THE GOOD ---------------- + Subs here are as good as any other location. + More tables and chairs for dining in than most locations. + Exterior and interior are relatively clean. + Location is part of the Fair Lawn Promenade where there is ample parking outside. THE NOT SO GOOD ---------------------------- - Nada. MIXED THOUGHTS --------------------------- = Nada. RANDOM OBSERVATIONS -------------------------------------- = They definitely get busy, especially with pickup orders, during prime dining times. read more

See all

- Spacious with plenty of tables for dining in; the shop is clean and bright - Service was fast and friendly; staff greeted us when we walked in and kept us updated on our mobile orders - Food was well prepared--cold subs were stacked high with fresh ingredients, and the hot cheesesteak had perfectly cooked meat read more

See all

How have I never been to a Jersey Mike's after all these years? After my brother-in-law told me how frequently he enjoyed their subs, I finally made a visit to this Fair Lawn location. Since I wasn't quite sure what to order, I chose a chicken bacon ranch sub straight off the menu and only substituted the cheese type. I've heard some comparisons to Subway's, but I love that there is a hot grill here, which makes all the difference. My sub was satisfyingly full of warmed chicken, bacon, and neatly piled vegetables. The folks behind the counter work so fast that our order was ready within mere minutes, and they were quick to respond to needs. For instance, I returned to the counter to request some extra pickles, and they were so nice about packing it neatly into a cup even though I was dining in. I know chains are frequently overlooked when it comes to dining recommendations, but I'm happy to report that my husband and I had a solid meal. This particular Jersey Mike's is part of a larger complex. Since there are quite a few eateries (mainly chains) that share the space, parking is plentiful but can get a little tight during meal hours. Inside, the space offers plenty of seating. read more

See all

Good, easy lunch! I get the tuna bowl with pickled jalepenos and it's always consistent.

Yum! Yum! Yum!! I love Jersey Mike's! Their sandwiches are so scrumptious!!! Even if there a wait, the lines move so quickly and the staff is always very nice. Turkey and provolone is my go to! read more

The dirtiest Jersey Mikes I have ever been to and I have been to many of them in Jersey. Trash on the floor in the dining area as well as the rest room. Both garbage cans overflowing with trash. The food preparation area looked clean and my cheesesteak was good. Maybe it was a bad day for this location although I know I will not ever go to this location again. read more

I picked this spot for lunch and ordered online. I ordered the mushroom sandwich. When I arrived I parked in the plaza parking lot. I walked in and was greeted. My food was ready but there were some things they didn't have that I had to substitute. I retrieved them and left. When I got in I ate and the sandwich was pretty good and filling. All in all I had a good experience. read more

See all

Had regular size turkey and provolone Good taste but sandwich got smaller Not worth it read more

I have ordered here multiple times ! One out of three ordered are correct. My most recent order was not correct. I ordered bacon and peepers and mayonnaise on my Jersey Mike sub and was disappointed as none of the three were on my sandwich. You pay extra for bacon so that was even more disappointing as it has occurred twice before. Please review your assembly process as it has been a reoccurring issue. Thank You E read more

Super nice staff at this location. Came here during covid19 situation today to pick up subs for me and the hubs for dinner. Friendly staff, clearly getting bombarded with orders bc they were slammed and not expecting high volume but they handled it like champs. I was high maintenance and asked for an extra side of chipotle mayo for the hubs and BAM! Like a genie they granted my wish and gave me a large side of sauce. Girl at cash register also super accommodating. She had my hot subs wrapped and I inquired about lettuce and mayo and she reply's "oh ok you're supposed to just tell them when you order bc hot subs don't come out over there" (she points to condiments section) but she still asked me what I'd like and re-opened the subs to fix them the way I wanted and said no problem and never gave attitude. I like the crew here. Super clean. Super organized. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Covid19 pickup stations for preorders - Fast Food Near Me - Fair Lawn, New Jersey

Very expensive sandwiches. They are very cheap putting on any type of cheese. Even if you ask for extra you get 1 slice. However they are so generous with there meats. There cold cuts are very lean and tasteful. Nice clean store and the workers are so friendly. read more

