Decided to try it out when the opened the location by Wendy's - just to try something different…read more Bad idea. The pizza was TINY, and in the five minutes it took me to drive home with it, it was already cold. Got a stromboli as well and it LOOKED like the right thing when it was in the box...but when I got it home they'd only put cheese and mushrooms in it. Vomit. Not at ALL what I'd ordered. The TL;DR? It's overpriced, small portions, and not great quality ingredients.

Great food and now three locations serving Clewiston, flag hole, and Moore Haven…read more It's nice to have a local business that serves great food

One of the not so good pizzas I have ever had. It was $18 with double pep and double cheese,…read morehowever the pepperoni was not what we felt was double. It had an odd smell in the cheese and the look was of cheddar? It was very think and the taste not good. I would have just liked to return it but instead, will not go back. Sorry to post a bad review but the whole pizza needs tested better to bring your ratings and business up to par.

Not sure what happened over the past year but the food has gone downhill. Makes me very sad. The…read morepizza was so bland and soft. It wasn't crunchy and delicious like it was last year.

Staff were friendly and the interior is just what you'd expect from a local pizza place on a main…read morestreet in a small town. On top of the pizza box was a copy of a local flyer that was a nice bit of local reading. The wings were fresh and tasted great prepared medium buffalo-style. However, they definitely weren't medium spice which was a bit disappointing. It might be the water in Okeechobee, but the pizza crust was dense. I suspect the cheese and pepperoni were of low quality, and the fresh garlic likely came from a jar. Overall, the pizza wasn't special and definitely wasn't worth the price. If you want to try just a slice or two, make sure to arrive before 4pm, because they only sell whole pizzas after that time.

When you walk into Joey's Supreme Pizza in Okeechobee, it feels like stepping into a local favorite…read morewhere pizza, wings, and good vibes rule the table. The space is casual and welcoming, perfect for a family meal, a game-day hangout, or just when you're craving a serious slice. We ordered a little bit of everything--because why not? The mozzarella sticks were golden, crispy, and came with that classic marinara dunk. The jalapeño poppers had the perfect crunch with just the right kick of heat. Then came the wings--juicy, saucy, and downright addictive (BBQ and teriyaki both hit the spot). But the real star? The pizza and stromboli. The pizza came out loaded with toppings, gooey cheese stretching with every bite, and a crust that held up like a champ. The stromboli was stuffed with melty cheese, peppers, mushrooms, sausage, and pepperoni--every bite a flavor-packed punch that makes you close your eyes and go yes. Joey's feels like one of those places that doesn't need to be fancy--it's just good food, good portions, and fair prices. Exactly what a neighborhood pizza spot should be. If you find yourself in Okeechobee, don't skip this place.

We ordered pizza for our grandpa and they proceeded to drop the pizza and cheesy bread in front of…read moreus and then take a longer time to remake it because they ran out of garlic and we did t get a apology or compensation for the incident and wasted out time. Then when we asked for compensation they said "Because we didn't give you the dropped pizza we can't give you anything in return" although it's common sense to not give your customers dropped pizza unless it's normal for them to do it here. double waste of food, double waste of time.

I don't even want to give them a 1. I called and made a delivery order. I was told my order would…read morebe ready in 25-30 minutes. I called them because I noticed it was already been an hour. When I called they said they did not have an order for me. I looked in my bank account and sure enough I was charged. I told the girl we were charged and the girl slammed the phone as she hung up on me. I drove over there and asked for the manager. The girl asked how could she help. I said I want the manager. She said how could she help. I told her what happened she said when she looked it up after telling her the name of the order that it was placed for carry out. I told her I'm more upset how I was treated on the phone. I asked for my pizza because she looked like she didn't know what to do next. The pizza was cold and hard. Never again. The small stores that serve food have better service and food then these main companies. Ridiculous

Was not impressed with this one, ordered a 12" roast beef sandwich with extra meat…read more I should have gone with Subway

The food is very good but my problem is that I got 2 panini's and 2 bags of chips and it cost 47…read moredollars. That is absolutely ridiculous. I go there at least once a week and have never even came close to that price for the same thing. I will not go back there again if that's what the prices are going to be. I'm very displeased!

Yummy pizza! Loved the garlic bread. Watched TV of the shows Dusty was on. We happen to bump into…read moreDusty as we left and snapped a picture. Lovely gentleman. Come try the pizza!

We are so glad we stopped by Wildman's pizza, this is a must try when in the area. I am a New…read moreYorker and can attest this is the best pizza I have had living in south florida. The cracker crust was delicious, can't wait to return and try more on the menu.

