I'll admit I had a difficult order for multiple pizzas. I expected it to be wrong,as usual but, thanks to Cameron,it was perfect . very clean, very welcoming and seemed thankful for my purchase. Thank you Cameron. I'll be back! read more

Nice and easy drive-through window for when I have a craving for Donato's. I've always liked their toppings and variety of the pizzas. I like the ease of ordering online and picking up my order at the window. Friendly employees and the line moves fast. I've seen several Donato's like this around town. I'm sure they're similar. read more

Donatos Pizza - Store front. - Pizza Near Me - Pataskala, Ohio

See all

The window ad for the chicken bacon ranch salad got me to stop in. It was as advertised. The star of the meal was the cauliflower crust pizza. It came with plant based sausage. We added pepperoni to the pizza as well. The garlic was a bit more than their other pizzas to help mask the cauliflower flavor. The crisp crunchy crust was quite impressive. The variety of cheeses on top were also refreshing. read more

Donatos Pizza - Chicken bacon ranch salad - Pizza Near Me - Pataskala, Ohio

Their service is consistently good but the quality has gone down hill. Not sure why, Just not the same. Not bad, but too many other pizza shops to choose from. read more

Not for the pizza. Donatos is special. I remember my first rectangle slice of pizza I ever had. How do you follow that up? It's pretty special learning how to eat this style of pizza. And while you're doing it, the elders tell you more and more why it is so. it's beautiful. Stop losing your edge donatos. You're better than this. tm.christina.tda read more

We have never had a problem with this location. Food is always hot when we pick it up and delicious. We actually drive farther to go to this location instead of the one down the road do to having issues with the other location. Keep up the good work read more

See all

Huge fan of this Donatos location! I frequently find myself ordering a pizza through this location due to the consistency and great taste. My orders are always correct and ready in a timely manner. The staff is AWESOME, whether it be the drive-up window employee with a flashy smile or the timely and respectful delivery driver. When I'm feeling lazy or unable to leave the house, I opt for the small delivery fee and tip for easy and timely service. My order has ALWAYS been on time or earlier than expected. I have received my pizza in less than 25 minutes before with the delivery service. The pizzas and subs hear ROCK. Pataskala is a pizza goldmine. You turn a corner and you're bound to find a pizza place every where you go. After trying many different pizza places, I have landed on Donatos as my go to. Their pizza cannot be beat. The prices are easily affordable for small groups or for personal pizzas. My favorite is a classic thin crust cheese pizza with extra sauce on top for more yummy flavor. I have ate in store a few times and have had no issues. The restaurant is clean and well put together. The staff in the kitchen will double as waiters/waitresses and do a great job of managing everything and keeping drinks full. Thank you Donatos! read more

Always hot n fresh. DriveUP window is always quick and exceptionally friendly. Love it.

I had called in to order some pizza and wings and lisa (the person taking my order) was absolutely amazing! she was thorough repeating my order back to me, was extremely patient and sweet! the food was amazing and arrived on time (: best experience yet! read more

In mind my this is the best pizza in town. The italian subs are also a good change of pace and are reliably solid. The restaurant is fast, friendly, and a favorite of mine in town. read more

I'm usually pretty cautious when leaving reviews for pizza places, especially chain restaurants. But I have ordered from this location several times since moving to the area and my food has arrived hot and consistent every time! Additionally I will add that their staff both at the restaurant and their delivery drivers are some of the nicest around. If we are getting delivery, we automatically go with Donatos. read more

Super disappointing when you have to wait 15 mins for your pizza after you already gave them 45 minutes to make it and you get there to be told they "lost" it and then you get a pizza that looks like this!!!! Really you actually think this is deserving enough to give to someone! read more

Donatos Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pataskala, Ohio

Amazing asf as always. I love this place, especially good for buckeye gamedays!!! Woot

I love Donatos pizza and have never had an issue with this location. The pizzas are always a good eat for the price and I've never had them mix any order up. The employees, whether delivery drivers or in store, have always been very courteous. I've found they tend to always beat their estimated time of arrival on delivery - a good problem to have! read more

Have always loved this pizza and have had really good service and they seem to manage to get my order correct. Recently it seems to me that they have changed the tomato sauce and its just my personal opinion, but I don't care for it. We ordered meatball subs and a pizza. The same sauce was on both and the pizza had an extra amount of sauce on it, when I had actually asked for extra cheese. Could hardly taste the little bit of cheese as the tomato sauce overpowered it. Will probably try another place next time. read more

Grew up in Pataskala , back from the South for a family visit . Had to stop and get a Donatos Pizza as always enjoyed the Pizza growing up . We ordered a large Pepperoni & Cheese for a pick up order . The pizza was nothing short of a horrible eating experience , The crust was like a soft noodle ! Not crispy at all - we even waited and saw pizza being pulled from oven ,, I believe it was a pizza that was ordered and not picked up and quickly re heated!!! After seeing the 4 kids working I assume I was correct ! I should have walked the 100 yards to MASSEYS PIZZA MY BAD ! Never again will I order from Donatos read more

Make sure you don't order within an hour of when they close or else they just won't get you your food, won't tell you they aren't coming, but also charge your account for the food. read more

I am a HUGE Donatos fan. That being said, the Pataskala branch must use a different recipe and their drivers must deliver in stunt cars by the way the pizza looks read more

Living in AZ, we don't have Donatos.. but we always miss it! So, when we come to Ohio to visit family it's a must to get some! As always, it didn't disappoint. Our go to is the classic pepperoni and it was delicious! Thank you for continuing to bring back family memories! Now, if only we could get it in Tucson! read more

