What a great cozy spot for pizza! Recommended when we staying at a nearby hotel. Pizza was very…read moretasty. Staff friendly and helpful. And the friendly manager / owner stopped by to check on us and our experience after our meal. That was a nice touch. Plan to return next time we're in the area!

I've been a fan of Taranto's for several years. I first discovered them around 2015 when I was…read moreworking in Lewis Center. I ended up ordering from them at least a couple times a month. At least once a month we would place a group order at my office and everybody loved it. I know that the ownership changed a couple years ago, but it's still the same great pizza and service! I've never eaten at the restaurant but I have gone in there a few times for pick up orders and it's always clean and neat and customers always seem to be happy. The service that I've received over the years whether it's over the phone or in person has always been great!

I'm impressed, Carlucci's! I've had countless "Supreme" or "Deluxe" pizzas in Columbus, and they're…read moreall pretty much the same quality. There's something about Carlucci's version of a Deluxe that sets it apart. The toppings were generous and delicious. I don't even like mushrooms, but they blended in well with the pepperoni, onions and green peppers. Shout out to the sausage for being the MVP ingredient. This was my first time going to Carlucci's, and I would go back to try additional pizzas - like their Super Deluxe!

Crust was not bad. Good amount of toppings for the deluxe. On the expensive side. Quick and very…read morenice employees. Sauce lacks flavor, pizza tasted bland

In when I first went in to try this place, that was the first day they were actually changing their…read moremenu into different options. I ended up trying this paneutica Pizza which actually tasted good and they also had some vegetable puff options that I was not able to get at that time because they were refreshing and opening up the menu puff option for the next day. They do carry out. They have a very small parking spot in the front. Their restaurant looked like it was only four carryout. There may have been a place or two for people to sit and eat but it's not necessarily sit down restaurant. Their service was great. They explained everything in the menu and the ambience inside was good.

The paneer tikka masala pizza was not good. Maybe it just wasn't my cup of tea, but the flavors…read morewere way off. Would not return.

Ordered a half cheese/half pepperoni pizza and a. Supreme pizza for dinner last night. Best…read moresupreme pizza I've had. I'm the guy who picks stuff off. I picked nothing off this pizza. So good!!

Stopped in after running a few errands, and left questioning every other pizza I've ever eaten…read more Four Points looks like your typical small pizza joint with a bar--but don't be fooled. The pies here come fully loaded, like they were built by an overachieving Italian grandma who refuses to accept "light toppings" as a concept. I grabbed a Supreme and a Carnivore, because balance is important--veggies for the soul, meats for the heart (and cholesterol). Both were cooked perfectly: crisp crust, cheesy layers of happiness, and toppings stacked so high they needed their own building permit. Had a couple of local microbrews while I waited--because what's pizza without beer? The bartender was friendly and clearly knew their stuff. Bonus points for serving up brews that didn't taste like they were filtered through regret. Took the pies home and--no surprise--they were a hit. Everyone's inner food critic went quiet after the first bite. Verdict: Four Points Pizza is the kind of place that makes "errands" sound like code for "pizza mission." Come hungry

My brother lives in Brooklyn so it seemed appropriate to order when he was visiting for movie…read morenight. One of the pizzas was a little too well done for my liking but the other two were amazing. We had the cheese and margherita. I can't comment on ambiance or service but the pizza is really good! Also got the seal of approval from my brother. Definitely recommend!

We appreciated the indoor seating. We were the first dining room customers but the small space…read morequickly filled up leaving only 2 bar stools against a small counter in the way back. The space was HOT. I noticed the thermostat was set at 78 degrees. But I understand, the pizza oven was cranking out carryout and dine in pizzas left and right. We ordered their speciality White pizza and added chicken I am giving it a 5/5. The crust was golden and held the folded piece of pie perfectly. I loved the pillows of ricotta Hubs is giving the pizza a 4/5. He is not a fan of ricotta and thought the chicken portion was too skimpy. We both agreed it was delicious and we polished off a medium / small pizza in one sitting. (They only have 2 sizes: Large and medium/small. The menu identifies the pizza as medium but the pizza pan hanging on the wall says small.) The female that took our order said it was a printing error on the menu. Either way the pizza is available by the slice or as a whole pie ether large or smaller. Drinks are sold by the can or bottle. Next time: we are going to order the small pizza with extra chicken and all of the Ricotta on half of the pie so I can have extra and he can have none. I think we need to add garlic also. And maybe a side of pizza sauce for dipping. We will be back. It was very good.

