I've been going to Jim's Pizza box for years. They have excellent pizza and I usually just pick up and take it to my grandma's house. Recently, we decided to go in for lunch on a Saturday. The pizza was good as usual we had a pepperoni pizza with double pepperoni. They have lots of other options for food besides pizza - they also have sandwiches, salads, and full dinners. They even have cannoli! This is one of two locations and this location has a full bar. The only reason this isn't a higher is the experience we had when we finally went inside for a meal instead of taking our pizza carry out. We just overall did not have good service. Our waitress was really short with us, not very friendly, and overall kind of made us feel like a bother for being in the restaurant in the first place. My grandma isn't going to complain, but she also mentioned it when we got in the car. I will continue to patronize Jim's pizza box just maybe will continue getting my pizza to go. read more

Jim's Pizza Box - Pizza Near Me - Huron, Ohio

Great pizza and garlic bread, sauce had a nice kick to it. Super friendly and fast service.

Great location. Good menu selections. Pizza is really good; both toppings and crust. May have been short staffed, but giving credit to the server who was there. Would definitely go back. read more

This place is always a favorite of my families. My husband likes the fold over pizza and I'm a big fan of the gluten-free pizza the grandbabies like both of their plates! I cant attest to the process of making the gluten-free, but I've never had it issue regarding that The service is always great. The pizzas always hot when it arrives and the taste never disappoints! read more

Jim's Pizza Box - Gluten free with ham and pineapple - Pizza Near Me - Huron, Ohio

The service was fantastic, the food was delicious and the drink selection was great! I would recommend to anyone looking for some amazing pizza!! read more

Just bad pizza, I wanted to return it for a refund but I lived too far to turn around and go back, honestly the worst pie I have ever tried to eat... threw it out read more

Great food, portions are generous & great service! Family friendly environment in a small family owned hometown restaurant.

Stopped by here to pickup a pizza on a Wednesday night. The prices are very fair and it seems that they do very good business. There's another pizza place across the street too - stiff competition around here! We ordered a pie with mushrooms, bacon and spinach to go. Once we placed our order, we were asked if we'd like to sit at the bar and have a drink while we waited, which of course we took advantage of! We met very nice locals there as well and enjoyed a beverage while our pizza was made. The amount of bacon they put on this pizza was really impressive! It was delish! This is a great spot to head to if you are staying at a nearby hotel and want to grab something fast and easy. I'd definitely return here. read more

Jim's Pizza Box - Beverage at the bar while you wait! - Pizza Near Me - Huron, Ohio

One random day of winter chilling adventures we happened upon a Pizza Box by the name of Jim wile it wasn't only Jim's Box as it was all there for anyone to share! Our friends were staying in the area and wanted pizza so they asked us to join them at The Box so we did on this given night it wasn't too busy so we were seated right away and got our order in quick! Our group decided on a large pepperoni & sausage pizza on the regular crust and in no time at all our pizza was right in front of us to share! The pie was cut into squares it had a good amount of cheese and toppings the sauce was definitely the best part as it was very flavorful and just good as for the dough I really didn't care for it too much as I just didn't like the texture of it really and since the crust is one of my favorite parts it just didn't really hit the spot for me but thankfully the rest of the pie was better! Overall this is a mellow little place who knows if I'll give them another try but it definitely was alright for the time being! read more

See all

A good place for lunch. After exploring the area we needed some sandwiches and Jim's Pizza Box did not disappoint. Fast service. Fresh chips -- I cannot tell you all how often I have had stale chips with a sandwich at lunch -- these were sharp and on point. I had the meatball sub and was quite content. It was yummy and tasty. No soft bread! Sometimes the bread in a meatball sub is soft and mushy and that is not the case here. Perfect! read more

Just paid 30 dollars for 2 medium calzones that were basically just glorified stuffed cheesy bread. Hardly any meat or veggies. Used to love Jim's,​ but it has become overpriced and extremely chintzy. Definitely ain't getting ripped off like that again read more

