I've been here a few times over the past few months and continue to get the same great service (warmly greeted), great tasting food exactly as I would expect it to be prepared, and prepared and ready ahead of scheduled time. I cannot ask for anything more to be honest. I'll likely be back again when working in the area. Great job! read more

The order and delivery were easy and fast. The sub was absolutely delicious and the price was fair. I'll be back.

Some customers have experienced rudeness and a lack of welcome, which can be detrimental to their overall experience and ambiance. It's important to ensure that all paying customers feel valued and appreciated. read more

Best team in the area. Always friendly, fast, and dedicated to their sandwich artistry. Small business owned by a local family.

They have an excellent assortment of sand which options. I love that they offer hot subs as well!

Picked up an online order at about 1:30 in the afternoon, so I expected food to be relatively fresh. The sub was pretty sad. Very hard bread and not a single onion in sight when Mike's way was requested. I ate half because I was hungry and then called the store to request a refund. Instead of being courteous and accommodating, she tried to suggest that I bought the sandwich elsewhere. She finally relented and told me to bring it back for a new sandwich or a refund. So she literally wanted me to get back in the car and drive to the restaurant rather than just refund the order online. Whatever happened to good customer service? I won't be back. read more

Nice people but she tried to take orders from four people in line and commit to memory. She didn't get them correct. Ordered a 13 and got an 8. Scraps of old lunch meat were in the case with the wrapped blocks of meat and cheese, all over the slicer, and the counter. They placed the assembled sandwiches on the cutting board to add toppings but then moved finished sandwiches to an uncovered countertop by the register to then be place on paper, cut and wrapped. Kinda feel like multiple heath violations present. We took our chances and ate the sandwiches but we won't be back to this location. read more

WARNING! The Jersey Mike's on Cabela Dr. in Garner was out of BREAD. Got a refund and drove to this Jersey Mike's location instead. As we are placing our order, I catch something scurrying up the wall in the prep area. It was a HUGE ROACH! I asked the employee if they had a roach problem and pointed to the wall. He looked at it and proceeded to walk away from me without a word!!! He just left me standing there! So, I decided to take a picture of the roach while I was standing there alone, post it here on Yelp, and drove away to ChickFilA for a roach-free sandwich on 2 fresh buns. Corporate needs to investigate the issues in the Garner stores ASAP! read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - A HUGE ROACH CLIMBING THE WALL IN JERSEY MIKE'S! - Sandwiches Near Me - Garner, North Carolina

My first Jersey Mike's sub. Reviews at other nearby JM locations were not that good and I wanted my first experience to be a positive one so tried this store few miles further away. Overall very positive experience. Good store, good service, good sub. read more

Went to jerseys Mike today order a 26 every was fresh they greet u when come in door I'm finding myself eating there 3 times a week

Picked up lunch for the office today - All items were perfect - ready on time and fresh. If you haven't tried the cookies - you are really missing out. The are hot, fresh and delicious. read more

No longer going to patronize. Any and all requests fall on deaf ears. Ordered cheese steak with triple onion. Lucky to see a string or two. Ask them to go lightly on the oil and vinegar. They put enough on to completely soak the sandwich that it's falling apart by the time you get home! read more

Quite possibly the friendliest Jersey Mikes ever. I have no idea where they are recruiting this much hospitality talent but I sure hope they keep them. Music was upbeat and the counter staff was engaging, so everyone in line was chatting it up. Thanks for making a small side of turkey for Delta Dog who was patiently waiting in the car ;-) read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Sandwiches Near Me - Garner, North Carolina

The subs were good...as usual. The only thing that I don't like about the service is that there seems to be a great sense of urgency for the customer to order quickly. The employees were polite. The establishment was tiny and clean. read more

I'm a huge fan of Jersey Mike's subs and this location is definitely top notch. The super friendly staff always pile on the lettuce and pickles so that you end up with a super delish sandwich. As is the norm of all Jersey Mike's, the meats and cheese are sliced fresh to order. The crusty french bread with the soft interior is made fresh daily. There is a variety of chips and cookies to accompany your order as well as fountain drinks. This location clean and convenient and the staff are very efficient. I've always had a great experience. No wifi, though. Bummer. But, they always have some sort of offer to help charities and that just makes you feel warm and fuzzy inside! read more

See all

We decided to order lunch out which is a rare treat for us these days. It was lunch time and they were fairly busy so we had to wait. It's not a big place. There were customers without masks but I was relieved to see the staff all wearing masks, until a young woman entered for her shift while we were waiting. She had a mask on below her mouth. Of course she's the one who then rang us up. When I asked her if she was required to wear a mask she put it over her mouth leaving her nose out. This does not help to protect me as a customer. It's also tight in there with only one door for entering or exiting so people passing close nearby where you have to wait in line. I probably won't be back. read more

This was my first time here and was very glad I went. The gentleman greeting us, Shareef, was really attentive and friendly. He greeted all of the following guests with a great attitude and the food was great as well. Thank you! read more

This is one of my go to spots for a sub on Timber dr in Garner. I have a new one that opened up closer to my house on Carbela dr in Garner. And I have to admit I did give them a try twice and both times they disappointed. The first time the called in order was never made and to make matters worse none of the employees knew the phone # so guess what I called them from inside the store the phone rang they answered and I gave them their number. So tonight I went back to my Fail-Safe on Timber drive in Garner I ordered two 12in subs on white to go, one Philly cheesesteak with peppers onions and mushrooms with mayo lettuce and tomato and the other cheese steak with lettuce tomato and mayo only. I see the lettuce, tomato and Mayo only had peppers and onions on it with no lettuce or tomato and the other had lettuce tomato mayo and steak where is the onions and peppers mushrooms and cheese !!!!!!! We are totally disappointed !!!!!! I even left them with a tip. But I'm going to chalk it up to saying that everybody has an off night and tonight must have been theirs. They were very pleasant and quick as always that's why I went back to Timber dr. I just wanted them to have gotten my order right. Not what I expect from my Fail-Safe for subs!!!!! read more