Jersey Mike's I have found to be really good for a sandwich chain (miles ahead of Subway). The hot sandwiches are always solid and the cold ones they make fresh by slicing the meat to order. While I will always prefer a local deli, I think Jersey Mike's is very respectable. read more

If you want to be mistreated as a customer and then scolded at for being cold, this is the spot. Worst of all the so called manager praises his workers instead of realizing what was done . If you are serving someone you look them in the eye and smile, not blame the customer for your lazy work ethic. That so called manager, short little fella needs to get some education in what he calls "hospitality". Avoid going to the Fairlawn Promenade location if you want your blood pressure to be normal. There is a reason why it got 3 stars. read more

The food is good can't complain . The sandwiches are great . However, walking in the staff was a bit sarcastic . And not that friendly. They could've done better with being professional . One employee made a passive comment when I picked up a menu . Saying I could just "look at the display menu" and I don't know about you but I like having my own personal menu close ...so that me when I look down it's more comfortable. Anyways my friend didn't order she went to the Habit burger ... anyways ....here are a few pics of my " Buffalo chicken cheesesteak sandwich" Delicious read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Fast Food Near Me - Fair Lawn, New Jersey

See all

Have had many different subs, but this was was awesome. They kinda grind the chicken and it was so juicy and tasty. Super quick and good place for a quick bite. Good options for veggies too. Thumbs up. read more

See all

A big shout out and thank you goes to Theresa and Domonique for all their help in putting together 7 cases of subs for our faculty luncheon. They were wonderful and did a great job!! read more

Just your typical Jersey Mike's. Fresh and delicious. The place was very clean and the employees were nice. I left full and happy.

So excited to find out they have gluten free sub rolls! The portions are big, quality deli meat and overall good chain sandwich. My only complaint is that it can be a bit pricey and the service at this specific location is extremely slow for no reason. read more

This was my first visit to Fair Lawn 's Jersey Mike's. It was a Friday at 11:00am. Since all restaurants in the state are prohibited from offering dine-in services due to the viral outbreak, I ordered the giant chipotle cheese steak online for pickup. I picked up my bag which was placed on a table near the entrance. Staff was friendly from afar. I enjoyed my meal on a promenade bench outside. read more

I know it's a franchise but the difference between the Fairlawn location and the Rochelle Park location is night and day. Fairlawn takes safety seriously. Everyone wears a mask employees and customers and they enforce it. They have protective plastic and distancing marks clearly displayed. They were clean and used gloves properly. The other location was a disaster with every employee wearing their masks below their nose and messy messy! I love Jersey Mike's and I am so glad I tried this location instead of giving up on the franchise after my other experience. read more

The store is clean the staff is nice , and best subs, ordered #2 , #7 and Philly Cheese Steaks , they are all very good!

My Buffalo chicken sandwich wasn't Buffalo-ey enough, no kick to it, overall was filling and decent

I enjoy the sandwiches at jersey mikes, and the staff is friendly. I just wish they didn't soak sandwiches in oil and vinegar. I'm not sure if it's because they have such big bottles, and too much comes out too quick? I've asked to go easy and sometimes it was fine, other times still too much. I try putting it in the comments if I order online, but sometimes it's over looked. It's just messy when it's that much, and the bread gets really soggy. Other than that I prefer Jersey Mike's over other sandwich chain restaurants. read more

Went to Jersey Mike's @3120 Promenade Blvd, Fair Lawn, NJ . Fresh baked bread but I got 2 sliced of Roast Beef. & it was so dry! They were cheap with the lettuces, Tomatoes. I was so disappointed.!! It was majority bead. Horrible sandwich but this is one of the worst sandwiches. The place was empty now I know why. I been in Norfolk Va. Now they make the BEST!!! Sandwich that was Jersey Mike's. That place is packed all the time. Love it there. Won't be back here again.... read more

Just another sub place nothing exciting not my favor but I hope they succeed. I went once and that was enough for me .

