Brought my wife to Niagara Falls, had a problem with our rental car and the guy at the rental company said "I'm pretty picky about my Pizza" - I knew that he knew. So to Broadway Pizza for lunch. He said the Dill pizza is becoming a thing around here and they have a good one. Walked into a true Pizza place. Line of locals waiting to order. The lady and her husband were taking the orders each local she hit with small talk. Great variety of pizza cheese, white, mushroom & pepperoni, Dill and half a dozen others. You could pick your own topping of you wanted but with this selection come on ... Tables and wooden chairs your typical pizzeria- you are not here for the furniture. Excellent place. Oh and they were making Stromboli's as well - maybe next time. read more

This place may not look like much but the pizza is terrific. Lots of options by the slice, including a pickle and ranch slice that was awesome, as well as full pies, rolls and calzones. The owner is super friendly, too read more

Enjoyed it so much we went back a second day over a three day span. We have a lot of pizza in my hometown, but not this specific type of pizza. This kind of pizza means it's available by the slice, with a crunchy crust, and generous toppings with the right amount of cheese. It means that the slice your order is gonna be thrown back in the oven for a couple extra minutes to warm it up. It means the people behind the counter are known nonsense and expect you to know a thing or two about the product. It means replicating which you would have in Manhattan. This place gets all of the important things right, and the product is delicious. The decor is not fancy, and it's not supposed to be. This is a pizza stand and the food is what counts. I ordered the traditional white pie, as well as their barbecue chicken. Both were magnificent. If I'm ever back in town I'm definitely coming back. read more

Ok, my hairdresser and I were having a conversation about Buffalo Pizza and I made a claim that no good pizza can be found. She said you have to have Niagara Falls Pizza! She pointed me towards Broadway. Having been to NYC multiple times I was a bit reluctant. I did stop in this past Thursday during lunchtime and grabbed 2 slices, a cheese and a ricotta. First bite of the cheese, wow, the crust amazing, the sauce not Buffalo sweet incredible! I scarfed that slice pretty quickly and was very satisfied. The ricotta first bite oh wow, the crust, so good, although a bit too much ricotta I managed to polish it off. I am a fan Broadway! I will see you again soon. read more

January 2024. This is one of my favorite pizza places. The owners and family are from NYC, and the area desperately needed some good NY style pizza. Walking in, there's a showcase of pizzas with different flavors and toppings, along with some rolls, calzones, and sometimes garlic knots and more. They're fully cooked slices, and they do get heated up when you order (or you can choose not to). All pizzas are made fresh daily. Between my multiple visits here, I'm always greeted by whomever is working at the front counter. Philly Pizza 10/10 One of my top 2 favorite pizzas they have. The shaved steak combination with the melted cheese is so delicious, and when you get those peppers and mushrooms in the bite it's even better. Buffalo Chicken 10/10 My other favorite in the top 2. This Buffalo chicken pizza is one of my faves in the area. Even over wegmans! It's your typical Buffalo chicken pizza, nothing crazy to describe here. Pickle Pizza 9/10 Pickle chips with a creamy ranch drizzle. Cooking the pickles does make the saltiness come out a bit, but that's too be expected. Think of a deep fried pickle without the breading. The ranch drizzle isn't overpowering flavor wise either. A good slice. Cheese & Pep 10/10 The regular pepperoni (not cup and char). This pizza is really good. Super authentic NY style, the red sauce is a good flavor, the perfect balance between sweet and robust. The cheese is a little thinner, plenty of pepperonis, and of course all the grease you would want. read more

Good crust...skimpy on the toppings. The extra large is the same size as large in most places. Won't go back. read more

Service was friendly and efficient. Lasagna pizza was perfect! Whenever we are back in the area this will be our pizzeria of choice.

