If you're a coffee Lover This is the place to go. It's an eclectic atmosphere with a hometown feel, This is where the locals go that says it all. The barista Ella was very friendly and accommodating and worthy of our appreciation in tips $$. Thanks Ella for your patience and your smile ~Drifter read more

I got an iced coffee post lunch here while visiting Mystic with my husband and sister. The interior is super cool, lots of stuff to look at and some indoor seating as well. The staff were nice too. read more

See all

Lamplighter Trading is a pretty cool space selling antiques, records, coffee, and some breakfast sandwiches. They are located in downtown Mystic. I have passed by here many times in the past, today was my first time getting a coffee. The man working here, I'm pretty sure is the owner, as he is the same man pictured on their company's website. He was not at all pleasant, a bit standoffish to be honest. I just got an iced coffee. This coffee was pretty weak in its flavor profile. It might be worthy trying something else from here. Unfortunately my experience was a let down this time. read more

See all

Such a fun, unexpected little spot in Mystic that's the exact opposite of all the other shops in the area. Rather than being nautical & sea focused, this shop takes on a more rustic, antique feel. They have food options and brew some yummy, delish teas right at the counter. Stop in and have some tea steep, and look around at all the bits and bobs lying about. read more

See all

The place has a lot of charm, so I would love to be able to recommend it. But my regular brewed coffee was almost $6...for plain black coffee. Can't go back, and can't recommend it. read more

Love the vibe here: very eclectic, part hippy, part coffee shop part Mystic Connecticut. Ordered an iced tea and an iced coffee. Both very good with moderate prices. Service was friendly and efficient- even on a busy holiday weekend. read more

Lamplighter Trading - Inside - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Mystic, Connecticut

See all

This is a very cool and cozy coffee shop full of history and antiques. The reggae music added to the great vibe while sipping my coffee on a rainy May morning. read more

Love the ambience and the coffee! One of my favorite places in the world! Discovered it while visiting mystic for the week last year and looking forward to the experience again this year! read more

I didn't even get to try the food or coffee because when I walked in with my family, the staff was too busy chatting with obvious regulars to care about us. When the man they were chatting with noticed, he turned and said, "Do you have to use the bathroom?" Turned back to the tattooed man with long hair and the woman with brown hair, said "do they have to use the bathroom?" And neither employee bothered to address us before carrying on in conversation with this man. When I finally spoke up and asked for service, both employees looked at me like I was being rude for interrupting. The woman told me they were out of the coffee I came in for, then promptly turned back to the other conversation. On their website they say that they prioritize their community-- well hi, I was a local looking for a good local brew. Really happy I wound up at Mystic Chocolate Cafe down the street instead, so I guess the horrible service and overall pretentious ambiance actually did me a favor. The general vibe in there was unwelcoming, very "Portland in Connecticut" and I would not recommend. read more

I am so happy that Lamplighter is in town. As a former Green Marble super fan, I was really sad to see it go. Having stopped by Lamplighter a few times now, I can confidently say that they are the perfect fit to take over the space! It is so cozy and welcoming inside - you just want to sit and hang for a while. Their coffee is great and the service is top notch. When it comes to Mystic, it is hard to find spots that feel more like home than a tourist attraction. Lamplighter is that new spot for me. I can't wait to come back again soon! read more

Eclectic vibes...delish coffee and sandwiches...fair prices...fine human- beings running the place...a true coffee shop to get inspired or come in from the cold (probably one of the last authentic ones left.) read more

Modern coffee served in a cafe from another era. Felt like the kind of place where you could debate philosophy with a stranger, like a cafe from 19th century France. They had a lot of cribbage boards on the tables, were playing jazz, and it felt like I could explore this small space for hours. Had an outstanding cold brew the...owner?...said that he had blended himself. It was fantastic and super satisfying. Rich and balanced, with a ton of flavor and sweetness. I savored it as long as I could. We talked coffee quite a bit, and he really knew his stuff. And he was brewing a batch of Ugandan coffee, so while the cold brew is all I had, clearly they have other good stuff too. It's on a fun strip with a cool record store next door. read more

Best pour over I've ever had--super smooth and chocolatey! The staff were cordial and funny, and the eclectic decor and antique items of the store gave the spot the comforting feeling of your grandparent's attic. Loved the nostalgia! read more

Bagel was delicious and organic coffee to go for our trip!! Thanks for the cool vibe, cool music, and good food/drink. read more

See all

Coffee was okay. Asked for a latte and the guy behind the counter with long hair and a mustache was rude af. To my suprise this coffee shop only sold hot or iced coffee..... read more

Has a wonderful and almost rustic atmosphere inside, with fast service and friendly staff, my only complaint is that the menu is somewhat lacking in items but I still think that this is very much worth visiting. read more

What an amazing find - the best sandwiches. We'll definitely be back next time we visit Mystic. Thanks.

