PERFECTLY. Not an easy task. The lakeside views from each table or outside seating is perfection. Thank you! read more

robert h.

17 years ago

so sad, so bad.....rude and arogant staff and servers, management very rude. Food ranges from very bad to just good. Soups are bland and tasteless, salads and dressings are warm and taste old. strange rules I sat near a table that was embarassed by the waiter and manager when he was chastized for moving a table. Very poor taste. Many people will eat once and never return........then they will be searching for customers. read more

Nicole L.

1 year ago

Recently moved to Cedar Lake Indiana, so I search restaurants near me and I found this one when here for a few cocktails and a steak dinner me and my husband for our anniversary. The food was decent, but the service was terrible. We was treated so badly that I wanted to run for my life. I was so afraid that the waiter was gonna spit in my food. I don't know if it was just the color of my skin or he was just having a bad day. read more

See more unrecommended reviews

Lighthouse Restaurant - seafood - Updated August 2026

People who viewed Lighthouse Restaurant also viewed

Tavern On Main

4.0

(234 reviews)

•$$

This is hands down, our favorite restaurant/bar. Consistently great, has an old style pub feel, and…read moreis always decorated beautifully and on theme seasonally. We also love the rotation of drinks and foods each month. It gives us a new reason to come back that keeps it fresh and interesting. We know there is a wait to get in at happy hour and dinner time so we check in and walk down to Martony's for a drink and some Golden Tee while we wait to be called. It's 21 and over due to Indiana law and the size of the space. It makes it a special night for just us though and it's also turned into a tradition to bring our older kids for a really fun evening out when they turn 21. I do wish they would bring back the caprese sandwich as a regular item on the menu. It was my favorite as a lunch time option. And I hope they NEVER remove the Dilly Dally Dip because omg it's the best spinach dip we have ever had in our lives.

Location right on the square across from the court house so parking could be an issue but if you're…read morewilling to walk parking is available. It's a great use of an old building keep the details in tack make so nice. During warm weather they have patio seating perfect for people watching inside they high tops ,bar and regular tables so something for everyone to be comfortable. They have a monthly menu that rotates for a variety the regular menu is filled with a wide variety. I ordered off the starter menu which was filling you will not leave hungry but you will leave planning on what you will eat the next visit. We went on a Sunday afternoon they had 2 servers one inside and one for the outside...these guys worked so well together not once did we want for something and to be honest I doubt anyone was neglected the service was that Good

Pivot Lounge

4.1

(48 reviews)

The key to eating out begins with service. And service at…read morePivot has been on a long slow decline. They keep losing good servers and the staff has expressed failures of management. This comes out in service to customers. The food still is acceptable but the failure to be nice and friendly has made the experience an abject failure. They have lost my confidence and we who go once a week are now done. No more. Consider yourself warned and buyer beware. Lots of good options in Crown Point that will provide good service. There has always been an off odor here but can be overlooked if all else is good.

If you haven't eaten at Pivot Lounge yet, "HOLD UP!" you're definitely missing out on one of Crown…read morePoint's MOST unexpectedly fantastic dinners. I and a few other family members were invited by my mother and by the time I walked out, I was wondering why this place wasn't packed wall‑to‑wall every night. Let's start with Monday's AYCE perch -- absolutely outstanding. Lightly breaded, perfectly seasoned, and fried just right. It's the kind of perch that makes you rethink every mediocre fish fry your uncle threw that your family tolerated. If you're a perch person, this is your new weekly ritual. Then came the walleye, WATCH OUT NOW, and honestly, my sister wasn't prepared. She said it was flaky, flavorful, and cooked with the kind of herbs & spices she recognized that said, "Yeah, we know exactly what the hell we're doing." "It's the kind of fish that makes you pause mid‑bite and appreciate life for a second." But the real surprise of the night? The bacon, mushroom, and American cheese hamburger -- unforgettable. This thing deserves its own billboard. Juicy, stacked, and unapologetically delicious. Every bite felt like a small celebration. On top of all that, the place is spotless. I mean impressively clean. Floors, tables, bar area -- everything looked like someone had just finished polishing it. You can tell the staff takes pride in the space. And speaking of the space... Yes, the building once housed a gentleman's club. But now? It's so clean, so friendly, and so well‑run that the only thing dancing is your taste buds. The only thing exotic here is how good the food is. Pivot Lounge has officially earned a spot on my "must return" list. Great food, great service, great atmosphere -- and a glow‑up story worthy of its own documentary.