One of our goals on our Niagara trip was to get good New York style pizza. This checked that box. We got the pepperoni pizza and 20 wings. Both were very good. Thought the cheese and crust on the pizza stood out. Wings had a good crunch, really enjoyed it the blue cheese it came with. Thought for the prices were fair, we all got stuffed. The service is what stood out the most though. They were very busy with take out orders but still took time to be invested in making sure we had a good experience to cap off our trip. Worth a try for sure read more

Broadway NY Style Pizza - Mild wings and pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Niagara Falls, New York

This is the best thin crust pizza place The place has an 80s feel. Kinda like the places I grew up going to. Pay, stay, eat. Very casual. It's always the same two people there when I go there. I don't think the girl likes Canadians but she's very nice. Their machines don't like Canadian cards...just take cash. PizZa is fresh. Hot. Very thin and saucy. Flavourful. Cheesy and amazing. Only get bottled drinks. A must while passing through the Buffalo area Decor ain't fancy, so what. There's so much free parking read more

Broadway NY Style Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Niagara Falls, New York

See all

Great customer service, closed at 9:15, they were still in there, and they said come on in we have slices! Thank you! The pizza was great. And the layout of the shop is great. Highly recommend. read more

Simply still the best pizza and the calzones are amazing. Vodka sauce pasta is also extremely tasty!

Authentic, NY style pizza!! My soccer team was in New York for a game and we were craving some pizza. One of the parents had been to Broadway on a prior trip and spoke very highly of it. We called and asked if they could seat 13 of us; they said no problem. They actually started cooking our order and had a table set up and ready for us when we arrived. As a group, we stuck to the basics: a couple cheese pies, and a couple pepperoni pies. However, they have a variety of specialty pizzas to choose from as well. One guy with us tried a slice of pickle pizza and he said it was really good. You can order full pies or by the slice. I definitely had to fold my slices to eat. They were delicious. Broadway Pizza is only about 20 minutes from Niagara Falls. It is not a full sized restaurant, but they do have several tables to eat inside and you can push them together to serve a large group. Both bottle drinks and fountain drinks are available. The service was excellent; the employees very nice and accommodating. If you in the area and looking for some authentic NY style pizza, I highly recommend Broadway Pizza! read more

Broadway NY Style Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Niagara Falls, New York

Small store with limited space and good ambiance (saw many localities picking up slices and having them in parking lot in their cars) During our recent visit to Buffalo, NY, we were looking for a quick dinner and decided to try Joe's Ny Style Pizza after finding out that Broadway NY Style Pizza was closed on Tuesdays. But the reviews were great so we came to Broadway NY Style Pizza on our way back to California. Loved the pizza, we ordered 2 Cheese Pizza, one with onion topping and another w/o any topping (even sauce as wanted to avoid garlic for few family members). There so many pizzas over the counter, next time will try them by slices than whole large pizza. Lady at counter was very friendly and made special pizza w/o garlic which was great and they charged what was shown on the menu (not like Joe's NYC Style Pizza where they move convenience fees on consumer w/o letting them know) will definitely visit this place when travelling to Buffalo, NY. read more

See all

As soon as I walked into the pizzeria, the aroma of the pizza hit me, and I knew I was at the right place. Since I am not from here, I decided to try the pizzeria closest to my hotel. I was pleased to receive an immediate greeting upon entering. The menu was displayed on screens above, and everything looked enticing, including the burgers, pasta and appetizers. However, I ordered a medium pepperoni pizza, which turned out to be delicio, from the crust to the sauce! read more

This morning, I pointed at the photo of a pickle pizza slice and announced that I'll finally have it. I needed a little reward. Seeing it in person, to my surprise, the pickle slices didn't look like the picture at all. Actually it didn't even look appetizing. With a few, transparent slices of pickle smeared with a line of mayo looking sauce, it wasn't what I expected. I was ready to spin around and leave, but my partner persuaded me to try something anyway. My choice of the "mozzarella and ricotta" deluxe slice was fine. I wasn't sure whether I should use salt, because its taste was rather bland. The dough itself was with no salt at all. I used extra parmesan to spice it up. My partner's choice was much better, but what's not to like about "cheesesteak," a salty, fatty meat covered with cheese. We opted for two slices and a soda offer. The fountain diet coke/pepsi was undrinkable. It was really bad. Someone totally screwed the syrup mix and created a tasteless drink. The slices weren't particularly big. Definitely, I wouldn't call it deluxe. I didn't even bother to fold it. Actually the end flipped over because it was so thin. I'm sure there must be a lot of great items on the menu, but my experience was just ok. The person who took care of us was super nice and friendly. Unfortunately, there was also a management guy running around talking pretty loud on the phone. Possibly he thought no one would understand his conversation because of a foreign language. It wasn't pleasant. Definitely he didn't care much about customers at that point. read more