This was carryout, but my gosh was it fantastic. I love Donatos and it's always great to eat some while visiting family in Ohio. The supreme was great and usually is always my go to for pizza, but there is something about Donato's basic pepperoni that really wins me over. It's just the combination of the thin, crispy crust and the slightly sweet/ slightly tangy sauce that just speaks to me. Between three different pizzas that were ordered, I probably ate a whole pizza piece by piece. Just delicious! read more

This place is lost on me. Pizza is like cardboard with pepperoni jerky. What is the deal here? Have the locals just never had good Pizza? Travel a little. You'll see. read more

If you order food with special requests, triple check before you leave the restaurant. Also when you bring it to their attention all they offer is the option to remake said food, but I just want to get my money back and that's just not possible. Terrible customer service and it's unfortunate because I do like their pizza. read more

Your pizza used to be really good and you could always count on consistency and quick delivery. But the last four pizzas we've had were undercooked, or should I say not cook completely and not very crisp, the last one was your bacon pizza. Perhaps oven calibration need to be done routinely. Donatos and Maceys have always been our favorites but this local Donatos is a hit or miss for us read more

I grew up eating Donatos from the original store on Thurman Ave and working for Donatos in my early college days. Donatos's Pastaskala has been hit and miss for us since we moved out here. Food is either cold when it arrives or order is incomplete. Several times drinks didn't arrive but one thing that is a no in my book pizza arriving Cold. Staff that answers the phone hit and miss as well teach the staff phone etiquette customer service is a key and knowing how to speak to people is necessary.... I'm giving this store a 2 but Donatos as a company is great and food on point when u get hot!!! read more

The pizza is fine, but we have literally NEVER received a correct order. We have ordered here at least 4 times now, and they never get it right. It's almost a joke now, because we don't even expect the order to be right. read more

Carried out a few nights ago..very fast drive up window service, food was fresh, price was great..and I love how I always get texts to get a special price.. Sometimes a large for $10 or 30 percent off my order..even though I really enjoy smaller chain pizzas, Donatos is a pizza place where they are consistent with quality at every chain I've ever visited.. read more

I was told that I had to try this place when I visit Pataskala. It's our last night in town - and I'm glad we did! Ordered a founders favorite and a pepperoni. Decently priced and very tasty pizza. Would recommend to others. read more

I love Donatos pizza, don't even care that it's your average chain pizza place. Still love it! The subs here are really good too, but a little on the small side.. Delivery, oh the other hand, is incredibly slow! They usually say 45 minutes but I always get my pizza an hour or so later. At least it still gets to my house though. To bad they don't have a delivery thing where it says 45 minutes or it's free. Is have a lot of free pizzas. Or this would make them bring it on time at least. Oh well, it's still good and I'll still order from here! read more

First time in my life I have walked into a restaurant to dine in and have the manager tell us that they don't have the staff to get to us right away and they will get to us when they can. Was told 30-40 min before they could get to us when asked how long would it be. Needless to say we left after that. read more

Fantastic job. We order two pizza on a Friday night full expecting to wait 45-60 minutes. Our pizza was at the door in less than 25 mins. The guy delivering the pizza was extremely polite and asked me to go online and fill out a survey. He also personally thanked me for choosing donatos. Great experience from start to finish read more

Love this place!! Friendly service and great pizza and it's one of the few Donatos where they take your order at the table. We go here every week, this place is GREAT!! read more

Amazing. Breadsticks are BOMB! Pizza is great too. I recommend the cheese pizza. You won't be disappointed!!!

Stopped in last night with a friend and glad I did. Food and service were outstanding. Pizza and sub were delicious. GM even stopped out to say hello and ask how everything was. This was an added value. I will drive just to go to this particular location. read more

Slow service and only okay pizza. If you have time and a couple more bucks to spend, look for Mama Lindas or Capuannos in the area.

forgot the peppers on our sub, and our dressing as well! super disgusted and disappointed with their service.

Terrible service at this location. Manager is unbelievable. Ordered pizza and subs online and was given a 7:04 pickup time. Loaded all four kids into the car and got there at 7:04 - had to wait behind four other vehicles, so by the time we got to the window it was 7:15. Once we paid for the food ($40) we were told only the subs were ready, the pizzas would be five minutes. We wanted to wait but were told we "had" to pull forward and someone would bring our food out. We waited 10 more minutes, then went around the building to the drive-through. Waited behind two more vehicles. Got back to the window, explained the situation, were told they couldn't find our food. Then they supposedly found it, and it was stone cold. At this point it was after 7:30, and we were waiting for the order we placed at 6:45 that was supposed to be ready at 7:04 that was finally located and was cold in soggy boxes like it had been sitting on the counter for half an hour. My husband asked for a refund, the manager asked for his receipt, looked at it and flatly told him she wouldn't be giving him one. He said he wasn't satisfied with the service level and the food and would sit there until she refunded us the order cost, and she told us she was not going to refund it and then called the police on us. Wasted our time, wasted $40 on nasty, cold pizza that we didn't even want to eat, wasted police resources, and lost a customer for good. Oh, and to top it off we waited until the officer she called showed up so we could explain the situation ourselves, because at this point we felt the manager was ridiculous enough to lie about the incident and get us into some kind of trouble, and having the police show up had my seven-year-old in hysterical tears thinking her daddy was going to get taken to jail. read more