Culinary Misfits

3.8

(137 reviews)

Family friendly restaurant serving up American cuisine and craft cocktails in a casual, relaxed…read moreatmosphere. The servers were friendly, attentive, and accommodating. I ordered an American staple, a burger with fries. The burger was juicy, well seasoned, and topped with crispy bacon. The bun was soft and held everything together without falling apart. The fries were crispy on the outside, soft on the inside, and paired well with the burger. A great spot for a laid-back meal with family or friends.

Culinary Misfits should not be confused with Culinary Dropout, as their food and drinks are…read moredifferent, though the prices are similar. This cute restaurant is located in Crown Point, IN, and it's best to use GPS to avoid getting lost. The venue is nice and perfect for photos, with plenty of space. The bar has a lively atmosphere, and the food is good, with large portions. I ordered the Classic Smashburger and substituted the protein for an Impossible Burger. I expected to receive two patties since I had to pay an additional $4.00. While it's my choice to be a pescatarian, I still think that an extra $4.00 for a single patty is excessive, both here and at any restaurant. This brought the price of my burger from $18.00 to $22.00, which reflects the current costs of dining out. Overall, our server was really nice and accommodating. She was patient with us as we decided on what to order and even shared her favorite dishes, which helped us make our decisions. The others in my party ordered a Mushroom & Swiss Smashburger and a Tuscan Turkey Sandwich. I must say, the turkey sandwich (Shaved Oven Roasted Turkey) had so much turkey on it that it could have fed us for Thanksgiving, but we weren't complaining! It was generous, and she happily took home the leftovers. The drink we had was blah, it had peach deep eddy's, elderflower liqueur (which I love), citrus and a few other ingredients. I'll pass on that the next time, I think it had too much elderflower and not enough peach. We all enjoyed our food and the ambiance of the restaurant. We will definitely return when we are in the area, and I will be sure to recommend this place to my friends who live nearby. I would also consider throwing a small b-day celebration upstairs in the lounge. Thank you, Culinary Misfits, for a great lunch!

Theo's Steaks & Seafood

3.5

(380 reviews)

•$$$

This was my second visit to the restaurant, and unfortunately, both experiences were disappointing…read more The first time, I ordered an old-fashioned that fell flat and lacked any real depth of flavor. On my second visit a year later, I decided to give it another shot--this time opting for the traditional version instead of the smoked one. It was better, but still only average at best. It was also served warm, and the ice melted quickly, suggesting the glass or drink wasn't properly chilled. The martini was also underwhelming--it tasted mostly like juice, with little to no noticeable alcohol. As for the food, the starters were definitely the highlight. The French onion soup was actually very good. However, the main courses didn't live up to expectations. I ordered the steak medium rare, but it came out closer to medium well--overcooked and under-seasoned. The chicken Vesuvio was also disappointing; the sauce tasted like it came from a jar, and neither it nor the rice stood out in any meaningful way. On a positive note, the ambiance was very nice. The lighting created a pleasant atmosphere, and the staff was friendly and attentive throughout the meal. Overall, while the setting and service were enjoyable, the food and drinks didn't justify a return visit.

