My experience with Irish pubs is long and diverse, so I had to try this new one. I gave it plenty…read moreof time to settle in. Still it's hard to say anything positive. Well, fparking and access are good. The name is cute. The tables and chairs were clean. It may be the loudest room I have ever tried to eat in. I usually don't like big tvs everywhere, but since conversations were impossible, I read the screen through dinner. The meat was okay. Although serving size was inconsistent. The mashed potatoes looked like they had been on the plate long enough to form a skin. They were very pasty. Vegetables were canned and not rinsed of the canning liquid. So they were slimy with a garbage like smell. We were given a bread plate but no bread or roll or butter. They stock a lot of beers which seem a little higher priced than other area places. The bath room was okay if you don't touch the rusty waste basket. It had more of the pub decor-wooden ad signs screwed to the wall. There was a toilet, sink and very thin toilet paper. As others have mentioned, service was slow. If we could have chatted,I might have noticed less. Our waitress was very pleasant.

We arrived before 6 pm and were seated promptly! The staff were friendly and helpful! The Pub…read moreatmosphere is nice and on Tuesday they had live music- which was very nice! The beer was cold, the server was friendly and the food was good. Our visit exceeded our expectations based on some of the negative reviews. Stop by and raise a glass!

Great food and service, our server Joe T was excellent and attentive…read more Great sports bar/ pub atmosphere

A little loud but lots of family activity! I'm a lobster hound (see pics...my husband calls me…read moreDarryl Hannah in Splash) The lobster was perfect and the corn and mashed potatoes... delish! Hubs ordered the lobster Mac and cheese and loved it. We had a great server, Hannah. She was a great server! We will be back!!

TRIED TO GO HERE TWICE AND THEY SAID BECAUSE I HAVE AN OUT OF STATE ID I CANT ENTER. mind you it's…read moresummer here on the cape so it's all tourists visiting. BUT SINCE I AM VISITING FROM FLORIDA I CANT GO IN??? They ask me to provide a second form of id like passport or birth certificate, I have never in my life been asked to do that at a bar, MIND YOU A DIVE BAR. Absolute insanity. Not only that but the bouncers were horrible, mean, disrespectful, AND HOMOPHOBIC. My straight white male friend was allowed in easily but when it comes to me (a gay man) and my friend (a girl) we were denied and asked for a second form. if you're reading this DO NOT GO TO Grumpys. worst place ever. would love to chat with the owner. could rate negative stars if possible.

The ambiance is we don't believe in cleaning - really disgusting floors etc…read more Food - I couldn't eat near all the dust and grime Service - rude

Fun happening bar. Great atmosphere. Delicious summer vegetable salad. I would come again.read more

Mikey was awesome! We sat at the bar to eat and drink prior to wandering over to the piano room. We…read morehad a great time talking to Mikey and he did a wonderful job serving us. We had many meals during our extended stay in Nantucket and this was one of the best. Tye scallops over fresh pasta were to die for! I lived the espresso martinis as well.

Good pub experience with a solid beer list. The appetizers we had were good as well. When in the…read morearea I will definitely be stopping in.

I got to meet Flynn and he was nice and very funny and if my friend, also I met captain gutt he…read moresang to me: "Here you are on a boat, you're adrift, you're afloat. One might even say you're stuck. Well I don't want to gloat, but I would like to note that you're in luck. You've been saved by the ape that rules these waters. So forget about your wives and daughters! " Then his crew (Shira, Gupta, Flynn and others) sang: "Aye, Aye, Captain Gutt. He's a big scary, elegant yet hairy, fear inspiring, years till retiring, looting, stealing, banana peeling! Undisputed master seas!" I'm a primate pirate pioneer and these are my brave buccaneers, All of whom were once lost souls like you. Chorus: It's true! Gupta: He rescued us! Squint: He saved our butts! Shira: For that we owe our lives to Gutt and assuming he doesn't kill you... Chorus: You will owe him too! Captain: Kill them? laughs Me? No, no. Well, at least not this very large, useful mammoth. Manny: Hey, hands off! Captain: Anyway, here we are on a ship, moving at quite a clip, through the ever-shifting ice. Shira: Come along, on a trip. Flynn: That's a hint! Squint: That's a tip! Silas: That's good advice! Shira and Captain Gutt: In a world that's going under, to survive you must learn to plunder. Captain Gutt: Luckily, that's my field of expertise. Shira: He's the best. Squint and Flynn: He's a robbing, thieving... Diego: We really should be leaving... Raz: Weapon-throwing... Manny: We gotta get going... Squint: Sloth-slaying... Sid: Uh, wish we could be staying... Chorus: Undisputed, uncontested, monkey-suited... Captain: Yeah, you guessed it. Chorus: Master of the Seas! Manny: Oh, please. Captain: That's me! Chorus Tis' he! Captain: That's me! Chorus: Tis' he! Captain: It's who? Shira: Tis' you! Capitain: Just testing, I knew. It's me! Flynn: Good shanty, sir! CAPTAIN GUTT AND FLYYN WERE THE BEST PEOPLE EVER!!!!!!