I always get delivery and was pleasantly surprised when I went in and saw the remodel. The bar was beautiful and very welcoming. The entire place had a nice refresh. We ordered a pepperoni pizza, taco salad, and chicken bacon ranch calzone. The pizza was ok, with a softer crust in the middle. The taco salad was good!! The chicken bacon ranch calzone was the winning dish. When I doubt always order a large calzone!! The staff was friendly and kind to our two loud children. read more

Jim's Pizza Box - Pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Huron, Ohio

See all

This is the best gyro I have ever had. A huge portion for a very low price. Excellent service and a nice atmosphere. It is clear that Jim has some serious culinary skills. The dough crust really makes it. I would stop by if you're in the area. read more

Jim's Pizza Box - Gyro Calzone - Pizza Near Me - Huron, Ohio

Tasty pizza - really enjoyed the margherita and the gyro calzone was delightful. Staff was efficient and kind even on a really busy night. Would order again! read more

Delicious pizzas and delivered quick! We're new to the area, but this could be our go-to. Super pleased!

Best foldovers and calzones in the Sandusky - Huron area! The owners are very personable and always checking on the guests. Can't sing enough praises for this place. read more

Nocci's are delicious, bread and drinks EXCELLENT! Italian sauce is the best I've ever tasted and I'm Italian!

Great ambiance and service for small town pizza dining. They have a full bar and plenty of TV's, however more family friendly than other establishments with a bar. The calzones are the best here! read more

Delicious! Small portion, but I should have read the description better. Still yummy! read more

Jim's Pizza Box - Mini pizza - Pizza Near Me - Huron, Ohio

Pizza was good presentation was a little poor when I got my pizza it looked like it had been shook up before I got it.

This pizza is one of the worst pies I've eaten. My wife quit eating it at two pieces. I was more bold. I ate four before throwing in the towel. I was over-hungry. It wasn't the crust. It was everything else. The cheap pepperoni should have tipped us off at first but we were reckless in our hunger so we dug right in. The sauce tasted straight from the jar and the cheese was mercifully a thin sprinkling. Like I said, we tossed the rest. There was no saving it. On a side note, it was sliced like a checkerboard. Maybe some people like it that way but the traditional wagon wheel slice pattern leaves every piece with some crust to grip. This leaves your hands free of sauce and grease. read more

Received a gift certificate for a birthday from Jim's so decided to try. It was pretty good pizza! What I liked was it was medium thickness and it was crispy! Also, the large was extra large for a decent price. Loved that and the inside was very nice and cozy. Lots of booths and great atmosphere. Will definitely go back when I'm in the Milan area. Try it! It's very good! read more

Went to Huron Ohio for the weekend and was told we had to stop and gets Jim's while we were up there. Great pizza and service!

I don't know how they get that buttery crisp bottom on the pizza crust but it's something special that you don't get from many other establishments, corporate or private. If the crust of the pizza is your favorite part, get to Jim's and indulge ASAP! The sauce is spot on as well. The service was exceptional for our dine in experience. This equates to high marks in the food service industry people! read more

This place used to be terrific. New management came in and has completely ruined it for us to the point that we won't go back anymore. We've been eating here for decades and loved it, when new management took over in the past year the first thing they did was raise prices and cut portion sizes. We ordered a medium calzone which used to be a good sized pizza for $10 and instead it looked like a personal pan pizza you'd get at a basketball game for $12. The pizza is good but don't expect much portion size or value for your money especially compared to what it used to be. We just decided to go to Huron Pizza House across the street. Update! went again and it seems they have completely fixed their issues. Calzone came out large and delicious. Prices seem very reasonable. We were very pleasantly surprised and will be back! read more

AMAZING absolutely deliciousThis is probably the one of the best pizzas I've ever had and we also had calzone and cannolis this is definitely worth the trip from the causeway of Cedar point this is a hidden gem of a food restaurant!!Everything was delicious from the sauce to the crust ,.. temperature perfect!! restaurant was beautiful and clean as was the outside very inviting with outdoor seatingPLEASE TRY THIS PLACE IT'S DELICIOUS FOOD!!! read more

See all

Taco Supreme pizza is my favorite item on the menu. When I first came here and read the menu and read the Taco Supreme I was skeptical, but totally glad I went with it because I get it for my family and I every time. read more