Theo's Steak & Seafood C/O District /Executive Director…read more9144 Indianápolis Blvd. Highland, IN 46322 Good afternoon, (A Really Bad Experience) I am writing to you concerning my visit to your establishment on February 7, 2026. I had the worst experience that I have ever had in a restaurant. First, I did not have a problem with the price because it was $60.00 per person and I paid for my daughter, son, and daughter-in-law, as well as myself. They were very unprofessional. One waitress came out and stated that we could order onions and mushrooms on our steak, but that would be an extra charge, if the bride state it was okay. I went to the bride, and they told her that it would be an extra $10.00, I gave her $15.00. So, at that point, they came out and took our orders and among the 4 of us we ordered a steak medium well with just a little charred on it. Well, I had to wait because the waitress came out and stated that they had charred it too much and they had to put me another one in. Now it is half an hour later and everybody in the place is complaining because now they are coming back stating that you can't order the onions or mushrooms that they have already given to the bride. Don't nobody want to go back and say give it back 1 /2 hour later, so we let her keep it. My steak came out burnt. Also, the waiter came around with water and one of the people at my table had gone out to the bar and purchased her a drink and he poured water in her glass that already had her drink that she paid for, and he told her that he would replace it. Then the manager whom I sent a picture of to the store came back and said she would get another drink, well she went back to the bar and purchased another and was waiting for the one that they were supposed to bring to her. So, I asked the manager if they could replace my steak and she threw her hands up in the air and stated that it is what you ordered and walked away. My daughter-in-law was so upset her husband had to make her be quiet because she was so mad at the lady who talked to me like that, and she travel all over the world and I have never seen her get upset like that. Everybody in the room complained about the services, we asked whether we could go out and order it from outside and still pay her and they kept telling us that we couldn't. I was so angry and I did not eat at all, and I only eat once a day and I had the worst service that I have ever had anywhere and we traveled all over the world. First, that Manager owes me an apology and I would like to meet with you concerning this, because it was so unprofessional, and maybe it was because of our race, I do not know, but at this point we all are saying I will never go back to Theo's. I feel that even if it costs extra, because not everybody eats steaks with onions or mushrooms on it, we still paid her $60.00 for their meal, that should have been able to order anything else. One lady just wanted a salad with any meat, just some lettuce, tomatoes, and croutons and they told her that they could not accommodate her with that. My god daughter that got married her son does not eat meat and she was able to just get him some noodles. I feel that even if we paid the $60.00 for the meal that we should still had been able to order something else, and not only that one waitress should not be able to tell you that you can order onions or mushroom on your steak and then the other one come back and say no. We did not care about the extra charge, and I feel we should have been able to order appetizers if we wanted them. A lot of us had not eaten all day, getting off the plane and going to the wedding and straight to your place and this is the service we received. I am not just complaining just about myself, but for my family, your staff need training on what they can or cannot do before entering that room and one person says one thing and the other one is saying something else. I have never been to any place where the manager did not try to rectify the situation or just remove that price off the bill. I sent a you the picture of the manager that was in charge I guess, but she was the one that threw her hands up in the air and said that is what you ordered. I order my steak chard everywhere and it has never been burnt, and they want me to except it, and I did not eat one thing on the plate. I just paid for something that I could not eat. Your place was very beautiful and that was my first time there, but that was a horrible experience, but when you went out of the room the bartenders and all the other people were so nice. I do not feel that the people that were working back there in the room can handle 50 people and one time ordering, but they should have been a little more accommodating. I know she had to pay $3,000.00 for just the people and a tip, but I don't feel that she got what she paid for. I tried to send this letter to the store,so that someone would contact me and they never did till this day.

Stacks Bar & Grill

4.3

(619 reviews)

•$$

My husband and I had the perfect date night at Stacks! We've dined here many times but this time we…read moredecided to dine on the Rooftop and it was absolutely perfect. The weather couldn't have been better, making it such a beautiful evening to sit back, relax and enjoy a great meal together. We started with the Steak & Lobster Stuffed Mushrooms and WOW.....they were fantastic! Such a delicious way to start the evening. My husband ordered the 24 oz. Tomahawk Ribeye with a Brandy Mushroom Sauce, served over mashed potatoes and asparagus. He thoroughly enjoyed every bite because when he was finished, there was absolutely nothing left on the plate.....which says it all! I ordered the Scalibut, featuring Blackened Halibut and Seared Scallops served over Lobster mashed potatoes and asparagus, topped with a Lemon Parmesan sauce and Tomato basil Cruda. It did NOT disappoint! Every bite was packed with incredible flavor and the combination of the halibut, scallops, lobster mashed potatoes and sauce was absolutely delicious. Between the food, the atmosphere and getting to enjoy a beautiful evening on the rooftop with my husband, this was such a wonderful date night. We've always enjoyed Stacks but this visit was definitely one to remember. We'll absolutely be back!