The only reason I'm giving this four stars is because they don't carry decaf. I wasn't able to try the coffees but I did enjoy going in and looking around at the items that they had for sale. It's really a lovely location and the shop is beautiful. I wish I could drink caffeine because I would have loved to have tried the coffee there. It smells so so good read more

See all

While at Mystic we were walking to that place to get some tea and maybe a sandwich when I witnessed a worker man with tattoos and long hair chaises away two teenagers who sat at the table outside with their drinks. They had 3 tables that were absolutely empty, no customers inside or outside. He was so rude and negative that I decided not to patronise such unfriendly rude place read more

Down an alley and unless you're looking for it or know it's there you won't find this place. The coffee was good, not incredible. One thing that was nice is that the coffee machine didn't work for a few so the barista only charged us for 1 coffee instead of two. read more

See all

This coffee and tea shop has a cool vibe. Unfortunately the machine was not working for my latte but it eventually came around and the staff was very nice about it. Would like to see a few more options but a nice place to relax over a cup. read more

See all

On a run for work and saw the bagel sign so I stopped in and was blown away. Best bagel of my life. Thanks guys!!! read more

Lamplighter Trading - Best bagel ever - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Mystic, Connecticut

I keep trying to support local coffeeshops and keep getting disappointed. Another warm milkshake filled to the brim with milk instead of my cappuccino order. If your baristas aren't properly trained to make your specialty coffee drinks, take them off your menu. Back to Starbucks I go... read more

Wanted to support a local shop. Came with 2 kids and 2 adults to get 4 bagels, 2 coffees. Walked out after a minute of being talked down to by someone behind the counter who had a comment for how we were dressed and the fact that my wife had a bottle of water in her hand. Was pretty sad of a person. I hope it was the owner because if I hired someone who went out of his way to turn away business I would be livid. P.S. we chose to walk away without saying anything (as he continued to laugh with another customer behind our back). We held in our comments about his try-hard hipster clothes and facial hair straight out of a methadone clinic. Just go to Sift, no reason to visit this place. read more

Visiting from indiana and found this cute little coffee shop! Very unique, very good coffee. read more

Lamplighter Trading - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Mystic, Connecticut

Finally a place in mystic I can just get a good ol' sandwich, pickle and chips with no bullshit attached.

I took my family here twice in one week because we enjoyed it so much. The staff was friendly and welcoming. We were thrilled to find cribbage boards and decks of cards and this is the type of place where you could play a game with a stranger and leave with a new friend. Delicious coffee, fresh bagels, and indoor and outdoor seating. The tables are first come first served but we didn't have a problem getting seats either time we went. My nephew recommends the everything bagel with veggie cream cheese, and his 13 year old brother enjoyed the PB&J sandwich. Its a small menu but there was something for everyone, with a classic coffee house feel. It's a must see in Mystic. read more

I'm all about atmosphere and couldn't figure out what was going on when I walked in. Was never greeted upon entering and felt a weird vibe so we walked out. read more

Absolutely horrendous. Rude rude rude staff. Don't waste your money. Coffee was terrible. So disappointing

The shop has a lot of interesting knickknacks for purchase, which was fun to browse while waiting for our coffee. The barista was knowledgeable and friendly. We literally turned down an alley just to see what was down there and stumbled across this place. It's easy to walk by if you're not looking, but worth it to look for it. read more

very good food. underrated and very impressive! The shop itself was a very cool theme and the bagels were very good. highly recommend

It was so bad, I wanted to give it zero stars. Alas, the lowest I can rate it is one. The line of two people in front of me took approximately 45 minutes. I ordered a coffee. The man working was rude and made me feel uncomfortable as a customer in the store. The coffee I received after patiently waiting, was not even what I had ordered. If you're looking for a place that has quality coffee or quality service, I reccomend looking elsewhere. Such a waste of time and money. read more

Number 9 bagel sandwich was great, well worth it, lots of fresh veggies, avocado, etc. Great service. Keep up good work!

Love this new shop! It has so many cool treasures and art that I would actually have in my own house! Great service and coffee, It's the perfect addition to the neighborhood. read more

It's really exciting to have a coffee shop take the place of the iconic Green Marble. It's also really exciting to have a place in town that finally sells bagels! This is proudly stated on their chalkboard at the top of the alley so we were very happy to support this new local business. That being said, imagine my shock when we ordered 3 bagels- not toasted- no toppings- just "as is" in a bag to go and were charged...$16.00 (this included tax) For 3 bagels! I could go on to say what $16.00 could buy at other places in town but it's not necessary. So disappointed. read more