As far as diners go, this one's in the middle of the road. Food is OK, and Service is terrific. My favorite thing about the Liberty diner Is that their menu has such a variety, not just of food but of portion sizes .You can order a half a sandwich and a cup of soup, or a small version of salads and sandwiches. I ordered a half a pastrami sandwich and a cup of soup. The rye bread was stale. I thought it was toasted, but the bottom portion was wet so it wasn't toasted, It was stale. read more

Liberty Diner - Pastrami Half Sandwich w/ Cup of Soup - Diners Near Me - Liberty, New York

See all

As our family was leaving the Catskills we wanted to stop for breakfast. Liberty diner was the perfect stop that was enroute to NYC. The diner is very festive, upbeat, and lively. Loved that they are one of the very few places in the Catskills opened late hours. Large variety of choices on the menu, the food is very good, coffee was great. Service was excellent. Loved that they serve cocktails if your in the mood for a glass of wine after a long road trip, or other spirits. When visiting the area this will definitely be a place I visit for a sit down, bite to eat. read more

See all

Was on a quick trip, and needed to stop quickly for some food. Walked in and already knew the food would be great by the sight of the dessert cases! We were sat and told the waitress the food needed to be to go and she put our order right in. She packed up the two best desserts for me. Food came out quickly, and hot and smelled amazing. Best part was finding out it was run by the father who just passed the restaurant to his daughter, but he still stays to keep an eye on things. read more

See all

We were in Liberty NY for a concert at Bethel Woods. There were fast food options but decided on the diner instead. Coffee was hot, fresh and delicious. Service was quick and attentive we probably should have specified cinnamon French toast but the challah French toast was delicious. A side of bacon and home fries. Everything arrived perfect temp taste was pretty delicious! The decorations made me think every day was a holiday! The case of homemade cheesecake and cakes looked tempting but decided to pass! Will definitely stop again! read more

See all

We got there late after a tournament and it was still pretty busy. The wait staff was attentive with multiple staff stopping by as they passed through the dining area. The food was cooked well and the table next to me had rave reviews of a number of items. The crepes looked fabulous. The old Greek diner I expected was eclipsed by the quality staff, but held on to the fair prices and good food I'd been expecting. The dish I ordered itself was fantastic, the picture is only half the portion as it was huge but it was good the second day as well. The NY style cheesecake was also fluffy and delicious but had to wait until late night as I was too full from dinner to have it at the diner. read more

Liberty Diner - Chicken and waffles - Diners Near Me - Liberty, New York

See all

We stopped in by happenstance as we were passing through....and wow -- so glad we did!!! Everything was outstanding. Delicious coffee. I had an omelette, my one daughter got a buffalo chicken wrap, my other daughter got a chicken BLT wrap and we ordered pumpkin French toast to share...so tasty. Friendly service and clean, nostalgic diner. Highly recommend. read more

See all

Best chicken tenders , Best rice pudding Excellent coffee Excellent service by George Jr Thanks so much read more

Great diner, especially when you are on the road! Friendly staff, and it looks like everyone knows each other! True diner feel! Food was good. They give you the perfect amount and not too much. read more

We tried our first Door Dash delivery. I ordered food from the Liberty New York diner. It was a great experience. The food arrived in a very timely manner, even though we live in the next town over. Our food arrived hot and freshly made. The order was delivered with the necessary utensils and napkins. Thankfully , the Liberty Diner sent garnishes that we had forgotten to ask for. Additionally, the Door Dash driver followed the exact and complicated delivery instructions (in the inclement weather). I would give the diner 10 stars if I was able to. read more

They are trying to charge New York City prices for local food, which is not that great to begin with.