Definitely won't be back, just horrible! I ordered an appetizer of bread and olive oil dipping with balsamic, both the bread and the dipping oil was awful, and way too much money. Then I ordered a caesar salad, blasé to say the least and once again way overpriced! My mother ordered the baked spaghetti with A meatball and a messy kindergartner could have done better. Just very gross horrible food I would have expected at a really cheap cafeteria buffet.... I think they have too many now, and just don't care.....They are supposedly going to have one downtown Sandusky but I will not patronize them. Milan, where they began was alway ok but who knows, I guess too many places and they don't control the quality of the food one bit. read more

Jim's pizza box is a great place to eat. Their pizzas are huge! The dessert pizza is *chefs kiss* (fantastic). I highly recommend.

THE BEST FOLDOVERS and staff! The spinach foldover is our favorite; I would skip the salads and stay with sandwiches, specials and pizzas. Awesome local hangout before and after football games. read more

Ugh no. It was, as my dad said "entirely forgettable". We placed our order and were seated. Drinks came quickly, and we were happy to see our food a few moments later. Food was not good...just not good. Salads were fine, but I could make it at home. Pizza was not good...sauce was WAY too sweet, toppings were not put on properly (like 2 pieces of chicken on the entire medium pizza?). Two stars for super great staff, they were awesome. But we won't be back. read more

The pizza was amazing! Def worth it. I haven't tried thejr boneless chicken wings yet because my children ate it all before I could get one! They said it was delicious. Their "cheese bread" wasn't worth it. It was like they used their sub bread and used a little bit of cheese. That was a disappointment. I would just focus on their pizza. read more

I really like their pizza, calzones and pasta dishes. Carry out is a breeze. Only thing I haven't liked is the wings.

Travel for work and have ate at many restaurants. Jims lunch box is unbelievably most tastiest places ever honestly a 10 soup was amazing thank you Jim yummy Very nice and friendly read more

Jim's Pizza Box - Pizza Near Me - Huron, Ohio

Best pizza around. The calzones are to die for. Rverything is always cooked correctly and the service is fast and reputable.

Deep dish is well worth the extra coin. Fast delivery. Great finished product. We always go deep dish if available. Never tried regular crust but the deep dish was great!! We'll be back, Jim. Don't go changing a thing. read more

We had a large carry out order on a very cold, snowy weekend. The order was ready when we got there. And they fixed some confusion on the ordering quickly and with a pleasant response. The food was great. Two of us got baked ziti. Wow, it was awesome. Full of meat, piping hot, and enough for two meals. The Smitty sub was good and the steak burger was one of the best burgers in a long time. Buffalo chicken pizza had bacon - a twist from most - and it was full of toppings without being overly spicy. Boneless wing flavor options are extensive. More nugget like than wing like. Get the homemade ranch on your salad if ranch dressing is your thing. Definitely would do carry out here again. read more

We tried this place out for the first time today. We ordered cheese bread and calzones. I ordered the white veggie calzone and my husband had the bacon chicken ranch. The food was good. The calzones and cheese bread had a good flavor and the bread they make is delicious. The only minor complaint I have is that the calzones are much thinner than what I'm used to. They're supposed to be denser with much more filling in them, almost like a pocket filled to the max with pizza toppings. It's OK though, because it was so good! The prices are also very fair for the portions they give you. We will be back to try the other menu options! read more

My family has been fans of Jim's since the old store on Milan. We love this pizza and the pasta is quite good too. Jim's sauces are awesome. The garlic bread is also a favorite. This time, on our way home from Detroit, my partner and I stopped by to see if they would prepare an unbaked pizza for us to take home for dinner. We were in between meals and didn't want to take home a hot pizza for another hour to warm up later. Jim made it himself for us and when we made it later on it was just as good as eating it in house. read more

Everything is great ! We have a very hard time deciding since everything we have ever ordered is GREAT !! So sometimes we eat there and take an order to go for later ! If you don't like the food and the friendly service ? Then YOU have a problem !!!!! People who posted a bad review were in a different restaurant if they rated this great place poorly !!! read more