Broadway NY Style Pizza - White pie slice was tasteless. Although I enjoyed the part with ricotta. - Pizza Near Me - Niagara Falls, New York

mmhmm. Delizioso! We do mostly our groceries/shoping in this plaza (Niagara Consumers Square), but it's our first time checking out this place and the experience was good. Staffs were friendly, hardworking, and accommodating even though they're so busy (mostly on the deliveries). Food was excellent. A lot of pizza slices and other items on the menu to choose from. Hard to decide. We ordered 4 deluxe slices and 2 orders of Garlic knots. Pizza slices were huge! Perfect thin and crispy crust. The buttery, soft garlic knots are to die for (worth the 7 minutes wait). Good prices too. We will be back to try more (wanted to try their gyros). Order online and Get 10%off (first time only). Catering also available for all occasions. read more

See all

Being from NJ, we expect A LOT from our pizza. We are ALWAYS leary of "NY Style" pizza even in NY‍ Being in Niagara Falls for the weekend, we were soon famished for something to eat. We were just going to grab a Five Guys Burger, when we happened across "You've tried the rest, now try the best!" flyer from Broadway NY Style Pizza. We were there late on a Sunday evening, so the cases did not have a lot to offer. We went with plain cheese slices. Oh.my.word so good. We were very pleased to say the least. Hot, crispy, cheesy, melty goodness so far from home Thank you Broadway for being a home away from . read more

i've bought a lot a pizzas from this place the last few years because they have the most authentic NY-style pie in WNY. Unfortunately, they've seen me for the last time because there are more important things in life than pizza and one of them is staying true to your code. And part of this man's code is not doing business with ignorant people. i came into one night for some slices after having a few drinks and the woman behind the counter couldn't resist the urge to insult me. She's no doubt pissed off because God created her with the short end of the ugly stick. If i looked like her i wouldn't be happy about it either. The incident reminds of an anecdote i once heard about Winston Churchill. While celebrating at a WWII victory party, the Prime Minister of the UK overindulged and was obviously intoxicated. A woman walked up to him and said, "Sir, you are drunk." Churchill famously replied, "Yes, ma'am, I am. And you're ugly. In the morning I'll be sober." The slices sucked, too. read more

I've popped in here for a slice or two in the past, but most recently ordered a whole pie from here (Hawaiian - ham/pineapple). They were open later in the evening on a Friday in early June during COVID, so the hours are still pretty accessible on weekends. The pie took about 30 minutes from order to car. It was about $20 for a large, which was a bit on the expensive side. Delicious and worth it though. The crust was a perfect thin crust-style, delicious sauce that's not too sweet and good toppings. The most impressive part was definitely the perfect crispy crust. I wouldn't hesitate to order from here again! read more

Decent pizza. A little small for the size and a little light. Could have more cheese Definitely the best pizza option in the area read more

Perfect thin crust pizza slices at a great price. One piece is big! Very friendly people.

Wow, what a place! From the time I walked in, till the time I left, it was such a nice experience. Sam the owner, was super friendly, welcoming me to his restaurant, making some friendly small talk, describing the different pizza slices on display, and telling me when my order will be ready--this is how it's done folks! Inside, the place has an nice clean look, with clear bright menus, solid wooden chairs and tables, and lots of glass. They have a huge menu, with all kinds of specials, and many different Italian food options. Surprisingly, there are many different kinds of pizza slices (and even Stromboli) on display that are ready to eat. They put together a few different pre-made slices for us to try and boy were they flavorful; with the meat-lovers slice being my favorite. We also ordered the Large Pizza & 20 Wing combo to go, for $30+tax. The cooked-fresh Large Pepperoni pizza was excellent. You can tell Sam is from NYC, he definitely knows how to make a mean pie--chewy thin crust, lots of cheese, and tasty pepperoni, cooked perfectly. Our 20 wings were outstanding. You don't have to tell these guys to cook them "crispy" or "extra crispy" as they are already cooked with the perfect amount of crispness! We ordered the wings half Hot/half Mild, and we really enjoyed both. The Hot being just a bit on the spicy side, and the Mild with such a delicious crispy chicken taste. They even know how to box the wings perfectly, putting many holes in the tops of the styrofoam container so the wings don't go all soggy on you--what pros! Carrots, celery, and blue cheese were all very fresh. Needless to say, I think this is one of the best pizza/wing places in the area, with excellent food and outstanding customer service. These guys know what they're doing, and really care about their customers; such a pleasant surprise. read more