Stacks has a huge variety of drinks and delicious apps! The breadsticks are some of the best around!read more

Square Roots

4.0

(275 reviews)

•$$

The service at this establishment was absolutely phenomenal. The food was terrific very tasteful…read moreflavorful. This restaurant was extremely clean tables restrooms it was just impeccable. I would highly recommend this restaurant to my friends and family. Haley are server. Her customer service was just great. This young lady deserves a raise. Please check them out.

Very nice location, downtown Crown Point, very nice outdoor patio area, large inside seating area…read more Spring is good time to enjoy outside seating, umbrellas over all seating. Food was good and plenty of it, had enough for lunch the next day. Had butter chicken on garlic mashed potato's with asparagus, very tender filets with nice breading, Philly cheesesteak eggrolls were large and good for splitting, nice cheese sauce. Wanted desert but no room, may start with it next time. Only flaw (minor) soups came out at same time as meal, it was busy dinner time. Peach old fashion was tasty and well made. Peach gummy was nice touch in the glass. Looking forward to go back, very full menu, vegan, gluten free choices and full fat, gluten choices for me. Large list of burgers too.

Coppolillos Italian Steakhouse

4.0

(84 reviews)

Took my mom here for Mother's Day and it did not disappoint. It has a lovely, bright interior with…read morewhite table cloths. One important thing to note about seating is that some of the tables are high-top bar tables. I happen to have a disability, so had they assigned our reservation with one of those tables it would have been a problem because it's hard for me to get up and down in those seats. The service was A-1! From the hostesses to the wait staff and management. They were extremely attentive throughout our meal. Instead of just putting the appetizers on the table, our waiter plated them for us. This is probably the only misstep during our meal. He assumed that all of us wanted a piece of each app instead of asking each of us which app we wanted. We ordered stuffed mushrooms and bruschetta. A couple people didn't like mushrooms. Also, we had more people joining us so by plating all the apps upfront there wasn't enough for the rest of our party. Even still he was a great waiter. The food was phenomenal! I got the steak and eggs from the brunch menu. The cut of steak was like a hanger steak. When I say cooked and seasoned to perfection!?! It was one of the best restaurant steaks I've had. Our entire table enjoyed the food we ordered, including the cocktails. The food is pricey, but for an elevated experience or special occasion it is absolutely worth the visit!

So much yes. My sweet friend invited me to celebrate my…read morebirthday. What a wonderful experience. Our server was tops. So sweet. So knowledgeable. So gracious and kind. The food was FRESH and delicious. We ordered the stuffed mushrooms, caprese salad and the spaghetti and meatballs. Everything. Delish. AND there was complimentary carrot cake WITH a sparkler for my birthday. I love this place. I cannot wait to go back... There is a lot for parking.

Station 21

3.4

(244 reviews)

•$$

Unsanitary and unbelievably rude service. My son and I both ordered the Station 21 burger medium…read morewell. When our food arrived, I cut into mine and it was extremely rare--so undercooked that one side of the patty was still pink. My son's burger was cooked correctly, so I know mine clearly wasn't. When our waitress checked on us, I explained the issue, and she politely apologized and took the burger back. A few minutes later, the manager on duty brought the same burger back upstairs, slammed it down, and asked with an attitude, "What is the problem?" I explained that it was undercooked and that I had ordered medium well. She then asked, "What do you want me to do with this?" while just standing there staring at me. After acting irritated, she asked if I wanted a new burger or wanted "this one" recooked. The idea of them recooking a burger I had already cut into and handled felt completely unsanitary. Her attitude throughout the interaction was awful. I declined a replacement, and she huffed that she'd remove it from the bill. Unfortunately, it got even worse. Just minutes later, an earwig crawled out of my friend's salad. We were horrified. We took a picture, caught the bug, and asked another server to get the manager. When she returned, she walked up with her hand on her hip and said, "Now what?" We handed her the napkin with the bug, and instead of apologizing, she opened it right there on the table, let the bug crawl out, scoffed at us, and said, "Fine, I'll take that off the bill too." At that point, my friend was covering her mouth in disgust after realizing she had been eating a salad with a bug in it. Rather than showing concern or professionalism, the manager snapped, "What do you want?! I didn't put the bug in the salad." I have never experienced such unsanitary conditions combined with such shockingly hostile customer service. Mistakes can happen, but the manager's behavior was beyond unacceptable. We left disgusted and will absolutely never return.