It's amazing how we always find these local diners and small restaurants that consistently knock the ball out of the park and I see this after my first trip here. We were headed up to Rochester and wanted a place for a quick breakfast, not fast food. They are right off HWY 17 and within a minute we were here. Plenty of parking and there were plenty of cars here. Walked in and immediately greeted at the door and brought over to our booth (as requested.) This is a lovely diner with plenty of booth seating and a separate dining room with tables. Within seconds are very lovely waitress stopped by for drinks then the order. Egg sandwiches can out quickly and exactly how we ordered them. (As I said before, that doesn't always happen.). Coffee was good, hot and plentiful. I definitely recommend the Liberty Diner and look forward to our next visit here. KUDOs to the team at the Liberty diner. read more

See all

Ordered a veggie omelette with mushrooms, Swiss cheese and onions. Very generous portion and omelette was cooked perfectly! The diner is very clean and a pleasant staff. read more

Liberty Diner - Dining area - Diners Near Me - Liberty, New York

Stopped back for dinner on the way through. Great attentive service and had a wonderful Cuban Panini "new" to the menu. read more

See all

Good delevery..nice neighborhood atmosphere. Great lunch specials. Different options.

Being from Jersey this was a whole different experience from the diners in NJ! We had stayed at a hotel up the road for a concert and wanted a "hangover cure" breakfast and the girl at the desk suggested this. For off our waitress and from what it seemed most of them there were pleasant , experienced and friendly. They seemed to enjoy their jobs and talking to the customers. Our waitress was outstanding , I don't recall ever having a waitress bring me an entirely new cup of coffee instead of just refilling the leftover at the table. Our breakfast was hot, fresh and delicious. We couldn't believe how small the bill was compared to diners at home. Stop in, enjoy some good food and take care of your waitress! read more

Traveling through, my husband & I enjoyed a delicious lunch at Liberty Diner. The portions were large and we could have easily split a meal. The Mediterranean Panini was delicious with the sweet potato fries I've had in quite awhile. My husband enjoyed the Mega Beef Melt. We both had leftovers for an additional full meal. Our server was friendly and attentive. Interior decor was that of an old diner but exceptionally clean and tastefully decorated. Easy on/off expressway. Ample off street parking. read more

Liberty Diner - Mega Beef Melt Sandwich - Diners Near Me - Liberty, New York

See all

A motorway emergency brought my family to this diner at a late hour, when all other non-fast-food eateries were closed. It was still bustling, signalling this place's popularity. The whole place gave off a warm air of home dining experience. The portions were unmistakably generous"diner" sizes! My vegetarian panini was delicious; I only ate half of it and the other half became next morning's breakfast. My son wolfed down his chicken sandwich. The only blemish was in husband's shrimp and avocado salad: the shrimps were undercooked. I took a few home and microwaved them to perfection the next day :-). Their fries were surprisingly nice - crispy on the outside while fluffy on the inside. The bathroom was pristine. We pass through Liberty on occasion, and sometimes even make a special trip to go antique shopping. Very happy to have discovered this culinary option! read more

See all

This place takes diners to the next level food is great prime rib and shrimp is off the shelf family run and the staff is always attentive

The waitstaff here was absolutely lovely -- Our waitress shared how years ago she worked at a local camp and as we sat, counselors from the camp (including our son) were treated so well! The waitstaff seemed to know many who were coming in - and loads of locals were engaging easily. It's a diner so the fare is normal diner stuff -- I had the chicken salad plate with potato salad and cole slaw. My husband and son both had paninis. Everything came out at good speed and was solidly good. The diner was bright and had good lighting which yes, did make a difference in the experience. read more

See all

Took an hour to get a corn beef sandwich and fried chicken fried chicken with ice cold corn beef was grayish color with some slime on it the matzo ball soup did come out quickly although it was only a hard pizza matzo ball with some broth poured over it. The worst diner I've ever been to and then saying a lot read more

10 pm Thursday, busy, very slow, service , 30 minutes order to eat, mediocre food, ok service, a local hot spot