See all

Okay so this place is interesting. I've seen them here for about 2 or 3 years and never tried them. This last Monday my wife and I decided to try them. First impression: Walked in with three employees upfront and wasn't greeted. Second impression: Looked at the food then noticed all of the employees were standing around laughing and galavanting in a foreign language. Third impression: the food looked days old with many pies and other "Italian" items just sitting under heat lamps. Fourth impression: I wondered why there were no other customers in the shop at 8 PM. Last impression: ordered two slices of cheese and pepperoni for $8.00 bucks yes compete RIP, (but I felt bad that no one was patronizing) and it came out hard / unfold-able and was put on a greasy dollar tree plate for a to go order, WTF?? Overall lesson learned: I will never go back to a pizza joint in NY that claims to be an Italian eatery that serves old pizza and Jamaican beef Pattie's. Also why was the guy rolling new pizza dough at 8pm with no customers in sight and 15 pizzas on display?! Something is cooking up here and it's not good, AT ALL!! read more

Absolutely freaking delicious pizza. This is just what we were looking for, nice greasy New York style pizza. The kind that hangs over the plate. My shirt is ruined from Greece, but I don't care because it was so freaking good. read more

I wanna say that this location had the dopest and freshest, most legit, totally real NY style pizza! But I can't... cuz I've never been to NY. Ok ok ok... I know I'm currently (and sadly- I hate it here), living in NY, but this NY they are talking about is like NYC type of NY. And I've never been to THAT NY. More do I want to honestly. A West Texan / Californian ain't got no business in no NYC. So... I'll just get my NY slice at this NY pizza place and pretend I know what I'm talking about and say Yooooooo Son, this place is the NY truth Yo! Word is bond! Eat up! Diversify yo bonds! Wu-Tang! The Pizza is really good though read more

See all

While traveling to Niagara Falls (the falls) we stopped in Niagara Falls (the city) at Broadway Pizza. We were looking for NY Style pizza and White Pizza, in particular, and wow! it was so good. I have had NY Style Pizza in several places in upstate NY as well as various places in Manhattan and Queens and this place stacks up with the best of them with a nice thin crust and good topping choices. We liked that they have pizza by-the-slice so we could get a bunch to try (shown in one of the pictures) and all were yummy. The Philly Cheesesteak was surprisingly good, even with some American Cheese interspersed. (My son was super happy about this) and the Buffalo Chicken was not too saucy. They even had a decent Jamaican Beef Patty, which I couldn't resist trying. The folks that run it were very friendly and it was a great lunch experience for a little over $30 for four of us. read more

Broadway NY Style Pizza - Most of their pizza choices - Pizza Near Me - Niagara Falls, New York

See all

NY Style Pizza and slice shop in Niagara Falls. Quality pizza and I always recommend buying NY Style Pizza by the slice for the deck oven reheat - better crisp / char. Hard working family from Staten Island runs the show and they are dedicated to their product. The highlight on this visit was the chicken bacon ranch slice - great flavor and it did not fall apart like other pizzerias. Not pictured, but don't miss out on their rolls / calzones. They make them fresh throughout the day with a lot of variety. read more

Broadway NY Style Pizza - Pepperoni Pie - Pac-Man Style - Pizza Near Me - Niagara Falls, New York