Food is fine but every time I've placed an order online and showed up at the time they told me my food would be ready I have ended up having to wait longer than if I had just got in line and ordered once I got there. Extremely frustrating. read more

Been a while since I've been to this location and though the customer service was excellent by some guy with a warm personality. I ordered a philly cheese steak, one of my favorites from Jersey Mikes. Waited for my food only to have my name called and while I greeted the young lady with a smile she didn't look too happy like I bothered her by ordering a hot sub. Got home and the sub was literally thrown together. I had to warm up the sandwich in the oven to take the soggy-ness away. Meat was in chunks and not chopped up like the other Jersey Mikes does. It literally looks like she warmed up meat on flat top cut a few times and threw everything in the sub bun. Very disappointed in my visit to say the least. . . read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - The "chunks" of meat and messy sub...smh - Sandwiches Near Me - Garner, North Carolina

Best Philly cheesesteak I have eaten in Raleigh friendly service fair prices and clean my friend and I have been twice and will definitely return to this location I have never been a fan of jersey mikes but this experience has changed my mind thank you and unlike some other restaurants they are well staffed read more

today i entered jersey mikes in tears. overall i was overwhelmed by generosity and kindness of the people in jersey mikes. i got an italian with everything and the girl offered me the chili relish and i was like ? ok sure i trust you and i left with quite a smile. little did i know my joyous visit would conclude in tears because the sandwich was delicious when i got home. it truly changed my life. im no longer gay read more

OK i know its been awhile since my last review but i can explain i have fell victim to my girlfriends all of a sudden health kick and have been well to say the least (been starved of real food for the past two weeks or so). so to keep the peace and my sanity i ran to jersey mike for a healthy alternative to my craving for baked ziti last night. Went with the chicken-salad sub which was awesome and to big to eat it all i have mad left overs but i digress. this place always gets it right with there fresh veggies and variety of choices they will hookup any thing you want. yes there kinda on the pricey side as a giant sub will cost about $13Bucks but there soooo worth it . Get Out And Get Sum! read more

Jersey Mikes Subs, but their service was TERRIBLE, I repeat, TERRIBLE! We had only 5 subs, how long does it take to make 2 tiny kids subs, 1 regular, and 2 cooked subs!? Well about... 1, 2, 3, ... 35 MINUTES! Their are nice people but some of those people are SO SLOW! read more

A very nice and clean establishment and as current local customer this evening I was extremely disappointed with the quality of my special request sandwich as I have previously purchased many times before. The kid making my sandwich made it his way rather than my request and said this is how we do it. Well, keep doing it the way you want but this Jersey Mikes just lost 2 customers from the community. I guess customers satisfaction does not matter at this store location. I definitely plan to share this experience with my friends and neighbors. read more

I love Jersey Mike's. Quality is awesome, freshest subs around. For a fast food chain, anytime they slice the meat in front of you, you can't get fresher than that. Highly recommend 'Mike's way'. read more

Best sandwiches in Garner. Sign up for their email list and get coupons and deals every week.

great team working. they were very busy yet worked well to accomplish the goal..assisting with different positions. food was fresh .

Huge fan of my huge italian sub for lunch today! Thank you for the great sandwich with all the fixings! The 40/42 area is LUCKY to such a great shop! read more

Excellent food and service. Wait persons are helpful and polite. Food is very good and portions are more than enough for most People. Price is right, nice place and as MacArthur said, " I shall Return". read more

Jersey Mike's has the best subs by far! The staff at this store is incredibly friendly and personable, and the product is always top notch. I frequent this location for a reason! read more

This Jersey Mikes is the best one around!! They always make the sandwiches fast and good. Staff is friendly and the manager here really seems to know how to run it. I always go at lunch time when it's really busy and I'm in and out easily. #7 is my favorite but all other subs are good too. Mikes Way is the way to go :) read more

Jersey mikes is amazingly fresh. I love the turkey and provalone on wheat. The staff is always friendly and inviting.

Best staff,Service &Food!! They are great here..super friendly! I lived right down the street from this Jersey Mikes-I always ordered myself the footlong turkey&would have them toast it for me & would have them top it with extra jalapeños-They always made my family's sandwiches perfect.Everything is fresh,it's very clean!my entire pregnancy I had "Ice Cravings" they would give me an extra Large cup to fill with Ice in addition to my drinks! The sweet manager would always send one of his cashiers out to my truck to help me carry my food and drinks! a++ read more

I love jersey mikes, but had to share this review: I just stopped by and bought $28 worth of subs for My family. The girl (brown curly hair) making my sub was clearly ANGRY that she was making a sandwich for us. At one point, she dumped oil on the sandwich and held it for at least 5 seconds. I normally would have asked to have someone else remake it, but was absolutely floored that she was doing that, so just said, "seriously??" To which she exchanged looks with another girl and laughed, then did the same thing with vinegar and oregano. The only thing that would make me feel better was writing this review. She was very rude, disrespectful, and they should not hire people who are averse to customer service for that position. It was a very weird exchange. read more