Was seeing some bad reviews on this location lately. I just picked up our large Famous Pepperoni today and it is perfect! Kudos to the crew that work at this location! Always good! read more

Had an AMAZING experience here this evening for my dads birthday. This location handled the Friday night rush on top of our very large party, 17ish people dining in, FLAWLESSLY! All of our 4 or 5 orders was exactly as requested. The manager is a great person and very friend and the staff did an INCREDIBLE job! Not to mention they have the best cauliflower crust pizza I've had. AMAZING Job masseys read more

We have been ordering your pizza for many years. The pizza we got tonight was awful. Crust was chewy, lack taste (not the original taste we're use too) and the edges were burnt more than usual. What happen? Afraid to buy it again, the taste was awful. Very disappointed. read more

We are new to the area and we're looking for a place to deliver to the country. Massey's was the first place who would. We have ordered 4 times prior to this post. Each time the pizza was hot and crisp. We are particularly fond of the spicy pepperoni they use. the garlic bread was flavorful and cheesy. The guido sub is packed with meat and Italian dressing. We will call again. I am glad that I didn't look them up on Yelp before I called them, or I would have passed on a decent pizza. read more

I haven't had Masseys in years. I moved to Pataskala and we wanted to grab a quick pie on Friday. I seen we had one not far from home. Ordered a large pepperoni with xtra cheese and jalapenos. It was very tasty. Definitely order from them again. read more

Massey's Pizza - a pepperoni and jalapeno pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pataskala, Ohio

See all

It has been years since we had eaten Massey's. This pizza was delicious, we ordered the deluxe. The salad was fresh the next day. We will order here again. I came in and picked up the order. read more

Massey's pepperoni lost it's zing. bland taste..used to rival pizza cottage, unfortunately not any more

Pizza was just like all other Massy's Pizza.....good!....the customer service from the girl with a nose ring couldn't have been more unfriendly....very nasty.... I'll go across the street to Taco Bell before I go back there.... read more

Really really enjoy the pizza here. Some of the best delivery you can get in the area. The only knock on it is that it's pretty pricey compared to some other options, but I suppose you get what you pay for. If the price were a little lower it'd be five stars no doubt. read more

Had lunch at Massey's today with my husband. This is the first time I've eaten at this location, although I have had Massey's once at another location. I was not very impressed at that visit, despite all I had about how good it was, so that was a long time ago. This is the first time I've been back to a Massey's. We had the lunch buffet, which really is a good deal at just $7.99 (soft drink included). There wasn't a lot on the salad bar, just pasta salad, lettuce, and a few other things to add to the salad, but the pasta salad was good and the lettuce was fresh. The hot part of the bar had a pasta dish that was hot and good, garlic bread, slices of a sub (Italian sub, I think) that was pretty good, and the pizza. I would not say I love the pizza, but there wasn't really anything bad about it. It was hot and fresh, with a thin crust. All in all, it was an ok lunch, even though I certainly wouldn't list it as my favorite pizza. If I were rating just the pizza, I would say 3 stars. But since the pasta salad was good, the lettuce was fresh, the hot items were fresh and hot and pretty good, and it was a good deal with the drink included, I'm giving it 4 stars overall. read more

My family's favorite pizza in town. Not only is the pizza good but the people are always really nice.

I'm always impressed with this Massey's, they all work so hard, always friendly! All of the employees hustle and greet everyone that walks in the door even though they are crazy busy before an OSU game! read more

Pizza and wings where great!! The staff was very friendly, a little pricey but worth it!

Ordered delivery last night and took 2 hours to get order. Food was good but not worth a 2 hour wait. When I called the store I was told my order was leaving in 5 mins, 30 mins later they arrived. read more

I called right at 9:50 to have a pizza delivered. Now this is on a Saturday night in Pataskala so I understand that not too much is open at this hour. When the girl picked up she asked "Pick up or delivery". I was excited that delivery was still an option and that is what I asked for. She was very condescending in her reply "I'm sorry but we stop delivering at 9:50 and it's 9:51". Without getting into the tit for tat on the one minute difference in time, she was very indignant about not taking an order after offering it in the initial contact. Thank god for Mama Linda's. They were willing to deliver 3 minutes past their delivery cutoff time. read more

One of the worst pizzas I've ever had along with it being extremely over priced makes it a good combination to stay away from. They told us when we got there, this is not New York pizza, they were right, not even close! read more

We always love their pizza! You have delivery person who drove down citation last weekend as though it's a speedway, got on bumper then right around us and increased speed at least 50 mph heading out toward Watkins. We were on our way to Kroger and because the car got stopped at a light I got his license plate number hyx388? There are many people that walk citation and if anybody had been out that person would've been hit for sure. It was dark also. read more

