My wife and I were brought into a busy back room with nice lighting, were seated and served cordially. We split the arugula salad which was simply arugula in a bowl with grated Parmigiano Reggiano cheese. We dressed the salad ourselves with oil and balsamic vinegar, both of mediocre quality and wished that we had some more acid to add. It wouls also have been nice with some ripe, fresh tomatoes. The arugula was of decent quality but not particularly rich and wonderful: a hint of pepperiness, a hint of bitter, sort of low in flavor. Still, it was good enough and we were not there for the salad... We both ordered the bone-in ribeye with fried potatoes. Classic. Mine came a punto, as asked, my wife's came rare (she ordered medium-well). The waiter gladly brought her steak back for more grilling. Still doing okay. But my steak was strangely not pleasant. Argentine meat is not as tender as meat found elsewhere, so I was expecting more chew but I could hardly even cut my steak without applying body-weight pressure. The fatty rind had hardened almost to the texture of bone as the steak had been over-aged and it all needed to be removed (typically the most delicious part of a rib eye). And the meat itself was really low in flavor. An aged steak should be rich and wonderful. I asked for chimichurri and the waiter rushed to get me some. He returned with a thimble full of sauce that lacked garlic, spice, and salt. It was like adding a splash of vinegar and oil to the steak. I asked for more and our waiter gladly provided two more thimbles of flavorless sauce to add to the flavorless meat. The fried potatoes were okay, a bit oily, but good quality potatoes with nice flavor and good exterior crunch with a soft middle. I did not care for the salsas that are provided for dipping but the fries were nice and salty which worked fine. When my wife's steak was returned, it was charred on the outside, Pittsburgh-style, and medium inside. Good enough... But her steak was so fatty and also so tough that she asked me to help her carve it up. After removing the rind and some truly enormous zones of gluey fat, she was finally able to swallow her first mouthful of meat. With a look of repulsion on her face, she turned to me and said, "I cannot believe how salty this is." I tried a piece and it was inedibly over-salted. We both like salty foods. We eat meat sparingly and were looking forward to this splurge. It was truly a let-down.
If La Cabrera was a neighborhood joint that was easy to get into and inexpensive parilla with great ambiance, then the delicious Cab Franc, passable salad and decent potatoes accompanied by helpful service would have earned La Cabrera 3 stars despite the disappointing meat. But tough, overly fatty, over-salted, over-aged, wrongly cooked steaks at a place touted as one of the best parillas in all of Bs As knocks this experience down to a disappointing 2 stars. We tried Don Julio the next night and had a 4-star experience there. Better ambiance, better service, better steaks, better chimichurri, same prices. Still had to send back one of the steaks from our party of 4 though. read more