This time we went to see how the pasta was. One of us got the specialty " Mr. Sammys Classic"…read morepizza. One got pasta and meatballs.They did not get the extra sauce they ordered but used what came with meatballs. The location is laid back, plenty of seating. The staff is very personable and service is good. The meatballs are big and very good. The pasta is a good size but the sauce had an odd taste. Not a fan of it. The bread is not garlic rolls which would have been good, it was sticks of dough baked and topped with garlic butter and sprinkle cheese. Dishes come with it but no salad . Expensive at $16 plus. The pizza is fresh made hand flipped dough. It is good, one of the better around but $20 and up. We will go back for a meatball sub to see how that is.

Let's start with the good. I had a Stromboli and my wife had eggplant. The Stromboli was good but I…read morehad much better. The size was appropriate for one person (personal size on menu) but the flavor was just not there. Would I order it again if we choose to return? Prob not. My wife had the eggplant, they give you a side of spaghetti I'm thinking because the portion size of the eggplant is kinda small. Mostly cheese and spinach and a hint of eggplant. She enjoyed it, took home the spaghetti only to discard at a later date. We visited on a Friday night, the place was busy, and I have to say it's like being on set of Ramsey . The yelling from one person, not sure if he was the owner or not but really? I'm not talking about raised voice, towering yelling voice yelling to his wait staff, get the telephone, you are on the phones tonight get to it, this order that order. Instant yelling to the wait staff was like OMG!!! I be would not return because of this. Sitting in that restaurant trying to eat with what sounded like a spoiled child was absolutely unpleasant. New York style pizza is supposed to be about the food not the ignorance and arrogance of the New Yorker.

We have been coming to Marco Island for 25 years. Somehow we missed this gem of a restaurant. My…read morehusband and I and our 2 teens thought it was a standout experience. Had to go a second night because we couldn't stop thinking about the first meal. Dinner and drinks, including appetizers was fairly priced due to portions and quality of food. We ate gyros, pizza and pasta. All very very good. The service impeccable. Small and tight quarters inside but all very clean and our plates cleared efficiently to make good space on table. Drinks were refilled immediately. Accommodating to making a few changes here and there for some of our "picky" eaters in the group. So so good. Definitely coming back next time around!!! Don't change a thing!!

The food and services was amazing. I love this place!!! Definitely check it out! I love the feel of…read morethe place. The people are very friendly and accommodating.

Delicious pizza!!!! A very good option after the beach! Fast service and homemade pizzaread more

Pizza after the beach? Yes please! Captiva Island Pizza is a great option for a meal while on the…read moreisland if you're okay with a bit of a wait. It's definitely a hard-working small business, so they're very traditional in how they work. You can walk in and order at their window, or call in an order. They don't deliver so you have to come pick up- they're on the main road in Captiva where most of the shops are, but up on the second floor. There's no true seating inside, it's truly just to walk in, order, and then wait elsewhere. We found the literal one table outside downstairs to eat at, but other than that you figure out in your own what to do once you have the food. But let me say, I really enjoyed the pizza! The wait was worth it. It had plenty of the toppings we asked for, and the crust was the perfect thickness. We also got cheesy bread which was lovely on thick Texas toast, and dipped in marinara it was chefs kiss. Though they're small, they're a great business and it's always better to support local! Plus, great pizza!

First visit even though I've lived in LP for 3.5 yrs. I did a take order of L pizza and 6 wings. I…read morehad an ice cold beer while I waited for my order. It was not busy but it was Saturday between lunch and dinner hours. The lady who took my order was friendly and offered to slice onions for my pizza instead of chop which I really appreciated. The food arrival timed well with the end of my beer. Food: the pizza crust is amazing! The taste and the thickness are perfect. The toppings pepperoni, mushroom and onions were good. The taste of the sauce was good but a bit more sauce would be my preference. 6 Thai chili wings the wings were good sized and cooked perfectly. The sauce was sweet with a very small hit of spice on the back end of your bite. I will definitely go back because in my opinion this is one of the very few places to get good pizza instead LP.

Service and atmosphere were great for a Saturday night after mass at church. We had 1/2 dozen…read moregarlic knots and I added some salt because I needed it ( don't judge). Also had the Cesar salad and the dressing was a kicker on the vinegar, and I called The All the Way a Supreme because we added black olives and peppers to the pizza. We wolfed everything except for a few crust but I think we got in our carbs for a month. Just kidding I don't watch my carbs during menopause! Great hang out spot on a Saturday after mass.