Stopped in here recently, first time. Sat on the upper deck balcony, very pleasant. I had the…read moreseared ahi tuna salad, and I normally don't order salads but this was fantastic! We also tried the frito chip pie, also very good. Service was decent but a tad slow. She may have been working too many tables inside.

Martinis in Valpo

3.5

(166 reviews)

•$$

Had a wonderful experience. Went out for a few drinks with my daughter!! bartender was helpful and…read morekind

Food Outstanding! Ambiance was beautiful. Really attractive…read morelooking place. Service was not so good. The female bartender was great. After serving me a drink already, my father in law walked in and while the bartender was busy in the back I asked the manager if he could get me another drink. The manager made me go get my father in law before serving it. Didn't look at his ID because he was obviously older than me, who already was drinking my beer. Then the male waitor was quite rude and wouldn't allow me to order my second drink until I finished my first. So I immediately pouded it right in front of him. He took so long to get me my second drink, that I could have just casually drank it instead. I've never been told that I can't order a second drink while enjoying my first one. The waitor really negatively impacted my experience and their rules for alcoholic beverages are horrid. I will try my hardest to never go there again. Food was super tasty though.

Teibel's Family Restaurant

3.2

(221 reviews)

•$$

The perch was delicious The service was superb and we come…read morefrom the northwest suburbs of Chicago to have your perch.. You're the best around!

I've been coming here since I was a little girl. It's always decorated so amazing at Christmas…read more Some of the decor has been here since I can remember. They have updated the middle section of the dining room. The rest of the place is a bit dated, but that's part of the charm. They have an old school coat room too. You can reserve for showers & funeral lunches. I've been to many that are always well staffed & attentive. They are known for their fried perch. I'll be honest when I say, that's what I always get. It's amazing with the homemade tartar sauce. Their dinner rolls are amazing. My family gets them for the holidays. Same with the coleslaw. Peppermint ice cream after the meal is so good too. It's a classic mainstay for Schererville.

Lighthouse Restaurant

Lighthouse Restaurant Photos

Lighthouse Restaurant Popular Dishes

Lighthouse Restaurant menu photos

LIGHTHOUSE RESTAURANT ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Lighthouse Restaurant

Reviews With Photos

More info about Lighthouse Restaurant

Payment methods

Food & Alcohol

Indoor Amenities

Outdoor Amenities

Other Amenities

Ask the Community - Lighthouse Restaurant

You might also consider

More businesses like Lighthouse Restaurant

Town Club Tavern

Hunley's Bar & Grill

Reichert's Tavern

Bugaboo's Bar and Grill

The Sandbar Grill

The Hill Tavern

Town Pub

The Dam Bar & Grill

Bennetts pub and play

Harry O's

136 Lighthouse Restaurant reviews that are not currently recommended

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

136 reviews that are not currently recommended

Lighthouse Restaurant - seafood - Updated August 2026

Best of Cedar Lake

People found Lighthouse Restaurant by searching for…

Trending Searches in Cedar Lake, IN

Browse Articles

Browse Nearby

Reviews from Lighthouse Restaurant

Browse Brands

Related Searches in Cedar Lake, IN

People who viewed Lighthouse Restaurant also viewed

Tavern On Main

Pivot Lounge

Culinary Misfits

Theo's Steaks & Seafood

Stacks Bar & Grill

Square Roots

Coppolillos Italian Steakhouse

Station 21

Martinis in Valpo

Teibel's Family Restaurant