Do you like really good, homemade, fresh salsa? Do you fiend for tantalizing tacos? For juicy…read moresteak? Have you never met a burrito you didn't love? Then don't sleep on Burrito Bay. The food is very delicious. The service is excellent. The consistency of quality across the board is impressive. One indicator of this is that Burrito Bay is the only burrito joint I will DoorDash from, content in the knowledge that everything I asked for will be on my burrito. That alone demonstrates an exceptional attention to detail -- a fine skill that takes commitment to quality, and that can seem like a lost art in this slap-it-together society. Their salsa is exceptional; we're talking real-deal, homemade salsa filled with that sunshine-taste trinity of cilantro, onion, and fresh lemon, not to mention the juicy and fresh tomatoes. Whatever you do -- get the salsa, and plenty of it. It's chunky and tasty and one of the most authentic salsas I've had. I love the steak burrito with rice (I recommend the Mexican rice option), black beans, shredded cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, black olives, onions, and of course, plenty of that mouthwatering salsa. I pay a little extra and have them add the fajita peppers and onions, which make for a very tasty addition. The steak is delish. I do takeout and have not dined in, but the dining area is clean and pleasant, and the staff members are friendly and very intent on providing excellent customer service.
My dining experience at Burrito Bay last week left me with the distinct impression that they're providing some of the very best food, and easily one of the very best fast casual dining experiences, in Western New York. Certainly there are plenty of other restaurants that may be more authentic, but the salsa is the real deal here, and everything I've ever ordered has been memorable, fresh, and crave worthy. They seem to have a lot of young, athletic, male customers, and that demographic generally tracks with good eats, and generous portions at a mostly fair price. My recent visit/recent steak burrito compelled me to write this review. I feel it's really important to recognize the good stuff that remains in this world, and this restaurant is one of the places where they're still serving just that.