Wings were amazing! Whoever answers the phone needs training in customer service. Delivery driver was very friendly read more

Used to live in Lewiston, NY then moved to the Syracuse, NY area several years ago. Loved Joey's Pizzeria and when back in the area stopped in with family and friends. I so miss this place. Best pizza, wings and the steak and cheese sub was to die for. Wish they could deliver to me in Central NY, LOL. Will go back again when I'm in the area. Will not disappoint you, if you have a chance to check it out. read more

Been coming to Joeys for years. Reliable food and service. It's my families favorite Buffalo pizza. Definitely worth the drive. read more

Joey's Pizzeria - Updated menu - Pizza Near Me - Niagara Falls, New York

Great big wings and delicious pizza!! the biggest wings we've ever had on a takeout order in their delicious. I would highly recommend this place for their pizza and their wings so good plus, I had their fish fry, which was also fresh and delicious on Fridays. read more

Staff needs a friendly course , no smiles and a "Thank you" would be nice.Pizza has little or no sauce or oregano and has a flat taste.Wings are a little small but cooked to order. Felt like I was imposing on the staff. read more

Pizza, wings and a steak and cheese sub were excellent. Awesome barmaid, friendly and helpful. Highly recomend

Steak and cheese subs are wonderful, always consistent! Great service! Pizza is highly recommended by many including my husband. Clean place . Cons : They don't serve alcohol , just beer and wine. read more

Excellent pizza, great flavor and excellent prices. Very pleasant staff, and quick service. My little girl loved their pizza .

I ordered their small pizza, and double order of wing special ($20.35+ tax) I enjoyed the wings, they were nice and crispy and not greasy. As for the pizza, it was ok. I really can't put my finger on it, but I thought it was just ok. Maybe it was the sauce, or even the crust. But for a lunch special, it hit the spot. read more

Joey's Pizzeria - a pepperoni pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Niagara Falls, New York

See all

We got some takeout from here Saturday. We had a small pizza with pepperoni mushrooms and black olives. We also got ten wings. Wings were very good crispy and right amount of seasoning. The pizza was also good and we were happy with our choice. read more

Joey's Pizzeria - Small pizza with pepperoni mushrooms and black olives - Pizza Near Me - Niagara Falls, New York

See all

alright, so first things first, the pizza was great. but the service was kind of a joke. let me explain. we stopped here for lunch before heading to Niagara Falls after reading a random guide online. when we got there, only two other guys were there for lunch & wrapping it up, leaving minutes after we sat. we sat ourselves as told by the man behind the counter. we realized after a few minutes of no menus or service, we needed to order at the counter (no big deal, we were happy to). we ordered & waited. & waited. & waited. drinks arrived at the table, but it was a while after ordering. the pizza arrived 20-30 mins after ordering. we had to ask for plates. then go behind the bar for silverware (so we could cut a few of the pieces smaller for our toddlers). it just felt like the staff forgot about us (which is hard to do when the place is so small & only had us as customers). was the pizza great? yes. would i go back? probably not since there are other pizzerias. would i recommend to friends? no, due simply to the lack of service. this is probably a fantastic place if you're a local & the manager knows you, but for visitors, we felt forgotten & like we were an inconvenience. read more

Do not eat here if you want to avoid an extremely aggressive and easily agitated owner. To start, I've never even left a review of any business on any platform- but my experience at Joey's Pizzeria recently is enough to change that. I'm a now former long-time customer, and have been getting pizza from them since I was probably 8 years old. The other day, I placed a delivery order for a half tray with cheese, sweet peppers, and onions, my usual. Unfortunately it showed up with pepperoni on it. I've been a vegetarian for 15 years, and couldn't eat it if I wanted to. This was not the problem. I wasn't even upset, it was a mild inconvenience. But, when I called to inform them about the mistake, the guy instantly got angry. He said he is the owner and took my order personally, that my phone was breaking up when I placed the order (it was not, he had no trouble hearing me when I placed it and never indicated ANYTHING to suggest that he did), claimed he read the order back to me (he certainly did not, three people in the room when I placed the order can confirm). But regardless of both of those facts, he didn't acknowledge even the possibility that the mistake was theirs. That he may have misheard "sweet -peppers-" as "pepperoni". An easy enough mistake to make, and one that I wouldn't even be bothered by, but the way he spoke to me was HIGHLY aggressive, accusatory, and not becoming of the owner of a business. All he could do was communicate how annoyed he was. Certainly not deserving of my business any further. The food here is okay, service has been generally okay until now, but just expect that if they happen to make a mistake, you will quite likely be blamed and treated poorly as a result. From what I read, this is not uncommon. Better options for pizza both in terms of taste and service are available in the Falls. Consider that before going here. read more