In my opinion I stopped at the right place outstanding East Coast diner food was extremely tasty everything tasted fresh The place is very busy but the amount of noise is at a reasonable level The restaurant was extremely clean the bathrooms were extremely clean the waitress was very helpful very polite and when I needed more coffee or water she was right on spot The only problem I had was get bigger plates or make the portion smaller too much for one plate. read more

Liberty Diner - Bison burger with avocado and bacon - Diners Near Me - Liberty, New York

Highly recommending this place ! Came for a visit with my friends from NYC and that was our first stop for brunch ! Such a lovely warm service ! Great food and made us feel so welcome and warm! FYI one of the only places in town serving alcohol . read more

Liberty Diner - Deserts of the Diner ! Chocolate cake , Baklava cheesecake, Coconut cake - Diners Near Me - Liberty, New York

We were in town over the weekend for camping and needed a place to eat past 9pm. We ended up going here because the kitchen closes at midnight. I ordered the chicken cobb salad which had everything that I expected. Large chunks of chicken, hard boiled egg, bacon, etc. It was very good and I finished it all. My wife got the lettuce roast beef and bacon wrap and she thought that was just average. My son got the homemade lasagna and it was just mediocre. All in all, the food is what you expected out of a diner. The waitress who took our order was very courteous and always checked up on us. If you are in a bind and looking for a place to eat at late hours, definitely come to this place. read more

See all

We stopped here on the way home from NYC. The food is excellent. Loved the coffee and generous portions. I would definitely come here again. I highly recommend it. read more

Liberty Diner - the front of the restaurant - Diners Near Me - Liberty, New York

It was my 1st time at Liberty Diner with my fiancé. She has been here before and unfortunately had constantly heard rumors that the food was not good, place was dirty, etc... However, we have been hearing great things about it recently from our neighborhood friends. We decided to give it a try. Absolutely did not disappoint. The place is a little bit modern but still has some of the old school diner flair lingering. Clean and the wait staff is friendly and accommodating. FYI - The menu online does not have the same prices as the menu inside the diner. We had breakfast, I had French Toast Deluxe with eggs and bacon and sausage and somehow got hash browns with it too even though the menu says it does not come with it. That was a pleasant surprise. The only thing that wasn't up to par was I asked for Challah French Toast, but I think I may have received the old-fashioned, because the bread was not the same as real deal Challah. Slightly disappointing. My fiancé got the Cali Benedict. Looked amazing and she was very pleased with the meal. I definitely would like to come back and try their tasty sounding milkshakes or anything else on the menu sounded just as great. read more

Long time diner in Liberty, immediately off Rt 17, offers well-prepared food, good service, in a clean spacious dining room. We loved the waffles, available with real maple syrup for an upcharge, and the veal parmigiana was a large veal cutlet, well fried, with a thick bed of cheese and bright red, fresh-tasting marinara. We were disappointed with the crab cakes. While large and well fried, with a nicely complex blend of herbs, pepper, onions, the crab flavor was entirely missing. Sevice was friendly and efficient. The dining room is large and the place is very clean. read more

See all

We were out for Autumn foliage viewing on the Southern Tier Expressway, better known as NY Rte. 17, soon to be I-86. We decided to stop in Liberty, NY for lunch and arrived at the Liberty Diner & Restaurant around 1:00 PM. We were greeted in a non-committal manner by the hostess and seated immediately. The waitress came to get our drink order and deliver menus right away, and delivered the drinks very quickly. It took us 2 visits by the waitress to decide on our meals. The menu is several pages and contains a plethora of items for all-day breakfast, lunch, and dinner. I had their Cajun Steak & Gravy. Meg had French Dip on Garlic Bread. Each meal was plentiful, delicious, and quite different from anything we'd had before. They came with French fries that were some of the best I'd ever experienced. The onion rings side order was mundane, but palatable. The food was a little slow to arrive, but since it was a relaxing atmosphere, and I was enjoying a warm conversation with a local man and his grandfather, it was not a problem. The waitstaff were friendly and cordial, the facility is charming and invitingly clean and tidy. The restrooms were among the cleanest, freshest, and most sanitary I've had the recent pleasure of using. I recommend Liberty Diner & Restaurant. I think that a traveler or local will find food here that they'll like, and a friendly place to enjoy it. From the moment we parked in one of their spacious parking spaces, until we left, the experience was excellent. read more