See all

Their pizza is good but very pricey. They charge $2 extra per topping but they barely put any toppings in there. We ordered a large sausage, green pepper and onion pizza. Each slice had maybe 2 or 3 very tiny pieces of green pepper and a couple of very thinly sliced onions. It was if they used about half a handful of each on the entire pizza. I give them a 4 for taste but about half a star due to their lack of toppings and price they charge for them read more

Broadway NY Style Pizza - Broadway Pizza sausage, onion and green pepper - Pizza Near Me - Niagara Falls, New York

Randomly stopped in for a couple slices on the fly after shopping. The thin crust pizza is definitely my thing and the pics and good reviews sucked me in. Did notttt disappoint! I'm very finicky, but this checked like every box.. high quality, very bottom of crust is very crisp yet buttery, w a softer middle, close to perfect. Great flavors. I wish I lived close.. this would probly become my new go to place. Excellent thin crust pizza, this place is a gem. read more

Broadway NY Style Pizza - Thin crust pepperoni and banana peppers - Pizza Near Me - Niagara Falls, New York

See all

This might be pizza heaven! Friendly staff, huge variety of pizzas, big portions and very tasty. Definitely by far the cleanest restaurant I've ever been to. Get the combo! You'll get 2 slices and a fountain drink for under $9. I will be back! read more

See all

Great service and amazing pizza it's my favorite pizza in the area and I highly recommend!!

Broadway Is the New York Way, this NY style of pizza is phenomenal, they offer several different varieties of flavor and different types of Italian dishes. My go to is the BBQ Chicken pizza as well as the Jamaican Beef Patty. They offer combos with two slices and a drink you just can't pass up. The staff is always friendly and usually helpful when making life decisions on what you'd like to order lol. Overall the establishment is very clean and the service is great, Food hands down is always phenomenal. "It's The Broadway " read more

See all

Ordered tonight thru Uber eats. Pizza was delicious. Meatballs very tasty. Food could have been hotter but this was my first Uber eats experience that took 25 min longer than it showed at first. So food wasn't hot because Uber eats doesn't have thermal delivery bags. The food here is a solid 5 stars though. Great NY pizza and meatballs. I'm a fan! read more

Pizza here is slightly different from most of the other places around here. I think there is something about the kind of cheese they use. Crust is very thin. They have a very wide variety of pizzas with different toppings. We got a pepperoni mushroom and black olive pizza. My wife and I both enjoyed it. The amount of toppings was okay but the black olives were not really distributed evenly. I would definitely come here again to try something different. read more

Broadway NY Style Pizza - Pizza with pepperoni mushrooms and black olives - Pizza Near Me - Niagara Falls, New York

Expensive pizza, and not very good. I paid a lot of money for mediocre food. And the service was slow.

In our area this is just an average pizza. Bocce,Imperial,Leonardi's Bella's and others leave it in the dust. I always judge a pepperoni and cheese pizza when comparing. I like the the cup pepperoni their's wasn't cup but was flavorful. The sauce and the crust doesn't live up to others in our area. read more

We were in the area and my husband was craving a NY style pizza. This seemed to be the only place within 15-20 min of where we were and with good reviews we took a chance. I am someone who doesn't really think bad pizza exists. The pizza was just OK. A lot was left to be desired. The crust got hard pretty quick and overall was just bland. Customer service was good. read more

Thin crust . Very good. Try it. Great service. Reasonable prices. Authentic NY pizza - fresh ingredients.. not too greasy

Visiting the falls for the weekend. Girlfriend wanted some pizza. Did not disappoint at all. We got the Pepperoni Pie, a slice of buffalo chicken and a Beef patty. All items were on point. Online it says they close at 9 but they actually close at 10! I let the owners know but that online time related to online delivery! The slice was consumed prior to photos. The owners were personable, engaging and accommodating! The pie was made fresh and we could tell! One bite everyone knows the rules---- solid slice 7.5/10. read more

Broadway NY Style Pizza - Pepperoni NY Style Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Niagara Falls, New York

See all

I was here at Niagara Falls on vacation. Got hungry and their brochure was in the lobby. I ordered a large thin crust with meatball. It was one of the best pizza that I had in a very long time. Their are very few places that I would give a rating on pizza this high. Everything was right on this pizza. Delivery came in great time . Pizza was hot and fresh. read more