This isn't a bad place to get a pizza if local choices are closed or otherwise unavailable. I do prefer local over any chain. The service was pretty good, courteous call, got delivery in 20 minutes after my typical place had closed, would have been 45 minutes to an hour at Donatos. The driver was excellent, very friendly and professional, got an extra tip. The pizza was just ok though, it used to be quite a bit better years ago at various locations but it wasn't as expensive as the other chains either. Maybe it wasn't the best night for them. I will probably try their subs again, as much as I would like to say not the pizza realistically I likely will try it again too at some point but I'm not in any hurry for it. Was overcooked for my taste. In short, 2 stars for the pizza, 4 for the service so 3 average seems fair. read more

We didn't check the reviews before coming here and I'm really surprised that they are so low. However, we also didn't have food delivered but instead dined in the restaurant. We really enjoyed the all the way pizza that we ordered. The toppings were piled on but the crust was still crispy and thin. The only complaint I have is that many of the tables were dirty so it was more difficult than it should have been to find a clean one. Also the price is pretty high but we felt it was worth it. read more

This is my second review. Let's just say THIS review is not a good one. We just got a Mexican pizza, which is usually wonderful. Today, as always, we requested the toppings on the side as the heat from the pizza makes them soggy. We have never had a problem with this before, however, the toppings were ON the pizza this time. I was sooo disappointed! Obviously someone wasn't paying attention to our request. Feeling disappointed. read more

Pretty good pizza ... thin crust. I can't really say I've craved another Massey's pizza since I tried it a couple weeks ago... better than the nearby Donatos (that particular Donatos is sub-par as Donatos goes). I suppose if you live nearby and need a pizza, you'd be OK with Massey's. read more

Giving this pizza place 2 stars solely for the decent customer service. We ordered the buffalo chicken pizza with a side of cheesy bread. The pizza is just not good. The bread was fine, but the marinara sauce was just plain spaghetti sauce (no flavor). For the price, it left much to be desired. We will probably not return since there are other cheaper, better options in town. read more

I ordered a pizza plus an order of pasta. The pizza was delivered burned and barely edible and the pasta was plane pasta with very little sauce. I know there is an occasional mistake but I called several times and no one could help,I was told only the manager could help me. After calling several times asking for him and no response from him I finally gave up. We were satisfied with Masseys but because of the total disregard and the manager ignoring me, my business is going to Donatos. read more

Love the crust! Lots of toppings! Ready quickly. Only negative - the sauce was a little salty for me but the rest of my group thought it was great. read more

I've been a Massey's customer for 30 years, but never again! The customer service at the Pataskala location is absolutely terrible. The manager (Roy) is disrespectful and has no idea what the term customer service means; in addition the pizza quality at the Pataskala location is substandard compared to other locations. I will never purchase another pizza from the Massey's corporation ever again (franchise or independent). read more

Have always got a good pizza here. Ordered one last night and it was terrible. Ordered a pep pizza I think they made a cheese and realized the mistake and scattered some pep on top. Way to much sauce. Won't get another one and especially not on a weekend. To many young people working or I should say just hanging out in the back doing a lot of talking. read more

You have heard of Ohio State's band being "The best damn band in the land." Well, Massey"s Pizza is The best damn pizza in Pataskala. It is always hot & fresh. Not greedy with there toppings at all. You will for sure say OMG after having a pizza from Massey's! read more

We went to Massey's today for the lunch buffet - it was the sorriest buffet we've ever been to. The pep pizza had like 1 piece of pepperoni on each triangle each. We will not be going back. read more

I ave always enjoyed Massey and had good service. This evening I called and after 15 minutes of workers not being able to process a gift card I received, nor could the manager. And after telling him I would just call somewhere else his reply was simply"ok". This is just bad service and disappointing. Nothing else to say read more

They suck for a pizza place they just fired a delivery drive that his car is in the shop to get the brakes fixed on it

I am a convert! Donatos has always been my favorite but after giving in to my husband and son-in-laws requests for Masseys I now find myself not being satisfied with anything other than Masseys. They have won me over. It is a consistantly good pizza and I love the cronmeal on the bottom of the crust. Just recently tried their subs and I must say they are also the best I have ever had. My entire family are Massey fans. read more

Ordered subs one night, took an hour to get them. Had to call back to check on them was told they just came out of the oven piping hot. When they arrived they were cold, I live right across the street. Called and spoke to the manager was told they would send more out, I told him that wouldn't work as it was already late and I had to get up early to go out of town, I asked him just to give us credit for our order he told me he could just give me 20%, really you can send 3 more subs out for no charge but can't give me credit for my next order for the full amount. We order their all the time, won't be back. read more