See all

Hey everyone!!! The Liberty diner is back!!!!! (Not that it ever physically went anywhere but for a short time the quality did). Ive been coming here for over 28 years now and I'm very happy to update my reviews of the famous Liberty diner. A Catskills landmark besides the good ole Miss Monticello Diner. Apparently their old chef is back. So now the ribs, the chicken, and the fries are all delicious once again. Something to look forward to when I'm in town. I just wish they would bring back the salad bar one day but I'll still eat here either way. Easy access from Rt. 17 exit 100 at the end of the exit ramp. read more

Went in for the famous (prime rib) first attempt was a well done cut of meat ..took a while for replacement they left the side plate of * broccoli, potatoe,and shrimp ... * to set on table while replacement was being prepared...came out as basically another steak ...had to ask waitress to micro the sides come to find out the cook has no idea how to serve prime rib at all I got it to go and threw it In dumpster $32 of waste never again! read more

Liberty Diner - That's right I didn't touch the sides while waiting 10-12 mins for the next side of meat u heat in broiler....wow - Diners Near Me - Liberty, New York

A little off kilter. Seems like kind of a local legend. Seems like there are local characters hanging out in there. Ladies playing mahjong etc. But staff was nice, portions were large and food was pretty good. read more

I always loved the Liberty Diner. Food was good. Most of the wait staff very accommodating. Now, recently, I don't know what's happening. I went for breakfast before work last week. After 40 minutes, still no food. I had to walk out and go to work without breakfast. Then I went in another morning. Supposedly they open at 7:00. It was 7:15 and they were just turning on the lights and stove not on. Fortunately Casi's Diner is right down the street. Food was great and the waitress is a doll. I know the owner of the Liberty Diner, I forget his name, who I never see there anymore, would never run a business that way. I guess Casi's has earned my business now. read more

I came in here for breakfast after seeing Steely Dan play the night before at Bethel Woods (where Woodstock was). This is a classic, old-school diner in every sense of the word. The outdoors architecture was fascinating. Inside there were photographs and other memorabilia from the local community. As I recall, the diner has been owned by a local Greek family for many years. The people eating there seemed to be mostly regulars, which is a good sign. As I recall I got an omelette, some hash browns, and some orange juice. The total came to $21.92. The meal was very good, no complaints. The service was quick and friendly. Keep up the good work. read more

Amazing Dinner food! Friendly staff. My most favorite dish is the chicken pot pie come hungry they give you a generous amount of food.

Easter morning...A wonderful Greek Omelet with fresh spinach and tomato n feta cheese. Crispy homefries and rye toast. Fabulous... read more

Liberty Diner - Diners Near Me - Liberty, New York

Fabulous! Quick service and good food! Love the old diner feel. Merry Christmas, our server was excellent given he's working on a holiday. Thank you! read more

Liberty Diner - Diners Near Me - Liberty, New York

Been there many times, always good. This time was not. Ordered a greek salad for $15. got a small side salad instead. You need to do better Sorry read more

One of the best diners I've been at in a while. Better than my local diner. Everything was great and the service was wonderful. Saw the sign from rte 86. So glad I so glad I did. Even the wine was good. read more

Good food, friendly staff and good prices. Everything is always fresh. Easy parking too.

I ordered chicken and waffles and it was awful ,the chicken breast was overly breaded and greasy,tha waffle was ok . Chicken and waffles is supposed to be real chicken pieces like legs wings thighs and such .Not worth the price and there was no seasoning.UGGH. read more