This is owned by my uncle "Jailbird Joey." He obviously didn't get any help from Marty and Doc because the pizza doesn't do it for me at all. Yes, it's dirt cheap and pretty large in size (the slice) and I appreciate that, but what I didn't appreciate was that it was given to me lukewarm. But hey, I could have taken it home and reheated it myself except for the interesting fact that it was totally congealed and had clearly been sitting out forever and a day. Even had it not been congealed, I could tell from the flavour and texture that it wouldn't have been one of my fave slices (by a long shot), especially not in a town with Mr. Ventry's and Pizza Oven. However, as it is a family business, cheap, and with generous sizes, 3 stars is good. read more

Joey's Pizzeria - Owned by your uncle Jailbird Joey - Pizza Near Me - Niagara Falls, New York

See all

Sunday night at 9:30pm and there are not a lot of options in this town to have a beer and a cooked meal. We stopped into another establishment, but they closed early--not nice. These guys were open and the bartender greeted us with a smile. We ordered the half tray with 20 wings (half charBBQ, recommended by him, and half medium) for $28. We had to wait quite a while for the food to come, but he gave us the wifi password so that helped pass the time and do some Yelping. ;) The place isn't that big, but it's pretty clean and friendly. There was a TV playing Sunday night football. We were able to snag a high table by the front window which was nice. The staff here are pretty loud, singing to the music playing, but it's not irritating. Other guests were decent and respectful, so you felt at home. When the pizza and wings arrived we were a little disappointed, especially with the pizza, it was overcooked with some black burnt edges. The crust was so hard I felt I might break a tooth! We mentioned it to the server/bartender and he offered to make a new one. But really, at 10:30 at night do we really want to wait another 30 minutes for a new pizza?--no thanks. I would have expected that he at least knock a few bucks off the bill, but nope. The wings were a good size and crispy, but the CharBBQ wings didn't have enough sauce on them. read more

See all

We ordered 20 wings for takeout and they gave us all drums (only 3 flats) ..The subs were good (no complaints on those) but we got screwed out of flats which was disappointing when it's over 1$ per wing these days. read more

Joey's Pizzeria - chicken wings in a plastic container - Pizza Near Me - Niagara Falls, New York

Both the food and service were really good. The prices are very reasonable and we very much enjoyed our visit.

Joeys is always on point, pizza, wings, subs, and the guys always take good care of me, can't beat the prices compared to everywhere else asking what they are, fast, hot and fresh every time I've ordered for pick up or delivery. read more

Great family atmosphere and terrific pizza. True New York pizza at a great price. We got two large pies, one cheese and the other pepperoni and paid a little over $34. We then got a 2 liter sprite for $3 and drank well throughout our meal. All 4 of us got full and had plenty of soda. The pizza came out fresh and was tasty. Had the right amount of sauce, cheese, oil, ect. Thanks for the great food and service! I would say I'll be coming back but I'm visiting from Arizona. I'm originally from Queens, NYC so I know what good NY pizza is and I approve of this place. They took about a half an hour to make both our pies fresh. We called ahead of time so by the time we got there we didn't have to wait for long. Great spot! read more

Best pizza in the falls! Pizza was ovened perfect! Good price and delivery was on point!!!! read more

Joey's Pizzeria - Best pizza in niagara falls; - Pizza Near Me - Niagara Falls, New York

Joey's is the worst. I stopped using them months ago because of their inability to foul through with a proper order. I gave them a chance today after another local restaurant was not available and they screwed it up. As always, to make things worse, they insulted me by calling me a liar and ordering improperly. They suck. On top of that their food is average at best and not cheap. Never again read more

This was my first visit to Joey's, and it will not be my last. The place is someplace I would have frequented in my younger days. It is a small joint, with a bar, but is clean and pretty inviting. It has a handful of tables, and the staff seemed like nice, regular people. We got simple stuff; a cheese pizza and wings, and they were great. The pizza was what I would call New York style, done right. A not-too-thin crust, fit for folding the large, delicious slice, with a great sauce. Lemme tell ya, the sauce is not too sweet, with just the right spice. The wings were also perfect. We asked for medium and crispy, and we got it. On a side note, I heard from a couple of regulars to try a sub there too. They said they were the best in town, so that will be next. I am thinking if you want a great pizza and some wings to go with it, this is a place for you. read more

The pizza is delicious the crust is not burnt and it's crunchy but not to crunchy the sauce is great it's sweet and not really sweet and just great if ur looking for pizza this is the place it's looks really ice inside and the old school look is really cool and bring out the cool vibe of a pizza place the outside looks really weird but trust me it's nice inside and the food there is great they have pizza, wings, subs,and more so go there if ur looking for a place to get pizza. REALLY GOOD FOOD. read more

Joey's Pizzeria - Delicious pizza - Pizza Near Me - Niagara Falls, New York

Cup and char, always great. Pizza, wings and subs. Still very fair prices when everyone else is raising theirs.