The four of us ventured here for dinner - and after enjoying the atmosphere, loving the courteous…read moreand accommodating service and the delicious menu offerings, we wondered how come we haven't been here before! The Olde Inne has been here "forever" and we're just discovering it now? My buddy and I started with the Irish Guinness. Flavorful and lighter than the typical drought. As appetizers we shared the Farmhouse (potato) Skins and the Fried Fish Bites. Yummy for both of these treats! As the main - he opted for the Corned Beef Reuben, I, the Fish and Chips. The Honey chose the Pan Seared Scallops while the Buddy's wife, the Baked Haddock. Everything was excellent. Well plated, well cooked and presented. An excellent experience and a great meal. We will all be coming back very soon!

Driven by several times, glad we found time to come in post Christmas weekend. Bustling authentic…read moreIrish pub with low wood ceilings, welcoming staff, and great Irish food and Guinness. Fish n chips and shepherds pie were delightful between the brick fireplace and cozy bar. Very nice trad music and rock band on a Saturday night. Happy to have found it and will without a doubt be back.

Quite a change from the old Starlight…read more Creative, well executed small plates and main dishes. Beef tartare was excellent, and the Tuna Sashimi Bowl hit the spot as well. Service was solid and prompt; the overall "price/value" relationship is arguably the only fly in the ointment...fine dining pricing in a "bar style" atmosphere, even by Nantucket standards. Will come again, though.

My wife and I were excited to try this place. She ordered the crab rangoons were actually very…read moregood. My wife ordered a raspberry drink and it was terrible. I ordered the Korean short ribs and the sauce smelled so offensive that my wife asked to leave before I could finish 3 short ribs. One water, one alcoholic drink, one order of short rib appetizers, and one order of 4 crab rangoons= $76.00. Do yourself a favor and get 4 bags of chips from the liquor store not far from there. I wanted it to be awesome- it just wasn't. The young lady that served us knew we were not happy, and her service was good. We still tipped her well, the food was not her fault.

Actually shocked to see this place with only 3 stars on here. It's one of the best restaurants…read morewe've been to on the island in our multiple trips to Nantucket. In my opinion, easily a top 5 restaurant on the island. The menu has so many items I wanted to try that I'm definitely going to need to go back! The menu has great variety ranging from sushi, to pastas, to steak. So many good starter options- we had the Town roll, tuna tar tar, and the mussels (red sauce). All 3 were excellent! We then shared the shrimp scampi... Also excellent! A person seated next to us had the Bolognese and it looked amazing as well. Our server was knowledgeable and efficient. Seemed like a good guy although he could have been a bit more personable. The place was very busy and he was working hard so it's totally understandable. Will absolutely go back to Town every time we visit Nantucket.

We were wandering around town. The bar outside unfortunately did not have any seats so we ended up…read moregoing up the steps to Town. We were greeted right away by the bartender. He told us he had been watching "spritz videos" and wanted to try to make the "spritz of the day" he had just watched. So we agreed. It had a lot of herbs in (wish i paid more attention to what was in it) we got to talking with other customers and the bartender. He had spent some time in iowa playing hockey. The women's bathroom had a large door that spung open, a waiter opened it for me as I approached, definitely made me feel important. We were just there for a drink before our dinner plans so we settled up and went on our way.

The last time we went to The Common Pub for dinner, someone told us that a new cocktail place had…read moreopened just across the street. Well, a new place that specializes in craft cocktails is right up my alley. We walked across, found the door, and entered. I was really impressed with the interior space. It was cool and dark. Lots of places to sit with a small bar area where everything is made. The cocktail book is large and has a variety of offerings for every palate. The bartenders were very helpful to our friends who are new to craft cocktails. They stick with vodka martinis. I started with a paper plane, which was very well-made. I then tried one of their specials, the Fig Leaf Old Fashioned, which was fabulous. Everyone had a fabulous time, and we will definitely be back to try some of the Absinthe recipes. I hope my fellow Yelpers support a new cocktail place. We need more of them.

We love coming to O'Brien + Brough when we're home visiting!…read more Great date night spot or meeting up for classy drinks with friends. We've been here a few times and my drinks are always on point. The Clover Club Punch is one of my favorites. It's a great spot with friendly staff in an awesome location.

Really cute and cozy breakfast spot with a lot of character. The walls are covered with patches and…read morememorabilia from police and fire departments from all over New England, which gives the place a unique, old-school Cape Cod feel. The portions here are huge. We tried a few different breakfast dishes, including the Irish breakfast and a potato cake Benedict. Everything was hearty, filling, and came out looking great. I especially liked the potato cakes. Crispy on the outside and a nice change from the usual English muffin you get with eggs Benedict. The Irish breakfast is definitely the move if you want to try a little bit of everything. You get eggs, multiple meats, toast, and plenty of food to keep you full for most of the day. Overall, great food, generous portions, and a fun atmosphere that feels different from your typical breakfast spot. Definitely worth checking out if you're on the Cape.

Came on a rainy morning and was seated right away. Our…read morewaitress came right over for drinks. We then ordered shortly thereafter. Place was decorated adorably with lots of Celtic decor. It had a laid back, homey feel. Great for families. My husband got the brisket, home fries and eggs with brown bread. I got the keltic fry with eggs and the different meats. His brisket was outstanding! And the Guinness mustard... I could drink it! His eggs were fluffy and cooked perfectly. My dish was fantastic. The Irish sausage was my favorite thing. The eggs were cooked perfectly and everything was flavorful. We would definitely come back!