Thank you for making my lasagna and veggie pizza with sausage 10 minutes before closing!…read more Such an amazing meal after a shitty day at work!!!

In town, stopped for something different based on rating…read more Once inside, it's a neighborhood joint - familiar awards, faces, smells. It's consistent. I got a walk in medium pepperoni with sausage. In & out in 20 min. Who I assumed to be the owner came over and stopped in to check on my order and went to the back of the house and asking what the delay was in my Pizza, and it suddenly appeared in less than 30 seconds later. Customer service is noted. In my opinion, the pizza was good, but the pepperoni was way too salty for my liking. I actually had to peel many layers off to make it palatable. Just for me, not you.

We had a Clipp coupon so decided to check this place out on a nice weather evening. Walking in, the…read morepizza cottage has tables and booths and then through a connected area, you can walk into the tavern bar area. They have a full bar with booths too. The covered patio is cute and we had it all to ourselves. There are TVs mounted and a small space for love music. We ordered a large pepp and sausage Sicilian crust pizza. My husband order a water and root beer. The water never came. He asked for a refill on his root beer, it came back with possibly cherry coke? The pizza was a 6/10. The crust was crispy, but the cheese either fell off when trying to take a piece from the pizza, or during a bite. The ambiance was a 10/10, but outside of that, the experience was fairly underwhelming.

They can never seem to get our order correct. Too bad because my toddler absolutely loves their…read morechicken tenders. Our order is always wrong. Ordered two pizzas, one plain cheese, one pep and onion, received two different sized cheese pizzas smh.

The food here is good and it is usually packed but that does mean that service is usually slow and…read moreit u Is VERY loud. I've definitely turned around an left before being seated because of the noise. The food is typical pub food and tastes fine, I do like the southwest Chipotle chicken salad. It's got a kick!

Went on a Friday. There wasn't too many people there. We both ordered pizza. I was not a fan of the…read moresweet sauce. The crust was thin which I like. But the sauce needs some seasoning .. add some garlic, oregano, a lil basil... something to make it not taste like sweet ketchup. A couple had walked in while we were having our meal. They had asked to sit at a table but the lady/waitress told them they only had six tops and they can sit at the bar. The couple didn't want to, which is why they asked for a table.. they ended up walking out. I was surprised they didn't just separate a six top to a two tables since that is what was next to us. I felt the waitress was rude to them and they lost customers cuz of that. The place is cramped and they have too many tables for the size of the room.

Denny made great suggestions on pizza and it was hot and fast. Also found a coupon to save us some…read moremoney. I would come back again!

Was craving New York Style, foldable crust, pepperoni pizza. Got delivery. Comes in X-Large 16"…read moreonly. Wonderful! Satisfied my craving for quintessential East Coast, pizza. Recommend!

I was just at the Worthington location and it was absolutely amazing. The store was clean. The food…read morecame out fresh and fast. Very efficient service. Customer service was great to not attend. Definitely will be coming back. Keep up the good work guys.

The worst customer service I've ever experienced in Columbus from ANY BUSINESS. This place used to…read morebe my families go to for good pizza yet we will never return. My husband and 7 year old daughter went to pick up at the Worthington Location and we called ahead to place our order and Alicia was who handled us from beginning to end absolutely horribly. On the phone she was extremely irritated with having to take our order so at pick up my husband walks up and she goes what's up, what's up aggressively before he can even say I'm here to pick up. He then said to her hey can I be honest she said sure he said when working in customer service I think it's important to be patient and kind when handling customers and she completely flipped out on him saying all kinds of curse words in front of a child. Saying you can get out of my store right now and you have till the count of three to get out or I'm calling the police. My husband then said you're gonna speak like that in front of a 7 year old, she then told him she'll be giving our pizza order away to the people who worked there. For $67 for two pizzas and 10 wings, we'll take our money where it's appreciated. Reached out to the owner he said he would deal with it and that he was reviewing footage only to not say anything else in response not even an I'm sorry for the way you were handled for this terrible and completely unprofessional behavior. Never again.