I loved Joeys pizza!!! I would always get a tray with wings- perfect western NY meal. I got a tray and wing special today (Dec. 27th) and there was multiple hairs found throughout the pizza. One hair can be overlooked but multiple hairs is absolutely disgusting! I will never go back there again- it really makes me leery of there quality control and cleanliness in the kitchen. read more

Been eating Joey's Pizza since I was a child. Same old reliable taste. A Delicious cheese and pepperoni pizza slice that everyone should love. read more

I read a lot of mixed reviews of this place - however , from my experience- this place was great. The food was delicious- ask for the pizza sub. The price was great and the beer cheap. The atmosphere and interior wax significantly better than I expected. I highly recommend this local pizza joint. read more

the guy was extremely rude. I asked for four blue cheeses, when he brung out two i asked for two more. he then slammed them on the counter and ran to the back and said "i didn't think you'll be doing all of this i'm charging your card again" because he had to get blue cheeses????? what a guy, horrible customer service read more

We have been going to Joey's pizza for well over 30 years. A great place to get the family together for some of the best Pizza, Wings and Steak -n-cheese subs in the area. The beer is cold and well priced too! Mark and Chris do a great job making their Father proud.... This is the only place that we get our Pizza from. read more

Went to the casino on the USA side and a nice gentlemen at the bar recommended we eat dinner at Joey's if we liked Pizza. We took his advice and are glad we did. Nice, quiet environment with a nice atmosphere. Service was very quick and friendly. Ordered a medium pie and it was delicious. Took great care of us and can't imagine going anywhere else for pizza when back in the Niagara Falls area Go here, you won't leave disappointed or hungry! read more

My wife and moved to the Niagara/Buffalo area back in May (2011) and so far the food in this area has been quite disappointing. We've tried at least 10-15 different places, possibly more, and have found maybe a 3-4 places that are actually good. Sadly, Joey's Pizzeria was not good. We'll start with the dough, or rather, some flour and water. Honestly, I don't think I've ever tasted pizza crust this bland. Then there was the sauce, which was sweet, but lacked any flavor. I wouldn't be surprised if it was tomato sauce + sugar. As for the cheese, well, cheese is hard to mess up. Even if you buy "low-end" it's still cheese at it's core. That said, not impressed. It's a shame too, we live just down the road from them. We won't be returning. read more

This place advertises it opens at 11 am but doesn't answer until approx. 11:10 & very rude. One time I called & the person answered & said: "you have to call back I just came in & can't handle it right now." Make sure you don't pay with 20 dollar bills either the person at the counter will yell about giving away all his singles. Absolutely no parking in the area and the sidewalk in front is never salted in winter. I have never seen more than 3 people in this place at one time. The person behind the counter is extremely rude & will yell (yes yell) at the drop of a hat. I will never recommend this place and will never go to this place to be humiliated again. Pizza is not bad but a little greasy not worth the belittling paying for it. read more

Great ambiance, friendly staff, and amazing food! They have high quality food for great deals, a must-try!

Food is pretty good overall . I like their subs. I just called to have food delivered. The guy here's I want a delivery , and in a snarky tone of voice he said. "well its gonna be an hour to an hour and a half" as if my wanting it delivered was a huge inconvenience. I said " ok no problem". I start to give him my order which was going to be a steak and cheese sub and chicken fingers. So he asks me for my order and I start with the steak and cheese. When he here's me say steak and cheese he says , " oh your really gonna piss this guy off". I assume he meant the cook or some other employee. I asked him " why , are you guys out of it ?? I can change my order" , and his response was " no , he's just got like 10 to do back there". At this point I just hung up. If there's 1 thing about the falls that's true ,its that there's plenty of other pizza joints to order from that are as good or better. So I called Jacos right up the road and they were very polite and professional. read more

Thought I would try some place new for pizza and wings last night instead of where I usually order'. called Joeys on buffalo avenue. I was not disappointed. Very nicely decorated inside and very clean.Pizza was ready in half hour and it was excellent. Wings were exactly as ordered and delicious!! Ill be ordering there again in the future!! read more

My family loves their pizza. It always arrives hot, delicious and they have THE best delivery service, fastest in the city.

They are horrible. I ordered four subs and they sent one wrong one. They were very rude, insisting I ordered a sausage sub when I did not. This was not the first time they f@#%ed up my order and were rude when I called! If you're smart you will not frequent this place at all! read more

Recommended by a cousin that lives in the area. Took the family. Quiet environment, tastefully decorated, and GREAT food. Most of family had pizza & wings - but I had a sub. It was terrific and owner/staff was friendly. read more

What a terrible place....as we speak been waiting 1.45 hours for.a med pizza and 10 wings..... I called 3 times...all 3 times .... he's on his way... what a joke read more