Service was awesome did online ordering and food was ready as I walked thru door . Very friendly and clean environment

Wish they'd spend the time and resources on the food they spent on the branding... seriously? And the prices... such a disappointment...

I feel like this place is bait and switch. I absolutely loved Jersey Mikes when it first opened. Though expensive, they'd pile on lots of meat to make for a spectacular meal. They cut way, way back. Now I get a fraction of the meat and cheese as before - yet the price is still the same. I keep going back hoping my prior experiences were one-offs, but they continue to be weak. I'll probably try another location or two, but if the rest are the same I'll stop going all-together. read more

I really like this place. The staff is good. Sandwiches taste great. I love how they have cherry pepper relish, fresh jalapeno and banana peppers. The bacon is always crispy and they give you a good portion of deli meat. Here's a tip. Add double the meat! Well worth it. They really do a good job. They also have a rewards program. read more

The staff at this location are very nice. While waiting for my order, I held a conversation with a few of them. As for the sandwiches, they were made accurate and tasted great. I will continue to use this location because it's close to home, the atmosphere is great and my order was made correctly! Great addition to the promenade! Edit: I returned to this location and they hired a sour lemon by the name of Bailey. Not sure if she's a zombie or she's just tired. In any case she shouldn't be working with people. She just stares at you, lifelessly. Even after I said hello and told her I was there to pick up an online order, she kept the same blank stare on her face. The place wasn't that busy, but asking her to retrieve my order was too much for her soul to take. Such a shame to have a dull person at the counter of a place that makes great sandwiches. read more

This is my favorite sandwich chain, hands down. The bread is delicious and the cold cuts are good, not cheap and the sandwiches have a good amount of meat in them. Always get our sandwiches "Mike's Way" because who doesn't like lettuce, tomato, onion, oil and vinegar? If we aren't feeling bread we get our sandwich in a tub. Love that option. Plus they will make a sandwich any way you want it, even if it's not posted on the menu. read more

Good subs and fast with a location that has parking. What more can you ask for? If you choose to eat in and want a coffee or whatever, a Starbucks is steps away. I usually get the original Italian, Mike's way. I'll grab a cheesestak from time to time as well. Not many places to get a decent one around the area, so this is a good option for that. read more

Lots of bang for your buck . Fresh veggies and delicious salted meats ! Whats not to like??? Perfect bread, to meat, to veggie ratio on every sandwich. Too many to list on that menu that are just great, i dont think there's a bad choice !!! Clean place and friendly staff . Great for a quick filling bite . read more

Management should make it mandatory for the employees to wear hair nets.. its gross when you find a strand of hair in your food.

The wife really enjoyed her chicken cheese steak and couldn't stop talking about it. I had a regular cheese steak and it was probably one of the best I've had. I'll definitely be back, I especially like the face that they have a choice of hot and cold sandwiches to choose from. read more

I had just recently picked up my sandwich today and I am not happy with my order. The people inside seemed nice and friendly but they were too busy talking with each other and not focusing on my order. I had ordered a Italian sandwich and asked for no onions. What I got was a ham and cheese sandwich with onions on it. They forgot to add the other meats that belong in the Italian sandwich and put something on my sandwich that I didn't ask for. I will never go back to this one again! read more

Awful! I'm sure if you stand there watching them they will get your order accurate but don't order online!! I ordered a BLT tub with extra bacon (literally the easiest thing ever) and I got 2 pieces of bacon with a mound of lettuce filled with salt, pepper, and oregano. Not to mention all the other orders they've messed up!! read more

I ordered a meatball sandwich with cheese and it wasn't even hot and the cheese didnt melt. I wouldn't recommend this place. I dont plan on going back. read more

Do all Jersey Mike's serve white American cheese I can't believe that why do you serve white American cheese with a mess up the taste of the sandwich so bad please stop doing that because you'll never see me in another f****** Jersey Mike's again read more

When you stop in to this Jersey Mike's ask for Josh. He exudes excellence. Character, a smile, and great service. The employees in this establishment are all very well trained, and delightful to deal with. Every time I make a trip to Fair Lawn, I make sure to stop in. Even if it's just for a soda. Food is awesome too!! read more